Hochul, NYC DAs take victory lap on discovery laws that led to slew of criminal dismissals
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience.
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience.
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience. Generate Key Takeaways
It's a brand new discovery.
Gov. Kathy Hochul and New York City's five district attorneys ran a victory lap Wednesday on a revamp to the state's discovery laws included in a sprawling budget bill.
The changes will prevent criminal cases from being thrown out over trivial mistakes and narrow how much evidence prosecutors must turn over to defense attorneys.
Gov. Kathy Hochul, along with five district attorneys across New York City, took a victory lap Wednesday for revamping the state's discovery laws while also including a $250 billion budget bill. James Messerschmidt
Hochul, speaking alongside the district attorneys at Manhattan's state courthouse, had refused to budge on the issue — which caused a weeks-long impasse on the overall mammoth budget deal.
'I said all along I would hold up a $250 billion budget on this issue,' she said.
'And here's why: behind all the legal jargon that some may not quite comprehend, there's real peoples' lives at stake here.'
'You can't have violent criminals who hurt other human beings be able to walk free because of evidence that was irrelevant might have been excluded.'
The changes made will ensure that criminal cases won't be thrown out just purely over trivial mistakes, while also narrowing how much evidence prosecutors can turn over to defense attorneys. James Messerschmidt
Big Apple prosecutors groused for years that 2019 reforms to the state's evidence-sharing laws — which were passed because many New Yorkers languished in jail awaiting trial on often-minor criminal charges — had led to a surge in case dismissals.
The reforms' onerous requirements forced prosecutors to turn over massive amounts of evidence, they complained.
Failing to turn over even inconsequential evidence led to accused criminals — including a man who allegedly beat his girlfriend and ripped off her clothes in front of his friends — walking free on technicalities, prosecutors argued.
Hochul initially refused to speak on the issue, which caused a weeks-long impasse before the budget deal got passed. James Messerschmidt
The deal struck by Hochul and state lawmakers would, according to the governor's office:
Require courts to consider the prosecutor's efforts as a whole and whether missing evidence prejudiced the defense — an effort to prevent cases from being thrown out over insignificant mistakes;
Narrow the scope of what evidence prosecutors must turn over so not to include frivolous materials that have no real weight on the case
Clarify that cases should only be dismissed by judges if prosecutors did not exercise 'due diligence'
Require defense attorneys to challenge a prosecutor's certification that they've completed discovery effort within 35 days
'In broad strokes what the bill does is requires us to turn over materials as quickly and as efficiently as we can,' said Staten Island District Attorney Michael McMahon.
'If the defense has objections, they have to make those objections within 35 days,' McMahon said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
JPMorgan's Jamie Dimon is getting louder about his US debt worries
JPMorgan Chase (JPM) CEO Jamie Dimon is increasingly concerned that the US government's surging debt is going to cause problems for the bond market, prompting some pushback from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Last Friday, the boss of the biggest US bank predicted a "crack" in that market while speaking at the Reagan National Economic Forum in Simi Valley, Calif. "It is going to happen. And I tell this to my regulators, some of you who are in this room, I'm telling you it's going to happen, and you're going to panic." This past weekend, Bessent dismissed that prediction, saying Dimon has made it before. "I've known Jamie a long time and for his entire career he's made predictions like this. Fortunately, none of them have come true. That's why he's a banker, a great banker. He tries to look around the corner," Bessent said in an interview on CBS' "Face the Nation." Dimon emerged in 2025 as an influential voice when it comes to the policies of the new Trump administration — and as someone who apparently has President Trump's ear. The president even acknowledged listening to Dimon just hours before he announced a 90-day pause of his "Liberation Day" tariffs on April 9. Dimon repeated his warnings about the bond market in an interview with Fox Business Network's Maria Bartiromo that aired Monday, saying the surging US national debt may create a "tough time" for that market as spreads widen. "If people decide that the US dollar isn't the place to be, you could see credit spreads gap out; that would be quite a problem," Dimon said. "It hurts the people raising money. That includes small businesses, that includes loans to small businesses, includes high-yield debt, includes leveraged lending, includes real estate loans. That's why you should worry about volatility in the bond market." Long-term Treasury yields have been climbing in recent weeks, driven by growing concerns over the trajectory of US debt as President Trump's proposed tax legislation advances to the Senate after clearing the House. Read more: What is the 10-year Treasury note, and how does it affect your finances? New concerns emerged last week after a Manhattan-based trade court struck down a wide swath of Trump's tariffs, citing legal issues with how they were implemented. Although a federal appeals court paused that decision on Thursday, temporarily allowing the tariffs to remain in place, the legal back-and-forth has added to market uncertainty. Treasury yields initially spiked on Monday, with the 10-year (^TNX) climbing to 4.46% while the 30-year (^TYX) reached 4.99% by the end of the day. They briefly retreated on Tuesday, only to return to Monday levels, a threshold breached only a handful of times since 2007. Bessent told CBS this past weekend that the administration's work on getting down the deficit is underway. "The deficit this year is going to be lower than the deficit last year, and in two years it will be lower again," he said. "We are going to bring the deficit down slowly. We didn't get here in one year, and this has been a long process." The administration intends to "leave the country in great shape in 2028," he added. One area that would cushion a bond market tantrum that the Trump administration has clearly telegraphed is giving JPMorgan and other big banks a larger role as US Treasury holders, and possibly dealers. Bessent has repeatedly said he wants to adjust a bank capital requirement known as the supplemental leverage ratio (SLR) to make it easier for lenders in order to inject more liquidity into the market for US government debt. Dimon agrees that amending the SLR would help the market during times of stress, though he noted that he also wants to see reforms across lots of capital requirements. "The reason to change some of these things is so banks — the big market makers could intermediate more in the markets," Dimon told analysts in April. "If they do, spreads will come in, there'll be more active traders," Dimon said. "If they don't, the Fed will have to intermediate, which I think is just a bad policy idea that every time there's a kerfuffle in the markets, the Fed has to come in and intermediate." To prevent a bond market crack, Dimon said in the Fox News interview that aired Monday, "the real focus should be [economic] growth." He also named several places for improvement from regulatory, permitting, and education reforms to broader government efficiency efforts meant to stamp out waste and fraud in Medicare and Medicaid. Dimon gave Fox an update about his plans to leave the bank eventually, saying that his retirement is still "several years away" but that "it's up to God and the board," the 69-year-old CEO said. "I love what I do." On Tuesday, the bank announced in a memo that it was giving more responsibility to one of Dimon's potential successors, consumer bank boss Marianne Lake. Lake will also oversee strategic growth and the overseas consumer bank following Sanoke Viswanathan's departure to become CEO of data provider FactSet. David Hollerith is a senior reporter for Yahoo Finance covering banking, crypto, and other areas in finance. Click here for in-depth analysis of the latest stock market news and events moving stock prices Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
CNN
28 minutes ago
- CNN
Family of Colorado attack suspect taken into ICE custody
Federal agencies CrimeFacebookTweetLink Follow The family of the Egyptian national charged with attempted murder after an antisemitic Molotov cocktail attack in Colorado has been taken into ICE custody and are being processed, a DHS official confirmed to CNN Tuesday. The suspected attacker, Mohamed Soliman, has a wife and five children, according to court filings. It remains unclear what the family members' US immigration status is and whether the whole family was taken into custody. This is a developing story and will be updated.
Associated Press
31 minutes ago
- Associated Press
COVID-related agreement continues to shield some on Georgia's death row from execution
ATLANTA (AP) — The fact that the COVID-19 vaccine is not available for newborn babies is shielding a group of prisoners on Georgia's death row from execution. Executions in Georgia were halted during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the state attorney general's office entered into an agreement with lawyers for people on death row to set the terms under which they could resume for a specific group of prisoners. At least one of those conditions, having to do with the availability of the COVID-19 vaccine, has not been met, and seeking an execution date for a prisoner covered by the agreement would breach the agreement, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Shukura Ingram ruled. The agreement includes three conditions that had to be met before executions could be set for the affected prisoners: the expiration of the state's COVID-19 judicial emergency, the resumption of normal visitation at state prisons and the availability of a COVID-19 vaccine 'to all members of the public.' Once those conditions were met, the state agreed to give three months' notice before pursuing an execution warrant for one of the prisoners covered by the agreement and six months' notice for the rest. The state has argued that the agreement should no longer apply, contending the conditions have been met. But defense attorneys say it's still valid because the vaccine isn't yet available to infants under 6 months old, and visitation at state prisons has not returned to normal. Ingram's ruling, issued Friday, addressed only the vaccination question. She plans to handle the visitation issue separately. Ingram wrote that the state's arguments 'all boil down to an attempt to rewrite the Agreement.' The state is '(u)nhappy with the language it drafted' and wants to change it so that the condition would be satisfied once vaccines are available to 'most members of the public.' 'But courts cannot rewrite contracts to relieve a party of their regrets,' she wrote. She ruled that the agreement is 'binding and enforceable,' that the vaccination condition hasn't been met and that seeking an execution warrant before the requirements have been met would breach the agreement. The state attorney general's office plans to appeal, a spokesperson said Tuesday. Ingram noted that the Food and Drug Administration has approved clinical trials for infants under 6 months old, and newborns receive other vaccines. That shows it is possible for the COVID-19 vaccine to ultimately be available for that age group, and the state should have foreseen that that could take years, she wrote. Experts for both sides had testified that it was probable that the COVID-19 vaccine would eventually become available to babies under the age of 6 months, Ingram wrote. That was before Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was appointed U.S. health secretary. Kennedy last week announced that COVID-19 vaccines are no longer recommended for healthy children and pregnant women. A few days later, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's website, which had said those groups should get the shots, was revised to say the vaccinations 'may' be given to those groups. The agreement covers fewer than 10 of the 34 people currently on Georgia's death row. While Georgia stopped carrying out executions during the pandemic, death penalty cases continued to wind their way through the court system, and as people exhausted their appeals, they became eligible for execution. A committee of a judicial task force on COVID-19 in early 2021 instructed lawyers for people on death row and the state attorney general's office to come up with terms under which executions could safely resume. The two sides reached the agreement in April 2021. The agreement only applied to people on death row whose requests to have their appeals reheard were denied by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals while the judicial emergency was in place. The agreement was to remain in effect through Aug. 1, 2022, or one year from the date on which the conditions were met — whichever was later. The legal fight arose from a lawsuit filed when officials set a May 2022 execution date for Virgil Delano Presnell Jr. The Federal Defender Program, which represents Presnell, said the state had violated the agreement because the conditions hadn't all been met. Based on that argument, a Fulton County Superior Court judge halted the execution less than 24 hours before it was to take place, and the Georgia Supreme Court ruled in December 2022 that the agreement was a binding contract. People on death row who are not covered by the agreement have since become eligible for execution. One of them, Willie James Pye, was put to death in March 2024.
