Sinn Fein TD apologises for ‘hurt and offence' in post about gender ruling
A Sinn Fein TD has apologised for a social media post about the UK court ruling on excluding trans women from the definition of 'woman' in equality law.
David Cullinane, the party's health spokesman, said the 'complex' issue needs to be approached with 'compassion' and he apologised for any offence caused.
Trans and Intersex Pride Dublin has said it has written to the party asking it to clarify its position and will consider banning it from its parade in July.
The UK Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the 2010 Equality Act 'refer to a biological woman and biological sex'.
This means transgender women with a gender recognition certificate can be excluded from single-sex spaces, such as changing rooms and homeless hostels, if 'proportionate'.
The judges also said transgender people are still protected from discrimination in the same law.
They said they can 'invoke the provisions on direct discrimination and harassment, and indirect discrimination' and are protected from discrimination on the grounds of gender reassignment.
I want to apologise for the hurt and offence that I have caused to the Trans community following a tweet I sent last night. That was never my intention. This is a complex issue for many but we need to approach it with compassion, understanding and dignity for all.
— David Cullinane T.D. (@davidcullinane) April 17, 2025
Authorities including the NHS are examining the implications of the ruling.
A spokesperson for the Equality Commission in Northern Ireland said while the ruling only relates to England, Scotland and Wales, 'our initial view is that the judgment is likely to be deemed by our industrial tribunals and courts to be highly persuasive and, consequently, it is likely to be followed in cases where similar issues arise'.
On Wednesday evening, Mr Cullinane called for the ruling to be 'fully examined in this state'.
The Waterford TD said on social media site X: 'The Scottish Supreme Court ruling on the legal meaning of woman is a common sense judgement.
'The ruling found that for the purposes of equality legislation a 'woman' means a biological woman & 'sex' refers to biological sex.
'It also confirmed that trans people are protected under their Equality legislation in a separate category of gender reassignment.'
The PA news agency contacted Mr Cullinane on Thursday morning to clarify his comments.
In a tweet sent on Thursday afternoon, Mr Cullinane apologised.
'I want to apologise for the hurt and offence that I have caused to the trans community following a tweet I sent last night,' he said on X.
I'm sure those in the Trans community will feel vulnerable and isolated today in the aftermath of yesterday's judgement, and I apologise that my words added to that.
— David Cullinane T.D. (@davidcullinane) April 17, 2025
'That was never my intention. This is a complex issue for many but we need to approach it with compassion, understanding and dignity for all.
'I'm sure those in the trans community will feel vulnerable and isolated today in the aftermath of yesterday's judgement, and I apologise that my words added to that.'
Trans and Intersex Pride Dublin said it is not clear whether Mr Cullinane still believes the ruling should be looked at in Ireland.
It said it 'shows the instinct and insensitivity to attack the community by a health spokesperson'.
The group added: 'The decision by the UK Supreme Court opens the door to further attacks on trans rights and has severe consequences for the people of Britain, and a knock-on for Irish trans people.'
It welcomed the decision by different Pride groups in Northern Ireland to ban all Executive parties that had signed off on the temporary suspension of puberty blockers.
Trans and Intersex Pride organiser and co-founder Ollie Bell said: 'We understand that many activists in Sinn Fein may disagree with the party's position, however it would be a disservice to the community we represent if we allow Sinn Fein to march.
'We encourage all Pride marches to consider our decision, in light of the ban on puberty blockers and the kowtowing to anti-trans forces with regards to agreeing with the Supreme Court decision, and join us in this decision.
'We welcome all activists, groups, organisations who genuinely want to fight for trans rights to join us on July 12 in protest against anti-trans attacks everywhere.'
A spokesman for Sinn Fein said: 'We are aware of the ruling from the British Supreme Court.
'It is important that we have effective equality protections that work to protect everyone and we will carefully examine the detail of this ruling in that context.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
4 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Harvard Also Has Christian Antisemitism
'As queer and trans people, political radicals, abolitionists and anti-Zionists, imagination is our calling,' a Harvard Divinity School student pronounced on campus. She denounced Israel's 'state violence, settler colonialism, fermented trauma and religious nationalism.' The setting wasn't an encampment, an unauthorized graduation speech, or a foreign-funded Middle East studies seminar. It was a sermon at morning prayers inside Harvard's Memorial Church. The university owns and operates the church, which occupies a prominent position in the physical center of campus. The Harvard Corp. selects and employs its minister. The church website, with audio and transcripts of sermons, has a address. Contributors to the church get a tax receipt that says 'thank you for donating to Harvard University.' Memorial Church calls itself 'an interdenominational Protestant church' and 'a community of social critique and human compassion.' When it comes to Israel and the Jews, as the Divinity School student's speech indicates, Harvard's main campus church has been heavy on critique and light on compassion. Hostility has come from professors and professional clergy, too.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Manchester City fans take legal action against club over season-ticket policy
Manchester City supporters have taken legal action against the club over what they describe as a discriminatory new season-ticket policy. The protest relates to a system that requires fans to attend at least 10 league matches if they are to retain their ticket for the following season. A group of fans known as the Trade Union Blues, whose members are union members, have engaged the law firm Leigh Day to ask the club to review the policy, arguing that the requirement 'potentially gives rise to claims under the Equality Act of 2010'. Advertisement Related: Beyond the apathy: the Manchester City and Chelsea fans off to the Club World Cup The secretary of Trade Union Blues, Chris Neville, said: 'This policy doesn't reward loyalty – it punishes people for being human. Illness, pregnancy, disability, caring responsibilities or working shifts [could] now cost you your season ticket. Many of our members have followed City through thick and thin and now face exclusion because of inflexible criteria that takes no account of individual circumstances.' The policy was announced by City last month, after season-ticket prices were frozen following consultation with the club's elected fan advisory board, City Matters. It increased the obligatory number of home league matches a season-ticket holder must attend from 14 to 16, but also mandated that only six of those games could be shared with friends or handed back to the club for resale. City believe that ticket utilisation is a growing issue for the club, having told City Matters in February that an average 8% of 37,000 season-ticket members do not attend a given Premier League game. Liverpool and Arsenal have mandatory attendance requirements for season-ticket holders, but neither cap the number of games that can be shared or resold. Arsenal exempt season-ticket holders with disabilities from the cap. Ryan Bradshaw, human rights partner at Leigh Day, said: 'The updated policy introduced by Manchester City applies a blanket requirement for personal attendance which significantly disadvantages a number of protected groups under the Equality Act. There is no indication that any meaningful mitigation procedures are in place. It disadvantages those working-class fans who are required to work shift patterns or precariously and may be unable to attend games for fear of losing their jobs.' City did not respond to a request for comment.
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
PM ‘utterly condemns' second night of violence after 17 officers injured in NI
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has said he 'utterly condemns' violence which left 17 police officers injured following a second night of disturbances in Ballymena. PSNI Chief Constable Jon Boutcher has warned that the rioting 'risks undermining' the criminal justice process into an allegation of a sex attack on a teenage girl in the Co Antrim town at the weekend. Stormont ministers have also made an urgent appeal for calm and said the justice process had to be allowed to take its course. Speaking during Prime Minister's Questions in the Commons, Sir Keir condemned the 'mindless attacks' against police. 'I utterly condemn the violence that we have seen overnight in Ballymena and in other parts of Northern Ireland, including against PSNI officers,' Sir Keir told MPs. 'It's absolutely vital that the PSNI are given the time they need to investigate the incidents concerned rather than face mindless attacks as they seek to bring peace and order to keep people safe.' In a joint statement, ministers from across the Stormont powersharing Executive, which includes Sinn Fein, DUP, Alliance Party and UUP, said those involved in disorder have nothing to offer society but 'division and disorder'. Police said their officers came under sustained attack over a number of hours with multiple petrol bombs, heavy masonry, bricks and fireworks in their direction in the Clonavon Terrace area of Ballymena on Tuesday night. The PSNI deployed riot police, fired plastic baton rounds, and used water cannon as well as dog units as part of its response to the disorder. Police also reported that 'sporadic disorder' had also occurred in Newtownabbey and Carrickfergus, as well as incidents in north Belfast. It came after similar violent disorder around Clonavon Terrace in the town on Monday night, following an earlier peaceful protest which was organised in support of the family of a girl who was the victim of an alleged sexual assault in the area. Two teenage boys, who spoke to a court through a Romanian interpreter, have been charged. A PSNI spokesperson said earlier on Tuesday evening that a number of protests took place in areas of Belfast, Lisburn, Coleraine and Newtownabbey. In Carrickfergus, two bins were set alight and bottles and masonry thrown at police in the Sunnylands area by a group of 20 to 30 young people at around 8.30pm. In Newtownabbey bins were set alight at the roundabout on O'Neill Road. During the course of the disorder in Ballymena, officers discharged a number of plastic baton rounds and the water cannon was also deployed in an attempt to disperse the crowds. The spokesperson said: 'Businesses and homes were attacked and damaged and a number of vehicles were also set on fire in the area. 'Seventeen officers were injured with some requiring required hospital treatment. 'Five people were arrested on suspicion of riotous behaviour and remain in police custody this morning. 'A male was also arrested on suspicion of disorderly behaviour on the O'Neill Road in Newtownabbey. 'A number of nearby roads were closed by police to ensure the safety of the public and local residents, and to enable officers to deal with the situation and disorder safely. All roads were subsequently reopened.' Fifteen officers had been injured during similar scenes in Ballymena on Monday. Mr Boutcher said: 'The mindless violence witnessed over the past two nights in Ballymena is deeply concerning and utterly unacceptable. 'These criminal acts not only endanger lives but also risk undermining the ongoing criminal justice process led by the PSNI in support of a victim who deserves truth, justice, and protection. 'Ironically, and frustratingly, this violence threatens to derail the very pursuit of justice it claims to challenge. 'Let me be clear: this behaviour must stop. I appeal to everyone involved to cease all further acts of criminality and disorder immediately.' The Chief Constable said the investigation into the violence would include reviewing video footage and images of individuals would be released to identify offenders. He added: 'Since 2010, the PSNI has been critically underfunded. This neglect takes no account of the enormous demands placed on us by legacy issues or the unique challenges of policing in a post-conflict society. 'Our resourcing levels are not just inadequate — they are dangerous. 'I will be making arrangements to activate mutual aid resources to ensure we have the necessary support to maintain public order and bring offenders to justice.' Northern Ireland's First Minister Michelle O'Neill and deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly both condemned the violent scenes in social media posts. Ms O'Neill said: 'The racist and sectarian attacks on families across the north, and the rioting in Ballymena are abhorrent and must stop immediately. 'Those responsible for this violence bring nothing to our communities but hatred, fear and division. 'No one, now or ever should feel the need to place a sticker on their door to identify their ethnicity just to avoid being targeted.' Ms Little-Pengelly said: 'Violence is always wrong. I have been in constant contact throughout last night with PSNI and in contact with local elected representatives. 'This disorder and violence must stop and justice be allowed to prevail.'
