White House to amend flagship health report citing phantom studies
The United States government has said it will amend a flagship report on children's health that was found to have cited non-existent studies.
White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said on Thursday that any citation errors were due to 'formatting issues' and would be updated. The problems with the report will do little to assuage concerns over President Donald Trump's appointment of Robert F Kennedy Jr as Health and Human Services Secretary.
The issues with the report, compiled and published last week by the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Commission, were revealed by digital news outlet NOTUS. It found that seven studies referenced did not exist, while there were also broken links and 'misstated conclusions'.
Leavitt insisted that the problems do 'not negate the substance of the report, which, as you know, is one of the most transformative health reports that has ever been released by the federal government'.
The report found that processed food, chemicals, stress and the overprescription of medications and vaccines could be factors behind chronic illness in children, citing more than 500 studies.
However, authors credited with producing some of those studies said that they were not part of the research, or that the studies did not exist.
Noah Kreski, a Columbia University researcher listed as an author of a paper on adolescent anxiety and depression during COVID-19, told the AFP news agency that the paper was 'not one of our studies' and 'doesn't appear to be a study that exists at all'.
The citation for the report included a link to an article in the peer-reviewed JAMA Paediatrics Medical Review that was broken. A spokesperson for the JAMA Network said that the article referenced 'was not published in JAMA Paediatrics or in any JAMA Network journal'.
The Democratic National Committee on Thursday slammed the report as 'rife with misinformation', accusing Kennedy's agency of 'justifying its policy priorities with studies and sources that do not exist'.
Kennedy's approval as health secretary in February stirred significant controversy. He previously spent decades sowing doubt about the safety of vaccines, raising concerns within the scientific and medical communities over the policies he would pursue.
Since taking the role, he has fired thousands of workers at federal health agencies and cut billions of dollars from biomedical research spending.
'The substance of the MAHA report remains the same – a historic and transformative assessment by the federal government to understand the chronic disease epidemic afflicting our nation's children,' the Department of Health and Human Services said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
6 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Truck accident unleashes 250 million honeybees in northwestern US
A truck carrying millions of honeybees has overturned in the northwestern United States, prompting emergency warnings from local authorities. The truck, carrying approximately 31,751kg (70,000 pounds) of active beehives, overturned on Friday in Washington state's Whatcom County – a rural area near the Canadian border, about 48km (30 miles) south of Vancouver. '250 million bees are now loose,' the Whatcom County Sheriff's Office (WCSO) announced on its official social media page. 'Avoid the area due to the potential of bee escaping and swarming.' Authorities sealed off parts of the area and urged the public to keep a safe distance of at least 200 yards (182 metres) as officials and bee experts helped recover, restore and reset the hives, according to the sheriff's office. The goal, officials said, is to safely re-hive the bees and help them locate their queens, a process that could take up to 48 hours. While some beekeepers focus solely on honey production, many others lease their hives to farmers who rely on bees to pollinate their crops. The loss of millions of bees, even temporarily, could threaten the productivity of nearby farms during the growing season. 'While there is no general health risk to the public, anyone who is allergic to bee stings or has concerns should check the State Department of Health webpage on bees and wasps,' WCSO said. Honeybees are crucial to the food supply, pollinating more than 100 crops including nuts, vegetables, berries, citrus and melons. Bees and other pollinators have been declining for years, and experts blame insecticides, parasites, disease, climate change and lack of a diverse food supply. In 2018, the United Nations General Assembly sponsored the first 'World Bee Day' on May 20 to bring attention to the bees' plight. Beekeepers often transport millions of bees from one location to another because leaving them in one location for too long can deplete resources for other pollinators, The Seattle Times newspaper reported. In 2015, 14 million bees escaped a truck north of Seattle on Interstate 5 and started stinging people, the newspaper reported at the time.
Al Jazeera
12 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Trump says China ‘violated' Geneva deal with US on tariffs, minerals
United States President Donald Trump has accused China of violating an agreement to mutually roll back tariffs and trade restrictions for critical minerals, as he suggested China was in 'grave economic danger' until he agreed to cut a deal earlier this month. Posting on his Truth Social platform on Friday evening, Trump said he made a 'fast deal' with China for both countries to back away from triple-digit tariffs for 90 days to 'save' Beijing from a 'very bad situation'. The US leader said his tariffs of up to 145 percent on Chinese imports had made it 'virtually impossible' for China to trade with the US market, resulting in closed factories and 'civil unrest' in the country. 'China, perhaps not surprisingly to some, HAS TOTALLY VIOLATED ITS AGREEMENT WITH US. So much for being Mr. NICE GUY!' Trump added. Trump did not specify in his post how China had violated the agreement – made following trade talks in Geneva, Switzerland, in mid-May – or what action he planned to take at their alleged failure to comply with its terms. Asked by reporters about the China deal later on Friday in the Oval Office, Trump said: 'I'm sure that I'll speak to [China's] President Xi [Jinping], and hopefully we'll work that out.' Trump's deputy chief of staff, Stephen Miller, told reporters that China's failure to fulfil its obligations 'opens up all manner of action for the United States to ensure future compliance'. Miller added that Trump hoped China would open up to American business in a similar manner to the way the US has been open to Chinese business 'for a very long time now'. China's embassy in Washington said Beijing has maintained communication with its US counterparts since the Geneva talks, but said they had concerns about recently imposed US export controls. 'China has repeatedly raised concerns with the US regarding its abuse of export control measures in the semiconductor sector and other related practices,' embassy spokesperson Liu Pengyu said in a statement. 'China once again urges the US to immediately correct its erroneous actions, cease discriminatory restrictions against China and jointly uphold the consensus reached at the high-level talks in Geneva,' Liu added. Earlier this week, media reports suggested the Trump administration had ordered US firms offering software used to design semiconductors to stop selling their services to Chinese groups. On Wednesday, a spokesperson for the US Department of Commerce confirmed that it was reviewing exports of strategic significance to China, and 'in some cases … suspended existing export licences or imposed additional licence requirements while the review is pending'. On Friday, shortly after lamenting China's lack of compliance with the Geneva agreement, President Trump also announced plans to increase tariffs on foreign imports of steel from 25 percent to 50 percent on June 4. The agreement two weeks ago dialling back tariffs for 90 days prompted a massive rally in global stocks, as it effectively lowered the US tariff rate on Chinese goods to the mid-teens from about 25 percent in early April. As part of the deal, China also agreed to lift trade countermeasures restricting exports of critical metals needed for production by US semiconductors, electronics and defence industries. But Trump administration officials have publicly stated that China has been slow to adhere to their Geneva commitments and have so far failed to comply. The Reuters news agency also reported on Friday that global auto executives are sounding the alarm on a looming shortage of rare-earth magnets from China that could force car factories to close within weeks. 'Without reliable access to these elements and magnets, automotive suppliers will be unable to produce critical automotive components, including automatic transmissions, throttle bodies, alternators, various motors, sensors, seat belts, speakers, lights, motors, power steering, and cameras,' the Alliance for Automotive Innovation said in a letter to the Trump administration.
Al Jazeera
14 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Trump says US will lift steel tariffs to 50 percent at Pennsylvania rally
United States President Donald Trump has announced his administration is raising tariffs on steel imports from 25 percent to 50 percent. Speaking to steelworkers and supporters at a rally outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Trump framed his latest tariff increase as a boon to the domestic manufacturing industry. 'We're going to bring it from 25 percent to 50 percent, the tariffs on steel into the United States of America, which will even further secure the steel industry in the United States,' Trump told the crowd. 'Nobody's going to get around that.' How that tariff increase would affect the free-trade deal with Canada and Mexico – or a separate trade deal struck earlier this month with the United Kingdom – remains unclear. Also left ambiguous was the nature of a deal struck between Nippon Steel, the largest steel producer in Japan, and the domestic company US Steel. Still, Trump played up the partnership between the two companies as a 'blockbuster agreement'. ' There's never been a $14bn investment in the history of the steel industry in the United States of America,' Trump said of the deal. Friday's rally was a return to the site of many election-season campaign events for Trump and his team. In 2024, Trump hinged his pitch for re-election on an appeal to working-class voters, including those in the Rust Belt region, a manufacturing hub that has declined in the face of the shifting industry trends and greater overseas competition. Key swing states like Pennsylvania and Michigan are located in the region, and they leaned Republican on election day, helping to propel Trump to a second term as president. Trump, in turn, has framed his 'America First' agenda as a policy platform designed to bolster the domestic manufacturing industry. Tariffs and other protectionist policies have played a prominent part in that agenda. In March, for instance, Trump announced an initial slate of 25-percent tariffs on steel and aluminium, causing major trading partners like Canada to respond with retaliatory measures. The following month, he also imposed a blanket 10-percent tariff on nearly all trade partners as well as higher country-specific import taxes. Those were quickly paused amid economic shockwaves and widespread criticism, while the 10-percent tariff remained in place. Trump has argued that the tariffs are a vital negotiating tool to encourage greater investment in the US economy. But economists have warned that attempting a 'hard reset' of the global economy – through dramatic tax hikes like tariffs – will likely blow back on US consumers, raising prices. Rachel Ziemba, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security, said the latest tariff hike on steel also signals that negotiating trade deals with Trump may result in 'limited benefits', given the sudden shifts in his policies. Further, Friday's announcement signals that Trump is likely to continue doubling down on tariffs, she said. 'The challenge is that hiking the steel tariffs may be good for steel workers, but it is bad for manufacturing and the energy sector, among others. So overall, it is not great for the US economy and adds uncertainty to the macro outlook,' Ziemba explained. Trump's tariff policies have also faced legal challenges in the US, where businesses, interest groups and states have all filed lawsuits to stop the tax hikes on imports. On Thursday, for instance, a federal court briefly ruled that Trump had illegally exercised emergency powers to impose his sweeping slate of international tariffs, only for an appeals court to temporarily pause that ruling a few hours later. Before the tariff hike was announced, Friday's rally in Pittsburgh was expected to focus on Nippon Steel's proposed acquisition of US Steel, the second largest steel producer in the country. 'We're here today to celebrate a blockbuster agreement that will ensure this storied American company stays an American company,' Trump said at the outset of his speech. But the merger between Nippon Steel and US Steel had been controversial, and it was largely opposed by labour unions. Upon returning to the White House in January, Trump initially said he would block the acquisition, mirroring a similar position taken by his predecessor, former US President Joe Biden. However, he has since pivoted his stance and backed the deal. Last week, he announced an agreement that he said would grant Nippon only 'partial ownership' over US Steel. Speaking on Friday, Trump said the new deal would include Nippon making a '$14bn commitment to the future' of US Steel, although he did not provide details about how the ownership agreement would play out. 'Oh, you're gonna be happy,' Trump told the crowd of steelworkers. 'There's a lot of money coming your way.' The Republican leader also waxed poetic about the history of steel in the US, describing it as the backbone of the country's economy. 'The city of Pittsburgh used to produce more steel than most entire countries could produce, and it wasn't even close,' he said, adding: 'If you don't have steel, you don't have a country.' For its part, US Steel has not publicly communicated any details of a revamped deal to investors. Nippon, meanwhile, issued a statement approving the proposed 'partnership', but it also has not disclosed terms of the arrangement. The acquisition has split union workers, although the national United Steelworkers Union has been one of its leading opponents. In a statement prior to the rally, the union questioned whether the new arrangement makes 'any meaningful change' from the initial proposal. 'Nippon has maintained consistently that it would only invest in US Steel's facilities if it owned the company outright,' the union said in a statement, which noted firmer details had not yet been released. 'We've seen nothing in the reporting over the past few days suggesting that Nippon has walked back from this position.' The rally on Friday comes as Trump has sought to reassure his base of voters following a tumultuous start to his second term. Critics point out that steel prices have risen in the US by roughly 16 percent since Trump took office, and his Republican Party faces potentially punishing congressional elections in 2026.
