Mi'kmaq band drops legal case on N.S. lobster fishery
Fishing boats from the Sipekne'katik First Nation prepare for the start of its self-regulated treaty lobster fishery in Saulnierville, N.S. on Monday, Aug. 16, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Andrew Vaughan
HALIFAX — A Mi'kmaq band has dropped a legal case alleging Ottawa was violating its treaty rights in the lobster fishery, after hopes were raised of a historic deal.
Last December, the lawyer for Sipekne'katik First Nation told Nova Scotia Supreme Court Justice John Keith that discussions with Ottawa to settle the matter were 'moving to a conclusion.'
Keith gave the parties until June 16 to finish the mediation, but said at that point the case would carry on before the courts.
However, a letter to the courts sent June 6 by Sipekne'katik's lawyer Nathan Sutherland dropped the case without any further explanation.
Neither side has provided an update on the status of negotiations for a new agreement.
Chief Michelle Glasgow, the leader of the Indigenous community about 70 kilometres north of Halifax, didn't reply to a request for comment.
Band members had argued their 'moderate livelihood' lobster harvest outside of the regular season is permitted by a 1999 Supreme Court of Canada decision, while non-Indigenous commercial fishers have contended it threatens stocks and fails to recognize how the courts have maintained Ottawa's right to regulate.
The original lawsuit was launched by the band in 2021, seeking a declaration that current federal regulations infringe on its treaty right to fish.
The Unified Fisheries Conservation Alliance, a group that represents commercial fishers, said in a news release Monday that the discontinuing of the case is a 'major victory' for its members.
'It is an acknowledgement by Chief (Michelle) Glasgow and Sipekne'katik First Nation that the rights to the illegal out-of-season lobster fishing ... are not a treaty protected right, it is poaching, plain and simple', said Colin Sproul, president of the group.
Meanwhile, the group said they will be pursuing separate legal action, filed in August 2024, asking the provincial Supreme Court to determine the rules and limits to be applied to Sipekne'katik First Nation's fishery under the Marshall decision.
The Supreme Court of Canada's 1999 Marshall decision said the Mi'kmaq, Maliseet and Passamaquoddy bands in Eastern Canada could hunt, fish and gather to earn a 'moderate livelihood,' though the court followed up with a clarification saying the treaty right was subject to federal regulation to ensure conservation.
In September 2020, the Sipekne'katik First Nation issued five lobster licences to its members, saying they could trap and sell their catch outside the federally regulated season.
In the months that followed there were confrontations on the water, rowdy protests and riots at two lobster pounds, one of which was razed by arson.
According to a letter the band's lawyers sent to the court last December, seven federal officials -- including the regional director of the Fisheries Department -- attended weekly mediation talks in the legal case, with 10 representatives of the First Nation participating.
'The progress made to date and moving forward from our 25 years of impasse is immeasurable,' wrote Ronald Pink, the lawyer at the time, in the 2024 letter to the judge.
The talks were also described by lawyers last December as being extensive, with former senator Dan Christmas and retired federal mediator Barney Dobbin guiding discussions.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 9, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
40 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Ottawa police probing defacement of National Holocaust Monument as hate crime
The Ottawa Police Service confirmed an act of vandalism on the National Holocaust Monument is being investigated by its hate crime unit. The words 'FEED ME' were found scrawled in red paint across the front of the monument Monday morning. Red paint was splashed on other parts of it as well. Ottawa police said they are treating the incident with the utmost seriousness, noting the impact such crimes have on the community. 'Reporting hate-motivated incidents is an important step in stopping cycles of hatred,' the service said in a statement. There has been an increase in reports of hate crime in Canada in recent years, which police agencies across the country link explicitly to the outbreak of war between Hamas and Israel in October, 2023. Police-reported hate crimes rose 32 per cent in 2023 compared with 2022. There has also been an increase of crimes targeting Jews in Canada, with 900 crimes reported in 2023, compared with 527 the year before. A petition condemning the vandalism in Ottawa was tabled in Parliament Monday by Conservative MP Tamara Kronis, who said 'the government must enforce the law and protect Jewish Canadians from hate, violence and intimidation.' Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture Steven Guilbeault also issued a strong condemnation. 'This monument honours the courage of survivors and the memory of the six million Jews murdered during one of humanity's darkest chapters,' he said. 'Acts of antisemitism, hatred and intolerance are attacks on us all – and they will never be tolerated in Canada.' Gaps in how justice system responds to hate crimes need to be addressed, report finds Deborah Lyons, Canada's Special Envoy on Preserving Holocaust Remembrance and Combating Antisemitism, said she was 'crushed' when she saw that the monument had been vandalized. She said that this was an antisemitic hate crime targeting Jews who have no connection to the Israeli government or its policies in Gaza. 'This is not a way to address the concerns that people have, either about what's happening in the Middle East or certainly about what's happened in our own country with the high spike of antisemitism,' Ms. Lyons said. Ottawa resident Robert Harmer, who lives close to the monument, called the vandalism 'a shame.' 'These monuments help us remember history – even the painful parts. Defacing something like the Holocaust Monument isn't protest; it's going too far.' Andres Bermudez, a resident and worker from Gemma Property Services involved in the cleanup, said the act was 'disrespectful and harmful.' 'These monuments attract tourists and beautify the city,' he said. 'Vandalism isn't the way to be heard. It's costly to clean up defaced walls, and the money comes from taxpayers.' Lawrence Greenspon, co-chair of the monument committee, spoke of his own family's experience of antisemitism. 'My father is a Holocaust survivor. His sister and his mother and father were all killed. My daughter is named after his sister,' Mr. Greenspon said. 'When somebody defaces the National Holocaust Monument, it is personal and it hurts, and particularly when it is such an act of hatred and antisemitism.' With a report from The Canadian Press
National Post
44 minutes ago
- National Post
B.C. premier says it's not him blocking Alberta oil pipeline, it's lack of money, backer
British Columbia Premier David Eby says it's not him standing in the way of Alberta counterpart Danielle Smith's longed-for oil pipeline from Alberta to B.C.'s north coast — it's that there's no proponent, no money and 'no project right now.' Article content It's Eby's latest rebuff to the idea, coming after Smith said on Sunday she could convince him to allow such a pipeline. Article content Article content Article content Eby says that if Smith succeeds in finding a proponent and funding, and assembles a project, then B.C. 'will certainly cross that bridge.' Article content But he says there are already 'countless projects' that B.C. could work on with Alberta to create prosperity in Western Canada. Article content Eby was speaking at a news conference on Monday from Seoul, South Korea, the final stop on a 10-day trade tour through Asia that has also included Japan and Malaysia. Article content Asked about B.C.'s green light last week for a Prince Rupert gas pipeline, Eby said the province was not 'in the business of turning away investments' — but wouldn't speculate whether that applied to an oil pipeline from Alberta. Article content Eby added that he understands Smith is 'keen' on such a project, just as Ontario Premier Doug Ford is 'keen on tunnel underneath the 401.' Article content
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Canada's energy future among top discussions at Calgary's Global Energy Show
The Global Energy Show kicks off at the BMO Centre in Calgary on Tuesday, and it comes amid ongoing national discussions about Canada's energy future. The Global Energy Show kicks off at the BMO Centre in Calgary on Tuesday, and it comes amid ongoing national discussions about Canada's energy future. The Global Energy Show runs June 10-12 at the BMO Centre in Calgary. It's Canada's largest B2B energy event, with over 500 exhibitors and more than 30,000 people expected to attend. 'The talk that's continuing to increase about major infrastructure projects—that's what's really driving more exhibitors and more delegates. Our registration is up by more than one-third compared to the 2024 event,' said Nick Samain on behalf of the Global Energy Show. Premier Danielle Smith will speak at the conference on Wednesday. Ahead of federal approval, she's working to convince B.C. Premier David Eby to allow a new pipeline to transport oil from Alberta to the coast. 'I think it's very clear from our perspective that no other project would provide as large of a positive impact to the Canadian GDP or, frankly, Indigenous economic reconciliation than this particular project,' said Brian Jean, Alberta's minister of energy and minerals. The Global Energy Show runs June 10-12 at the BMO Centre in Calgary. The Global Energy Show runs June 10-12 at the BMO Centre in Calgary. The conference component will host discussions on energy security, climate responsibility and global demand challenges. 'There's change in the air. There's a change in opportunity. Donald Trump has taught us we need to think of Canada first and more of a Team Canada approach on our energy,' said Jean. On Tuesday, OPEC Secretary General Haitham Al Ghais will make the keynote address at 10 a.m.
