Pakistan Refuses Assistance To IndiGo Flight Stuck In Hailstorm Danger
The pilots of the IndiGo plane, which was damaged in rough weather en route to Srinagar, were denied permission by the Lahore ATC to venture briefly into Pakistan airspace to escape the hailstorm, in complete violation of humanitarian norms.
India's civil aviation regulator, the DGCA, said the aircraft was cruising at an altitude of approximately 36,000 feet near Punjab's Pathankot when it ran into a thunderstorm and hailstorm.
Experiencing severe turbulence, the crew first requested the Northern ATC of the Indian Air Force to allow the flight to deviate towards the International Border. However, the request was denied because it was felt that the plane would face danger from the Pakistan side due to the recently witnessed intense hostilities between India and the neighbouring country during Operation Sindoor.
The pilot then sought permission from the Lahore air traffic control (ATC) to briefly venture into Pakistani airspace to avoid the storm. But it was refused, too.
With limited options left, the pilot initially considered returning to Delhi. However, since the aircraft was close to the "thunderstorm cloud", returning was considered an unsafe option. The pilot then decided to continue forward through the storm towards Srinagar on the shortest possible route, the DGCA statement said.
While navigating the thunderstorm, the aircraft encountered "extreme updrafts and downdrafts", leading to the autopilot disengaging and its speed fluctuating.
"While in the thunderstorm cloud, warnings of an angle of attack fault, alternate saw protection lost, and unreliable airspeed indications were triggered," the statement further said.
The DGCA said that at one point, the aircraft's rate of descent reached 8,500 feet per minute. It further said that the crew took manual control of the aircraft during this critical phase till exiting the hailstorm.
The pilot then declared an emergency to the Srinagar ATC, which then activated radar vectors. The flight eventually landed safely in Srinagar with no reported injuries to any of the passengers or crew.
The DGCA said that the plane made a safe landing with the auto thrust system operated manually.
There was no injury to any of the passengers on board the flight. A post-flight check revealed damage to the nose of the aircraft. A full-fledged investigation has been launched into the incident, the statement added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 hours ago
- Indian Express
Avalanches are no longer seasonal inconveniences. They demand urgent attention
It is often said that the mountains have a mind of their own. They increasingly seem to be sending us messages that we are either too slow or too proud to heed. The recent tragedy in Blatten, a serene Swiss village flattened by an avalanche unleashed by the Birch glacier, has stirred global concern. In a region known for meticulous monitoring and preparedness, such devastation underscores how vulnerable even the best-equipped societies are becoming to the ferocity of glacial systems under stress. We, in the Indian subcontinent, have long been acquainted with the wrath of mountains. Avalanches, ice falls, and glacial lake outbursts are not abstract threats for us — they are frequent, brutal realities. In 2016, a monstrous ice collapse at Sonam Post in Siachen buried ten Indian Army soldiers under tonnes of ice. The post sat atop what is termed the 'third pole,' where soldiers live on the edge of human endurance. The odds were always difficult. Despite superhuman rescue efforts, there was little that could be done once nature took its course. In October 2023, a lesser-known but no less alarming incident took place in Sikkim. The South Lhonak Lake burst its banks, triggering a cascade that breached a dam and swept away significant amounts of Indian Army ammunition and stores. Though the loss of human life was lower than in past events, the implications were severe for national security infrastructure. Then there is the Chamoli disaster of February 7, 2021 — a textbook case of how cascading events in the mountains can wreak havoc downstream. An icefall, most likely caused by a detaching glacier chunk, surged into the Rishiganga river, leading to a catastrophic flood. It obliterated a hydropower project and took over 200 lives. An incident that haunts military minds was at Gayari. In April 2012, 129 Pakistani soldiers were entombed under 60 feet of snow after a one-kilometre long swathe of snow struck their position in the Siachen sector. It was nature at its most merciless. In the Gurez sector of Kashmir just a month earlier, 18 Indian soldiers lost their lives when a massive avalanche hit their winter shelters on February 24, 2012. As someone who has commanded troops across multiple mountain sectors, including the Line of Control (LoC) in Kashmir, these are not distant tragedies to me. They are memories, responsibilities, and in one case — deep personal loss. In January 2008, while commanding a division headquartered in Baramulla, I faced an excruciating decision. Meteorological inputs forecasted a severe snowstorm across higher reaches of the LoC. I had nearly a dozen soldiers deployed at 14,000 feet, in a crucial post responsible for preventing terrorist infiltration. The approach route to that post was notoriously avalanche-prone. I assessed that leaving the soldiers there would be tantamount to risking their lives. I requested permission to pre-emptively evacuate them. That request was denied. The rationale? We could not afford a gap in our counter-infiltration posture. In high-altitude command, decisions must be made swiftly; moments of hesitation often make the difference between success and tragedy. My fears were realised. Once we finally initiated the evacuation — ironically, using brave civilian high-altitude porters — an avalanche struck the moving column. We recovered who and what we could. But the moment remains etched in my mind forever: The terrible clarity of knowing that this had been avoidable. This is why avalanches must not be treated merely as natural phenomena. They are increasingly conflict multipliers, logistical disruptors, and silent killers in zones of both peacetime deployment and active conflict. What climate change is now doing is making their frequency and unpredictability worse. Over the past decade, accelerated glacial melt, warmer winters, and erratic snowfall patterns have created instability across the Himalayas and Karakoram ranges. The line between snow and slush is thinner than ever. Despite this, avalanche preparedness in our region remains a challenge. The Defence Geoinformatics Research Establishment (DGRE) — earlier known as SASE — has made significant strides in avalanche forecasting, terrain analysis, and hazard zonation. Its modelling of snow accumulation patterns and vulnerability mapping has greatly helped the armed forces, especially in places like Siachen and Kargil. However, wider dissemination of this critical data and its timely integration into command-level planning still needs streamlining because it's an area relatively less understood. The challenge often remains not just scientific, but institutional — ensuring that precautionary measures are not overridden by operational compulsions. On the disaster management front, there is now some welcome movement. The Central Government has approved the National Glacial Lake Outburst Flood Risk Mitigation Project (NGRMP) with a total outlay of Rs 150 crore. Four Himalayan states — Arunachal Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Sikkim, and Uttarakhand — are part of this vital effort. Of the total cost, Rs 135 crore comes from the National Disaster Mitigation Fund (NDMF), while the states contribute the remaining Rs 15 crore. The project aims to develop early warning systems, reduce vulnerability of downstream settlements, and prepare for potential GLOF (glacial lake outburst flood) events — such as the one that caused devastation in Sikkim in 2023. Just days ago, the International High-Level Conference on Glacier Conservation in Dushanbe underscored these very concerns. Leaders and experts from across Central and South Asia highlighted the deep links between glacier health, water security, climate resilience, and the livelihoods of mountain communities. Special focus was given to the unique vulnerability of high-altitude populations, where climate-induced disasters are beginning to shape patterns of migration, poverty, and socio-political stress. The conference also reinforced the role of glacier conservation in advancing the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) — particularly those relating to clean water, climate action, and sustainable communities. These are not distant, abstract targets. For India, where national security and civilian life both depend on the stability of our glacial regions, they are central to our future. Yet, the most critical shift must be one of mindset. Avalanches and glacial hazards are no longer seasonal inconveniences. They are now frontline risks — endangering soldiers, civilians, and infrastructure alike. We need to enhance knowledge and awareness to bring even greater foresight and urgency. Just as we have grown to understand cyclones and heatwaves better, avalanches now demand their own urgency. Whether in Siachen, Gurez or Blatten, the message is the same: When the mountains warn us, there's hardly time to debate. The writer is a former corps commander of the Srinagar-based 15 Corps and a member of the National Disaster Management Authority. Views are personal
Indian Express
a day ago
- Indian Express
What happened to the IndiGo flight which lost its nose in a hailstorm last month?
On the evening of May 21, IndiGo flight 6E 2142 flying from Delhi to Srinagar experienced extreme turbulence after it was caught in a severe hailstorm. Videos shared by the passengers revealed a scary situation, with the aircraft shaking violently amid flashes of lightning in the windows. And upon landing in Srinagar, it was discovered that a large part of the Airbus A321's nose cone had suffered significant damage due to the hail. We had a narrow escape from Delhi to Srinagar flight indigo. Special thanks to the captain and cabin crew. @indigo @GreaterKashmir @RisingKashmir — I_am_aaqib (@am_aaqib) May 21, 2025 'Flight 6E 2142 encountered bad weather and a hail storm and emergency was reported by the pilot to the ATC. However, the flight landed safely at Srinagar at 8.30 pm. All Aircrfthe inew and passengers are safe,' the spokesperson of the Srinagar Airport Authority said. Thunderstorms pose a grave risk to aircraft and can result in structural failure and loss of control (LOC) accidents. Pilots go to great lengths to avoid or deviate around storm clouds, unless inevitable. Here is everything to know. Thunderstorms are cumulonimbus (CB) clouds, thousands of feet tall and hundreds of miles wide. Some thunderstorm clouds rise over 50,000 ft, well above the maximum altitude an aircraft can climb, and far higher than the ceilings of most aircraft. Types of thunderstorms * Single-cell: The cumulonimbus formation contains only a single thunderstorm cell. The formation of a thunderstorm inside a CB cloud, its maturing and finally its dissipation constitute a cell. * Multi-cell: The cumulonimbus formation contains several thunderstorm cells at different stages of formation and maturation. * Squall line: A multi-cell thunderstorm in which the cells are arranged in a long line stretching hundreds of miles. * Super-cell: A super-cell is a rotating thunderstorm, the rotating movement caused by the presence of a mesocyclone, a rising vortex of air rotating around a vertical axis. Super-cells pack the most destructive weather for flying. * Embedded thunderstorms: Embedded inside ordinary cloud decks, these can be hard to spot visually or without weather radar. Why do thunderstorms pose a threat to aircraft? Thunderstorms pack severe turbulence, hail, heavy rain, icing, lightning, downbursts, microbursts, windshear, updrafts, tornadoes, gusty winds, and engines ingest a lot of water – all of which are a hazard to flying. A thunderstorm's destructive effects can be felt 10 to 20 nautical miles from its outer edges. * Ice accumulation on wings alters their aerodynamic properties and destroys 'lift', the aerodynamic force that keeps an aircraft aloft. Ice crystals can block pitot tubes, the nozzles near an aircraft's nose that feed air to the airspeed indicator. * Lightning can damage an aircraft's skin, communication antennas, electronic navigational equipment and magnetic compass. It can also leave the pilots temporarily blind. * Downbursts, microbursts and updrafts are powerful vertical columns of air moving up or down. An aircraft flying through a downburst, microburst or updraft loses or gains altitude rapidly without pilot inputs. * Windshear is a rogue wind that rapidly changes direction. An aircraft encounters both headwind and tailwind in a windshear. Close to the ground, windshear encounters have led to several fatal air crashes. It was hail that stole the nose cone of the IndiGo A320. In his classic book The Fate is the Hunter, American aviator Ernest K Gann compared his experience of getting caught in a hailstorm with being trapped in a 'tin can' with a 'thousand machine guns' pointed at the aircraft. How does a pilot account for a thunderstorm? A mere thunderstorm warning is not enough basis for an automatic no-go decision. If all pilots of all scheduled flights along a route with a thunderstorm warning were to take a 'no-go' decision outright, it would result in the cancellation of hundreds of flights and impact passengers and airlines. Before each flight, the pilot files a flight plan with the Air Traffic Control detailing all information about the flight: The destination, the aircraft operator, fuel, weight, route, flight time, alternate airports in case of diversion, winds aloft, airspace restrictions, weather en route and at destination (including thunderstorm warning). Thus, the pilot carefully studies the weather before taking a 'go' or 'no-go' decision regarding take-off, even choosing to cancel or delay the departure when necessary. A host of weather bureaus provide weather data to pilots. Aircraft today have onboard weather radar and datalink weather, making modern jets better-equipped to divert or deviate around storms. SIGMET, or Significant Meteorological Information, reports contain warnings about hazardous weather like thunderstorms, turbulence, icing and hail. Onboard weather radar is an effective tool for storm avoidance. Scanning for precipitation, it 'paints' a picture of the weather ahead on a screen in the cockpit: Black patches indicate very light precipitation, green patches indicate light precipitation, yellow medium precipitation, red heavy precipitation and magenta extreme precipitation or turbulence. However, it cannot detect a storm cell hiding behind heavy rain. Every Airbus aircraft is equipped with an Electronic Centralised Aircraft Monitor (ECAM), which displays engine and aircraft system information to pilots along with audio alerts, including system failures and corrective actions to be followed. The Airbus computer operates under three flight control laws. Essentially, when an Airbus is flying under Alternate or Direct Law, the flight is warning its pilots: 'Now be careful with what you do, as my ability to automatically keep the aircraft safe has been reduced.' The pilots of the IndiGo flight, 6E 2142, were confident they could steer the plane away from the path of the thunderstorm. To deviate, they first sought permission from the Indian Air Force's Northern Area Control Centre (NACC) to fly towards the India-Pakistan International Border (IB), which the IAF refused. The Indian Express had cited IAF sources who said that the NACC's directive was 'within the frame of the ban on Indian aircraft in Pakistani airspace'. A request to Lahore ATC to permit a brief entry into Pakistani airspace to bypass the storm was also turned down. The pilots considered turning back, since the flight was likely experiencing the effects of the thunderstorm. 'Crew initially attempted to turn back, but as they were close to the thunderstorm cloud, they decided to penetrate the weather,' the DGCA said in a statement. It is generally not recommended to turn back once inside a storm, as turns can overstress the airframe. Flying straight ahead and 'riding the storm' is the best bet to reach smooth air in minimum time. Inside the storm, the A320 was tossed up and down by severe updrafts and downdrafts, climbing and descending wildly on its own. A severe hailstorm pried out the nose cone protecting the weather radar, which is designed to detect inclement weather. This rendered the radar unusable, with the readings of cockpit gauges exceeding their design limits and likely becoming unreliable and unreadable. The IndiGo crew received multiple fault warnings about aircraft systems, including 'Angle of Attack' fault, 'Alternate Law' loss, unreliable speed, stall and overspeed warnings. It is likely that many of the warning messages the IndiGo pilots received were false alarms. But if they lost Alternate Law protection, it definitely increased their workload at a critical time. Despite the scary scenes, the loss of the aircraft's nose did not pose a direct threat to the passengers within the plane. The passenger cabin is essentially a sealed, pressurised tube, and the hole was outside of this area.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
3 days ago
- First Post
Pakistani dams near dead level, 15% drop in waterflow in Punjab after India's IWT move
Official Pakistani data shows that Pakistan released 15 per cent less water from its dams this week when compared to the same period last year amid concerns after India's IWT move read more A child stands near Chenab River with the Baglihar hydroelectric project in the background, about 155 km northwest of Jammu. File photo/Reuters A sharp drop in water flow from Pakistan's dams in the Indus basin has been recorded following India's move to hold the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance in April. Official Pakistani data shows that Pakistan released 15 per cent less water from its dams this week when compared to the same period last year, amid concerns that India's move to restrict water flow in western rivers can cause a serious shortage. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD On June 5, water release in Pakistan's Punjab fell to 124,000 cusecs from 144,000 cusecs the previous year, according to recent data. The Indus River at Tarbela Dam in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is at 1,465 meters, close to its dead level of 1,402 meters. At Chasma Dam in Punjab, also on the Indus, the water level is 644 meters, just above its dead level of 638 meters. Mangla Dam on the Jhelum River in Mirpur is at 1,163 meters, slightly above its dead level of 1,050 meters. The dead level is the lowest level where outlets are present to drain the water into reservoirs by gravity. Below the dead level, water pumps have to be used to drain the water. A top government source in Pakistan told Network 18 that situation in Pakistan was critical, especially for late Kharif season. 'The situation in Pakistan is clearly grave, especially for the late Kharif season from June till September," the source said. They added that the situation will only improve once Monsoon season arrives. 21% water shortage anticipated Pakistan expects a 21 per cent water shortage because of India's actions during the early Kharif season, which runs until June 10. The situation is especially serious at Marala in Sialkot, Punjab, where the Chenab River's average flow fell to 3,064 cusecs on June 5 from 26,645 cusecs on May 28, according to Pakistani data. Heatwave makes matters worse Pakistan is facing worsening conditions due to a severe heatwave forecast from June 8, with daytime temperatures expected to be 5 to 7°C above normal in central and upper Punjab, Islamabad, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Kashmir, and Gilgit-Baltistan. Last month, Pakistan stated that a 'crisis had been created by Indian short supplies in Chenab River", leading to shortages in the Kharif season. Pakistan has called India's actions an 'act of war' and warned that water could spark the next conflict.
