No action on High Court assessment of needs disability as last government ‘couldn't agree'
The last
government
did not act on a
High Court
decision three years ago on assessments of need for children with
disabilities
because 'there wasn't agreement' on it, Taoiseach
Micheál Martin
has said.
In 2022 the High Court ruled that assessments of need should take more than 30 hours, which resulted in the HSE changing its model of assessment.
More than 15,000 children have been waiting longer than six months for assessment and 25,000 are expected to be in this situation by the end of the year.
Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan said the accelerated procedure 'was struck down for a good reason. It consisted of one hour of observed play time and a 30-minute discussion with a parent.
READ MORE
'Children were then diagnosed as having a disability but not told which disability they had. It was a completely inadequate box-ticking exercise. Are you telling us that this is a system that you're going to return to, or is your plan to get rid of assessment and need altogether?' he asked Taoiseach Micheál Martin.
[
Government 'all talk but no action' on disability assessment backlog, says activist
Opens in new window
]
Mr Martin said, 'I have no intention of going back on the standing operating procedures' that applied before the High Court ruling.
But he said, 'I believe when the High Court makes a decision it is clinicians that should ultimately decide in terms of the nature and type of provision on therapy, medicine or anything.
'The last government did not follow through for different reason. There wasn't agreement in respect of it after the High Court decision.'
The Taoiseach said, 'an assessment of evaluation is not a static thing, nor should it be. As a child develops, the child needs ongoing review' and the Government had decided to have a national 'in-school therapy service', a 'red-line' issue for this Government.
Mr O'Callaghan said 'that is an astonishing answer'.
'When 15,000 children are waiting for needs assessments 'you haven't got your act together in this because the previous government couldn't agree on what to do'.
Mr O'Callaghan said: 'You've been talking around changing the law, hiring more people. But when are you actually going to stop breaking the law?'
[
Government to change law in bid to speed up autism and disability assessments
Opens in new window
]
Accusing Mr O'Callaghan of 'deliberate distortion', the Taoiseach said this Government will deal with the court decision but the previous government had dealt with a lot of other related issues, including a 30 per cent increase in assessments in 2023 and a 65 per cent increase in the first three months of this year compared to last.
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald said the Taoiseach had met Cara Darmody on Wednesday morning and 'you gave no commitments'.
Mr Martin confirmed he met the teenager on Wednesday morning and 'we discussed all the issues involved and I outlined what the Government is going to do'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Government to further discuss proposals to reform rent caps
Further discussions are expected to take place tonight among Government party leaders and the ministers for Housing, Finance and Public Expenditure ahead of an expected Cabinet decision tomorrow on Rent Pressure Zones (RPZs). Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the proposals are well balanced and they would give greater protections to renters and provide certainty for investors. However, this is a contentious political decision. Already, the Government has been accused of throwing renters to the vulture funds, but it remains resolute that it will take action. Under the plans, which will be pored over again, rents in newly built properties will no longer be capped at 2% annually but will instead be tied to the rate of inflation. The proposal, which Minister for Housing James Browne will bring to Cabinet, will likely state that there will be no changes for existing renters if they stay in their current tenancy. However, if they move a landlord can reset the rent for the new tenant at the market rate. There will also be protections for new renters which will provide security of tenure for at least six years.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on Ireland's research agenda: the vital role of innovation
It is not surprising that there are demands made, almost on a daily basis, by lobby and special interest groups for the State to increase funding. After all, Ireland has one of the healthiest fiscal surpluses among OECD member states. It is also one of the fastest growing economies, which is putting significant pressure on existing capacity. There is no doubt that almost every call made on the government to increase spending has some justification. But decisions must be made on the basis of what is best for the country in the long term rather than political expediency. The State must, as one key priority, focus on investment that lifts the long-term potential of the economy. In this context, the Government should consider Ibec's calls to increase public investment in research and innovation to 1 per cent of Gross National Income (GNI) by 2035. Donald Trump's second term as US president has underlined the growing vulnerability of Ireland's foreign direct investment model. These include moves to try to force pharma companies and other multinationals to relocate capacity to the US. There is also the growing risk of a global trade war, which will accelerate de-globalisation. READ MORE Against this backdrop, every effort must be made to build up the domestic economy. Producing a world class research and innovation infrastructure is an effective way of doing this. Moreover, Trump's attacks on universities are poised to grow, which will lead to a steady brain drain from the US. Increased investment in research and innovation would put Ireland in a much better position to attract some of this talent. Right now, poor funding of the sector here means the goal of attracting key researchers from the US is a nice headline, but one with little substance. Ireland also has work to do to underpin the funding of the third level sector, for both undergraduate and graduate students, which has a key role in underpinning innovation. Education has been vital to the longer-term success of the economy, but there is a sense of complacency about our position which needs to be tackled
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Young people and AI
Sir, – In one of his first speeches as pope, Leo XIV outlined his priorities for his papacy. Interestingly, one of these is the challenges posed by artificial intelligence (AI). The pope believes that AI is a threat to 'humanity, justice and labour'. He said that this was one of the key reasons for him choosing the name Leo XIV. He had spoken previously about the impact of the industrial revolution on workers' rights. We are now arguably going through another 'industrial revolution' of sorts. Before, it was concerns that machines would replace people and take their jobs. Now it's the same but with AI. We adapted before and we can adapt again; not by trying to beat AI by being robots but by fully embracing our humanity – the qualities that set us apart from AI, qualities like our emotions, our ability to connect and build strong, trusting relationships and our ability to empathise. READ MORE If we are fully human, if we stop trying to beat AI at its own game, AI can never truly replace us, never truly do away with the need for real, human people in the workforce and in society. As a young person, I'm often asked the question, 'what do you want to be when you grow up?' Whatever answer I give, the response is usually: 'Oh, that job will be done away it; AI will be doing it in the future.' But I remain hopeful, faithful that I will be needed in society. And that AI can't replace humans if we are truly human, fully ourselves. – Yours, etc, TESS LIFFEY, Birr, Co Offaly.
