Starmer's immigration comments ‘dumbest of dumb politics', says Sturgeon
The British Prime Minister's immigration speech this week was the 'dumbest of dumb politics', former Scottish first minister Nicola Sturgeon has said.
Keir Starmer had come in for criticism after he said the UK risked becoming an 'island of strangers' if new immigration curbs were not implemented, with some drawing comparisons to Enoch Powell's infamous 'rivers of blood' speech, assertions rejected by Number 10.
Advertisement
Speaking during a campaign visit in Blantyre, South Lanarkshire, ahead of the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election next month, former first minister Nicola Sturgeon hit out at the Prime Minister, accusing him of a 'very deliberate dog whistle'.
Ms Sturgeon talked up the benefits of immigration to Scotland, describing diversity as 'one of our strengths' and urging 'progressive politicians' to push back against anti-immigrant rhetoric.
Asked if the British Prime Minister was aware his comments could draw comparisons to Enoch Powell, the former first minister said: 'There's one of two answers to that.
'Either he was aware, in which case it's disgraceful, or he wasn't aware, in which case: what is he doing in the senior position he's in?
Advertisement
'For goodness' sake, he is Prime Minister, he's not some political newbie with no experience.
'Of course he knew that was a very deliberate dog whistle, and you know what? Shame on him.'
Monday's comments, Ms Sturgeon added, have not boosted support for Labour.
'The limited polling and real voting evidence that we've seen since he made those comments show that it's not doing him any good,' she said.
Advertisement
'That's the real irony of this – the more he legitimises the politics of Reform, the more he will boost Reform at his expense.
'So it's not even smart politics.'
The British Prime Minister announced changes to the immigration system on Monday (Ian Vogler/PA)
She added: 'Even if, and this is not my view, you decide that principles don't matter … it's really dumb politics.
'It's the dumbest of dumb politics.'
Advertisement
This week, she said, had been 'one of the most disreputable' in the history of the Labour Party, adding: 'At a time when we need progressive politicians to stand up and take on and beat the arguments of Nigel Farage, we've seen Keir Starmer lie down and surrender to Nigel Farage with his policies on immigration.
'Which are wrong in principle, but would be devastating, catastrophic for the Scottish economy and for big sections of our public sector in Scotland.
'We need to see politicians stand up and take the argument to Reform, and instead we see Labour rolling over and surrendering.'
Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: 'Nicola Sturgeon left her party and the country in a disastrous state, and it seems she still has not found the gift of introspection.
Advertisement
'Promoting her own personal brand for financial gain might be Nicola's main aim now but she leaves behind her an atrocious record of soaring levels of homeless children and a crashed NHS – all a personal indictment of her disastrous time as first minister.
'It was Nicola Sturgeon who was the health secretary and first minister that fought tooth and nail against fair pay and rights for care workers, and left behind a wake of wasted money and services in deadly crisis.
'If Nicola Sturgeon wants to see a politician that has created division, ruined public services and set back workers' rights, she need only look in the mirror.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
26 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Zia Yusuf returns to Reform 48 hours after resigning
Zia Yusuf has returned to Reform UK two days after he quit as party chairman. Mr Yusuf announced his departure with a social media post on X on Thursday, declaring that his work for Nigel Farage was no longer 'a good use of my time'. His resignation was triggered by a disagreement with Sarah Pochin, the party's newest MP, after she called for a burka ban in the House of Commons, which he described as 'dumb'. The 38-year-old businessman, who is a practising Muslim, will now rejoin the party's senior team in a new role. In an interview with The Sunday Times, he said his resignation had been a 'mistake' and a result of 'exhaustion'.
Telegraph
27 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Koran burner told of imminent terror threat to his life
An asylum seeker who burnt the Koran has received a police warning of an imminent terror plot to murder him, The Telegraph understands. Hamit Coskun was woken by officers acting on behalf of the Metropolitan Police at 2am on Saturday, who told him of 'an imminent threat', his lawyers said. The officers, who were from another force at a location where Coskun is in hiding, are understood to have read out what is known as an Osman warning. The 50-year-old was last week convicted of a racially aggravated public order offence, after shouting 'f--- Islam' and 'Islam is religion of terrorism' while setting fire to the religious text above his head during a protest on Feb 13. His supporters have accused the Met Police and Crown Prosecution Service of putting his life in danger by pursuing a prosecution against him. The court heard that Coskun, who was living in Derby and had to move to a safe house after a video of the incident was posted online, had been forced to leave his home country of Turkey two and a half years ago to escape persecution. In a letter to Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley, on behalf of Coskun, Lord Young of Acton, General Secretary of the Free Speech Union, stated: 'We consider that the risk to Mr Coskun's life was caused, in part, by the actions of your officers and the CPS. Danger from 'Islamic extremists' 'Your force had repeatedly suggested publicly that Mr Coskun had offended the 'religious institution of Islam'. Doing so has increased the risk to Mr Coskun from Islamic extremists.' Police are obliged to issue an Osman warning when there is intelligence of the threat, but there is not enough evidence to justify the police arresting the potential murderer. A spokesman for the Met Police said: 'There remains an ongoing police investigation in relation to allegations of threats to kill against a 50-year-old male. Given the investigation is ongoing, we won't be able to comment further at this stage.' Coskun was prosecuted under the Public Order Act after burning a copy of the Koran outside the Turkish Consulate in Knightsbridge. Critics of the decision to prosecute him accused British courts of reviving blasphemy laws by the back door in pursuing his prosecution. Robert Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, said: 'This decision is wrong. It revives a blasphemy law that parliament repealed. 'Free speech is under threat. I have no confidence in two-tier Keir to defend the rights of the public to criticise all religions.' 'De facto blasphemy laws' Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch added on social media: 'De facto blasphemy laws will set this country on the road to ruin. This case should go to appeal. Freedom of belief and freedom not to believe are inalienable rights in Britain. 'I'll defend those rights to my dying day.' Blasphemy laws were abolished in the UK 17 years ago. In a statement after the verdict, Coskun said the decision was 'an assault on free speech' that would deter others from exercising their democratic right to protest. He added: 'As an activist, I will continue to campaign against the threat of Islam. 'Christian blasphemy laws were repealed in this country more than 15 years ago, and it cannot be right to prosecute someone for blaspheming against Islam. 'Would I have been prosecuted if I'd set fire to a copy of the Bible outside Westminster Abbey? I doubt it.' He has pledged to continue burning Korans and intends to go on a tour of the UK, visiting Birmingham, Liverpool and Glasgow, where he will set fire to the holy book. It is unclear if he will resist doing so until the case is heard at appeal - should he be able to challenge the verdict against him in a higher court. The CPS said that Coskun was not being prosecuted for burning the book. They argued it was the combination of his derogatory remarks about Islam and the fact that it was done in public that made it an offence. The CPS originally charged Coskun, who is an atheist, with harassing the 'religious institution of Islam'. CPS charge amended However, the charge was later amended after free speech campaigners took up his cause and argued he was essentially being accused of blasphemy. Katy Thorne KC, Coskun's barrister, had argued that his actions were not motivated by hostility towards the followers of Islam, but the religion itself. District Judge John McGarva, however, said he did not accept that argument. Giving his verdict, Judge McGarva said: 'Your actions in burning the Koran where you did were highly provocative, and your actions were accompanied by bad language in some cases directed toward the religion and were motivated at least in part by hatred of followers of the religion.' The judge ordered Coskun, who is currently claiming asylum, to pay a fine of £240. A man has admitted assaulting Coskun during his demonstration outside the Turkish Embassy, but has denied using a knife in the attack. The man, whose identity is subject to reporting restrictions, is due to go on trial in 2027.
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Zia Yusuf makes astonishing return to Reform UK just 48 hours after quitting as party chairman
Zia Yusuf has sensationally announced he is returning to Reform UK - just 48 hours after quitting as the party's chairman. The businessman, who said his decision to quit was a 'mistake' that came as the result of exhaustion, will take up a new role in the party following peace talks with Nigel Farage. While his formal title has not been decided, he is expected to lead Reform's Elon Musk-inspired Doge unit, as well as overseeing some aspects of policymaking, fundraising and media appearances for the party. It comes just two days after Mr Yusuf said he no longer believes 'working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time'.
