Young children should avoid drinks with sweeteners, experts say
Pre-school children should not be given drinks laden with sugar or artificial sweeteners, experts have said.
Younger children – typically those under the age of five – were already advised not to consume sugary drinks.
Now experts advising government have said they should not be given 'drinks sweetened with sugar or NSS (non-sugar sweeteners)'.
Academics said that limiting intake of sweetened drinks in early childhood means that children become accustomed to drinking unsweetened drinks.
But for older children sweeteners 'may help reduce sugar intake', experts said.
The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN) also said that younger children should be given 'unsweetened food (not sweetened with either sugar or NSS)'.
Low or no calorie sweeteners are used instead of sugar to sweeten some foods and drinks.
These substances are found in products such as drinks, desserts and ready meals and cakes.
Sweeteners approved for use in the UK include acesulfame K, aspartame, erythritol, saccharin, sorbitol, steviol glycosides, sucralose and xylitol.
Some squash drinks, which are popular with children, contain sweeteners such as sucralose and acesulfame K.
Scientific evidence has linked sugar consumption to a range of health conditions including obesity and type 2 diabetes.
Because of the ability of artificial and natural sweeteners to impart a sweet taste without calories, some have argued they can help to prevent people becoming overweight or obese
But global health leaders from the World Health Organisation said in 2023 that people should avoid NSS as a tool for weight control.
The latest SACN update is in response to this report.
Experts on the committee, which advises government on nutrition and related health matters, said some of the evidence assessed by the WHO about sweeteners and weight loss should be 'treated with caution'.
It said the evidence linking NSS to non-communicable diseases is 'concerning' but should also be 'treated with caution'.
The evidence on the impact of NSS on tooth decay is 'poor', the committee added.
The SACN said it agrees with the WHO that a reduction in free sugars, alongside 'other positive changes to diet', is likely to be beneficial to health overall.
It added: 'In relation to the use of NSS to reduce free sugars intake, SACN concludes that the evidence indicates that there may be some value in using NSS to help reduce weight gain in the short to medium term but it is not essential and is not the only option.'
The committee said it is 'concerned about the gap in data on UK population exposure to NSS'.
And it said there is 'currently insufficient evidence to carry out a full risk assessment of the evidence on NSS and health.'
Nonetheless, the committee made 'precautionary' recommendations that younger children should not have drinks sweetened with sugar or NSS, and they should only be given unsweetened food.
But the group of experts say that for older children 'swapping sugars for NSS may help reduce sugar intake from foods and drinks (and so reduce energy intake), at least in the short term – the long-term goal is to limit both sugar and NSS intake'.
Commenting on the recommendations, Naveed Sattar, professor of cardiometabolic medicine at the University of Glasgow, said: 'I think this is a very balanced statement.
'SACN have accepted that the best quality evidence available (ie randomised trials) show that non-sugar sweeteners (NSS) lower weight albeit modestly as compared to taking sugar rich drinks and that other types of evidence which suggest some harm from NSS are unreliable.
'I fully agree and would rather people take low calorie drinks with artificial sweeteners every time than sugar rich drinks both for weight and dental benefits and potentially other gains.
'However, SACN also correctly points out that until we have more evidence in the future on benefits and safety of NSS, it would be best to limit the intake of all such sweetened (including NSS) drinks in early childhood so that children become accustomed to drinking unsweetened drinks, preferably water.'
Dr Hilda Mulrooney, reader in nutrition and health at London Metropolitan University, added: 'Recommendations were already – and have been for several years – that ideally young children should not drink squash – milk or water are the best options.
'Sugar sweetened squash is not recommended due to the sugar content but even sweetened with NSS, it enhances preferences for sweet tastes in children which can be hard to overcome.'
Prof Robin May, chief scientific adviser for the Food Standards Agency (FSA), said: 'We welcome SACN's advice on the consumption of non-sugar sweeteners and their call for further research.
'All sweeteners approved for use in foods in GB have been subject to a rigorous risk assessment before being authorised and the FSA maintains strict oversight of these products.
'We strongly support SACN's call for industry to make data on the quantity of these sweeteners in their ingredients publicly available to provide better information on how much people are consuming and to help inform our assessments of these ingredients.'
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'This government is committed to turning the tide on obesity and we have already taken bold action to block fast-food outlets near schools, alongside further measures to crack down on child-targeted junk food advertising on TV and online.
'These are just the first steps we'll take as we shift the focus from sickness to prevention to deliver our Plan for Change and meet our ambition of raising the healthiest generation of children ever.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
2 days ago
- Politico
WHO sounds the alarm as US measles cases mount
Presented by Driving The Day WHO SPEAKS UP ON MEASLES — President Donald Trump might not care for the World Health Organization's advice, but that isn't stopping one of its top officials from warning his administration about what's at stake as measles cases accumulate in the U.S. Dr. Katherine O'Brien, the WHO's vaccines director, told POLITICO's Carmen Paun that U.S. political leaders should clearly endorse and promote measles vaccination to prevent the country from losing its disease-elimination status — and become a location that gives rise to future outbreaks that can easily spread domestically and abroad among travelers. If the disease spreads continuously for a year, it would be considered endemic for the first time in 25 years. 'It's really a sign of a country going backwards in terms of their ability to protect people,' O'Brien said. Why it matters: O'Brien said 'leadership voices really matter' when people consider medical interventions for their children. If one family is influenced enough to decline the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine for their child, that's 'one child too many,' she said, given how highly contagious the virus is. Measles is 'not just a fever and a rash that people get over,' O'Brien said. So far this year, three unvaccinated people — including two young girls — have died from the disease in the U.S. Before the most recent outbreak, the last U.S. measles death occurred in 2015. Background: HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has couched his promotion of the MMR shot with statements emphasizing that vaccination is a personal choice. Before he ran for president and then entered government, Kennedy founded Children's Health Defense, an anti-vaccine nonprofit that suggests shots cause a slew of pediatric medical problems such as autism, asthma and developmental delays. Kennedy has also inaccurately asserted that the MMR vaccine contains cells from aborted fetuses and has touted supplements like vitamin A as a disease treatment. HHS has defended the secretary's measles response, calling 'claims' that he's 'spreading misinformation or undermining vaccine confidence … flat-out false.' WELCOME TO FRIDAY PULSE. I'm FDA reporter Lauren Gardner, filling in for Kelly today. Pass along your tips, scoops and feedback to lgardner@ and khooper@ and follow along @Gardner_LM or @Kelhoops. POLITICO PRO SPACE — Need an insider's guide to the politics behind the new space race? From battles over sending astronauts to Mars to the ways space companies are vying to influence regulators, this weekly newsletter decodes the personalities, policy and power shaping the final frontier. Find out more. In Congress THIRD RAIL NO MORE? Senate Republicans are considering ways to incorporate Medicare cuts into their domestic spending package to help offset its cost — a move that could divide a party that can't afford many defections to pass the president's signature legislation, POLITICO's Jordain Carney, Meredith Lee Hill and Robert King report. The House version of President Donald Trump's big beautiful bill includes cuts to Medicaid, the government health insurance program for low-income people and those with disabilities. But cuts to Medicare — which insures those 65 and older — are widely seen as politically dangerous. The idea percolated in private meetings this week as GOP leaders try to placate budget hardliners who want more spending cuts in the package ahead of a self-imposed July 4 deadline for passage. And some Republicans believe Trump supports Medicare cuts — provided they're limited to targeting 'waste, fraud and abuse' — despite the potential for backlash from rank-and-file senators and House moderates who already sank efforts to touch the program. HEADING TO THE HUMPHREY BUILDING — The Senate confirmed Jim O'Neill on Thursday in a 52-43 vote to be HHS's deputy secretary, your morning host writes. O'Neill, a George W. Bush-era HHS official who's close with early Trump supporter and tech billionaire Peter Thiel, will be the department's No. 2 official charged with managing operations. AROUND THE AGENCIES FDA'S RARE DISEASE DRUG APPROACH — The FDA's leading biologics regulator said Thursday that he was open to using alternative measurement methods when evaluating rare-disease therapies, combining what he called 'gold-standard science and common sense' in the approval process. 'We will rapidly make available therapies at the first sign or promise of biomedical success or action, but we're also going to follow up overall survival and quality of life on the back end,' Dr. Vinay Prasad, director of the FDA's Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, said during an agency roundtable on cell and gene therapies. The remarks were notable given Prasad's history of criticizing past FDA approvals of certain treatments, including a controversial Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene therapy and certain cancer drugs, using surrogate markers. Prasad added he's often asked whether he's 'solely' interested in randomized controlled trials and said he's open to a variety of methodologies demonstrating a drug's benefit. Background: His remarks come weeks after he and Commissioner Marty Makary unveiled a new Covid-19 vaccine framework that limits approvals of future formulation changes to people 65 and older and younger individuals with an underlying condition — and requiring new RCTs to prove the shots are safe and effective for young, healthy people. Cell and gene therapies are often discussed in the context of rare diseases as the technologies can address root causes instead of solely managing symptoms. But a condition's rarity hinders a company's ability to conduct a large-scale trial for a drug candidate, an issue with which regulators and industry have long struggled. The FDA launched a rare disease 'hub' last year to better align its drug and biologics regulators in their approach to considering those therapies for the market. NIH LOOKS TO AI — The National Institutes of Health is building an AI strategy to help HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. target chronic disease, POLITICO's Ruth Reader reports. Principal Deputy Director Matthew Memoli announced the plan Thursday, asking the public to weigh in at the Coalition for Health AI's Innovation Summit at Stanford University. NIH wants industry to comment on both the broad approach and the specific actions the administration should take in developing the strategy. The agency plans to create a new website to highlight its AI work. 'Addressing this crisis is going to require large-scale efforts — research that's going to generate large amounts of data — and we are going to need all the tools available to us in order to try to address this,' Memoli said. Names in the News Courtney Rhodes is now head of news and media relations at the U.S. Travel Association. She was previously a spokesperson at the FDA. The Health Resources and Services Administration announced its new 34-member board of directors for the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network. WHAT WE'RE READING House FDA appropriators advanced their fiscal 2026 spending measure Thursday for the agency and the U.S. Department of Agriculture, POLITICO's David Lim reports. Infectious disease and other medical experts fear HHS's changes to Covid-19 vaccine recommendations will make it more difficult to immunize people by complicating discussions with providers and likely leading to fewer places stocking them, Stat's Helen Branswell writes.
Forbes
2 days ago
- Forbes
Food Safety Depends On Every Link In The Supply Chain
Colorful fish and vegetables can be purchased at a public market. For communities to be nourished, their food supply must be safe to eat. This sounds obvious, but it's worth repeating, because every year, about 1 in 10 people worldwide (or about 600 million people) become sick from contaminated food, and 420,000 lose their lives. About 125,000 of those deaths annually are children under 5 years old—a disproportionate tragedy that comes at the expense of our future. And in low- and mid-income countries, US$110 billion is lost every year in productivity and medical expenses resulting from unsafe food, per World Health Organization (WHO) data. Addressing food safety is truly crucial not just to our lives but to our livelihoods, our economic success, and the well-being of every aspect of the food system. World Food Safety Day, on June 7, is a perfect opportunity for everyone around the globe to recommit to ensuring a safe food supply for all. 'Food safety is not just about preventing harm,' says Markus Lipp, Senior Food Safety Officer at the UN Food and Agriculture Organization. 'It is about creating confidence and trust in the food we eat, in the systems that protect us, that protect food safety and in the institutions that serve the public good for safe food.' So how do we ensure the future of food is safe? First: Food safety is not isolated—every link along the food chain must prioritize safety. Food safety begins on fields and farms, with healthy soils and positive growing practices, and continues through processing, transportation, cooking, and serving. This whole-system approach can be truly transformative. In fact, many of the 200+ diseases 'that we know can be carried by food are preventable and sometimes even eradicable,' says Luz María De Regil, Director of the Department of Nutrition and Food Safety at WHO. Second: We can't just respond to challenges that currently exist; we have to be prepared to face unprecedented and complex challenges to food safety as the climate crisis worsens. According to the WHO, the changing climate will affect the persistence and occurrence of bacteria, viruses, parasites, harmful algae, and fungi—and the vectors that spread them. 'We're going to have emerging pathogens coming in, especially given that the climate is changing…microbes like hot, humid, wet environments,' said Barbara Kowalcyk, an Associate Professor at the Milken Institute School of Public Health. Third: Perhaps most urgently, we need to champion evidence-based policymaking and global cooperation. This year's World Food Safety Day highlights this, focusing particularly on the 'essential role of science in ensuring food safety and enabling informed decision-making.' Now more than ever, we need to devote more resources to scientific progress, international collaboration, and solid regulatory frameworks—not less. But recent cuts to research funding and staff in the United States by the Trump-Vance Administration, including in food safety inspection labs, are having concerning ripple effects across the globe. Foodborne illness outbreaks could become harder to detect and contain, leading to more people in more widespread areas getting sick, experts warn. In addition, the dismantling of the U. S. Agency for international Development (USAID) shuttered several Feed the Future Innovation Labs, which brought university research to countries including Kenya, Nepal, Nigeria, Bangladesh, Ethiopia, Ghana, and Guatemala to design and implement food safety interventions in poultry production, post-harvest crop storage, farmers markets, households, and more. So this World Food Safety Day, WHO's calls to action encourage all of us—policymakers, business leaders, and eaters—to step up. Communities can find ways to apply the WHO's Global Strategy for Food Safety 2022-2030, to ensure that all people, everywhere, consume safe and healthy food. And initiatives like the GAIN's EatSafe program and the Codex Alimentarius Commission, which aims to standardize evidence-based food safety protocols in ways that respect local culture, offer models to learn from. I often think of something Abdou Tenkouano told me last year. At that time he was the Executive Director of CORAF, an organization in West and Central Africa that uses agriculture to build community resilience, and now he's Director General at icipe, which uses insect science to tackle food security, health, and environmental challenges in Africa. 'This is a global village,' he said. 'We are all interconnected, interdependent, interlinked.' And when it comes to food, we all have a responsibility to keep one another safe.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Brits issued Covid booster warning as cases of new strain rise
Brits have been urged to get their Covid booster jabs, as experts warned of a rise in cases following a recent spell of warm weather. The message comes after health experts also warned of a new COVID-19 variant, with cases of the strain are on the rise around the world. Covid NB.1.8.1 is a variation of the XDV.1.5.1 strain and was first detected back in January 2025. Ifti Khan, superintendent pharmacist at Well Pharmacy, urged those eligible to book as soon as possible and get the booster while it is still available. He said: 'Covid will most likely rise coming into the end of spring and into summer as people mix with friends and family more often. 'We know from previous boosters that they are effective in making sure that patients' symptoms are not as severe as they might have been without so I would urge patients to pop into their local Well Pharmacy store and get their jab. 'Patients have just over two weeks as the spring booster programme ends on June 17 so it would be my hope that those who can get a jab, opt to do so before enjoying socialising during summer.' Mr Khan warned that at this time of year, some people may believe they have hay fever as early symptoms of Covid include a runny or blocked nose or a sore throat. Covid tests can be obtained at any Well Pharmacy. The WHO has placed the Covid NB.1.8.1 "under monitoring" due to the rise in cases worldwide. It is one of six COVID-19 variants currently being monitored. The new 'Strategic and operational plan for coronavirus disease threat management: at a glance' sets out the global framework for supporting Member States in the sustained, integrated, evidence-based management of coronavirus disease threats, including #COVID19, MERS, and… — World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) May 28, 2025 However, the WHO stated that the risk posed by the new variant was "low," and that approved COVID-19 vaccines are expected to be effective against it. The world health experts, in a recent risk evaluation, said: "Despite a concurrent increase in cases and hospitalisations in some countries where NB.1.8.1 is widespread, current data do not indicate that this variant leads to more severe illness than other variants in circulation. The WHO added: "The available evidence on NB.1.8.1 does not suggest additional public health risks relative to the other currently circulating Omicron descendent lineages." COVID NB.1.8.1 has already been detected in 22 countries. These include the likes of Australia, China, Hong Kong, Thailand and the US, according to The Independent. The coming COVID-19 Winter Surge in Australia will show the world where we are actually headed is happening in South-Eats Asia and East Asia are just the 'preludes'...watch how NB.1.8.1 spawns are evolving including PQ.1, PQ.2 and even sub-lineages like PE.1. — Thailand Medical News (@ThailandMedicaX) June 4, 2025 Cases of the NB.1.8.1 variant have also been confirmed in Northern Ireland, Wales, and "popular British tourist hotspots", the news outlet added.
