Why did Republican senators abandon Alex Padilla?
It was one of the most dramatic moments of the hotly-contested 2008 presidential campaign between Barack Obama and John McCain. Remember?
A woman stood up at a McCain campaign rally and said, 'I can't trust Obama. I have read about him, and he's not, he's not — he's an Arab.' Before she could continue, McCain immediately reached out, took the microphone from her, shook his head, and said: 'No, ma'am. He's a decent family man, a citizen that I just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues, and that's what this campaign is all about.'
It was a magic moment. Unfortunately, it's also a rare moment these days — when a politician demonstrates not only courage, but also decency, civility and respect for a fellow politician, regardless of party. And it's just that sense of decency, civility and respect that was so woefully lacking last week in the silence of Republican senators after the violent treatment of fellow Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.) in a Los Angeles federal building.
First, let's be clear about what happened and what did not. Watch the video. Padilla did not, as alleged, 'charge' Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem. Padilla did not 'lunge' at the secretary. Padilla did not resist arrest. Nor did he fail to identify himself. He did so verbally, and the polo shirt he wore said 'United States Senate.'
In a meeting with federal agents, the senator was informed that Noem was holding a news conference, at that very hour, in the same building. He was escorted to the briefing by a National Guard officer and an FBI agent. For several minutes, Padilla stood silently in the back of the room. But when the secretary said she was in Los Angeles 'to liberate this city from the socialist and burdensome leadership that this governor and this mayor have placed on this country,' Padilla felt obliged to respond.
He stepped forward, raised his voice, and said loudly and clearly: 'I am Sen. Alex Padilla, and I have questions for the secretary.' At which point, FBI agents tackled the senator even as he continued to identify himself, threw him to the ground, handcuffed him, and dragged him out of the room.
You would think anyone with a sense of decency would agree, despite any differences over policy, that this was an ugly, appalling and unnecessarily violent way to treat any sitting U.S. senator. You know John McCain would have condemned such an abuse of force. But not Noem. And, worse yet, only one of Padilla's Republican colleagues had the courtesy to do so.
Even after it was clear that the man handcuffed and dragged out of the room was a senator, Noem still defended the way he was roughed up and — wait for it — insisted she didn't even know who he was.
That in itself is appalling: that a Cabinet secretary did not recognize a U.S. senator, especially when she is speaking in his state about immigration there and he is the ranking Democrat on the Senate Subcommittee on Immigration.
Even more appalling was the response from Republicans in Congress. Democrats rushed to condemn the way Padilla was treated. But only two Republican senators had anything negative to say about it at all. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) called the incident 'horrible' and 'shocking at every level.' She continued: 'It's not the America I know.' Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), although she did not go so far as to explicitly condemn the violent treatment of Padilla, called it 'very disturbing.'
But other Republicans either refused to comment or even applauded Padilla's treatment. Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) accused Padilla of 'making a spectacle of himself.' House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) went so far as to say Padilla should be censured by the Senate. Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) sniffed that Padilla 'got what he wanted, he's on TV.'
And the response from the vast majority of Republican representatives and senators was: crickets. What a shameful lack of common courtesy and decency and courage. After all, how difficult would it be for members of Congress to stand together and say: 'We may disagree with our friends across the aisle on many issues, but on this we all agree: Every member of Congress, Republican, Democrat, and Independent, deserves to be treated with the utmost respect. Especially when he or she has committed no crime, and is only doing their job.'
It wasn't so long ago when people used to make fun of senators for being so polite toward one another, using phrases like 'My good friend from Tennessee,' or 'the distinguished senator from Ohio,' but no longer.
Where's John McCain when we need him?
Bill Press is host of 'The Bill Press Pod.' He is the author of 'From the Left: A Life in the Crossfire.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
37 minutes ago
- Politico
GOP megabill faces grim polling for Republicans
As the Senate continues to work through the House-passed megabill, the public's opinion of the legislation is starting to shape — and so far it's not looking good for Republicans. A series of polls released in recent days have revealed the bill, which would be President Donald Trump's signature piece of legislation in his second term's first year, is broadly unpopular except with self-proclaimed MAGA Republicans. The 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act', which narrowly passed the House late last month, includes tax changes and Medicaid cuts, two key issues that are still being debated by the Senate as it rushes to meet Trump's July 4 deadline. Here are three takeaways from the recent surveys: Three separate polls released in the last week showed that more Americans who are aware of the legislation do not support it, though the split remains largely along party lines. A Washington Post-Ipsos poll released Tuesday found that 42 percent of Americans are not in favor of the bill, while 23 percent support it and 34 percent say they have no opinion. A KFF Health Tracking poll also found more adults dislike the bill than support it, with 64 percent of adults having an unfavorable view of the legislation and 35 percent having a favorable view. Meanwhile, a Quinnipiac University poll released last week found that 53 percent of voters oppose the bill, with 27 percent supporting and 20 percent not offering an opinion. Separated along party lines, a majority of Republicans who have an opinion support the legislation, but not by the margin in which Democrats oppose it. Across the three polls, 49 percent to 61 percent of Republicans support the bill. Among Democrats, however, 70 percent to 90 percent are against it. The KFF Health Tracking poll asked Republicans and Republican-leaning independents if they are a 'supporter of the MAGA movement,' which revealed a further split in the polling. Among self-professed MAGA Republicans, support for the bill went up to 72 percent, while Republicans who did not identify as part of the MAGA movement held an unfavorable view of the bill at a 2-to-1 margin, 66 percent to 33 percent. Since the House passed the megabill, Democrats have worked to define the bill by its reductions to Medicaid spending. The fresh round of polling shows their messaging may be having some success. In the Quinnipiac poll, just 10 percent of voters said federal funding to Medicaid should decrease, and 47 percent of voters surveyed favored increased funding for the program. When asked about the bill's Medicaid cuts, 67 percent of adults surveyed in the KFF poll said the decrease in funding left them with an unfavorable view of the bill. But work requirements — one of the changes to Medicaid championed by Republicans — has broad support. In The Washington Post-Ipsos poll, 52 percent of adults said they support 'requiring low-income childless adults to prove they are working or disabled to get health insurance through Medicaid,' compared with 33 percent who oppose the requirement (15 percent had no opinion). KFF's poll showed even greater support for the work requirements, at 68 percent, including half of Democrats and nine in 10 Republicans. However, when respondents were informed of some of the barriers that work requirements create — like filing paperwork to prove eligibility — support dropped in both polls. Across all of the polls, most Americans still haven't heard of Republicans' premier piece of legislation, which gives both parties the opportunity to shift public opinion with their messaging. In The Washington Post-Ipsos poll, 66 percent of adults said they had heard little or nothing at all about the bill, compared with 34 percent who had heard a great deal or a good amount. In KFF's poll, 50 percent of adults said they had heard little or nothing at all about the legislation. In the Quinnipiac poll, a majority of voters were aware of the bill, with 36 percent saying they have heard or read 'a lot' and 32 percent saying they have heard or read 'some.' Fourteen percent said they had heard or read 'not too much' and 18 percent said 'not much at all.' The Quinnipiac poll surveyed 1,265 self-identified registered voters from June 5-9, and had a margin of error of plus or minus 2.8 percent. The Washington Post-Ipsos poll was conducted from June 6-10 and surveyed 1,167 U.S. adults with a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percent. The KFF Health Tracking poll was conducted June 4-8 and surveyed 1,321 U.S. adults, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percent.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fmr. Michigan House Speaker Tom Leonard announces governor candidacy
LANSING, Mich. (WLNS) — Tom Leonard, a former Michigan State Representative and Michigan House Speaker, announced his candidacy for governor on Tuesday. 'Michigan currently ranks second-to-last in unemployment, and our education is bottom-10 in the nation,' Leonard said in a news release announcing his campaign. 'We cannot afford another lost decade where our children are forced to leave the state for better opportunity.' Leonard is a Republican from DeWitt and served three terms in the Michigan House from 2012 until 2019. Before serving in the House, Leonard worked as a clerk, then later in the Genesee County Prosecutor's Office under Democratic prosecutor David Leyton. He served as the assistant attorney general for the State of Michigan before running for state representative in Michigan's 93rd district. Leonard unsuccessfully ran for Michigan Attorney General in 2018, losing to current Attorney General Dana Nessel. During President Donald Trump's first term, Leonard was nominated to serve as U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Michigan, but his nomination was blocked in the U.S. Senate. Leonard announced his campaign with a launch video, along with his campaign website. Rep. John James will join Michigan Senate Republican Leader and in seeking the MI GOP nomination. Secretary of State , Genesee County Sheriff , and will also be running for office, declaring as Democrats. Detroit Mayor will be running as an Independent. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Sen. Tina Smith says she confronted Sen. Mike Lee over his 'cruel' social media posts about the Minnesota shootings
WASHINGTON — Sen. Tina Smith, D-Minn., said Monday that she confronted Republican Sen. Mike Lee of Utah over his social media posts about the suspect in shootings that killed a Minnesota lawmaker and her husband. Smith said she confronted Lee after his 'cruel' posts Sunday, in which he included a photo of the suspect and wrote, 'this is what happens When Marxists don't get their way.' 'I wanted him to know how much pain that caused me and the other people in my state and I think around the country, who think that this was a brutal attack,' Smith told reporters in the Capitol. She added that Lee needed to hear from her 'directly' and think about the 'impact his actions had.' 'I don't know whether Sen. Lee thought fully through what it was, you'd have to ask him, but I needed him to hear from me directly what impact I think his cruel statement had on me, his colleague,' Smith said. A gunman fatally shot state Democratic Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, and injured Democratic state Sen. John Hoffman and his wife, Yvette, early Saturday. Vance Boelter, the suspect, was arrested Sunday night. Authorities have described the killing of Hortman as a 'politically motivated assassination.' The top federal prosecutor in Minnesota told reporters that notebooks found in Boelter's car included more than 45 federal and state elected officials' names. Several Democratic members of Congress have said their names were on the list. Lee's posts sparked condemnation from other Democrats, as well, including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn. Asked by NBC News about the confrontation with Smith, Lee declined to answer, and an aide tried to shield him from cameras as he left the Capitol. In an email to Lee's office after the confrontation, a top Smith aide blasted him and his staff for using the 'awesome power of a United States Senate Office to compound people's grief' and of causing 'additional pain … on an unspeakably horrific weekend.' 'Is this how your team measures success? Using the office of US Senator to post not just one but a series of jokes about an assassination—is that a successful day of work on Team Lee?' Ed Shelleby, Smith's deputy chief of staff, wrote in the email, which the senator's office shared with NBC News. Shelleby went onto recap Saturday's events, accusing Lee and his office of having 'exploited the murder of a lifetime public servant and her husband to post some sick burns about Democrats.' 'I pray to God that none of you ever go through anything like this. I pray that Senator Lee and your office begin to see the people you work with in this building as colleagues and human beings. And I pray that if God forbid, you ever find yourselves having to deal with anything similar, you find yourselves on the receiving end of the kind of grace and compassion that Senator Mike Lee could not muster,' Shelleby added. This article was originally published on
