AI ban or fan? The debate over using generative AI in schools
Since ChatGPT was released just over two years ago, its use everywhere from the workplace to academia has expanded significantly. In schools across the country, teachers and administrators have been grappling with how to contend with this new tool. While some say it has benefits, others point out the negatives, like cheating.
This is leading to a divide in classrooms across the country with some teachers encouraging the use of AI and others voting to ban it completely.
"We believe very strongly that AI literacy, actually teaching kids in developmentally appropriate ways, what A.I. is and isn't and then how to use those tools responsibly, is a better approach than just outright AI banning," Amanda Bickerstaff, CEO of AI For Education, a group that provides what it calls "AI literacy training," told CBS.
A former high school biology teacher, Bickerstaff now works with educators across K-12 and higher to adopt AI in their classrooms so students can learn how to use the tool ethically. She believes students need to be prepared for both the short- and long-term changes technology brings.
However, philosophy professor James Taylor from The College of New Jersey disagrees.
Taylor told CBS that he was open to using AI at first. But, after seeing many identical essays, often full of false or misleading information that was obviously AI-generated, he decided to ban it.
"If you type in a prompt, boom! There's the answer. But that means the student has now outsourced all of their thinking to a machine. They haven't worked out and developed the skills themselves," Taylor explained.
In Taylor's philosophy classes, students have to complete handwritten assignments without any devices. Rather than allowing AI to do all the work, students are encouraged to discuss their views, analyze others' arguments and come to a conclusion on what's right.
"Using it responsibly is important, but I think there has to be some classroom spaces where it's prohibited and its use is eliminated," Taylor said.
"As soon as it's banned, it's forbidden fruit," Bickerstaff pointed out. She believes kids will use AI in ways that could be harmful if parents and educators don't allow or encourage their use.
Instead, she's teaching students and teachers how to write effective AI prompts, which she says will enhance learning, and how to verify AI outputs.
While both Bickerstaff and Taylor may not see eye-to-eye on bans, they both believe in taking a proactive, balanced approach to AI.
"We're living through an inflection point unlike anything we ever lived before," Bickerstaff said. "Generative AI is becoming ubiquitous in a lot of our tools, social media and devices. If you have a new iPhone, then you already have generative A.I. models that are in your hands."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
8 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Inside Cursor's hiring strategy: no AI in interviews and a 2-day project with the team
AI coding assistant Cursor, built by Anysphere, bans AI in technical screeners. Anysphere's CEO said programming without AI is a "great time-boxed test for skill and intelligence." Cursor's hiring process ends with two-days at the office, where candidates build real projects with the team. To get hired at Cursor, an AI coding assistant built by Anysphere, you can't use AI in your interview. "We actually still interview people without allowing them to use AI, other than autocomplete, for first technical screens," said Michael Truell, the cofounder and CEO of Anysphere, on an episode of Y Combinator's podcast published Wednesday. "Programming without AI is still a really great time-boxed test for skill and intelligence," Truell said, adding that those are core qualities he looks for in a teammate. There's another reason behind the rule: fairness. "We've hired lots of people who are fantastic programmers who actually have no experience with AI tools," Truell said. "We would much rather hire those people and then teach them on the job." That beginner's mindset can be a product advantage, offering fresh insights from first-time users, he added. The final step of Cursor's hiring process isn't a traditional interview. Shortlisted candidates are invited to the company's office for two days. They work on a real project alongside the team, join in for meals, and demo what they've built at the end. Truell said this setup helps them spot people who are genuinely passionate about the "problem space" — not just shopping around for a job. "You're probably not going to be super willing to do that if you're maybe just viewing it as a job and you're applying to a bunch of technology companies at the same time," he added. Cursor also looks for engineers who are eager to experiment. Truell said the company encourages carving out time for "bottom-up experimentation" — sometimes even sectioning off teams to build independently. Truell said in an episode of "Lenny's Podcast" published in May that early hiring at Anysphere was slower than it should have been. The goal was to build a world-class group of engineers and researchers — "a certain mix of intellectual curiosity and experimentation," he said. Anysphere, Cursor's parent company, raised $900 million at a $9.9 billion valuation last month, the company said last week. Business Insider's Eugene Kim reported earlier this month that Amazon is in talks with Cursor to adopt the AI coding tool internally. Cursor did not respond to a request for comment from Business Insider. AI ban for job applications Anysphere isn't the only AI company banning the use of AI in job applications. Business Insider's Alistair Barr reported last month that leading AI startup Anthropic will not let candidates use AI when applying for jobs. "We want to understand your personal interest in Anthropic without mediation through an AI system, and we also want to evaluate your non-AI-assisted communication skills,"Anthropic wrote in a job posting for an economist. The requirement was listed across multiple roles, including technical ones like machine learning systems engineer. About a week later, the company behind Claude backtracked on this policy. "We're having to evolve, even as the company at the forefront of a lot of this technology, around how we evaluate candidates," Mike Krieger, Anthropic's chief product officer, said during an interview on CNBC in May. "So our future interview loops will have much more of this ability to co-use AI."
Business Insider
17 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Silent Giant TSMC Returns to the Peak of its Powers as the AI Boom Continues
AI and U.S. growth stocks have rebounded to record highs after their slump in February and March, rewarding those who bought the dip, especially in the IT and AI sectors. At the heart of this resurgence is Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing (TSM), better known as simply 'TSMC', the silent powerhouse behind the AI boom. The stock is within grasp of yet another historic high around the $225 mark. Confident Investing Starts Here: TSMC produces the chips that drive everything from Nvidia's GPUs to Apple's iPhones, and it's now experiencing accelerated growth fueled by surging AI demand, global factory expansion, and massive capital investment. Despite its strong rebound and concerns about exuberant valuations, TSMC still appears attractively priced. Given how sharply TSM has bounced back, the stock could become the ultimate Tech play, with its best days still ahead. AI's Engine Room: TSMC's Chip Dominance Many tech giants are currently riding the AI wave, but when it comes to TSMC, it's more appropriate to say that the company is steering it. As the world's largest contract chipmaker, it produces the advanced processors that Nvidia, AMD (AMD), and Apple (AAPL) rely on to bring AI to life. In TSMC's latest earnings call in April, CEO C.C. Wei revealed that AI chip revenue, which tripled in 2024, is expected to double again this year. This is currently a major tailwind for TSMC, driving a 41.6% year-over-year revenue surge. Specifically, advanced 3nm and 5nm chips, critical for AI's heavy lifting, made up 73% of wafer sales. With cloud giants like Microsoft (MSFT) and Amazon (AMZN) building AI data centers at breakneck speed, the company's factories are running at full capacity, with no signs that demand is slowing down anytime soon. Going Global: TSMC's Strategic Power Move In the meantime, with AI entering the sphere of national security, TSMC has been incentivized to not keep its magic in Taiwan. It's spreading its wings to secure its AI dominance and sidestep geopolitical risks. The company is investing $165 billion in U.S. factories, with Arizona's first fab already fully booked by heavyweights like Nvidia and Qualcomm (QCOM). Here's how all these giants stack up on TipRanks' stock comparison tool: Moreover, in Europe, a new $10 billion plant in Dresden, Germany, and a chip design center in Munich are positioning TSMC to capture the continent's growing AI market. Beyond the motive of diversifying supply chain and hedging geopolitical risk, TSMC has managed to secure long-term, high-value contracts with global tech titans through these moves, as they, in turn, can make such commitments with notably less risk involved. Wei emphasized that these expansions will cement TSMC's leadership for decades, even as U.S. trade policies loom as a potential headwind. By building closer to its customers, TSMC ensures its chips remain the go-to for AI innovation. Betting Big: Capex Fuels the AI Future TSMC is doubling down on AI with an aggressive capital expenditure plan of $38–$42 billion for this year, up from $29.8 billion in 2024. Over 70% of that spending is allocated to next-generation 3nm and 2nm chip production, set to launch later this year, which will deliver the performance needed to stay well ahead in the AI race. Realistically, few competitors are even operating at TSMC's level. This investment reflects a broader trend, as tech giants invest billions in AI infrastructure. TSMC sits at the center of this transformation, converting that capital into the cutting-edge chips driving AI's next evolution. As CEO C.C. Wei put it, 'AI demand is insatiable,' and TSMC is positioning itself to meet it, powering years of potential growth. TSMC Valuation Defies Expectations Here's where the investment case gets compelling: despite TSMC's explosive growth, the stock remains attractively valued. With Wall Street projecting a 33% jump in EPS this year, TSMC trades at a forward P/E of just 22. For a cyclical chipmaker, that might seem high, but TSMC isn't a typical semiconductor company. The AI boom is a multi-year tailwind, driving sustained top and bottom-line growth. With over 60% global foundry market share and ongoing global expansion, TSMC's scale and strategic positioning make that valuation look like a bargain—even if EPS growth slows in future years. Is TSMC Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold? Wall Street appears strongly bullish on TSMC's prospects, further emboldening the stock's recent rebound alongside most other high-growth tech stocks. TSMC stock carries a Strong Buy consensus rating, with seven analysts currently bullish and one neutral. TSMC's average stock price target of $223 indicates a modest 5% upside potential over the coming twelve months, amid a broader long-term trend that is expected to deliver amiable returns for several years to come. The AI Bet You Can't Overlook Calling TSMC just a chipmaker misses the bigger picture—it's the backbone of the AI era. With AI demand soaring, global fabs in development, and billions in capex reinforcing its dominance, TSMC's growth story is far from over. Trading at a forward P/E of ~26, the stock offers a rare opportunity to own a high-growth industry leader at a reasonable valuation. Yes, geopolitical risks remain, but TSMC's strategic positioning keeps it ahead of the curve. For investors looking to ride the AI wave, TSM may be one of the shrewdest long-term bets available.
Tom's Guide
17 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
I let smart glasses read my emotions and watch what I eat — and now I can't unsee the future
I believe the next great fitness wearable will not be a smartwatch or smart ring — it will be glasses. I saw this for myself when trying a prototype of the new eyewear Emteq Labs is keen to launch next year. Sporting sensors all around the rims, it can detect the subtlest of changes in your facial expressions (even those you aren't consciously aware of doing). With this data, paired with AI, it can become a personalized life coach for your fitness, your diet and even your emotional health. I put this to the test in my time talking to Emteq CEO, Steen Strand, to see what they can truly bring to the table for the average user and what the future holds. At the core of Emteq's glasses are a series of nine sensors that can identify facial movements to a near-microscopic degree. They're dotted across the bottom of the lenses in these prototypes, which are paired with AI to deliver a personalized set of specs that can sense you. Of course, there are plenty of fascinating use-cases for these, such as using your face to interact with a computer, or adding more true-to-life emotion to your in-game character. But the one that jumped out at me is health — not just physical health but emotional health. Currently, health tracking via consumer tech is limited to your fitness routines — filling in Apple Watch rings and checking your sleep. These are all fair and good, but as I've learned in my journey of losing 20 pounds, good nutrition is just as important. And while there are apps like MyFitnessPal that can deliver effective nutritional information. None come quite as easy to use and complex with actionable detail as Emteq's prototype setup. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. Using ChatGPT-4o, the on-board camera takes a snap of what you're eating and breaks it down into total calories and detailed macros. And on top of that, it will even give you a chewing score…yep, you read that correctly. Digestive issues and impacts on metabolic health can creep up if you chew too fast, so it's important to take your time. So those sensors on your glasses can track biting and chewing speeds to ensure you don't become too much of a food hoover. 'We can use AI to give you custom personalized guidance — some of that actually in real-time,' Steen added. 'We have high fidelity information about how you're eating and what you're eating, and are already using haptic feedback for in-the-moment notifications.' And with their ability to track activity too — tracking different exercises such as walking, running and even star jumps — this can all come together with the AI infusion to give you a far better understanding of your fitness levels. Then there's the emotion sensing piece of the puzzle. Up until this point, it's all been very surface level — prompts to fill in a journal, heart rate tracking to detect stress, or practice deep breathing exercises. All nice-to-haves but beyond the big issue that people could just lie to their phones, nothing has really gone deeper. We believe that understanding emotions is a force multiplier for AI, in terms of it being effective for you in the context of wearing glasses all day. If you want AI to be really effective for you, it's critical that it understands how you're feeling in real-time." Well, beyond accurately assessing eating behaviors throughout the day, other data points can be used to assess emotional context, such as mood detection and posture analysis. While I'm able to fake a smile, the upper section of my face and forehead gave me away in the moment. And then when you tap into the evergrowing popularity of people using ChatGPT for emotional support and therapy, you're surely going to get a more personalized, more frank conversation when data is added in there too. 'We believe that understanding emotions is a force multiplier for AI, in terms of it being effective for you in the context of wearing glasses all day,' Steen commented. 'If you want AI to be really effective for you, it's critical that it understands how you're feeling in real-time, in response to different things that are happening around you.' It sounds creepy on paper, and it kind of is when you think about it. But it's certainly a gateway into real emotional honesty that you may not get by rationalizing with yourself in a journal app and possibly glazing over any cracks in your mental health when filling out that survey for the day. Now this may all seem fascination (I think it is too), but I'm not ignorant of the key questions that come with strapping a bunch of sensors to your face: the questions of privacy surrounding a device grabbing so much data, or simply asking do we really want to be judged for our chewing. Privacy is always a question you can have of many different items that collect a lot of information like this. And to that latter question, that's asked with every big step forward like this. But the end result is something so much more advanced than a smart ring, and much more proactive. Here at Augmented World Expo (AWE), I found a breadcrumb trail of a lot of things that could lead to the smart glasses of the future that everyone will wear. Emteq is probably the biggest crumb of them all, because while AI is definitely the key to unlocking XR, personalizing it is the real challenge. Sensors and real-time data collection like this to help aid you into a better life is the clearest step towards tackling that challenge.
