Plans for less frequent breast screening criticised
Calls have been made for the Isle of Man government's health department to review its policy on breast cancer screening following the publication of plans to offer screenings every three years.
Manx Care has set out its aims for the next financial year in line with a mandate from the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC).
The department has directed the operator to align its screening policy with the UK, where breast screenings are offered every three years - whereas in the Isle of Man they are currently available every two years.
Cancer survivor Karen Wagstaff said if she had had to wait another year to be diagnosed she "might not be sitting here today telling this story".
The mandate, to be debated in Tynwald later this month, directs Manx Care to implement recommendations from the UK National Screening Committee, which includes "decreasing the frequency of routine screening for breast and cervical cancer".
Ms Wagstaff is one of the founding members of the Manx Breast Cancer Support Group, which has set up a petition to prevent the change moving forward.
She was diagnosed with breast cancer 16 years ago, and said she "managed to get through the 10-year mark" before discovering the disease had returned after attending her biannual screening.
She said: "I was diagnosed and it was picked up at a screening at a very early stage.
"Had I had to wait another year I might not be sat here today, that's the harsh reality."
She called any potential move to three-yearly screening "shocking" and pleaded with health bosses to "see some sense here".
However, the health minister said there were no plans to change the system over the next 12 months.
Claire Christian said there were "no supported recommended changes to the screening for any cancer services".
However, when asked to commit to keeping the screening frequency at its current level, Ms Christian told the House of Keys it was "difficult to give assurances".
Recommendations on cancer screenings are among a raft of changes laid out by the DHSC, as part of various money-saving measures.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Focus away from hospital care in plan to cut costs
Rising costs ignite review into off-island care
Additional £20m sought for healthcare overspend
Health minister resigns over future funding
Mandate to Manx Care 2025
Manx Breast Cancer Support Group
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
On the brink: Why slashing spending on global health will make us all sicker
This week, the Chancellor received a letter from those who know the NHS inside out with a plea to think again about international aid. It was signed by Presidents of diaspora health associations from across the UK, representing thousands of overseas-born healthcare workers serving in our NHS. Their message was clear: if the UK retreats further from its global health commitments, we all lose. These are not lobbyists or idealists. They're doctors, nurses and specialists on the front line of British healthcare. They understand the hard economics of government budgets. But they also understand something the Treasury may be in danger of missing: global health isn't charity. It's a vital investment in our own safety, economy and NHS resilience. When the UK backs health partnerships abroad, it's not altruism. Helping others stay healthy is one of the smartest ways to protect ourselves. Programmes like the Commonwealth Partnerships for Antimicrobial Stewardships funded by DHSC's Fleming fund, link NHS teams with hospitals in low-and middle-income countries to tackle antimicrobial resistance. So far, more than 65,000 health workers have been trained. Prescribing has improved. Infection controls are stronger. Meanwhile, UK staff return with invaluable experience that strengthens our NHS, from leadership under pressure to a deeper understanding of infectious diseases. It's the kind of low cost, high impact intervention any sensible government should double down on. Before the 2021 cuts, a programme called the UK Partnerships for Health Systems was set to train 78,000 global healthcare workers and improve care for hundreds of thousands of patients. It was abruptly slashed by £48million. Programmes were halted. Partnerships paused. Opportunities for mutual learning lost. That was the last government. We did not expect to see the same thing happen under this government, with its distinguished track-record of supporting UK Aid over many decades. The letter from the Presidents of Diaspora Associations makes it clear what this means in real terms – not just for patients in low-income countries, but for UK health care workers whose knowledge and innovation stem from these international exchanges. One in five NHS workers is a non-UK national. Their expertise connects the UK to over 200 health systems worldwide. They help make the NHS one of the most internationally engaged healthcare systems on the planet. Many trained in countries with fragile systems. Many are already playing leadership roles in linking British institutions with their counterparts overseas. In Tanzania, a partnership led by Northumbria Healthcare NHS Trust helped introduce laparoscopic surgery and set up a burns unit. In Ethiopia, Nottingham's NHS trust collaborated with Jimma University to improve trauma and diabetes care. The return on investment? More skilled, confident UK staff - and stronger UK healthcare at home. Health partnerships do far more than train workers. They help develop curricula, fortify health systems overseas and importantly, build Britain's global reputation at a time when influence is in short supply. The UK-Africa Health Summit earlier this year showed the power of collaboration, bringing together Ministers, health leaders and diaspora professionals to forge solutions on workforce mobility and pandemic preparedness. This diplomacy is with a scalpel, not a sword – and it works. The Chancellor faces tough choices. But cutting the global health budget and not mitigating the consequences, would be a false economy. It would weaken our defences against future pandemics, shrink the NHS's talent pipeline and damage our standing in the world. As the letter from diaspora leaders makes clear: this is not a plea for charity. It's a call for strategic investment. Let's not wait for the next global crisis to remind us that disease doesn't respect borders. Let's act now – to protect the NHS, promote economic stability and ensure Britain remains a trusted force for health and progress worldwide. Ben Simms is CEO of Global Health Partnerships (formerly THET) Protect yourself and your family by learning more about Global Health Security Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Boy, 10, arrested after fire at block of flats
A ten-year-old boy has been arrested on suspicion of arson after a fire at a block of flats that caused 50 people to be evacuated. The fire at Rynet Court on Marsh House Lane, Warrington broke out at about 17:20 BST on Monday, and firefighters from across Cheshire and Manchester were called to try to bring the blaze under control. A joint investigation into the cause of the fire, which flat residents described as "terrifying", has been launched by Cheshire Fire and Rescue Service and Cheshire Police The boy who was arrested on suspicion of arson has since been bailed pending further enquiries, a spokesman for the force said. Thomas Harris and his family were safely rescued from the blaze, while one woman said she had had to pass her six-year-old son to safety from her first floor window. Mr Harris, who has lived on the second floor in the block of flats for five years, said he was shocked to see smoke in the stairwell. Det Insp David Schofield from Cheshire Police said: "I'd like thank residents for their patience throughout the night while emergency services dealt with the incident." A Cheshire Fire and Rescue Service spokesman added: "A total of 50 people had been rescued from the building, including through the windows and balconies of the third and fourth floor. "North West Ambulance Service triaged and treated those rescued on the scene and thankfully no serious injuries have been reported," he added. A nearby Territorial Army centre was opened up as a relief centre to house the 50 residents evacuated from the second, third and fourth floors of the flats. Read more stories from Cheshire on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC North West on X. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230. 'Safety leaflets helped me in terrifying flat fire' Firefighters rescue 50 people from flats blaze Cheshire Constabulary Cheshire Fire and Rescue
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Hundreds of Manx patients affected by data error
More than 430 patients on the Isle of Man have been subject to a data error resulting in their home addresses being changed to UK ones, Manx Care has said. The island's healthcare provider said NHS England had incorrectly recorded temporary UK residences as permanent addresses for island residents who were receiving treatment there. A spokeswoman said that so far about 446 patients had been affected, with further cases likely to be confirmed as "awareness increases". She said Manx Care was "actively collaborating" with UK healthcare bodies and integrated care boards to "improve how address changes are managed, particularly for patients moving between the Isle of Man and the UK". NHS systems on the Isle of Man and in the UK work independently, but data is shared when address changes are made. The Manx Care spokeswoman said: "In some cases the UK system assumed a permanent relocation rather than a temporary visit." This led to "unintended updates to patient records", she added. Manx Care said it was contacting GP practices to verify permanent addresses to all of those affected by the error and had reiterated "the importance of not replacing records" to UK health providers. Meanwhile, the health body has urged anyone who has been treated in the UK and expected correspondence from Manx Care, to get in touch with their GP practice to "review your records". Potential impacts on care could mean people miss or have delayed invitations for routine screenings or appointments at Noble's Hospital. Manx Care said that despite the error, patients would not lose their places at their Manx GP practice. The healthcare body apologised for "any confusion or disruption" and said people's "health and peace of mind [were] top priorities". Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X. Rising costs ignite review into off-island care Society outlines concerns over Manx Care mandate Patients 'in limbo' over health cuts, MHK says Manx Care NHS England
