logo
MSD sanctions double, impact on employment unclear

MSD sanctions double, impact on employment unclear

NZ Herald05-05-2025

Data released to RNZ after an Official Information Act request shows that there were 3015 times that a client was sanctioned, then recomplied with their obligations and then left the benefit to work.
There were 210 times when a client was sanctioned and then left for work, then recomplied with their obligations. That could include people who found work and then ended up back on the benefit.
Graham Allpress, group general manager of client service delivery, said sanctions and obligations were one part of a broader picture that could contribute to a jobseeker finding work.
He said MSD could not provide data about sanctions that led to someone re-engaging and then finding work because it could not link the sanction and the person finding a job.
'People get jobs because they apply for them, and because they take steps to become ready for work.
'We use sanctions as a last resort if someone is not meeting their obligations, to encourage them to engage with us and get back on track by re-complying their obligations.
'In 2024, 92.8% of sanctions were lifted after the client re-complied with their obligations and got back on track. That is the purpose we use them for.
'If someone gets a benefit and they have work obligations, one of the main things they agree to do is regularly apply for suitable jobs. By meeting their obligations, they maximise their own opportunity to get a job and 'exit to work'.
'We are engaging with more jobseekers more frequently through proactive appointments and Kōrero Mahi seminars. Our support for jobseekers includes training, work assessments or work experience, and help with CVs and applying for jobs.'
In 2018, the then-Labour Government produced a paper on the effects of work-related sanctions.
'Real barriers'
It said that regimes less severe than New Zealand's were effective in increasing movement from benefits to work. But evidence from the UK and US was that very harsh sanctions could have adverse effects that drove people away from employment.
Isaac Gunson, spokesperson for the Child Poverty Action Group, said it was unlikely that so many more people had started missing appointments.
'What seems more likely is that MSD has become quicker to cut people off, despite the very real barriers many face in attending.
'These are people doing their best in tough circumstances. They may not have access to childcare, a working phone, or may simply be confused by the system.
'Pushing people off income support doesn't make the job market fairer or more accessible. It just assumes success is possible while unemployment rises and support systems become harder to navigate.'
Economist Shamubeel Eaqub said there should be clearer ways to determine whether sanctions were having the effect intended.
'How can we be confident they are doing their job?
'I have no problem with them pulling these levers if they're effective. If they're creating a better outcome then of course we should be doing it. But we shouldn't just punish people.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tuvalu Calls For Sea Level Rise Treaty At UN Oceans Conference
Tuvalu Calls For Sea Level Rise Treaty At UN Oceans Conference

Scoop

time13 hours ago

  • Scoop

Tuvalu Calls For Sea Level Rise Treaty At UN Oceans Conference

Article – RNZ 'Tuvalu calls for the development of an international treaty on sea level rise, to enshrine the legal rights of affected states and people.' RNZ Pacific Tuvalu prime minister Feleti Teo has called for an international treaty on sea level rise at the UN Oceans Conference in France. Speaking to delegates in Nice, Teo said the ocean is critical to his country's economy, culture and survival. He said he supports the UN Secretary-General's call for all nations to deliver on the 1.5 degrees Celsius promise in order to halt the rate of sea level rise. 'In that regard, Tuvalu calls for the development of an international treaty on sea level rise, to enshrine the legal rights of affected states and people, including the principles of statehood continuity and the permanency of maritime boundary,' he said. 'For Tuvalu, building the resilience and adaptability of our coastlines against the impact of sea level rise is our top adaptation program.' Solomon Islands prime minister Jeremiah Manele used his speech to condemn the pursuit of deep sea mining in the Pacific. Addressing delegates in Nice, Manele said his country has placed a moratorium on deep sea prospecting and mining. He said the world's oceans face three planetary crises: biodiversity loss, pollution and climate change. 'Despite this, some are pursuing deep sea mining with minimal regard for scientific understanding, environmental risks and global consensus,' he said. He said the UN Sustainable Development Goal 14 – to conserve and sustainably use oceans, seas and marine resources – is off track and underfunded. 'We must move beyond rhetoric to concrete actions that matches the scale and urgency to address today's crisis. 'We must also reform our global ocean governance architecture and shift from harmful exploitation to sustainable use of the ocean.' Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape said his national government does not support deep sea mining due to potentially devastating environmental consequences. However, his stance on the issue is opposite to the one the governor of his country's New Island Province has taken. Governor Walter Schnaubelt recently issued a statement backing Niu Solwara, the company planning to launch the controversial Solwara 1 seabed mining project in the Bismarck Sea by late 2027. Governor Schnaubelt said the new mining techniques employed by Niu Solwara are environmentally safe. Meanwhile, Palau's president Surangel Whipps Jr said financing is key to ensure a sustainable ocean economy that works for the planet. He said the mechanism must include grants for science and governance, patient capital for community-led enterprises, sustainable revenue mechanisms for marine protected areas, and robust local financial systems supporting nature-positive businesses. French Polynesia's president, Moetai Brotherson, spoke of his administration's plan to establish a network of highly protected marine areas (MPAs). This was met with applause. 'Why do we do it? We do it because we are not just looking at the ocean; we are not just seeing it at some place that we can fish. We are part of the ocean, and the ocean is part of us.'

Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit
Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit

Scoop

time13 hours ago

  • Scoop

Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit

Article – RNZ Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia. , Correspondent French Pacific Desk French president Emmanuel Macron chaired a Pacific-France summit on Tuesday, in the margins of the UN Ocean Conference (UNOC) held in Nice. In his opening speech, the French head of state touched on several aspects of France's cooperation in the Pacific region, including in terms of environment, defence and geostrategy. €2 million Euros for Pacific Forum's Resilient Facility Pledging to maintain France's diplomacy 'in very close connection with our common interests in the Pacific', including the recent opening of a new Embassy in Apia, Samoa, Macron acknowledged the 'central' role played by the Pacific Islands Forum, which will receive about €2 million Euros as a contribution to the Pacific Resilient Facility fund for the region. He also mentioned the opening of a project to introduce new air links connecting French Polynesia, the Cook Islands, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa. He also touched on France-Pacific cooperation at 'strategic and military' levels, through a recently-created 'Pacific Academy' and regular joint regional exercises in order to foster 'common credibility to protect our zones and fight against illegal fishing'. High on the agenda were key issues such as climate change and its adverse effects on Pacific Island states on human lives and biodiversity, natural disasters affecting the region, breaches of sovereignty and security resulting from illegal fishing, and trans-regional crime, especially the rising problem of drug trafficking. In terms of regional maritime security and fight against criminality, especially illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing (IUU), France, but also Australia and New Zealand Navys are regularly contributing to patrols in the Pacific Islands Forum's Fisheries Agency (FFA) member states' exclusive economic zones (EEZs). Significant part dedicated to New Caledonia Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia, one year after the deadly riots that broke out in May 2024 (causing 14 deaths and and estimated €2.2 billion Euros in damages). He told Pacific leaders he was aware of Pacific concerns about 'the events that destabilized New Caledonia a year ago '. 'I want to tell you here… The French state has respected its commitments made decades ago by organizing in recent years three referendums with United Nations observers which were validated and noted. 'But a year ago, violence broke out, triggered by several factors… which we took very seriously.' Macron said since then, France has unlocked 'more than €3 billion Euros' for New Caledonia's economic reconstruction. 'And we have spared no effort with the government, in particular the Minister of State [Minister for Overseas Manuel Valls] to restore dialogue between all parties.' Since February Valls has managed to bring all of New Caledonia's political camps around the same table, something that had not happened since 2022. But the proposal he put on the table in early May, during a behind-closed-doors 'conclave', drew ire from parties in favour of New Caledonia remaining a part of France. They objected, saying Valls' project failed to take into account that the three recent referendums had expressed a rejection of independence and that the Minister's 'sovereignty with France' offer (including transfer of key powers from France to New Caledonia, a dual Kanaky-France citizenship and an international standing) was tantamount to some form of independence which they strongly objected to. A 'new project' on the table in July? On discussions about a resumption of talks to find a bipartisan and comprehensive agreement on the French Pacific territory's future political status, Macron also confirmed that he will 'hold a summit in Paris in the coming weeks to bring together all stakeholders again and manage to come up with a new project'. Macron said after holding three referendums between 2018 and 2021 on New Caledonia's sovereignty, he was not in favour of holding yet another one. 'I must say I honestly believe Pacific, Oceanian or Melanesian cultures are more based on consultation and circularity, not really suited for referendums …whereby you're supposed to express a clearcut yes or no.' We won't make the same mistakes again 'We will not make the same mistakes again in the future,' Macron told Pacific islands leaders, including those from the three French Pacific territories of New Caledonia, French Polynesia and Wallis and Futuna. He said building a political solution for New Caledonia was still work in progress 'with a lot of humility, together'. And in this process, he told regional leaders 'we welcome your advice' and 'recommendations'. He mentioned and thanked Pacific Islands Forum leaders for a fact-finding mission that travelled to New Caledonia in late 2024 and gave rise to 'very productive exchanges'. 'We will do all we can to succeed and I am confident we'll do it with respect for everyone and for all (New) Caledonians, for peace, unity and stability in the region. 'But we are trying to hold this dialogue while respecting the various opinions and the principles of democracy.' During the same Pacific-France summit, Macron also held talks with leaders from Papua New Guinea, Palau, Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, Marshall Islands, Kiribati, the Federated States of Micronesia, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu. The Pacific Islands Forum delegation was headed by its secretary-general Baron Waqa.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store