High Court upholds acquittal of Chinese company accused of bribing ex-LTA deputy group director
High Court upholds acquittal of Chinese company accused of bribing ex-LTA deputy group director
Source: Straits Times
Article Date: 31 May 2025
Author: Selina Lum
Henry Foo Yung Thye, who was in financial difficulties from gambling, had reached out to two senior employees from China Railway Tunnel Group's Singapore branch and asked for loans.
The High Court has upheld the acquittal of a Chinese company that was charged with bribery after two of its employees gave loans totalling $220,000 to a Land Transport Authority (LTA) deputy group director.
In a written judgment on May 29, the court said there was insufficient evidence to show that the company's top management was aware of or somehow complicit in the illegal acts.
The Singapore branch of China Railway Tunnel Group was first acquitted of three corruption charges by a district judge in March 2024 on grounds that the two employees' acts could not be attributed to the company.
Xi Zhengbing, who was the general manager and head representative of the branch, and Zhou Zhenghe, who was a deputy general manager, gave the loans to Henry Foo Yung Thye between January 2018 and August 2019.
The district judge said Xi did not have a sufficiently high level in the chain of command. The Singapore branch is only one of the sub-departments within the company's overseas department, which is in turn only one department in the company's corporate structure.
The prosecution appealed to the High Court against the acquittal.
On May 29, the appeal was dismissed by a panel comprising Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon, Justice Tay Yong Kwang and Justice Andrew Phang.
The court also noted that Xi and Zhou had resorted to defrauding the company with false invoices to obtain the $200,000 that was given to Foo as loans in 2018.
Zhou then had to borrow $20,000 to provide the subsequent loan.
'All these showed clearly that the respondent was never involved in its employees' illegal activities and neither did it give its tacit approval (nor) pretend to be ignorant of what the Singapore branch's employees were doing,' said the court.
In September 2021, Foo, then 47, was sentenced to 5½ years' jail for taking about $1.24 million in bribes in the form of loans from contractors and sub-contractors.
Foo, who resigned from LTA in September 2019, was also ordered to pay a penalty of about $1.16 million, equivalent to the amount he had not returned.
Xi and Zhou were arrested in September 2019 by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau.
After being released on bail, they absconded to China, where they were arrested and subsequently convicted by a Guangzhou court.
Xi was sentenced to a five-year jail term and a fine of 300,000 yuan (S$57,400). Zhou was sentenced to two years' jail and a fine of 100,000 yuan.
China Railway Tunnel Group has 24 branches, eight of which are overseas.
The Singapore branch was a sub-contractor for two different projects on the Thomson-East Coast Line (TEL), and was awarded the main contract for a project on the Circle Line.
At the time of the offences, Foo was involved in the project management of the main contractors in respect of TEL projects.
Between 2016 and 2019, he reached out to the company's employees, including Xi, to ask for loans.
No loan was given as a result of Foo's first request.
Subsequently, Xi agreed to give him a loan upon his second request in the hope that Foo would refer more job opportunities to the company.
Zhou then arranged for false invoices to be issued to the company and prepared supporting documents with forged signatures.
These documents were presented to the company's finance department, which disbursed the payment.
After receiving the money, Xi and Zhou passed $200,000 to Foo.
In 2019, Foo made a third request.
Xi agreed to give him another loan, in the hope that Foo would expedite the company's payment claims and help the company to win the tender for another project.
On Xi's instructions, Zhou borrowed $20,000 from a friend and passed the money to Foo.
The prosecution alleged that in 2016, Mr Liu Chenyu, who was based in China, was told of the discussions to pay Foo a bribe and approved his request for a loan.
Mr Liu was then the deputy general manager of the company's overseas department, which was in charge of all the overseas branches.
The prosecution presented text messages, including one from another employee of the Singapore branch telling Foo that Mr Liu was grateful for his support.
But the High Court panel said the prosecution had not presented the necessary evidence to prove that Mr Liu was involved.
The messages did not prove that Foo's request for a loan was actually conveyed to Mr Liu, said the judges.
Lawyer Paul Loy of WongPartnership, who acts for the company, said his client will continue to respect the laws of countries in which it operates.
Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction.
Print
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
China tells US envoy Washington must get ties back on 'right track'
Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi attends the signing ceremony of the Convention on the Establishment of The International Organization for Mediation (IOMed) in Hong Kong, China May 30, 2025. REUTERS/Bertha Wang/File Photo China tells US envoy Washington must get ties back on 'right track' BEIJING - The U.S. should create the necessary conditions for bilateral relations to get back onto "the right track," China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi told the U.S. ambassador to Beijing on Tuesday, according to a ministry statement. After trade talks last month in Geneva, China has "conscientiously and strictly" implemented the consensus reached by both sides, but it is "regrettable that the U.S. recently introduced a series of 'negative' measures", which China firmly opposes, Wang told Ambassador David Perdue. Bilateral relations are at a critical juncture, and dialogue and cooperation are "the only correct choice," Wang said. Perdue said in an X post after the meeting that he had emphasized U.S. President Donald Trump's priorities on trade, fentanyl, and illegal immigration, adding that "communication is vital" to U.S.-China relations. Trump on Friday accused China of violating a bilateral deal to roll back tariffs and trade restrictions，and the U.S. has ordered curbs on chip design software and other shipments to China. The Geneva truce to dial back triple-digit tariffs for 90 days prompted a massive relief rally in global stocks. But it did nothing to address the underlying reasons for Trump's tariffs on Chinese goods, mainly longstanding U.S. complaints about China's state-dominated, export-driven economic model. Senior U.S. officials have said this week that Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping would speak soon to iron out trade issues, including a dispute over critical minerals and China's restrictions on exports of certain minerals. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told a regular news briefing on Tuesday the Trump administration "is actively monitoring China's compliance with the Geneva trade agreement," and added that "there will be a leader to leader talk very soon." REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
Katong Plaza and Novotel on Kitchener Rd to be redeveloped
Katong Plaza and Novotel Singapore on Kitchener hotel were in the past two years sold to new owners. ST PHOTOS: AZMI ATHNI, ARIFFIN JAMAR New hotels to replace Katong Plaza and Novotel hotel in Kitchener Road SINGAPORE – The Novotel Singapore on Kitchener hotel and Katong Plaza are set to be replaced by new hotels. Both properties date back to around 1981, with the Kitchener Road hotel branded with different names along the way. They were in the past two years sold, and the new owners have recently secured at least provisional planning approvals from the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA). Worldwide Hotels subsidiary Midtown Development has permission to redevelop the Kitchener Road property into a hotel with 1,625 rooms and 1,214 sq m of retail space. The hotel opened in 1981 as President Merlin Hotel – a part of the President Hotel and Shopping Complex that also included the President Shopping Centre which opened in 1970. The hotel was later rebranded as New Park Hotel in 1990 after a $30 million facelift. In 2007, it became Parkroyal on Kitchener Road, while the shopping centre was demolished in 2017 to make way for Centrium Square. In 2023, UOL sold Parkroyal on Kitchener Road for $525 million to Worldwide Hotels, a Singapore-based firm that owns chains such as Hotel 81 and Hotel Mi. The hotel reopened in November that year as the 543-room Novotel Singapore on Kitchener , a brand under French multinational hospitality company Accor . The hotel is on a freehold 7,780.1 sq m site and has a gross floor area of 37,827.71 sq m. A spokesperson for Worldwide Hotels told The Straits Times on June 3 that it is unable to share further details about the new hotel. Katong Plaza in Brooke Road, which opened around the start of 1981 , is set to make way for a hotel with 374 rooms and 537 sq m of retail space. The strata-titled mixed-use development near Marine Parade MRT station with 132 retail units and 14 residential apartments was in 2024 sold to Fragrance Group for $180 million . At the time of the sale, the building's owners had outline permission from the URA to convert it for hotel use. The existing building is on a freehold 3,162 sq m site and has a gross floor area of 9,488 sq m. The Fragrance Group did not respond to requests for comment. When ST visited the building on May 30, most of the retail tenants had vacated their units. Some were packing up and said they had to leave by end-June. A notice dated April 16, put up alongside minutes of the building's collective sale committee's meetings, stated that owners choosing to stay in the building until July 2025 will be responsible for covering all expenses such as air-conditioner and lift maintenance fees. Traditional Chinese medicine practitioner John Ng, 70, who has operated a clinic in the mall since April 2006, said he is disappointed to leave behind neighbours of almost two decades. 'We all knew each other and were very friendly. Everyone trusted each other and I could leave my clinic unattended, knowing others would help to keep watch,' said Mr Ng. He was in the process of relocating his clinic to Kreta Ayer in Chinatown . Items at a traditional Chinese medicine clinic being kept on May 31, ahead of the closure of Katong Plaza. ST PHOTO: AZMI ATHNI Mr Alan Cheong, Savills Singapore's executive director of research and consultancy, expects that the Katong site will house a mid-tier hotel, given the planned number of rooms. He also pointed out that the Kitchener Road hotel is likely to be an economy-tier type geared towards mass market tourism. He added that Worldwide Hotels' plan to triple the number of rooms is 'logical', as the move will help to boost its earnings. Asked if there is sufficient demand for rooms in the Farrer Park and Marine Parade areas to justify the planned supply, analysts said Singapore's hotel market has performed strongly in the past 12 to 18 months. Mr Edwin Loo, an associate director at real estate consultancy Cistri, said: 'Much of this growth is in the mid-market and upscale segments, reflecting Singapore's success in attracting event-focused visitors as well as visitors from emerging Asia who are willing to spend but remain price-sensitive given Singapore's relatively higher room rates when compared with other regional destinations.' But he noted that the site of Katong Plaza, which is next to Roxy Square, is relatively long and narrow. Mr Edwin Loo, an associate director at real estate consultancy Cistri, felt that the planned redevelopment of Katong Plaza would be boosted if neighbour Roxy Square is also roped in. ST PHOTO: AZMI ATHNI 'An integrated development incorporating both of these sites would have resulted in a better outcome in terms of land optimisation and urban design, especially considering the need to accommodate the extensive pickup, drop-off and coach parking requirements at the ground level and the potential for a larger site to provide greater amenity for the community,' he said. Ng Keng Gene is a correspondent at The Straits Times, reporting on issues relating to land use, urban planning and heritage. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
CNA
8 hours ago
- CNA
FAQ: All you need to know about the findings of the major East-West Line disruption in Sep 2024
SINGAPORE: Investigation findings for the six-day East-West Line disruption in September last year were released on Tuesday (Jun 3), with the Land Transport Authority (LTA) set to impose a S$3 million fine on train operator SMRT. CNA breaks down the key points of the reports released by the Transport Safety Investigation Bureau as well as LTA. What happened in September? Disruptions started on Sep 25 last year when a defective part known as an axle box on a first-generation KHI train dropped onto the tracks, causing a bogie – or an undercarriage with wheels – to come off the running rail between the Dover and Clementi stations. This resulted in extensive damage to the tracks and other equipment, with a total of 46 rail breaks identified in a 2.55km stretch between Dover station and stretching beyond Clementi station, which took days to repair. An estimated 500,000 out of 2.8 million train journeys were affected each day during the disruption, with train services resuming six days later on Oct 1. How did SMRT respond then? SMRT activated free public bus and bridging shuttle bus services immediately when they understood that the train services would take some time to resume. They also took action to limit the affected sector between Buona Vista station and Jurong East station. Shuttle train services with 10-minute intervals operated between Boon Lay and Jurong East stations, as well as between Buona Vista and Queenstown stations. Station staff members and track repair workers were also reported to have gone above and beyond their call of duty – from providing commuters with directions and assistance to coordinating track repairs round the clock. What did further investigations find? The root cause of how the axle box failed could not be determined because key train components involved were too badly burnt and damaged in the incident, LTA said. These parts were: the axle box itself, which secures the wheels to the axle the axle bearings, which reduce friction so the wheels spin smoothly the chevron springs, which contain rubber to absorb shocks to keep the ride smooth The axle box had dislodged from the third carriage of the train, causing extensive damage to the tracks. Although the root cause could not be determined, the report concluded that the likely cause was degraded grease in the axle box, LTA said. The degraded grease could have increased wear and tear on the axle bearings, eventually causing overheating, potentially burning the rubber of the chevron springs. The chevron springs could have then progressively dropped off and eventually caused the axle box to dislodge, LTA added. The sequence of events was further substantiated by the Hotbox system, which is set up along the tracks on both the East-West Line and North-South Line. The system has been in place since 2014 and consists of a trackside infrared sensor. When a train runs by, the sensor measures the temperature of each axle box. It is an extra monitoring tool put in place by SMRT and not a requirement set by LTA. The system had detected higher temperatures on one of the axle boxes of the affected train before the incident. However, on the incident day, even though a warning was displayed in the maintenance engineering centre, the train identification number or train ID was not detected due to a system error. Instead, a 'Null ID' was indicated. This led the controller monitoring the system to believe the warning was a false one and no follow-up action was taken. How much of a factor was maintenance? The train in the incident was among 66 in SMRT's first-generation KHI fleet that were rolled out in the late 1980s. They are progressively being replaced by new Movia trains. Initially, 66 Movia trains were to be handed over to SMRT by March 2024, with the first fleet in October 2021. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a delay of 1.5 years and the first Movia train was handed over only in May 2023. Upon receiving the first fleet of the new trains, SMRT began decommissioning the KHI trains. In the meantime, SMRT was required to continue carrying out regular maintenance for the KHI trains still in service, including preventive works and overhaul, which refers to a complete tear-down and rebuild to restore trains to a condition "as good as new". By the time of the incident on Sep 25, 18 KHI trains had been overhauled, but the incident train was not among them. The stipulated interval for an overhaul was 500,000km, but SMRT twice extended the interval – first to 575,000km in August 2022 and then to 750,000km in August 2024. At the time of the incident, the train had logged 690,000km since its last overhaul in 2018. The extensions were carried out based on SMRT's internal procedures, LTA said. The authority also noted that since axle-box failures were not common, SMRT did not undertake a detailed engineering risk assessment on extending the overhaul interval for the axle box. Speaking to the media on Tuesday, Mr Lam Sheau Kai who is president of SMRT Trains said the operator's overhaul regime has served it well over the past 38 years. 'What may have caught us off-guard this time was the convergence of factors – delays in new train deliveries due to COVID-19, our efforts to balance and adjust overhaul schedules, and the lag in receiving critical spare parts.' What penalties were imposed? SMRT was fined S$3 million by LTA, an amount that was 'proportionate" to the incident's circumstances, the authority said. In determining the fine, LTA said it took into consideration that SMRT had borne the cost of repairs as well as provided free bridging buses, regular bus services and shuttle train services at the affected stations. SMRT also provided free travel to passengers alighting at Jurong East and Buona Vista stations during the six days of disruption. The total cost of SMRT's service recovery amounted to more than S$10 million. The financial penalty collected by LTA will go to the Public Transport Fund, which helps lower-income families with the spending on public transport fares. SMRT will have the opportunity to appeal the fine to the transport minister. What follow-up actions have SMRT and LTA taken since then? After the incident, SMRT pre-emptively withdrew all KHI trains that had exceeded 500,000km mileage since their last overhaul from service to undergo overhaul activities for axle boxes before they were put back into service. In consultation with LTA, SMRT has also starting using data analytics for earlier detection of abnormal axle-box temperatures, so that pre-emptive action can be taken. SMRT has also worked with the Hotbox system maker to rectify the Null ID indication issue. It now requires its maintenance engineering centre to share system warnings with the operations control centre. SMRT has also instituted that the withdrawal of trains back to the depot under such scenarios should occur at a slower speed of 35kmh to limit the potential damage to the tracks and trackside equipment. LTA was not involved in and did not review SMRT's proposed extensions to the overhaul intervals of the trains. The authority said that as an asset owner, it has since strengthened its oversight of operators' management of assets, including their internal procedures to adjust maintenance schedules. 'LTA and operators will work together for future overhaul decisions,' it added. Mr Lam from SMRT said that for 'rare, black swan events like COVID-19', it is important that SMRT the operator and LTA the asset owner come together to 'reassess collectively'. 'In hindsight, we could perhaps have exercised greater caution in how we managed the transition and decommissioning of the older trains,' he added.
