'Makes no sense': Hollywood shocked by Trump's film tariffs announcement
LOS ANGELES - Hollywood reacted Monday with skepticism to US President Donald Trump's announcement of 100 percent tariffs on foreign films, with movie insiders calling it a policy made up on the fly by a president who fails to understand how the industry works.
"It makes no sense," entertainment lawyer Jonathan Handel said of Trump's idea.
Handel explained to AFP that many US productions, from James Bond flicks to the "Mission Impossible" franchise, are filmed abroad for obvious creative reasons.
"If the stunt is Tom Cruise climbing up the Eiffel Tower, what are we supposed to do, shoot at the replica Eiffel Tower in Las Vegas?" Handel said. "I mean, it's just nonsensical."
Writing Sunday on his platform Truth Social, Trump said: "I am authorizing the Department of Commerce, and the United States Trade Representative, to immediately begin the process of instituting a 100 per cent Tariff on any and all Movies coming into our Country that are produced in Foreign Lands."
Trump added: "WE WANT MOVIES MADE IN AMERICA, AGAIN!"
His words plunged the movie industry into uncertainty, as entertainment companies saw their stock prices fall, unions struggled to understand if the bombshell also applies to TV series and everyone wondered if the policy could even be enforced.
Handel noted that movies involve intellectual property.
"You can buy a movie ticket, but you don't buy a movie the way you buy a piece of clothing or an automobile," which can be taxed as they cross a border into the United States, he said.
Even if a system could be devised to impose tariffs on movies filmed outside the United States, these levies would do more harm than good to the US industry, the lawyer added.
"The result of that would be to reduce production, to increase the cost of movies, to reduce the number of movies available for movie theaters and streamers to show, which would damage the distribution side of the business," Handel argued.
'Confusion'
Unions for actors and other media and entertainment workers said they awaited more details of Trump's plan but supported the goal of increasing production of movies, TV and streaming in the United States.
"We will continue to advocate for policies that strengthen our competitive position, accelerate economic growth and create good middle-class jobs for American workers," said one such guild, SAG-AFTRA.
Many movie studios and other industry organizations had yet to officially react Monday but Trump's announcement triggered crisis meetings, Hollywood press outlets reported, publishing skeptical comments from insiders speaking on condition of anonymity.
"I can't see his target here other than confusion and distraction," the showbiz news outlet Deadline quoted a top distribution executive as saying.
"Let's hope this only encourages desperately needed increases in US state tax incentives being implemented ASAP," that person added.
Such incentives offered by other countries -- like Britain, Canada and Ireland, among others -- are a lure for US movie studios to film outside the country.
While Trump's idea is divisive, there is widespread agreement that the US movie industry is in dire straits.
Since the historic strikes by actors and writers that shut it down in 2023, Hollywood has struggled to get back on its feet.
In Los Angeles, the number of filming days hit a record low in 2024, if one excludes the total shutdown in 2020 because of the Covid pandemic.
This is in part because many movies are now filmed in a growing number of countries that offer incentives such as tax rebates.
Deadline quoted a Hollywood movie financier as saying he actually agrees with Trump's goal of having more movies filmed in the United States.
"But obviously the need is for rebates, not tariffs. Tariffs will just choke the remaining life out of the business," they were quoted as saying.
As Hollywood fretted over Trump's announcement, the White House said no decision on foreign film tariffs has been made.
"The Administration is exploring all options to deliver on President Trump's directive to safeguard our country's national and economic security while Making Hollywood Great Again," the White House said in a statement.
Trump told reporters Monday, "I'm not looking to hurt the industry. I want to help the industry. But they're given financing by other countries."
That seemingly conciliatory remark stopped short of walking back the film tariff announcement, as Trump criticized California Governor Gavin Newsom, who is pushing for his state to double the tax credits it grants to the movie industry.
"Our film industry has been decimated by other countries taking them out, and also by incompetence," Trump said, attacking Newsom.
"He's just allowed it to be taken away from, you know, Hollywood." - AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
34 minutes ago
- The Sun
Iranians' World Cup dream crushed by US travel ban
A year out from kick-off, Iranian football fans are watching their World Cup dream slip away after a US travel ban barred them from entering the land of 'Great Satan' to cheer on their team. The 2026 tournament will be co-hosted by the United States, Canada and Mexico, but most matches, including the final, are scheduled to be played on American soil. Many in Iran had clung to hopes of cheering from the stands until Wednesday when US President Donald Trump rolled out a new travel ban on 12 countries including Iran, which will take effect from Monday. 'My friends and I have been waiting for years to watch Team Melli (a nickname for the national team) play in a World Cup on US soil, and when they qualified, it felt like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,' Sohrab Naderi, a real estate agent in Tehran, told AFP. 'Now with the new travel ban, that dream is shattered because of politics that we don't care about and have no control over,' said the 46-year-old who attended the 2022 World Cup in Qatar which saw the US side defeat Iran 1-0 in the group stage. The prospect of Iran competing in a US-hosted tournament comes against the backdrop of a decades-long enmity, with diplomatic ties broken since the 1979 Islamic revolution. The two sides are currently engaged in high-stakes talks over Iran's nuclear programme, with the United States threatening military action if no deal can be reached. - 'Degrading to all Iranians' - Trump said the new travel ban was prompted by a makeshift flamethrower attack on a Jewish protest in Colorado that US authorities blamed on a man they said was in the country illegally. The ban will not apply to athletes competing in either the 2026 World Cup or the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, the order said. Nonetheless, supporters who had dreamed of crossing the Atlantic to cheer on their team will no longer be able to make the trip. 'Every Iranian has the right to support their team, just as much as any other country, whether the game is in America or in any other country,' said Hasti Teymourpour, a 16-year-old football fan. Since his return to office in January, Trump has reinstated his 'maximum pressure' policy of sanctions against Iran and vowed that 'something bad' would happen unless the Iranians 'move quickly' towards a nuclear deal. Naderi, who called the ban 'inhumane' and 'degrading to all Iranians', still hopes the Iran-US nuclear talks will yield a deal that might persuade Trump to reconsider. The outcome of the US-Iran talks that began in April remains unclear, and many fans worry that even if they result in a deal, it may be too late for them. Some Iranians have refused to give up hope, however, seeing in the World Cup an opportunity to thaw relations. 'Sports diplomacy can act as a strong catalyst and bring the efforts of political diplomats to fruition sooner,' said political commentator Mohammad Reza Manafi. It could be 'a great opportunity to help advance diplomacy between the two countries'. - Friendly? - In a memorable 1998 World Cup clash, Iranian players handed flowers to their American adversaries and posed together for photos -- a rare public gesture of goodwill between the nations. Iran won 2–1, a victory celebrated in Tehran as a source of both sporting and political pride. With the 2026 draw expected in December, it remains unclear whether Iran and the United States will face off again, but anticipation is building. 'The two countries are not hostile to each other, this political discussion is for the governments,' said 44-year-old day labourer Siamak Kalantari. Another fan, Mahdieh Olfati, said: 'If we face the US again, we'll definitely win.' 'Ours are real players,' the 18-year-old added. Manafi, the commentator, said a friendly before the tournament, possibly hosted by a third country, could help ease tensions. Such a game, he said, could help 'achieve what politicians from both sides have not managed to do for years'.
The Sun
38 minutes ago
- The Sun
Putin ready to ‘help resolve' Iran nuclear stand-off: Kremlin
MOSCOW: Russian President Vladimir Putin is ready to 'help resolve' the standoff between Iran and the United States over Tehran's nuclear programme, the Kremlin said Thursday. 'We have a close partnership with Tehran. And President Putin said that he was ready to use this partnership to help resolve the Iranian nuclear issue,' Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters. After a call between the leaders on Wednesday, US President Donald Trump said Putin had offered to 'participate' in talks on Tehran's nuclear programme, as Trump accused Iran of 'slow-walking' its response to Washington's offer of a deal. Washington and Tehran have held five rounds of talks since April to thrash out a new accord to replace the nuclear deal that Trump abandoned during his first term in 2018. Trump said Monday that his administration would not allow 'any' enrichment of uranium, despite Tehran's insistence that it has the right under the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said earlier Wednesday that Washington's proposal was against Tehran's national interest. Russia and Iran have deepened their military ties amid Moscow's military offensive on Ukraine. The Kremlin said earlier this week that Tehran had the 'right' to a run a peaceful nuclear energy programme.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Malaysia must brace for future US tariffs, says US-Asean Business Council chief policy officer
KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia must be prepared to negotiate the next wave of potential US tariffs targeting key strategic sectors and products such as semiconductors, technology products and pharmaceuticals, rather than focusing solely on negotiating reciprocal tariffs reductions currently with the United States. US-Asean Business Council (US-ABC) executive vice-president and chief policy officer Marc Mealy warned that although the 50% tariffs on aluminium and steel may not severely affect Malaysia in the near term, future tariffs imposed under US national or economic security provisions could have a direct impact on Malaysian industries that are highly integrated into global supply chains. 'Steel and aluminium are not Malaysia's primary export sectors to the US, so these new (aluminium and steel) tariffs, which come into effect today (Wednesday), may not hit Malaysia as hard as they would some other countries. 'But we should be clear, there are other tariffs coming and when we talk about semiconductors, high-tech products, pharmaceuticals, the impact on Malaysia could be significant,' he told Bernama in an interview after appearing as a guest on Bernama TV's 'The Nation' programme hosted by Jessy Chahal. Malaysia was hit with baseline and reciprocal tariffs totalling 24% on April 5, along with 168 other US trading partners, with tariffs ranging as high as 54% and a staggering 145% on China but which have now been reduced to 30%. US President Donald Trump then paused the implementation of the tariffs for 90 days, which are supposed to end on July 8, but he moved forward to impose sectoral tariffs on aluminium and steel imports into the US. In a further twist to the tariffs saga, a US Federal Court struck down most of Trump's tariffs, ruling them illegal, but the ruling has now been temporarily halted following an appeal by the Trump administration. Mealy noted that under US law, additional tariffs could be imposed unilaterally by invoking national or economic security reasons, citing Section 232 of the US Trade Expansion Act, which opens the door for Washington to target sectors beyond those currently under reciprocal tariff negotiations. 'In the semiconductor space, Malaysia is globally competitive and that puts it directly in the line of sight for possible future US tariffs. 'So, when Malaysian officials, like Investment, Trade and Industry Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz, go to the US, I would expect them to raise this issue and start negotiating for exclusions or carve-outs in these areas,' he added. The same concerns apply to Malaysia's medical devices and pharmaceutical exports, as these sectors could also fall under US scrutiny. 'Now is the time for Malaysia to reassess its domestic policies, particularly in key industries, and consider reforms to further strengthen investment appeal and mitigate potential fallout. Engage with the US government, but also look inward,' said Mealy. 'What changes can Malaysia make to enhance competitiveness? And as Asean Chair, Malaysia can lead the region to push for progress on initiatives like the Asean Digital Economy Framework Agreement – that will show global investors that this region is serious about future-proofing its economy.' Mealy underscored that the US private sector remains deeply committed to Asean, with many American companies continuing to expand in Malaysia, particularly in the technology and medical sectors. 'The private sector sees value in Malaysia and Asean, but trade policy changes from Washington could complicate that, unless mitigated by smart diplomacy, reform and regional cooperation.' Although Malaysia might not be severely impacted by the initial round of reciprocal tariffs – which could result in import duties of up to 24% on selected products – the real concern lies in future sectoral tariffs, that could reduce US demand for Malaysian exports. 'Even a 15 to 19% import tax can be a tipping point for an American buyer to source from another country,' Mealy said. Mealy also pointed out that while some Asean countries may not complete negotiations within the current 90-day timeframe, he did not rule out the possibility of the US extending the pause or focus on select countries for deeper discussions. 'For Malaysia, which has been strategic and measured in its approach, this may work to its advantage. But the time to prepare for the next round of trade measures is now,' he said. – Bernama
