US HR firm Deel admits it instructed ‘discreet' surveillance on manager at centre of ‘spy' case
One of the companies in the international human resources (HR) firms' 'spy' dispute instructed that 'discreet' surveillance be carried out on the Irish payroll compliance manager at the centre of High Court proceedings over the affair, a judge was told on Wednesday.
US headquartered Deel Inc, which allegedly recruited Dublin man Keith O'Brien to pass on trade secrets to it from his employer Rippling, also headquartered in the US, did not instruct that there be covert or intimidatory surveillance on Mr O'Brien, Mr Justice Brian Cregan was told.
Last Friday, Mr O'Brien, of Balrothery in north Dublin, was granted a one side only represented injunction preventing 'persons unknown', who were seen driving two different cars in the vicinity of Mr O'Brien's home and workplace, from harassing or intimidating him by following, photographing and recording him or members of his family.
They were also restrained from attending within one kilometre of those places.
READ MORE
The case was against persons unknown because his lawyers did not at that stage know the identities of the owners/drivers of the vehicles.
The court was also told by Imogen McGrath SC, for Mr O'Brien, that it was believed the people involved were working for Deel and the conduct was designed to intimidate him because he had agreed to co-operate with Rippling in a separate case it is bringing over the spy affair against Deel and Mr O'Brien.
The court heard however that, in response to requests to desist, Deel's solicitors Hayes LLP had written to say their client had 'no knowledge' of surveillance by any persons in the vehicles identified.
On Wednesday, when the case returned to the High Court, Ms McGrath said there had been dramatic developments over the previous 24 hours.
The identities associated with the two cars had been provided and the owner/driver of one car allegedly seen in one incident, a couple who attended court, were not involved in any surveillance and the case against them was being discontinued, counsel said.
The driver of the second vehicle which was involved in five other alleged incidents of following and surveilling had also come forward.
John O'Regan BL, for the second driver, asked the judge that his client's name be anonymised until he is able to make a formal application in this respect.
Counsel said the application will be in accordance with case precedent or statute law because his client has significant health issues and operates 'in the sphere of surveillance' and revealing his identity could put his safety at risk and damage his business.
Counsel also asked the case be put back as his client, while refuting Mr O'Brien's claims, wanted to come to a practical agreement in relation to the court orders.
Mr Justice Cregan said he was prepared to hear the application for anonymisation of the defendant but was reluctant to make an order in relation to that at this stage.
The court heard that while Deel was not a defendant in Mr O'Brien's action, which includes a claim for damages, the judge had directed that their lawyers attend court on Wednesday to say why they should or should not be a party.
Paul Gardiner SC, for Deel, told the judge his client had instructed that 'discreet surveillance' be carried out on Mr O'Brien but there was no question that it should be covert and used to intimidate or harass him.
'My client (Deel) engaged with Person B (to carry out surveillance) and unknown to us they engaged Person A and Deel was not involved in instructing anyone to carry out intimidation and we refute that', he said.
The judge said given Deel's solicitors' response to requests to desist from Mr O'Brien's lawyers of having 'no knowledge' of those involved in following him, it 'could be interpreted as being economical with the verité (truth)'.
Mr Gardiner replied his side only ascertained the actual position over the weekend. He also said his client was agreeable to not surveilling Mr O'Brien any further and if he (O'Brien) wished that Deel should be a defendant he should serve papers to that effect.
Ms McGrath, for Mr O'Brien, said they would have to consider that as they would need to see what instructions, including text messages, Deel gave to Person B to carry out the surveillance.
The judge continued the injunctions and adjourned the matter for a week.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Former Ryanair pilot further remanded over €10m cannabis seizure
A former Ryanair pilot charged in connection with the possession of more than €10 million of cannabis is in the process of having the material independently analysed, a court has heard. At Ennis District Court, solicitor Ted McCarthy said the independent analysis of the material will help determine a bail application for Brendan O'Mara. Mr O'Mara (62), of An Tulach, Summerhill, Meelick, Co Clare, was making his fifth court appearance following the seizure of about 500kg of cannabis valued at an estimated €10 million at his home on May 7th. Mr O'Mara appeared in court via video-link from Limerick Prison after a judge refused him bail at a special sitting of Ennis District Court on May 10th following Garda objections. READ MORE Sgt John Burke told the court the Garda investigation is complex and 'involved the seizure of €10 million worth of cannabis'. He said two gardaí are working full-time on the investigation, which involves international contacts and ongoing inquiries into devices that were also seized. 'I take on board what the State has said,' Mr McCarthy said. 'We ourselves are in the process of having the material independently analysed. 'The outcome of that will determine our bail application, which is imminent.' Judge Alec Gabbett remanded Mr O'Mara in custody to appear again at Ennis District Court on July 9th. Mr O'Mara faces two charges – possessing cannabis for sale or supply, and possessing cannabis. At a bail hearing on May 10th, gardaí told the court Mr O'Mara made no reply to the charges after caution, and that 'further, and more serious charges' may be brought against him.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Court increases jail time for rapist who failed to tell gardaí he was a sex offender
A convicted rapist who was jailed last March for rape has been given more time in custody for having failed to inform authorities he was a sex offender. Randi Gladstone (41), formerly from Guyana, had 19 previous convictions from the UK, for offences including rape, kidnapping, robbery and false imprisonment. Last March he was sentenced at the Central Criminal Court for the rape, sexual assault and false imprisonment of a young woman two weeks after he arrived in the State in August 2023. He had previously been subjected to a deportation order from the UK. The offence occurred in 'budget accommodation' in south Co Dublin. READ MORE On Wednesday, Mr Justice Paul McDermott said Gladstone failed to notify gardaí within seven days that he was a sex offender, which was required by law. Mr Justice McDermott said failure to register as a sex offender carries a maximum sentence of five years' imprisonment. He said Gladstone was 'not really appreciating his obligations to register ... but that doesn't cut it'. Noting the guilty plea, he sentenced Gladstone to six further months in prison. The judge noted Gladstone offended within days of arriving in the State, so he said the six-month sentence should be served on top of the 10-year sentence imposed on him last March. The court heard Gladstone flew from Suriname to Schiphol Airport in the Netherlands and arrived into Ireland on August 11th, 2023. Det Garda Carol Corrigan told Patrick Gageby SC, prosecuting, that Gladstone did not inform gardaí of his address within seven days, as is required by law. The court heard Gladstone dragged a young woman into his room where he raped and falsely imprisoned her. Gladstone was made aware of the accusations against him that August 25th. The court heard he went to Dublin Port and bought a ticket to the UK. He was told he was not allowed back into the UK. He was arrested two days later. Gladstone had been residing in South America for some years and had some work history in construction. He is now serving his sentence in Midlands Prison.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Cork man died after he received five to six wasp stings, inquest hears
A man died at his Co Cork home after he received five or six wasp stings as he picked up hedge clippings to the rear of his property, an inquest has heard. Michael (Mick) Sheehan, originally from Ballinlough, Cork City, was pronounced dead at 2.16pm on November 5th last year at his home in Glen Tanar in Carriganine, Macroom. His wife Carmel Sheehan told the inquest on Wednesday how her 56-year-old husband had gone out to help two men who were cutting the hedge at his property some time after noon. After a short period, the retired tax consultant came into the house and told her he was 'after getting stung by a wasp'. READ MORE Mrs Sheehan said her husband, a father of three, was not showing any ill effects at this point. There was no obvious cause for concern. She realised there was not any over-the-counter allergy medication in the family medicine cabinet, so she made the short journey to the local chemist to get the allergy medication Zirtek. When Mrs Sheehan returned to the property she found her husband 'face down on the kitchen floor'. She ran out the back to the two men who were working in the garden. She said they all rushed in to the house. 'I [then] saw John [the gardener] trying to get Mick to respond. He was sitting Mick up and slapping his face.' Mrs Sheehan called an ambulance. The Irish Community Air Ambulance from Rathcoole landed in the nearby golf club. Mrs Sheehan said that when she knew the air ambulance was coming she rushed down to try to show the medics the shortcut to her house. When she arrived back to the house, a first responder told her that if she had prayers to say then it was probably the appropriate time to start them. Mrs Sheehan said that sometime after 2pm the emergency medicine consultant Dr Jason van der Velde told her that her husband had died. A priest was contacted and prayers were said in the kitchen before Mr Sheehan's body was taken to the morgue at Cork University Hospital for a postmortem. Garda Don Coomey gave evidence of going to the Sheehan home after he was told of the death. He said there was a small number of wasps in a nest at the back of the property. Assistant state pathologist Dr Margot Bolster said Mr Sheehan had suffered five or six wasp stings on his head, back and arms. She said very high levels of tryptase were recorded. Elevated levels of tryptase can be a marker for severe anaphylactic reactions, including those triggered by insect stings. Dr Bolster said Mr Sheehan suffered a swelling of the larynx which obstructed his breathing, causing him to 'collapse very suddenly.' She said he had suffered a massive allergic reaction. She told the family she did not think that 'anything could have been done' to change the outcome. Coroner Frank O'Connell recorded a verdict of accidental death. He said it was 'most unfortunate' that Mr Sheehan died when he was 'innocently picking up hedge clippings'. After the inquest at Macroom Court, members of the Sheehan family urged the public to be aware of possible side effects of insect stings. They said people who know they have an allergic reaction to wasp or bee stings should consider investing in EpiPens. These medical devices that are used in an emergency to inject life-saving adrenaline into people when they have severe allergic reactions.
