Erin Patterson denies foraging death cap mushrooms hours before buying food dehydrator, murder trial hears
Erin Patterson denies leading health officials on a 'wild goose chase', and that she foraged death cap mushrooms two hours before buying a food dehydrator, a Victorian court has heard.
Patterson, 50, faces three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder relating to poisoning four lunch guests with beef wellington served at her house in Leongatha, Victoria on 29 July 2023.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to murdering her estranged husband Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, and attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, Simon's uncle and Heather's husband.
Lawyers for Patterson say the death cap mushroom poisoning was a tragic and terrible accident.
In her seventh day in the witness box, Patterson was again asked repeatedly by Nanette Rogers SC, for the prosecution, whether she agreed with a series of suggestions about the lunch, and her behaviour in the weeks before and after it.
Patterson denied that she deliberately bought separate eye fillet steaks as she wanted to make individual beef wellingtons, and not because she could not source a single larger 'log' of eye fillet, as the recipe had called for.
She agreed that she may not have needed to put additional dried mushrooms in the dish, given she had bought enough mushrooms from the supermarket for the recipe, but denied that the dried mushrooms were too 'overpowering' to be included in the 'special' beef wellingtons.
'I thought it was the perfect dish for them,' Patterson said.
Patterson also denied she had been wrong to tell police she had been 'very helpful' to health authorities who were trying to find an Asian grocer she had bought dried mushrooms from, nor that she lied about buying these mushrooms.
Erin Patterson hosts lunch for estranged husband Simon's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and his aunt and uncle Heather and Ian Wilkinson. Patterson serves beef wellington.
All four lunch guests are admitted to hospital with gastro-like symptoms.
Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson die in hospital.
Don Patterson dies in hospital. Victoria police search Erin Patterson's home and interview her.
Ian Wilkinson is discharged from hospital after weeks in intensive care.
Police again search Erin Patterson's home, and she is arrested and interviewed. She is charged with three counts of murder relating to the deaths of Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson, and the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson.
Jury is sworn in.
Murder trial begins. Jury hears that charges of attempting to murder her estranged husband Simon are dropped.
'You sent them on a wild goose chase, trying to locate this Asian grocer, correct or incorrect,' Rogers asked.
'Incorrect,' Patterson replied.
She also said she did not know or suspect that Don and Gail were ill because of eating the beef wellington at the time she decided to feed leftovers of the dish to her children for dinner the night after the lunch.
Rogers said it was alleged Patterson visited Loch in April and Outtrim in May after posts were made on the website iNaturalist identifying sightings of death cap mushrooms in the nearby towns.
Rogers said that Patterson picked death cap mushrooms in Loch on 28 April 2023, and within two hours of finding them went and bought a Sunbeam food dehydrator to dry them.
Patterson denied that she had seen the iNaturalist posts, or deliberately visited the towns on the dates in which the prosecution alleges her phone data suggests she did so.
The court has previously heard that Patterson dumped the food dehydrator at a local tip the week after the lunch. It was later recovered by police and a forensic examination uncovered her fingerprints and traces of death cap mushrooms.
Patterson admits she dumped the food dehydrator, saying she did so in a panic about a visit child protection authorities were planning to make, and the fact she says Simon accused her of using it to poison his parents.
Patterson's supreme court trial at the Latrobe Valley law courts in Morwell continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Under-pressure Brisbane Broncos take extraordinary measure after recent controversies and rumours of player unrest engulf the club
A recent number of controversial incidents have forced the Brisbane Broncos to take a huge measure to maintain the club's reputation. Following the fallout relating to Ezra Mam's car crash, Reece Walsh's punch video and the sacking of Marty Taupau, the Broncos have hired a crisis management expert, according to reports. Buzz Rothfield of The Courier Mail writes that Grant Williams, a renowned reputation management expert, has joined the club. The NRL journalist added that Williams was 'rushed in to protect the club and its brand'. The footy club have been dragged into several off-field controversies this year, and the club have opted to draft in a crisis management expert to provide advice on multiple operational matters. Rothfield adds that Williams, who has previously worked with the NRL's media and communications set-up and worked as an advisor to NSW Police commissioner Mick Fuller, will work with players and managers at the club. That work is due to pertains mostly to their responsibilities in line with the NRL's rules on conduct and social media use. Mam pleaded guilty to one count of driving with a relevant drug in his system and another count of driving without a licence for an incident that took place in Bardon, Brisbane, last October. He was fined $120,000 by the NRL and the Broncos and handed a nine-match ban after he had crashed into an Uber taxi, injuring a four-year-old girl. Meanwhile, the Broncos were left furious at Walsh after he uploaded a bizarre and worrying video of himself appearing to punch a friend with a boxing glove on. Another player, Taupau parted company from the football club on amicable terms after he had appeared to like a social media post openly criticising Michael Maguire. The Broncos boss himself has also had a turbulent induction to life at the Clive Berghofer Centre. Williams' website states that he is a 'public affairs, strategic communications and media management advisory, providing crisis, issues and reputation management to companies organisations, family offices, boards, chairs chief executive officers, professionals and individuals.' His website adds that Williams will: 'personally prepare you for any crisis or issue' as well as 'identifying risks before they happen and provide a 24/7 urgent and bespoke response when they do'. Williams told Rothfield: 'The Broncos are a tremendous club and I'm looking forward to supporting their team with strategic counsel where required.' On the pitch, the Broncos have had a mixed season, despite being pipped to be a premiership contender prior to 2025. However, they have struggled to consistently perform, with Brisbane having won only one of their last five matches. Earlier this week, boss Dave Donaghy has also criticised claims that there is a fractured changing room at the club, throwing his support behind Maguire. There have been suggestions that the Broncos boss is facing a player revolt, but Donaghy said: 'The talk of unrest is simply not true. 'I'm not there every day, but I have asked the football department to give me some feedback if there is some discontent and I've had nothing come back of that nature. 'I have asked questions. We had a board meeting last week, we had 'Madge' in to talk about things and one of the directors was at training and they called me and said the players have been nothing but positive of Madge. 'Myself and the directors walk around the club and we get a feel if there's some major issues. We see none of that. The issue we see is Madge has come into reset a team and it could take longer than we thought.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Why this picture of a father and son peacefully fishing on a quiet river has Aussies up in arms
Photos of a father and his young son fishing on the bank of a crocodile infested lake have sparked outrage on social media. The pair were pictured fishing at Cahills Crossing in Kakadu, in the Northern Territory, this week. Karen Beckham caught them casually standing within inches of the water and mere metres away from signs warning tourists of the danger they were in. Ms Beckham shared the photos on Facebook in an attempt to caution others not to do the same. 'And the parent the year award goes to? This dude,' she wrote. 'Poor child would have no idea about crocodile danger.' Others debated in the comment section of Ms Beckham's post about how much danger the two were really in. Crocodile experts have also taken note of the photos and urged people to be more careful in the area. Matt Cornish, co-founder of Community Representation of Crocodiles, said complacency can be a killer around dangerous predators. 'Cahills Crossing is considered to be a high-risk crocodile location where people need to be extremely vigilant,' he told Yahoo News. 'We have had crocodile fatalities there over the last couple of decades.' The stretch of the river where the photo was taken is a popular fishing area despite the risks it poses. Signs in the area attempt to warn tourists and locals to remain vigilant at all times due to the fatal attacks which have happened in previous years. 'Do not risk your life,' one sign reads. 'A fatal crocodile attack occurred here.' Even with signs like these people are still seen fishing on the bank quite frequently. Those who commented on Ms Beckham's post went back and forth with some defending the father while others similarly condemned him. 'Looks to be a reasonable distance off the water from the photo,' one person wrote. 'Doesn't look that bad. They'll be right,' another said. 'Disaster just waiting to happen parents should have informed them crocks are about and no swimming parent's failed,' a third added. 'Cahills Crossing, more Crocs there than the rest of Australia,' a fourth wrote. Anyone who visits the area has been advised to ensure they are up to date with the latest Croc Wise advise. Ensuring that fish and other food is kept away from the water's edge and remaining alert at all time is essential. Crocodiles can move so fast however that it is often impossible for people to react fast enough to escape their attack.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Heartbroken mum reveals Pheobe's secret DISABILITY - as she hits back at the local whispering campaign that threatens to destroy her livelihood
The mother of Pheobe Bishop has revealed her daughter lived with a disability, and slammed local rumours she will shut down her NDIS-registered business. Pheobe, 17, went missing near Queensland's Bundaberg Airport about 8.30am on May 15 after booking a trip to WA to visit her boyfriend. Last Friday, officers discovered the teenager's remains near Goodnight Scrub National Park. The teen's housemates, James Wood, 34, and Tanika Bromley, 33, have been charged with her murder, three weeks after she missed her flight and vanished. Police allege they moved her body more than once. Daily Mail Australia earlier revealed that Bromley was employed by Pheobe's mum as a support worker, until she was made redundant from her role last year. This week rumours have circulated in the Gin Gin community that Pheobe was an NDIS recipient through her mother's company. Claims also emerged that Smiley's Support Services, the business run by Pheobe's mum Kylie Johnson, was 'unregistered' with NDIS. However, NDIS records show that Smiley's has approved registration status and is in force until it's up for renewal in February 2026. Ms Johnson took to social media on Thursday to hit back at the allegations. 'We've heard a few rumours about ourselves lately, however, we'd like to assure you all that Smiley's has NO intention of closing,' she wrote, adding that the business was 'continuing as usual'. Ms Johnson implied the rumours had come from other NDIS providers in the area. 'Imagine people from your own industry using this tragedy to benefit themselves?' she wrote. 'After 23 years of working between the disability and aged care sector I'm actually pretty disappointed. 'My journey started as a carer, cleaner and worked in dementia specific units and aged care homes. I've worked and studied for the last 23 years to be professionally where I am today. 'My company was established at the same time our NDIS registration was applied for. We were approved for all levels of support that we provide.' Ms Johnson mentioned that 'our last audit in June 2024 was completed as per the NDIS Guidelines'. 'This means we had meet the significant NDIS industry standards which we did with beautiful feedback,' she added. 'This has given my staff a high level of confidence and transparency in their service delivery. 'Team Smiley's won't let the bullies and trolls WIN and even though I'm not there at the moment, this company has an amazing team that continues to go above and beyond for everyone. 'Your disability only defines you if you allow it to and Phee never let hers define her.' Ms Johnson did not specify what Pheobe's disability was. However, before she disappeared, the teen had shared a post to TikTok about bipolar disorder. 'Having a partner with bpd means... getting blocked or left over small incidents... they will say very harsh things they don't mean when having an episode,' the post said, apparently in an attempt to explain her sometimes unpredictable behaviour. Ms Johnson previously said Pheobe 'didn't fit the mainstream school model' and struggled with her education until she was enrolled at the alternative Y School in Bundaberg. Pheobe's final posts to social media suggested the troubled teen had fallen out with her mother and would not return home. She also claimed in text messages to her aunt, Caz Johnson, that her mum had told her to 'get out'. The rubbish-strewn flat where she lived with Wood and Bromley was just down the road from her mother's business. Prior to registering Smiley's Support Services in 2021, Ms Johnson ran another Queensland business called Butterfly Spiritual Healing and Massage from 2015 to 2017, ABN records show. The business offered services such as reiki healing and aura cleansing. NDIS declined to comment when asked if Pheobe was a care recipient, citing privacy reasons. Support workers are potentially subject to a range of requirements prior to employment, such as working with children checks and police checks. Pheobe's cousin Whitney Woodfield replied to Ms Johnson's post, adding: 'These rumours are utterly ridiculous. 'The things this company has done for the community is incredible 'Phee would never've been okay if they were taken down over this. Proud of you for standing your ground.' Neither Wood nor Bromley appeared in court when Pheobe's alleged murder was mentioned in Bundaberg Magistrates Court last Friday. They have not entered pleas and have now been sent to jail on remand -after previously being being in police custody for several days after they were charged. Wood is now being held at Brisbane Correctional Centre, and with Bromley in Brisbane Women's Correctional Centre.
