Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case appeal decision expected this morning
Australian special forces veteran Ben Roberts-Smith is today expected to learn if his appeal against a multi-million-dollar defamation loss is successful.
A decision in the Federal Court in Sydney is due this morning.
The appeal was heard in February last year after his defamation case against three Nine-owned newspapers was dismissed.
Mr Roberts-Smith sued over a series of articles five years earlier on allegations of war crimes in Afghanistan, bullying and domestic violence against a woman in Canberra.
The Federal Court found the publisher had proven four allegations of unlawful killings in Afghanistan were substantially true to the civil standard, along with allegations of bullying.
While the alleged domestic violence was found to be not sufficiently supported by evidence, the court found any reputational harm fell away in the context of the overall decision.
The defamation case was estimated to have cost upwards of $25 million and lasted more than 100 days.
In the appeal, Mr Roberts-Smith's legal team argued Justice Anthony Besanko made several legal errors, including incomplete fact finding, insufficient reasoning and arbitrary conclusions about witness reliability.
In a broad challenge to the judgement, they argued the evidence at trial fell short of the level of cogency required to support such serious allegations.
In late March, they began an eleventh-hour bid to add a further ground of appeal by arguing there was a miscarriage of justice in the original trial, after they were anonymously emailed a conversation recorded in secret of investigative journalist Nick McKenzie speaking to a witness in 2021.
Mr Roberts-Smith's counsel Arthur Moses SC told the court McKenzie had made a "series of damning and unambiguous admissions" during the conversation.
"It reflects a real-time understanding by Mr McKenzie that what he was doing — receiving and using information about the appellant's legal strategy from individuals who had unauthorised access to his private email account — was professionally improper and ethically indefensible," he said.
He alleged the journalist had received details of Mr Roberts-Smith's confidential legal strategy from the veteran's ex-wife and her friend, which McKenzie denied under cross-examination.
"Getting information about your opponent's confidential legal strategy would be a serious breach of your ethics as a journalist, correct?" the barrister asked.
McKenzie replied: "I accept that getting legally privileged information would be wrong. I do not accept I ever got legally privileged information."
A Nine spokesperson said the claims of miscarriage were "baseless" and were a "continuation of the sustained campaign of mistruths peddled" by Mr Roberts-Smith and his backers.
"Nine has full confidence in the reporting and actions of Nick McKenzie," they said in March.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
23 minutes ago
- ABC News
Push to fix home care package backlog
The government's overhaul of aged care laws was due to take effect next month, but there had been some concern in the sector about that timeframe. ( Supplied: Rosie O'Beirne )

News.com.au
28 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Mother is demanding her daughter's suicide video be played to students
A Queensland mother is demanding her daughter's suicide video be played to students at every school in Australia, furious nothing has stopped the wave of deaths since her daughter died 12 years ago. Vanessa Love said she feels rage every time she sees another headline about another child dying. She is speaking out after hearing about the death of Sydney schoolboy 13-year-old Atreyu McCann earlier this month and now, the death of Hamish Carter who was just 12 when he took his life just 50 metres from his southern Sydney home. Ms Love's daughter Courtney shared a harrowing farewell video with friends on social media before suiciding in Kiama. Ms Love allowed the vision to be part of The Sunday Telegraph 's Charlotte's Wish documentary, which called for change after the death of 12-year-old Santa Sabina student Charlotte O'Brien last year. 'What is it going to take? This is just insanity, that children keep on dying and bullies keep on being bullies,' Ms Love told this week. 'I want every single school in this country to show Courtney's video, to show the sadness in her eyes, to show her giving up to the people who told her to cut deeper and deeper. 'If schools won't play it then I want to know why. I would love to hear them justify it. Is it too distressing? Too real? Well I'll tell you something, this is my reality and it's reality for all these other mums.' Ms Love said she was gutted for Charlotte's mum Kelly and Hamish's mum Jodie and wants to team up to make a real difference. All three mums have flagged talking at schools to get through to children and all three support the Federal Government's pledge to create a national bullying policy. Newscorp's Growth Intelligence Centre (GIC) recently completed a study focusing on the Australian primary and secondary education sector that found bullying and school safety was the number one issue for parents. They want immediate and sustained focus on making schools safer and strengthening anti-bullying policies. The study found three in five Australian school children have experienced bullying at school and one in three parents say their child's school doesn't take bullying seriously. Ms Carter, who lost Hamish in 2022, said there is no time to waste. 'This is so f**king serious. We are losing these gorgeous children far too often. The time is now to stop it,' Ms Carter said. 'The world has lost too many of these special souls, and we can no longer stay silent about this. 'It is time to scream and shout as loud as we can and change the rules, change people's lives, train teachers and authorities to pass laws against this.' All three women have made submissions to the Anti-Bullying Rapid Review, being led by Dr Charlotte Keating and Dr Jo Robinson AM, examining current school procedures and best practice methods to address bullying behaviours. The experts have been working with key stakeholders across metropolitan and regional Australia, including parents, teachers, students, parent groups, state education departments and the non-government sector. Charlotte's parents have met face to face with the two experts - and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese - and are optimistic change will come. 'The government's rapid review task force has a real chance to save lives and can I just say thank you to the government for taking the initiative to face this pandemic head on and not continue to put the issue of bullying in the too hard basket,' said Charlotte's still-devastated mum Kelly O'Brien. 'We educate our children about kindness, we educate our children about bullying and anti- bullying behaviours, but when they are brave enough to come forward and speak out we label them the problem,' she said. 'Let's educate children when they come forward so they know they are safe, they are believed and their problems will be solved. We don't all need to like each other but we all need to respect and be kind to each other.' Mrs O'Brien said teachers, parents and students all need help. 'We need to tackle the issue of bullying as a community. No child should ever feel so beaten down, so disbelieved and rejected when they come forward. 'There needs to be a zero policy to bullying. One-off incidents are still bullying. It doesn't need to be repeated to be classed as bullying. 'Why do we let it get to the level of repeated behaviour. 'My baby is gone. So many babies are gone. The ripple affect of every death is catastrophic to victims and their bullies alike.'

News.com.au
44 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Defecting Greens senator Dorinda Cox pens extraordinary resignation letter
Defecting Greens senator Dorinda Cox has launched an extraordinary broadside at her ex-party, accusing it of racism on her way out the door. In a formal resignation letter, reported by the ABC, Ms Cox said the Greens had failed her as the Party's 'last' First Nations MP. 'In my experience, the Greens tolerate a culture that permits violence against First Nations women within its structures,' she wrote in the letter. 'In this respect, the party is deeply racist.' Ms Cox left the Party last week after a failed bid to become its deputy leader, instead defecting to join the Australian Labor Party. In her letter Ms Cox specifically mentioned a 2023 incident at Perth Airport, which reportedly turned into a physical confrontation between Ms Cox and the former leader of the Blak Greens Tjanara Goreng Goreng. At the time both women made reports to police about the incident. 'My reports to the party and parliamentary workplace services range from being assaulted at Perth Airport by a party member, which was ignored (indeed, I was advised not to report it to police), to incidents involving my staff who were isolated by the state and other MPs offices,' Ms Cox's letter reads. She continued to make broad claims about the Party failing in its 'duty of care' to her and her staff, accusing the Greens of being 'solely' focused on winning seats. Tensions have been high since Ms Cox left the party, with South Australian Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young insisting that the 'honourable' move would be for Ms Cox to hand back her seat. At the time of her resignation newly-minted Greens Leader Larissa Waters expressed disappointment in Ms Cox's decision. 'Senator Cox would have had more chance of effecting change by continuing to work with the Greens in the sole balance of power,' Ms Waters said at the time. 'We wish her well.' The Greens have since revoked Ms Cox's party membership. The letter also addressed bullying allegations against Ms Cox, after it was revealed last year that a reported 20 staff had left her office over a three-year period – some over bullying complaints. 'I have faced an unremitting campaign of bullying and dishonest claims over the last 18 months,' Ms Cox wrote. 'I am not, and have never been, a bully. I do not perpetrate it.'