Construction workers in Ireland are a third less productive than elsewhere, report warns
Irish construction workers are one-third less productive than their international peers, partly because of poor uptake of modern methods of construction (MMC), a new report warns.
While the Government is now set on developing MMC as a core means of addressing the housing crisis, a new report from the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) today indicates that Irish construction workers lag behind their peers in productivity.
The report notes that a shortage of infrastructure is a 'legacy' of the financial crisis.
It says: 'Much of the capacity in the construction sector was lost thereafter. Many construction firms went bust, and many of the workers emigrated. Construction employment quickly fell from almost 240,000 to 85,000.
'Although employment has gradually recovered since then (up to 170,000 workers), investment in new construction methods has lagged behind other countries. As a result, output per hour worked is 33% lower than in peer countries. Pic: Getty Images
'This partly reflects the low uptake of modern methods of construction, such as off-site manufacturing.
'This low level of investment may be due to the boom-bust nature of the construction sector in Ireland.
'When firms see how quickly things can change, they may be more reluctant to invest for the long term.'
The report says that in order for Ireland to catch up it needs to do three things. Firstly, it will need to sustain high levels of investment in key areas.
It states: 'Some of the infrastructure deficits are in areas where the State is the biggest provider, for example healthcare. Government capital investment in healthcare is already at high levels. If this can be maintained in the coming years, this will help address infrastructure shortfalls in that area.' Pic: Getty Images
Secondly, the Government will need to boost productivity in the construction sector if it is to make the need for additional workers less acute.
And thirdly, the planning and objection system for construction will need to be streamlined.
The report states: 'Delays and uncertainty created by the system are impacting projects.
'The new Planning and Development Act may help but it is too soon to tell.
'Most investment is carried out by the private sector, so this needs to be facilitated as much as possible.
'This is particularly important now, as investment tends to be delayed during periods of uncertainty.'
The report also notes that Ireland's infrastructure continues to lag behind other high income European countries, citing research that shows Ireland's infrastructure is about 25% behind that of our peers. Pic: Shutterstock
The report states: 'Significant shortfalls in housing, health, transport and electricity are evident.
'These challenges can only be addressed through sustained high levels of investment in these areas.
'Regardless of what happens to the international environment, these infrastructure deficits need to be addressed.
'If the economy weathers the changing environment, it will have high levels of employment and high demand for infrastructure.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
41 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
New arrival: MGS5 offers range of up to 480km and costs €29,995
Irish customers can choose from two trim levels, Excite and Exclusive, and two battery sizes. The entry-level model is powered by a 49kWh battery and can cover up to 340km, while the top version gets a 64kWh unit that generates 227bhp and a 0-100kmh sprint time of 6.3 seconds. Both are capable of fast-charging at 120kWh, meaning you can get 80pc battery in just 24 minutes. Standard kit includes 17-inch alloys; LED headlights; rear parking camera with sensors; 10.25-inch driver display; and 12.8-inch colour touchscreen, which is home to sat-nav and wireless AppleCarPlay and Android Auto. The Exclusive adds heated steering wheel and front seats; 18-inch rims; wireless phone charging; and powered tailgate. Order books are open now, with first deliveries in the coming weeks. Prices for the Excite start at €29,995, while the Exclusive is €35,995.
Irish Independent
44 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Wells Fargo has charge over shares in Dublin Liberties Distillery owner
Newly-filed paperwork with the Companies Registration Office (CRO), which was signed off by directors just last month and lodged last week, confirms the charge. The sign-off came just as Quintessential Brands was closing its Dublin Liberties Distillery in the capital, as it faces headwinds affecting the global whiskey market. It said at the time that the closure is temporary and that it is committed to reopening the venue 'soon'. A spokesperson for Quintessential Brands said the paperwork filed with the CRO relates to refinancing completed in 2020. It's unclear why there was a near five-year delay. Because of the nature of the agreement, which involves shares, a declaration had to be filed under Section 203 of the Companies Act, which relates to transactions involving financial assistance for the acquisition of shares. 'Failure to file the declaration not later than 21 days after the date of the restricted activity will invalidate the carrying on of that activity,' the CRO says. The High Court can validate a late filing where it is 'just and equitable' to do so. The Quintessential spokesperson said: 'It is paperwork that is finally being put in place for the refinancing that was completed in December 2020. Its covenants haven't changed and still apply today and moving forward.' The paperwork signed off by directors on May 16 states that Quintessential Brands Ireland Holdings 'will accede' to a facilities agreement originally dated in 2011 and subsequently amended and restated a number of times between Quintessential Brands Ireland Whiskey Limited and Wells Fargo Capital Finance (UK), including on April 29, 2020, and on December 17, 2020. 'It is a condition to the continued availability of the facilities available under the amended and restated facilities agreement that the company… enter into a share charge, between the company and Wells Fargo Capital Finance,' according to the new filing with the CRO. Quintessential Brands Ireland Holdings also owns First Ireland Spirits, the largest independent producer of Irish cream liqueur and Irish country creams in Ireland, according to the group. It has a manufacturing facility outside Abbeyleix in Co Laois. The Irish holding company is part of the wider Quintessential Brands group, which manufactures own-label and private-label drinks. Its stable includes Greenall's Gin, Dead Rabbit Irish Whiskey and O'Mara's Country Cream.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Fears new rent controls will lead to landlords hoarding properties
There are concerns that the Government's plans for a new system of rent controls will create a 'very big financial incentive' for landlords not to put properties on the market if they become vacant between now and next March. This would enable many landlords to set rents at market rates in March, instead of being tied into 2pc increases under the current Rent Pressure Zone (RPZ) rules. A government-commissioned review warned it could take four years before the new rules have any dampening effect on rising rents. A review of RPZs by the Housing Agency also warned that any hoped-for boost to housing construction arising from a reformed system, could be wiped out by global factors including a trade war. The agency recommended reform of the rent pressure zone system, saying this should 'incentivise a return to investment' after a sharp decline in the number of rental apartments being built. 'It will take at least three to four years for this investment to result in more homes being built, but in the longer term any increased supply of rental properties should have a dampening effect on rising rents,' it said. The review further warned that the reforms will not be enough to attract desired investment in investment, and further measures will be needed. Factors including a potential rise in interest rates mean that institutional investment 'might not return at the scale desired, or for the duration of time necessary, to reach housing targets'. It said: 'Externally driven inflation could be triggered by an escalation of geopolitical tensions or renewed stress in global supply chains. At the time of writing, the US had just announced a worldwide imposition of tariffs. 'As a result, the international macro framework is in a state of flux and there's high levels of uncertainty regarding the trajectory of interest rates in the near to medium-term.' I think the only way we can get rents down is by increasing supply As the opposition claimed that the proposed measures will increase rents, the Housing Minister James Browne, was unable to say when the changes would result in falling rents. 'I think the only way we can get rents down is by increasing supply,' he said. 'I expect rents to fall over time. What the particular length of time is, I wouldn't be able to predict.' Sinn Féin's housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin said there is now a 'big financial incentive' for landlords not to bring properties on to the market if they become available between now and next March. 'Any new tenancy agreement created from the first of March next year will come in at the top market rent,' he said. 'If a new tenant moves into a rental property tomorrow, the RPZ rules will apply. So there is an economic incentive to wait and given the level of churn in the rental market, that will have an immediate impact.' Under the new plans, the RPZ system, which was due to expire at the end of the year, will in effect be extended nationwide. All existing tenancies will come under a 2pc cap or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. Rent increases in new apartment developments will be capped at the level of inflation – in an effort to encourage new developments. New tenancies, created from next March onwards, will be set at market value and offer a six-year rolling tenancy, after which the rent can be reset and put back to the market rate. Large landlords, defined as those with four or more tenancies, will be banned from carrying out no-fault evictions. Smaller landlords can end tenancies via no-fault evictions in limited circumstances such as economic hardship or to move a family member in. But if they do so, they cannot reset the rent. The Government is looking at increasing fines for landlords who break eviction rules and is consulting the Attorney General on the matter. Mr Browne said the fines they should be 'higher' and 'substantial' but there are limits in increasing fines before it crosses into the jurisdiction of the courts. He said he would also 'like to see' a rents register that would bring transparency to what a property had charged in rent previously. Asked who would police the ban on resetting rents except in the case of no-fault evictions, Mr Browne said it would be the Residential Tenancies Board. Renters will pay for government policy failures The Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne warned the changes would lead to increased rental costs and incentivise evictions, adding: 'Renters will pay for government policy failures.' He said the no-fault eviction ban will not apply to at least half of all tenancies. 'There are huge loopholes here. It appears that tenants of large landlords will have no-fault protections, but tenants of smaller landlords – at least half the market – will not be covered,' he said. 'In these cases, we will see thousands and thousands of renting families exposed to higher rents and it will, as Focus Ireland said, be incentivising evictions.'
