Wrongly accused nurse 'mourning loss of career'
A nurse who was falsely accused of having an inappropriate relationship with a mental health patient says she is in "mourning" for her lost career.
Jessica Thorpe, from Newcastle, was working as a nurse for the Cumbria, Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust when she was suspended after a patient claimed she was pregnant with his child.
This week an employment tribunal ruled she was entitled to £23,500 compensation from the trust, which said it was disappointed with the constructive dismissal ruling.
"Nursing is not something that you get into for that pay cheque at all - it's about your character and who you are as a person," Miss Thorpe said.
"I feel like I'm mourning the loss of my career."
Miss Thorpe joined the trust in 2016 and was carrying out a nursing apprenticeship with Sunderland University when the allegations surfaced in 2020.
In the five years which ended with the tribunal proceedings, the nurse fought to clear her name.
"I feel like the last five years have been incredibly claustrophobic.
"I've used things like social media to distract me from that and pretend that it's not happening.
"But now that it's all over, I feel like I can really breathe again and carry on with my life."
After her suspension, the 31-year-old started an Instagram and YouTube profile which became so popular she made enough money from her posts to enable her to pay the bills after leaving nursing.
"Social media was a complete accident for me," she said. "It never was meant to turn into what it has, it was never something that I thought: 'I'm going to make money from this, I'm going to change my career'.
"It was a total distraction to me, it took me away from the reality of what was going on in my life."
Miss Thorpe said she was the first to flag issues with the patient when he told her he believed she was pregnant and that the baby was his.
She reported it to the nurse in charge of the mental health unit where she worked and included what he had said in his patient's notes.
But, a few weeks later, when he made the same allegation to another member of staff, Miss Thorpe was suspended pending an investigation.
"I honestly felt a bit sick - I couldn't believe that it had actually escalated this far, considering I had already raised concerns," she said.
"I don't disagree with being suspended. It's just the way that they dealt with it afterwards."
Miss Thorpe faced a disciplinary hearing and the allegation against her was not upheld.
However, the patient later died and a separate investigation was launched, as a result of which Miss Thorpe was kept off work for a total of two years.
When she was eventually told she could return to work, she felt her reputation had been tainted and she was not getting the support she was hoping for from the trust, so she resigned.
Lynne Shaw, executive director of workforce at the trust, said they had put measures in place for Miss Thorpe's return, including a return-to-work plan and mentor.
"However, Ms Thorpe decided to end her employment with the trust."
Miss Thorpe sued the trust for constructive unfair dismissal, unlawful deduction of wages and breach of contract, and won on all three counts.
"I thought, if I take them to tribunal then I can actually officially clear my name and say to them you can't treat people this way."
Miss Thorpe said the tribunal process was not just very difficult but also very costly, and she was concerned about the wider impact on the NHS.
"We always hear that the NHS has got no money and they're struggling for nurses, but they're literally haemorrhaging money on cases like mine," she said.
"Lengthy suspensions are so expensive. Why is it that this is what taxpayers are spending their money on when it should be on care?"
Ms Shaw said the trust was disappointed with the outcome of the tribunal but "respect its findings and will look at what lessons can be learned".
Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
Payout for nurse suspended over fake patient claim
Nurse suspended after patient baby claim wins case
Cumbria, Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Medscape
an hour ago
- Medscape
NHS Blood Supplies Running Low Amid Donor Shortage
NHS Blood and Transplant (NHSBT) has issued an urgent call for more blood donors 'to stabilise the nation's blood supply', warning that stocks of O negative red cells are nearing red alert status. NHSBT said there was an annual shortfall of 200,000 donors needed to meet growing demand. Dr Jo Farrar, the body's chief executive, said that maintaining stocks over the past 12 months had been 'challenging'. Cyber-Attack Led to Acute Shortage The supply problem was exacerbated by last summer's ransomware attack on several London hospitals. The disruption to cross-matching procedures forced clinicians to rely on O negative blood. This blood type is known as the 'universal donor' because it can be given to patients of any blood group without triggering a transfusion reaction. Just 8% of the population has O negative blood but it accounts for 16% of hospital demand. As the ransomware threat unfolded, NHSBT shut down multiple IT systems as a precautionary measure. This led to major disruptions in blood collection and transport. Several London hospitals declared critical incidents, cancelled surgeries and tests, and faced transfusion delays. Blood Stocks Remain Critically Low NHSBT said stocks have yet to recover, with current levels strained by a recent series of bank holidays falling in quick succession. NHSBT aims to maintain 6 days' stock of red blood cells. As of 9 am on 9 June, supplies of O-, B-, AB-, O+, and A+ all fell below that threshold, with O- at just 3.4 days. Only A-, B+, and AB+ blood types registered more than 6 days of stock. A letter sent to senior managers and practitioners on 21 May warned that the ongoing amber alert for group O red cells could escalate to a red alert. A pre-amber alert remains in place for group B D-negative red cells. The letter urged adherence to the National Blood Transfusion Committee's red cell shortage plan which was updated in October 2024. Call for One Million Active Donors To meet NHS demand safely, NHSBT said it needs one million regular blood donors. However, its most recent analysis showed participation fell short by over 200,000. Despite an increase in new donor registrations over the past year, only 24% of registrants went on to give blood. Currently, just 2% of the population is supporting the country's blood supply. In support of National Blood Week (9-15 June), NHSBT urged people to join 'the country's largest volunteering force' by donating blood. Focus on Donors with Ro Subtype NHSBT highlighted a critical need for more donors of Black Caribbean and Black African heritage. Around half of people in these groups have the Ro subtype, vital for treating sickle cell disease, the UK's fastest growing genetic blood disorder. In a press release, Health Minister Baroness Merron said: 'The NHS is in urgent need of more lifesaving blood donors from all backgrounds. We are working alongside NHSBT to make donating blood easier than ever before, opening up new donor centres and making appointments available closer to home.'
Entrepreneur
3 hours ago
- Entrepreneur
5 Ways We Can Improve Men's Mental Health in Business
There are subtle ways businesses can improve the well-being of men who face the highest risk of poor mental health. Here's what you need to know. Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own. Men's mental health is in crisis worldwide. Statistics show that men account for 70% of suicides worldwide, as described in an article by Rob Whitley, a professor in psychiatry from McGill University in Canada. Despite this alarming fact, men are less likely than women to seek help when experiencing poor mental health. This is due to the fact that there is still a social stigma that makes many men believe that being perceived as vulnerable or seeking help goes against the norms of societal constructions of masculinity. Interestingly, research by Mind, a UK mental health charity, found that work life is the main source of men's mental health issues. The charity found that one in three men attribute work stress to the ill effects on their mental wellbeing, which is twice as many as women who report this. According to another study conducted by CV Library in 2019, 61% of men surveyed wanted to quit their work as it affected their mental health, compared to only 48.5% of women who said so. Moreover, the pressure to perform well in business has meant that CEOs and entrepreneurs are disproportionately affected by mental health issues, too, compared to the wider public, according to an article published in Small Business Economics. Related: Taking Care of Mental Health Is Powerful, Not Weak When the Priory Group, a mental healthcare facilities provider in the UK, interviewed 1,000 men for a survey on men's mental health, they discovered that although 60% of men have talked about their mental health with someone at some point in their lives, 40% of men still haven't discussed their mental health issues with close friends, family or even a medical professional. Among these men who have never opened up about their mental health, the majority reported that the underlying reason for it is that they'd learned to deal with it themselves, with the second and third most popular reasons being, "I don't wish to be a burden to anyone" and "I'm too embarrassed." These findings tell me that there is a way forward, but it requires out-of-the-box thinking. To tackle men's mental health in business, we need to craft solutions that will make men more likely to seek help in their workspaces, without feeling embarrassed about it. Here are five ways we can do this: 1. Bringing awareness to the workplace One of the first steps to destigmatizing the shame many men face with regard to mental health issues is to normalize the discourse around mental health issues. According to an independent workplace mental health review by Lord Dennis Stevenson and Paul Farmer conducted in 2017, "the correct way to view mental health is that we all have it and we fluctuate between thriving, struggling and being ill and possibly off work." Bringing the realization that even a seemingly healthy and productive employee or business leader can have underlying mental health issues will lessen the pressures many men face around seeking help. Through normalizing these discussions via newsletters, group projects and even casual training sessions, a workplace can be an easier space for men to discuss their mental health challenges if the subject matter is actively framed as something that everyone collectively could go through. Related: 6 Common Barriers to Happiness and Productivity for Men 2. Reduce the usage of the term "mental health" To ensure that mental health services in the workplace are utilized by men, it is vital that we change the language we use to describe the problem in the first place. Using the term "mental health" can be distressing or off-putting for men, according to research, and instead, more specific terms such as "stress" or "burnout" should be used to describe mental health problems. Men prefer focusing on and talking about problems that are more solvable, so avoiding broader terms when discussing mental health issues can make them open up more. Asking men specific questions relating to work performance could be easier for them to tackle instead of asking more general questions like, "Are you okay?" 3. Encourage lifestyle-based solutions Men can often feel isolated if they are identified as having a personal problem in their workplace. Instead, greater benefits could be achieved in men's mental health when mental health solutions are tied to wider lifestyle solutions, creating workplace activities that carry out themes such as sportsmanship, camaraderie and teamwork. Making mental health something that a company can work together to improve will make men's participation more likely, since the focus is not entirely on them as individuals. Well-being outings, group mentorships and friendly sporting events could be promoted as activities that could improve the collective well-being of a workplace and help colleagues work together collaboratively. According to the mental health charity Mind's "Get It Off Your Chest" study, men have a high preference for physical activities when it comes to tackling their mental health. 4. Provide access to online therapy Research has found that men are more likely to seek help when they can consult a mental health professional, especially when this can be done online, where anonymity can be guaranteed. This approach would also ensure that men would be confident to discuss their mental health struggles without feeling like they're putting their job or position at the company at risk. Related: We Need a Real Commitment to Mental Health at Work. Here's How (and Why). 5. Create good senior role models Men are more likely to be empowered to take care of themselves and others when other men in leadership positions are seen to be doing the same. It can be very powerful, for instance, for a male CEO or senior executive to talk to their employees about their own mental health struggles and explain how they work towards their mental well-being. The same could be said about the CEO and entrepreneurial communities, where businesses can work together to ensure that their leaders can work collaboratively and share personal experiences to improve their mental health and well-being together.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Nottingham attack families ask Streeting for names of staff who treated killer
The families of the Nottingham attack victims said they have told the Health Secretary they want the names of staff involved in treating killer Valdo Calocane to be made public. A February report into the care received by Calocane detailed how he was not forced to have long-lasting antipsychotic medication because he did not like needles, and how other patients at Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust also went on to commit 'extremely serious' acts of violence. The relatives of 19-year-old students Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Barnaby Webber, and 65-year-old caretaker Ian Coates, met with Wes Streeting on Monday and asked for those responsible to be held accountable. After the meeting, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, Grace's father, said: 'It was the actions of a few people that put a dangerous man out in the community'. Calocane, who had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, killed three people and attempted to kill three more in Nottingham in June 2023. He was sentenced to an indefinite hospital order in January 2024 after admitting manslaughter by diminished responsibility and attempted murder. Calocane was admitted to hospital and sectioned under the Mental Health Act four times between 2020 and 2022 because of his violent behaviour and refusal to take his medication, before NHS services lost track of him and discharged him in the months before the attacks. Three reports: including one by the Care Quality Commission (CQC); described failings in his care but none included practitioners' names, Dr Kumar said with copies of the documents in-hand. Speaking outside the Department for Health and Social Care (DHSC), he told reporters: 'We'd like to know who was involved in the care of this person who committed all this harm. Why aren't there any names? 'He was sectioned four times – was it four different consultants? Was it one consultant? Who were the teams who didn't do their jobs?' He said: 'I think we deserve to know the detail – everyone in the country who has suffered the way we have through mental health-related homicide deserves to have the detail. 'When an operation goes wrong, someone gets named.' Dr Kumar added: 'We want people to just know, if they did wrong, what is it they need to do to be put right? Whether it's retraining, whether it's … doing the professional development again. 'The point is that you just can't have people who are providing a risky service even now.' He added that the Health Secretary was 'very much on our side, he very much wants to see a way through' and that Mr Streeting has promised 'he's going to work hard at it'. Prior to the meeting, the families said in a statement that their correspondence with the mental health trust's chief executive, Ifti Majid, had been 'light on detail, vague, evasive, defensive and contradictory'. They added that he failed to answer Dr Kumar's questions. Dr Kumar said he has given Mr Streeting the questions he put to the chief executive. He said the Health Secretary 'has promised to do his best to get us all the answers', adding that he has confidence in Mr Streeting because he has 'taken a personal interest in this case' and likewise 'wants to end homicide by mental health'. Their meeting also follows a complaint lodged with the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) by the families regarding an 'offensive' encounter with one of the watchdog's regional directors. Dr Kumar told The Sunday Times newspaper that their meeting with the IOPC, nine months after the attacks, began with a prayer, which he found 'patronising'. The issue was not discussed with Mr Streeting on Monday and would require a different meeting, he told reporters. A DHSC spokesperson said: 'Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust and NHS England have accepted all the recommendations made in both the CQC and NHS England-commissioned reviews into the care and treatment received by Valdo Calocane. 'The Health and Social Care Secretary has called for recommendations from both reviews to be implemented as soon as possible and met with the bereaved families today to discuss the NHS England-commissioned Independent Homicide Review. 'As part of this work, NHS England has developed and is actively implementing evidence-based national guidance, so that all trusts are clear on the standards of care expected for patients with serious mental illnesses. 'We remain committed to delivering the fundamental changes needed to mental health services to prevent similar tragedies from occurring in the future.'
