'We had concerns:' Subpoenaed Veterans Affairs officials testify in Métis National Council trial
Federal officials testified under subpoena this week about whether former Métis National Council (MNC) leaders mismanaged millions of dollars earmarked for the recognition of Métis war veterans, as a high-stakes civil trial continues in Toronto.
A senior official testified Friday that Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC) was immediately concerned when it learned of a "service delivery agreement" transferring control of the publicly funded program from MNC to the Manitoba Métis Federation (MMF) in 2021.
"We had concerns over whether it was aligned with the contribution agreement or not," said Dennis Manning, a senior director of financial and re-establishment policy at VAC, in Ontario Superior Court.
MNC's current leaders dispute the service agreement. They allege a past administration improperly diverted nearly $9 million to the MMF as part of a broader conspiracy to harm the council and benefit themselves shortly before MMF broke from the national group in September 2021.
The money came from a $30-million recognition fund for Métis Second World War veterans, which VAC provided to the MNC under a 2019 contribution agreement. Manning said Canada was concerned the contribution agreement may have been breached.
Poring over documents in the witness box, the public servant testified Canada only learned of the service delivery agreement when newly elected MNC president Cassidy Caron reached out in November 2021.
Caron's administration sued in January 2022, alleging former MNC president Clément Chartier and David Chartrand, who is MMF president and was also MNC's minister for finance and veterans, orchestrated the program transfer as part of a "scorched earth policy."
The statement of claim seeks $15 million in damages, $1 million in punitive damages and return of the veterans fund and other disputed assets. The sweeping claim names about a half dozen other former employees and consultants as defendants.
MMF co-founded the MNC in 1983 to advocate for Métis rights on the national stage. Chartier and Chartrand, both long-time politicians, deny any wrongdoing, arguing the service delivery agreement validly outsourced program administration to the MMF.
"Not one cent of the veterans fund has been paid to the MMF, Mr. Chartier, Mr. Chartrand or any other defendant. Rather, the funds have exclusively been used for the purposes contemplated," reads Chartier's defence.
In cross-examination, Manning clarified VAC hasn't seen the disputed service delivery agreement and based its concerns on information the Caron administration provided. He acknowledged that the minister retains the right to audit the program, yet has never done so.
VAC hasn't officially taken a stance on whether the contribution agreement was breached, he added, while agreeing that nothing in it bars consulting or contracting for services.
'Major political ramifications'
On Thursday, VAC manager Jeff Gallant testified the department was granted authority to enter into an agreement with MNC — and only MNC — to facilitate $20,000 individual recognition payments and approve commemoration projects.
"They were the recipient of the funds, and it was expected that they would be delivering the program," he said in direct examination by MNC's lawyer.
"VAC did not expect any other party to be involved."
In cross-examination, however, Gallant confirmed VAC dealt mainly with MMF officials from the outset, but he said this raised no questions because MMF was perceived as representing the national organization at the time.
Before MMF's withdrawal, MNC had five members but now counts just two. Saskatchewan and British Columbia withdrew last year, leaving only Alberta and Ontario.
The MNC's lawyer Robert Cohen previously described the conflict as a "political civil war." The nine-week trial began earlier this month and already put years of political infighting and governance gridlock under the microscope.
The dispute dates back to at least 2018, when the Chartier administration sought to suspend the Métis Nation of Ontario over concerns it had allowed thousands of non-Métis to join. That led to a long struggle over Ontario's status in the council, culminating in the court-ordered 2021 election.
Evidence presented Thursday suggests officials in Ottawa were well aware of the political aspect to the feud. Gallant was asked about a September 2020 internal document that said the MNC designated MMF as program administrator "without approval from the board of governors."
"This means that MMF has been making decisions on program administration without including governing members with whom they are currently in disputes with," said the document, as read in court.
"This in turn has major political ramifications."
Gallant said he wasn't involved directly at this time and couldn't elaborate on those political ramifications. The other VAC witness wasn't asked to elaborate.
MNC also alleges the former administration offered lucrative payouts for consultants and engaged in excessive or inappropriate spending on gifts and benefits for themselves and their associates, among other things.
The defendants categorically deny the allegations, with the MMF and Chartrand calling the case attempted character assassination and a legally baseless political vendetta.
The trial continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
6 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Alberta judge rejects robber's Indigenous identity claims, proposes test for deciding who should and shouldn't get Gladue reports
An Alberta judge is proposing new guidelines for how courts handle people who say they are Indigenous during sentencing hearings, but don't have proof to back up their claims. Article content Last month, Justice Jordan Stuffco of the Alberta Court of Justice sentenced Jonathan Anthony Ninan to 33 months in prison for robbing a Leduc sports bar, after Ninan admitted to pointing a replica firearm at the bar's lone female employee and making off with $12,000 cash. Article content Article content Article content After pleading guilty to a pair of charges, Ninan requested a Gladue report, a pre-sentence document which examines the impacts of government policy towards Indigenous people on an Indigenous person's criminal conduct. Article content Article content While some offenders' claims of Indigenous identity are uncontroversial, Ninan had only the vague sense that his mother — with whom he has had almost no contact since age 10 — had 'some ancestral connection to an unspecified Indigenous community,' Stuffco wrote. Article content 'Although Mr. Ninan endured substantial childhood trauma and intergenerational harm due to abusive and neglectful biological parents, I do not find these factors are connected to Indigeneity,' wrote Stuffco, a member of the Métis Nation of Alberta. Article content 'I find Mr. Ninan is not an Indigenous offender because there was no meaningful evidence, other than self-identification, establishing Mr. Ninan as an Indigenous person.' Article content Article content The decision comes amid ongoing debate over Indigenous identity fraud, including deeper examination of Indigenous identity claims from public figures in government, pop culture and academia. Article content Article content Stuffco did not accuse Ninan of trying to mislead the court, noting the 24-year-old simply knew little about his mother 'due to his chaotic and abusive family history.' Article content Gladue reports Article content Since the Supreme Court of Canada's 1999 decision in R. v. Gladue — the first case to interpret Criminal Code amendments aimed at addressing the over-representation of First Nations, Métis and Inuit people in Canadian prisons — Indigenous offenders have been able to request pre-sentence reports examining their family histories and how government Indigenous policy may have contributed to their criminal behaviour. Article content Gladue and subsequent cases recognized Indigenous people 'endured many generations of unparalleled systemic abuse and discrimination at the hands of all levels of government,' Stuffco wrote, including residential schools, displacement from traditional lands and adoption into non-Indigenous families.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Wildfire evacuation underscores need for Red Dress Alert system
Opinion The grassroots organization Giganawenimaanaanig released an interim report this week on the progress of the proposed Red Dress Alert, an initiative that would notify the public and help co-ordinate responses when an Indigenous woman, girl, or two-spirit person goes missing. Similar to an Amber Alert, which is issued when a child goes missing, the program responds to the calls for justice in the national inquiry on murdered and missing Indigenous women and girls and the parliamentary motion put forward by Winnipeg Centre MP Leah Gazan in 2023 to create the initiative. After receiving unanimous support in Parliament, a $1.3-million fund was established to research and make recommendations on how the program could be implemented nationally. Manitoba stepped up to take the lead. RUTH BONNEVILLE / FREE PRESS FILES Giganawenimaanaanig called on all governments to implement the Red Dress Alert program by early- to mid-2026. After consulting with 29 urban, rural, and First Nations and Métis communities throughout Manitoba, Giganawenimaanaanig called on all governments to implement the program by early- to mid-2026. 'Every day that the Red Dress Alert is not implemented,' project lead Denise Cook said, 'is a day that someone could go missing.' In the wake of four murders of Indigenous women by a serial killer in Winnipeg, and countless other MMIWG in Manitoba, the value of a Red Dress Alert is obvious. When considered alongside the amount of young women and two-spirit people in the child welfare system, the rise in domestic violence, and a city of Winnipeg police force that called the search for Indigenous female remains at a landfill 'unfeasible,' the initiative is need more than ever. It's needed now, in fact. More than 17,000 evacuees, mostly from northern First Nations, have been displaced owing to wildfires. In excess of 10,000 of them are in hotels or other lodgings in Winnipeg. That means this city has had an influx of thousands of Indigenous women, girls and two-spirit peoples — individuals preyed upon by many forces here. It's well-known that when Indigenous peoples are evacuated due to fires, floods, or some other traumatizing disaster, certain considerations in the health, justice, and emergency management systems must take place. For instance, many First Nations are alcohol-free due to a long history of complicated relationships with substance use. This community law is impossible to maintain off-reserve but community leaders combat the issue in other ways: such as by providing extra mental health services, family-building events, and even patrols to support people during their time as refugees. The same could be said about health, justice, and even governance. Simply put, due to a long history of political mistreatment, Indigenous communities require specific considerations when displaced by disasters. The issue of MMIWG2S+ is a disaster, too. Combined with recent fire evacuations, the situation has become critical. All this week, Indigenous social media has been full of individuals working overtime to protect Indigenous women, girls, and two-spirit peoples from nefarious forces. 'I'm gathering a crew of helpers this evening,' posted activist Rylee Nepinak of the downtown patrol group Anishiative. 'After speaking to multiple sources (mainly our women), it's clear we need as many boots on the ground watching for any predatory/exploitative signs (and) talk to the kids about safety.' Indigenous leaders are reporting that predators have approached displaced vulnerable individuals online and in person to offer drugs, alcohol, and invite them to 'party' in a private home — where a sexual or physical assault can easily take place. Advocates have created a list of 'safety tips when heading out in Winnipeg' that include: travelling in pairs, informing family and support staff of travel and return plans, and keeping location apps activated on their cellphones. Isabel Daniels, a vulnerable person advocate, warned in a post: 'Nothing is for free: if people are offering FREE substances SAY NO… Please be cautious of the things people are offering, Fentanyl is in a lot of street drugs.' Daniels also posted a dire message: 'People offering you FREE clothing, cellphones and liquor can be human traffickers, ALWAYS SAY NO.' Winnipeg police are joining the fight to educate and keep Indigenous people safe by providing extra officers and visits to evacuee shelters and printing 3,000 pamphlets with emergency contacts and tips to remain safe. Similar situations have been reported in other cities where evacuees are being sheltered, such as Thompson and Brandon. Wednesdays Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences. Community groups have recommended Indigenous families take photos of their female and two-spirit members in case a missing person report needs to be filed. If one didn't know better, one might see the release of the Red Dress Alert interim report, alongside a real-life emergency related to the safety of Indigenous women, girls, and two-spirit individuals, as a well-planned political move. It isn't. It's evidence the issue is urgent, laid bare right before our very eyes, now more than ever. Red Dress Alert report Niigaan SinclairColumnist Niigaan Sinclair is Anishinaabe and is a columnist at the Winnipeg Free Press. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
5 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Hall of Fame QB Peyton Manning becomes latest sports celebrity to join NWSL Denver's ownership group
DENVER (AP) — Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning became the latest sports celebrity to join the ownership group of Denver's National Women's Soccer League expansion team on Tuesday. Manning follows two-time Olympic champion ski racer Mikaela Shiffrin, who was announced as an investor last month in a club that will make its debut next season. Manning and Shiffrin join an NWSL group in Denver led by controlling owner Rob Cohen. Denver was awarded the NWSL's 16th team earlier this year. 'Peyton's legacy as a champion and a leader is second to none,' Cohen said in a news release. 'His impact on Colorado sports is unmatched, and we're incredibly proud to have him as a partner. He brings passion, insight, and deep local roots — all of which will help us shape the future of Denver NWSL.' All around the NWSL, big-name athletes are investing in teams. Manning's brother, Eli, is part of Gotham FC, while Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes is involved with the KC Current and NBA star James Harden backs the Houston Dash. Decorated Alpine ski racer Lindsey Vonn supports the Utah Royals FC. Manning was a five-time MVP and two-time Super Bowl winner in a career that started with the Indianapolis Colts and ended in Denver after helping the Broncos to a title following the 2015 season. He was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2021 after throwing for 71,940 yards with 539 touchdowns and 251 interceptions. Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. Since his retirement, Manning has grown his entertainment company Omaha Productions, which produces ESPN's 'Manningcast.' The show is hosted by the Manning brothers and offers an alternate way to watch 'Monday Night Football.' 'It's a real honor to be part of something so meaningful to the Colorado community,' Manning said of joining Denver NWSL. 'I'm proud to support the growth of women's sports and excited to help build a club that our city and our state can rally behind.' Denver NWSL is building a 12,000-seat temporary stadium that will be its home during the 2026 and '27 seasons. The team also recently unveiled plans for a state-of-the-art, 14,500-seat stadium that will be located in downtown Denver. ___ AP soccer:
