Jury retires in trial of police officers who Pava-sprayed and tasered amputee
Pc Stephen Smith, 51, and Pc Rachel Comotto, 36, faced trial at Southwark Crown Court accused of using excessive force on Donald Burgess during an incident at Park Beck care home in St Leonards-on-Sea, East Sussex, in June 2022.
The care home had called 999 after Mr Burgess, a single-leg amputee and wheelchair user, reportedly grabbed a knife and threatened to stab staff.
Judge Christopher Hehir, summarising the evidence on Wednesday, told jurors: 'The reason for his behaviour that day, we now know, is that he was delirious as a result of a urinary tract infection.'
Smith sprayed synthetic Pava pepper spray into Mr Burgess's face and struck his wrist with a baton, with Comotto deploying her Taser, all within a minute and 23 seconds of entering the wheelchair-bound pensioner's room.
Smith denies two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm for his use of Pava spray and for using a baton, whilst Comotto denies one count related to her use of a Taser on Mr Burgess.
Judge Hehir asked jurors to retire and consider their verdicts on Wednesday, adding they should reach their decision 'with their heads, not their hearts'.
Prosecutors say the force used against Mr Burgess, who had been reportedly waving the serrated cutlery knife around and telling staff he would 'take pleasure' in murdering them, was 'unjustified and unlawful' given his age and physical condition.
Mr Burgess was taken to hospital after the incident and later contracted Covid.
He died 22 days later aged 93.
Smith previously told jurors he did not see that Mr Burgess was disabled and using a wheelchair as he was focused on the knife the pensioner was holding in his hand.
During his evidence, he denied emptying a full can of Pava in Mr Burgess's face, saying it was 'a short burst'.
He also denied hitting Mr Burgess with a baton, claiming he instead flicked the baton towards the pensioner's wrist to 'knock the knife out' of his hand.
During her evidence, Comotto said she believed using the Taser was the safest way to 'protect' Mr Burgess as she feared her colleague using the baton again would cause more harm.
'I'm not a trigger-happy officer,' she told jurors.
'It's the first time I've fired my Taser.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Costly inquiries are all very well if we learn lessons from them
Lord Hardie's inquiry into the long and costly tram project cost £13 million Lord Hardie, the retired judge who chaired the nine-year long inquiry into Edinburgh's trams, admitted to MSPs last week that he was upset when he found out that the public were told about his £1 million pay cheque for his work on the investigation. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... He thought the revelation might lead to journalists 'pestering' him at home. As it turned out no-one, not even the most enthusiastic tabloid hack, knocked on his front door, so he was free to enjoy his post-retirement bonus with his family, unmolested by the press. As for the general public, well they had more things on their plate to worry about than Lord Hardie's bank balance – the cost of living crisis for a start. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Even more staggering than Lord Hardie's daily rate – set by the Scottish Government, which apparently has a fee schedule for retired judges – was the total cost of the inquiry itself. It cost tax payers £13 million, which works out about £1.5 million a year to produce a report that told us what we all knew any way. The 961-page report can be summed up in three points: the city council's original budget was way off track; the management of Tie – the arms-length company set up to deliver the tram system – was chaotic; and the Scottish Government ducked its responsibility for oversight of the project, despite giving it a £500 million grant. None of which came as surprise to any of us who had been subjected on a daily basis to the 'living hell' that was Edinburgh city centre during the construction of the (shortened) tram route. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad So why did it take nine years and £13 million to come to the same conclusion the average Edinburgh citizen had reached only months after the work started? Lord Hardie's evidence was to Holyrood's finance and public administration committee, which recently established its own inquiry into the cost of public inquiries. Kenneth Gibson, the committee's convenor, hit the nail on the head when he said his inquiry had 'the potential to be a really interesting piece of work given the significant sums of money that public inquiries often involve.' There are four public inquiries ongoing in Scotland right now, looking at the Covid crisis, hospital safety, child abuse and the death of Sheku Bayoh. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad So far the costs of these are estimated at a staggering £200 million. This is money the country can ill-afford to spend. How many social care staff would one public inquiry buy? Of course, public inquiries are important for finding out why bureaucrats bungled major capital projects such as the parliament building and Edinburgh's tram network, or what mistakes politicians made during a health crisis such as Covid. But they are not worth the reams of paper they are written on if no-one learns any lessons from them. Nor should any public inquiry take nine years. What on earth did Lord Hardie and his team find to ask questions about over a seven-year period? And why did it take two years to write the report? That works out at just over a page a day – which deserves a separate inquiry of its own.
Daily Mirror
10 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Full cost of failed pandemic- PPE finally revealed after major fraud probe
The Covid counter-fraud commissioner uncovered the £1.4billion figure in the first phase of his investigation into wasteful Tory spending during the Covid-19 pandemic Failed pandemic-era PPE contracts cost the British taxpayer £1.4billion. The Covid counter-fraud commissioner uncovered the figure in the first phase of his probe into wasteful Tory spending during the pandemic. Some £762million is unlikely to ever be recovered, as the Sunday Mirror revealed. These failures saw substandard PPE, including gowns, masks and visors, not inspected for two years, meaning public money could no longer be recouped. Most of the wasted money went on surgical gowns, with more than half (52%) of them being non-compliant. Chancellor Rachel Reeves is now urgently trying to claw back £468million that could still be recovered, which she wants to reinvest in public services and local communities. The next phase of Tom Hayhoe's investigation will look into fraud and error in other pandemic spending programmes such as furlough, bounce-back loans, Business Support Grants and Rishi Sunak 's Eat Out to Help Out scheme. Mr Hayhoe's final report is due to conclude in December. Recovery action has so far resulted in £182million being returned to the public purse, with some PPE suppliers having been referred to the National Crime Agency for suspected fraud. Ms Reeves said: 'The country is still paying the price for the reckless handling of Covid contracts which saw taxpayer pounds wasted and criminals profit from the pandemic. This investigation and plan to recover public money underlines our commitment to ensure that every penny spent during the pandemic is fully accounted for.' The Chancellor confirmed her Covid fraud crackdown at Labour 's annual conference last September. At the time, she said: 'I won't turn a blind eye to rip-off artists and fraudsters. 'I won't turn a blind eye to those who used a national emergency to line their own pockets. I won't let them get away with it. That money belongs in our police, it belongs in our health service, and it belongs in our schools.' In December, she tasked Mr Hayhoe with the job of trying to claw back lost money. The Tory Government has always insisted that it was operating in a crisis, with global PPE shortages driving up prices for kit that was essential for frontline workers. Former Health Secretary Matt Hancock told the Covid Inquiry in March: "I have been subject to enormous amounts of conspiracy theories about what went on here, when in fact what happened was so many people working as hard as they could to save lives, and they bought more PPE as a result. And therefore people are alive who would otherwise be dead."
Press and Journal
15 hours ago
- Press and Journal
Weekend court roll – a weeping rapist and two sacked nursery workers
Our reporters have been sitting in courtrooms across the north and north-east this week and covered a wide variety of cases. A dog owner burst into tears and said she was 'heartbroken' after a court ordered that her unregistered XL Bully must be put down. Shannon Kane, 41, had previously admitted possessing the regulated breed without an exemption certificate at Tain Sheriff Court. But when she appeared for sentencing this week, the court heard she had still not managed to apply for an exemption for one-year-old Zeus. Since August 1 last year, it has become illegal to own the controversial breed in Scotland without an exemption certificate. An Elgin man who repeatedly called 999 and threatened emergency workers has been locked up for more than a year. Wayne Taylor appeared at Elgin Sheriff Court on Thursday for sentencing after admitting to calling for paramedics and police to attend his home more than 30 times and brandishing weapons at them. On another occasion, he even asked his sister, who was recovering from open-heart surgery at the time, to contact them on his behalf. When she refused, he turned his anger towards her and punched her on the chest. An Aberdeen man has admitted embezzling more than £12,000 from businesses in the Highlands. Ben High pled guilty to two charges of embezzlement at Inverness Sheriff Court. The charges detail how he took the money when he was employed, first at an events company and then at an Inverness soft play centre. High, 36, represented himself at a hearing in Inverness, which heard that he wished to change his previous not guilty plea and admit the crimes. An Aberdeen man who drove just yards while he had traces of drugs in his system has been banned from the roads. Lewis Robb, a scaffolder, had been moving van on St Mary Street in Peterhead last May when police carried out a random roadside test. At Peterhead Sheriff Court on Friday, Sheriff Lesley Johnston said banning him was the 'appropriate' decision. The court heard the incident happened on May 1 at about 10.25am. A former criminal lawyer who was caught dealing nearly £87,000 worth of ketamine from her Peterculter country house has been jailed for 18 months. Advocate Amanda Lothian, 65, was convicted of being concerned in the supply of the controlled class B drug from Lower Kennerty Mill in Peterculter during the Covid-19 pandemic. A jury of six women and nine men took less than an hour to find Lothian guilty by a unanimous verdict following her trial in April. During her sentencing hearing, Lothian represented herself and told Sheriff William Summers that she accepts that she was involved in drug supply – but denied the drugs were hers. A man who launched an unprovoked attack on a dad walking to collect his child from nursery has been branded a 'violent thug' by a sheriff. Eddie Macgregor targeted his victim in an alley near the Pulteneytown People's Project in Wick, knocking him to the ground and kicking him twice to the head. The attack left Macgregor's victim with a broken nose, scalp haematoma and a 'footprint bruise' to his arm. Macgregor, 29, appeared at Inverness Sheriff Court for sentencing, having previously admitted assault to severe injury in relation to the attack on August 2 of last year. An Alness man has been jailed after spitting at a police officer and telling her he had hepatitis. Scott Lapsley had breached a court-imposed curfew order for a second time when police found him unconscious at an address in Alness. After being checked by paramedics and confirmed fit, he was placed under arrest – but reacted by assaulting an officer. Lapsley, 29, appeared from custody at Inverness Sheriff Court to admit two charges of breaching his curfew and two of assaulting officers. A man who told a teenage girl that her legs were the only reason he kept visiting Peterhead's Cross Keys bar has been warned he faces jail if he cannot be of good behaviour. Mark Davidson, 55, made the comment to the 17-year-old within the Wetherspoon bar on September 8 last year. The court heard that Davidson, who is unemployed, was in the pub at about 3pm when he targeted the girl with what he believed to be a 'compliment'. However, when she complained to staff members and they advised him to mind his manners, he then started to accuse others in the premises of being 'nonces'. A delivery driver has appeared in court accused of carrying out sexual assaults on two teenage girls in Torry over the weekend. Fidelis Amu appeared in private at Aberdeen Sheriff Court, facing four charges. The 26-year-old, whose general address was given as Aberdeen, was charged with sexual assault. He also faces a second charge of indecently communicating with another person – electronically or verbally – and then sexually assaulting them. Every day our reporters are sitting in courtrooms around the area and now you can get their stories sent directly to you, five days a week. A Fraserburgh man who tried to collect packages of cocaine from the Post Office will be sentenced next month. Shaun Atkinson, who the court heard only has one previous conviction for failure to own a TV licence, appeared at Peterhead Sheriff Court on Monday where he admitted to a charge of attempting to be concerned in the supply of the class A drug. The 46-year-old was released on bail for the preparation of a background report ahead of his sentencing. Fiscal depute Lydia Williams told the court Atkinson had attempted to retrieve a parcel containing two packages of cocaine from the Post Office in Fraserburgh's Mid Street prior to staff raising the alarm on June 3 last year. An Aberdeen man has avoided a prison sentence after he bought an illegal stun gun to emulate his heroes on US TV prank show Jackass. Raymond Hutcheon, also known as Munro, bought the weapon so he and his friends could taser themselves. Hutcheon – who also tried to import an illegal butterfly knife using the alias 'Raymond Babags' – appeared in the dock at Aberdeen Sheriff Court and admitted the offences. The offences, which took place between 2019 and 2020, were described by the 40-year-old's lawyer, Graham Morrison, as 'bizarre'. A dangerous drug driver had been jailed after causing a head-on crash into a family's car while 16 times the limit. Scott Nicolson was slurring his words and drooling in the immediate aftermath of the Ellon smash, which badly injured a mum and her 10-year-old daughter. It later emerged that Nicolson, 50, had been involved in another drug-driving crash just weeks before in Aberdeen. On that occasion, he was spotted swerving across the road and eventually ploughed into a wall. A convicted stalker has avoided jail after admitting harassing two women over a seven-year period after meeting them both whilst studying in Aberdeen. Andrew Will, who was convicted of similar offences last year, appeared at Aberdeen Sheriff Court to be sentenced for two charges of stalking between 2016 and 2023. The 28-year-old admitted repeatedly emailing and calling one woman and turning up to her workplace uninvited, causing her fear and alarm. Will, whose address was given as Cornhill Hospital in court papers, also admitted a further charge of repeatedly emailing Judo Scotland about another woman and making inappropriate comments about her – also causing her fear and alarm. An Inverness man who mooned a night porter at an Oban hotel after being told to leave its spa area has been fined £400. Liam Miller, 24, of MacEwen Drive, Inverness, was staying in Oban while working on power lines in the area. He had been out drinking on February 9 when he returned to the Oban Bay Hotel on Corran Esplanade, where he was staying. After stripping down to his boxer shorts, he joined a group that had privately booked the spa. A man has been jailed after leading police on a blue-light chase through Easter Ross. Alexander Burke sped away from officers between Alness and Evanton, reaching estimated speeds of up to 90mph. When he was traced and the car searched, a meat cleaver was found beside the driver's seat. Burke, 30, appeared before Sheriff Ian Cruickshank for sentencing, having previously pled guilty to charges of dangerous driving and having a meat cleaver in a public place. A British Army sapper from Moray has admitted attempting to communicate indecently with a child. Alex Tunnicliffe admitted two sexual offences, which saw him placed on the sex offenders register. The 34-year-old Royal Engineers sapper, based at Kinloss, faces being discharged from the Army. At Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court he was warned the offences 'properly merit' a prison sentence but given his previous good character Sheriff Robert More chose to impose an alternative sentence. Almost two-dozen jobs would be put at risk if a woman who smoked cannabis lost her driving licence, a court has been told. Jennifer Anderson, 34, admitted being in charge of a car while under the influence of the Class B drug. But crucially, Anderson was not driving the car when police had reason to speak with her, Oban Sheriff Court was told. Anderson, of Strathmore Drive, Cornton, Stirling, had pulled into a layby on April 29 2023, when police officers in an unmarked car smelled cannabis from her car. Every day our reporters are sitting in courtrooms around the area and now you can get their stories sent directly to you, five days a week. A Mull hotel worker set fire to a boat in Bunessan after arguing with the owner in the pub. Peter Owens, who worked at the Bunessan Inn on the Isle of Mull at the time of the offence, admitted setting fire to the Orkney Fastliner vessel. Owens, 36, of Elderpark Gardens in Glasgow, was living at the hotel on March 27 2024. Oban Sheriff Court was told the boat was completely destroyed in the fire. A moped driver who got into a high-speed chase with police and crashed into a tree was found with thousands of pounds of heroin and cocaine. Lewis Edwards, 25, appeared in the dock at Aberdeen Sheriff Court, where he admitted speeding off when police spotted a drug deal taking place and tried to pull him over. Edwards, originally from Liverpool, took off on his moped at speed, leading police on a dangerous chase through the streets of Bucksburn and Danestone. He ultimately crashed into a tree and tried to make off on foot, but was stopped by officers who found thousands of pounds worth of illicit drugs in his pockets. A woman who claimed her German Shepherd was a 'good-natured' pet after it bit a delivery driver has lost a bid to overturn her conviction. Janet MacFarlane's canine, Diego, attacked the worker through a gap in the gate of her home in Drumnadrochit, on April 14 2023. Inverness Sheriff Court heard how the man needed stitches after the incident. She was charged with having a dog dangerously out of control following proceedings in September 2024. Sheriff Sara Matheson ordered Diego to be muzzled and kept on a lead and muzzled when in a public place – she also ordered MacFarlane to pay Diego's victim £600. Almost two-dozen jobs would be put at risk if a woman who smoked cannabis lost her driving licence, a court has been told. Jennifer Anderson, 34, admitted being in charge of a car while under the influence of the Class B drug. But crucially, Anderson was not driving the car when police had reason to speak with her, Oban Sheriff Court was told. Anderson, of Strathmore Drive, Cornton, Stirling, had pulled into a layby on April 29 2023, when police officers in an unmarked car smelled cannabis from her car. Two nursery workers who assaulted a four-year-old child at an Aberdeenshire nursery left the court without any punishment for their actions. Joseph Picker, 36 and Stacey Kerr, 30, were convicted earlier this year following a long and drawn-out trial that took place over a number of days across a 12-month period. Aberdeen Sheriff Court had considered the evidence, including CCTV footage, and found both Picker and Kerr guilty of assaulting the boy whose arms were left bruised. However, the pair were admonished by the sheriff, meaning they received no penalty and were merely warned not to reoffend. An Invergordon man was robbed at knifepoint in his own home by two people he had invited for coffee. Daniel McLean was accompanied by a woman who had both arrived at the property as guests of the unsuspecting victim. Once inside, the female accomplice held a knife to her host's throat and the pair forced him to transfer £100 into McLean's bank account, Next, the nasty visitors helped themselves to a soundbar attached to the man's television. A vicious killer who went on a spending spree after savagely beating a woman to death was jailed for life for the 'horrible' murder. Owen Grant repeatedly bludgeoned Lucretia Donaghy, known as Kiesha, with a weapon such as a claw hammer in the fatal attack. A judge ordered that Grant, 43, must serve at least 24 years in jail before seeking parole. This is due to what the judge called the 'exceptionally brutal nature of the murder' and the killer's extensive record for violent crime. A man has been jailed for headbutting his girlfriend after she refused to come to his granny's house with him. Lewis Ivory appeared in the dock at Aberdeen Sheriff Court, where he admitted assaulting the woman and making terrifying threats to stab police officers. The 27-year-old seriously injured the woman during the ordeal, which took place on a footpath in Inverurie. In the run-up to the attack, the victim had asked Ivory to leave her alone and shouted for help from others. Owen Grant has now been jailed for life after a trial in which – on top of telling other lies – he denied murdering Elgin mum Kiesha Donaghy in her own home. On November 15, 2023, Grant repeatedly bludgeoned Lucretia Donaghy, known to friends and family as Kiesha, with a weapon such as a claw hammer in the fatal attack. On Thursday, a judge ordered Grant to serve at least 24 years in jail before seeking parole. Throughout his time in court, the 43-year-old told many lies that have now been debunked. At the High Court in Edinburgh on Thursday, Lord Scott sentenced Owen Grant to life imprisonment for the murder of Kiesha Donaghy. Lord Scott told him: 'You have been found guilty of the murder of Lucrezia Donaghy on November 15 2023, a little over 18 months ago. 'On the evidence, the jury decided that it had been proved beyond reasonable doubt that you murdered an unarmed and defenceless woman in her own home by repeatedly striking her on the head and body with a claw-hammer or similar implement. 'Lucrezia Donaghy died as a result of blunt force head injuries.' A dangerous driver ran a red light during roadworks causing his car to flip over. And when Angus Mitchell was hauled before a sheriff to explain why he couldn't queue on the road like the other motorists – he blamed his diabetes. A sheriff told Angus Mitchell that he had driven as if he had a 'death wish' before crashing on the A835 near Rogie Falls – about 10 miles west of Dingwall. His solicitor told the court that Mitchell had panicked after experiencing symptoms as a result of his medical condition. A pensioner driver knocked a man off his bike – then failed an eye test. Allan Turner, 81, failed to spot the cyclist as he made a manoeuvre at a busy junction in Muir of Ord – west of Inverness – knocking the rider to the ground. Turner's licenced was subsequently medically revoked. His solicitor said he has since undergone a cataract operation and now hopes to regain his licence. A rapist from Aberdeen wept as he was told he would be caged for the next decade for raping a former partner and sexually assaulting another. Jamie Forbes, of Willopark Crescent, stood trial at Aberdeen High Court last month where he had denied all of the charges against him – including shooting his girlfriends with a BB gun. But the lout was ultimately sent down after a jury took seven hours to consider his case. At the time, the 33-year-old claimed his victims had consented to his sick attacks.
