Gaza humanitarian group is a 'distraction' from what is needed, UN says
The work of a US-backed private humanitarian organisation tasked with distributing aid in Gaza is a distraction from what is needed, such as the opening of crossing points, a UN spokesperson said on Tuesday.
The GHF, which began as an Israeli-initiated plan and has drawn criticism from the United Nations and others, said on Monday it began distributing supplies in Gaza.
This follows an Israeli blockade for 11 weeks that was only partially lifted in recent days and that prompted a famine warning from a global hunger monitor and international criticism.
"We do not participate in this modality for the reasons given. It is a distraction from what is actually needed (...)," Jens Laerke, spokesperson for the UN humanitarian office (OCHA) told a Geneva briefing, calling for the reopening of all crossings.
He also called for an end to Israeli restrictions on the type of aid being allowed to enter the enclave, which he said was being "cherry picked" and did not always match needs.
Israel is in charge of vetting all aid entering Gaza and regularly rejects a wide array of items it considers could be put to military use by Hamas.
It says the new system is aimed at separating aid from Hamas, which it accuses of stealing and using food to impose control over the population, a charge rejected by Hamas, which says it protects aid convoys from gangs of armed looters.
Juliette Touma, communications director of the UN Palestinian refugee agency, said that it had large medical shipments waiting that have been denied entry into Gaza.
"We have over 3,000 trucks, not only of food, but also medicines that are lining up in places like Jordan, like Egypt, that are waiting for the green light to go in, and they're carrying medicines and that is expiring soon," she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
How Trump's team squandered a chance to end the Gaza war
The administration of US President Donald Trump appeared close to securing a ceasefire to end the Gaza war, halt the inhumane blockade imposed on its starving people, and ensure the release of all Israeli captives held by Hamas. Indeed, a preliminary deal was reached in Doha between Hamas and the US administration's interlocutor, Palestinian American Bishara Bahbah. Acting on behalf of Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff, Bahbah, who headed an organisation that encouraged Arab Americans to vote for Trump in the last election, had been key to the previous negotiations that secured the release of American Israeli captive Edan Alexander. Alexander's release paved the way for the subsequent talks. According to an interview with Bahbah on Israel's Channel 12, Witkoff initially suggested that Hamas should release Alexander as a 'gesture of goodwill' towards Trump, who could then use 'his influence for a ceasefire and to allow the aid to come into Gaza that is desperately needed by people'. But soon after the preliminary ceasefire deal was struck, Witkoff changed course and came up with a modified plan that was accepted by the Israelis, thus tossing the ball back into Hamas's court. Clearly, Witkoff could not persuade the Israelis to accept what had been agreed with Hamas in Doha, instead adopting as his own Israel's counterproposal - which, to Hamas, seemed nothing short of capitulation. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters The Israelis and their US backers might have concluded that after many months of war, Hamas had been severely battered and was too weak to reject the proposal. This is not the first time they've been proven wrong. The Americans took the right step by opting to negotiate directly with Hamas. Earlier this year, the first direct talks were led by Trump's hostage envoy, Adam Boehler, who was so confident about his mandate that he publicly responded to Israeli criticism by saying: 'We're not an agent of Israel.' Talking to 'terrorists' This was all promising. The cliched notion that 'we don't talk to terrorists' has proven to be little more than a pretext to avoid the responsibility to engage fairly and honestly with all parties. Since the time of former President Bill Clinton, all US administrations, both Democratic and Republican, have continued designating Hamas as a terrorist organisation. European nations, including the UK, followed suit. This is despite the fact that Hamas was democratically elected by the Palestinian people in free and fair elections. Follow Middle East Eye's live coverage of the Israel-Palestine war Colonial and oppressive powers have always tended to designate those who resist their tyranny and hegemony as terrorists who should not be spoken with. South Africa's ruling African National Congress (ANC) was once designated a terrorist organisation by the US and UK, with former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher vowing never to meet its leader. Just a few years later, ANC leader Nelson Mandela was elected head of state in his country, and was subsequently given a hero's welcome when he visited the UK. War on Gaza: Why forcing Hamas to disarm will not end Israel's genocide Read More » Indeed, the adage that 'terrorists' should not be spoken with has not held up across history. The Viet Cong, considered by the US to be terrorists, eventually sat around the same negotiating table with the Americans in Paris. More recently, the Taliban, who now rule Afghanistan, have held talks with the US in Doha. Interestingly, in both cases, it was not negotiations that ended the conflicts, but the humiliating defeat and withdrawal of American troops. When Trump authorised direct talks with Hamas, it was seen as a step in the right direction. Many observers thought it indicated that Trump was serious about stopping the war. Subsequent developments, however, have dashed these hopes and infuriated some of Washington's regional Arab allies. In short, the Trump administration appears to have wasted a historic opportunity - a chance to play a more constructive and less biased role in the Middle East. Trump himself has stated repeatedly that he wants to end wars. Here was a real chance for his administration to show the world that it would no longer be a party to Israel's genocide in Gaza and its war crimes across occupied Palestine. Instead, Trump's team once again revealed itself to be untrustworthy and incapable of controlling Israel, even as the latter relies almost entirely on US military, financial and diplomatic support. What a missed opportunity. The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Daily killings as Hamas and Israel-backed gang engage in battle of attrition in Gaza
The ranks of a shadowy, Israeli-backed gang in southern Gaza are swelling, with its armed members attacking Hamas operatives and their families, as well as gathering intelligence on behalf of Israel 's military. Sources told The National on Monday that Hamas has hit back at the gang, known as the Yasser Abu Shabab Popular Forces, by quietly eliminating its members and supporters. "Hamas is assassinating them in the range of five to seven a day," a source said. "It's the latest chapter in a history of enmity between Hamas and armed gangs and families opposed to its rule in Gaza." The Yasser Abu Shabab gang now has up to 150 members, up from about 75 a little more than a week ago, who are equipped with assault rifles, walkie-talkies and night vision goggles, the sources said. They added that members of the gang are paid, which explains its rapid growth at a time when job opportunities are extremely scarce in an enclave devastated by war since October 2023. Drugs and murder The leader of the gang is Yasser Abu Shabab, 31, the sources said. He has long been viewed with suspicion by residents of Gaza and many of his men have criminal records for drug trafficking and murder. But the gang has been operating in full view of the Israeli military since emerging in Gaza last month, the sources said. The group operates outside the framework of any recognised Palestinian authority and is accused of trying to create an alternative government model amid the leadership vacuum created by the war. Israel has not yet publicly shared its plan for Gaza after the conflict, which it says will not end until Hamas has been eliminated and all hostages held by the group are freed. Israel said on Thursday that it has "activated" Palestinian clans in Gaza as part of its war, confirming long-held suspicions that it is working with anti-Hamas groups. The announcement followed claims by a former Israeli minister, Avigdor Lieberman, leader of the opposition Yisrael Beiteinu party, that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu approved the transfer of large quantities of arms to organised crime families in Gaza. In a video posted online late on Thursday, Mr Netanyahu offered an explanation for his actions, saying the government was acting on the advice of 'security officials" to save the lives of Israeli soldiers. But the sources said supporting anti-Hamas groups raised the spectre of civil strife in Gaza, pitting Hamas fighters against the groups at a time when the majority of the enclave's 2.3 million population are facing severe shortages of food, water, medicine and other essentials. Targeting Hamas tunnels Israel last month eased a nearly two-month blockade on aid, but only a fraction of the supplies needed has since found its way to Palestinians. The sources said the Yasser Abu Shabab gang, which has a track record of trafficking in drugs and arms, as well as black market profiteering, was also carrying out tasks on behalf of the Israeli military, including blowing up structures suspected of concealing the entrances of Hamas tunnels. The gang has also besieged suspected tunnel entrances, hoping to prevent supplies from reaching Hamas fighters inside, the sources added. The sources could not ascertain the effectiveness of that anti-Hamas activity, but noted the militant group's weakness, estimating that it may have lost more than half of its fighters and a significant amount of its arsenal since the war began. Israel has a record of empowering groups potentially dangerous to its security to weaken major enemies. Taking advantage of Gaza's woeful economy, it is also known to be running an elaborate network of paid spies in the enclave, providing real-time intelligence on the whereabouts of senior Hamas officials and the group's military wing. Hamas dedicates a significant part of its policing capabilities to counter-espionage, hunting down informants and subjecting them to secret trials. It is known to have executed dozens of suspected spies since it took power in Gaza in 2007. The sudden rise of the Yasser Abu Shabab gang is widely seen as an Israeli experiment in government by proxy. Gazan civilians told The National last week that they view such groups not as a protective force, but as collaborators offering people false promises in exchange for political and social submission. The gang claims to be guarding Israeli and US-backed food distribution centres in southern Gaza, but aid workers say it has a long history of looting UN lorries. Gaza's armed groups have ties to powerful clans or extended families and often operate as criminal gangs. Aid workers have said Israel's backing of such groups is part of a wider effort to control all humanitarian operations in the enclave. Israel denies allowing looters to operate in areas it controls. Step up from cigarette smuggling But with Hamas weakened after 20 months of war, gangs have regained the freedom to act. The leadership of several clans – including the one from which the Yasser Abu Shabab group's members hail – have issued statements denouncing looting and co-operation with Israel. The group went public in early May, declaring itself a "nationalist force". It said it was protecting aid, including around food distribution sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a mainly American private contractor that Israel intends to replace the UN-led aid network. Before the war, Yasser Abu Shabab was involved in smuggling cigarettes and drugs from Egypt and Israel into Gaza, according to two members of his extended family, one of whom was once part of his group, according to an AP report. Hamas arrested him, but freed him from prison when the war began in October 2023, they said. The conflict began when Hamas-led fighters attacked Israel in October 2023, killing 1,200 people and taking about 240 hostage. Israel's relentless military campaign has so far killed nearly 55,000 Palestinians, Gaza's health authorities have said. The conflict has displaced the majority of its population and laid to waste much of the enclave's built-up areas.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Ex-Israeli PM:Trump must tell Netanyahu 'enough is enough'
US President Donald Trump should tell Israel's leader Benjamin Netanyahu "enough is enough", a former Israeli prime minister told AFP, denouncing the continuation of the war on Gaza as a "crime" and insisting a two-state solution is the only way to end the conflict. Ehud Olmert, prime minister between 2006-2009, said in an interview in Paris that the United States has more influence on the Israeli government "than all the other powers put together" and that Trump can "make a difference". He said while the international community accepted Israel's right to self-defence after 7 October, this changed when Netanyahu spurned chances to end the war in March and instead ramped up operations. "If there is a war which is not going to save hostages, which cannot really eradicate more of what they did already against Hamas and if, as a result of this, soldiers are getting killed, hostages maybe get killed and innocent Palestinians are killed, then to my mind this is a crime," said Olmert. "And this is something that should be condemned and not accepted," he said.
