Elon Musk labels Geoffrey Hinton ‘carelessly ignorant, cruel' after ‘godfather of AI' calls for him to be banished from Royal Society
Geoffrey Hinton, the oft-named godfather of AI, has gotten into a row with Elon Musk on the billionaire's own social media platform over his Fellowship at the prestigious Royal Society's scientific institution.
The 365-year-old Royal Society is set to hold a meeting on Monday to debate 'principles around public pronouncements and behaviours of Fellows,' after thousands of academics co-signed an open letter calling for Musk to be removed for breaching its code of conduct.
Stephen Curry, a biologist who penned the letter, said Musk should be banned after attacking Dr Anthony Fauci and labeling MP Jess Phillips a 'rape genocide apologist,' behavior made all the more serious following his placement at the head of DOGE, which Curry argued hurt the scientific community.
Two members of the Royal Society resigned their Fellowships in protest at Musk.
Hinton, who has been a Fellow at the institution since 1998, is the latest scientist to provide a brutal assessment of Musk on the billionaire's own platform X and of his unsuitability for a Fellowship.
'I think Elon Musk should be expelled from the British Royal Society. Not because he peddles conspiracy theories and makes Nazi salutes, but because of the huge damage he is doing to scientific institutions in the US. Now let's see if he really believes in free speech.'
Hinton was referencing Musk's salute to crowds after the inauguration of Donald Trump, which replicated a fascist salute. Musk denied the accusations, accusing critics of a 'dirty tricks campaign.'
Hinton's post on Sunday elicited a furious response from Musk, who is at risk of experiencing the first expulsion from the Royal Society in more than 150 years.
'Only craven, insecure fools care about awards and memberships. History is the actual judge, always and forever,' wrote Musk.
'Your comments above are carelessly ignorant, cruel and false.
'That said, what specific actions require correction? I will make mistakes, but endeavor to fix them fast.'
Musk and new Nobel Prize winner Hinton's trading of jabs on X marks a turn for the worse in the pair's complex relationship.
Speaking to the Globe and Mail last year, Hinton admitted he made up an excuse to get off a call with Musk after 20 minutes after the billionaire 'started rambling.' Musk had been in touch with Hinton to ask if he would sit on an advisory board focused on AI safety.
'He's not going to like that. Because him being the center of attention, that's what he wants. I don't think he's my friend anymore,' Hinton said at the time.
However, Musk and Hinton have long been aligned on the need for AI safety, with both sitting on the hawkish side of the argument that the technology could overpower humanity.
In December, Hinton put his differences with Musk aside to publicly back his lawsuit against Musk's fellow foe, Altman.
Upon receiving his Nobel Prize in Physics last October, Hinton highlighted his pride for his students at the University of Toronto, calling out one in particular, Ilya Sutskever, after an OpenAI boardroom coup in 2023.
'They've gone on to do great things,' Hinton said. 'I'm particularly proud of the fact that one of my students fired Sam Altman. And I think I better leave it there.
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fast Company
7 hours ago
- Fast Company
Enough hype about AI in health—let's talk about results
There's no shortage of big promises about AI in healthcare. The U.S. government announced a $500 billion Stargate initiative to fund AI infrastructure, while the UK government announced £82.6 million in research funding for three projects, two of which are using AI to tackle cancer and Alzheimer's disease. But ask any patient waiting for a diagnosis, or a clinician searching for certainty, and the real question cuts through all the noise: When will all the innovation deliver real impact where it matters most? We've entered an era where healthcare data is measured in exabytes—genomes, images, clinical notes, labs, and signals from every continent. At SOPHiA GENETICS, we've just achieved the milestone of analyzing 2 million patient profiles. It's a number that was unimaginable a decade ago. Yet the value of data isn't in volume. It's what you do with it. Insight matters only if it changes an outcome, shortens a diagnostic odyssey, or opens up a new chance for a patient. It's time to move from conversation to action. Too often, insights get trapped in institutional silos or left in endless pilot projects, just out of reach of the people who need them. 3 ways AI is already transforming medicine Today, technology can connect, for example, a patient in São Paulo with expertise in Seoul, uncovering patterns invisible to the human eye. Here are several ways AI is helping now. 1. Improving diagnostic accuracy: AI algorithms, particularly those based on deep learning, have demonstrated remarkable accuracy in diagnosing diseases from medical images and test results. These systems are trained on vast datasets, allowing them to recognize patterns and anomalies that might be missed by the human eye. For example, in dermatology, AI systems trained on images of skin lesions have shown the ability to detect skin cancers, such as melanoma, with high levels of precision. 2. Enhancing cancer prevention: AI techniques can be used to screen individuals for genomic markers and develop personalized cancer risk prediction scores. This proactive approach can help screen younger patients for genomic predispositions, empowering them to make informed prevention decisions and proactively monitor their health. 3. Tailoring treatments to genomic profiles: One of the most significant applications of AI is in the field of genomics. AI can analyze vast genomic datasets to identify mutations and variations that might influence an individual's response to certain treatments. For example, our SOPHiA DDM product can identify specific genomic markers that are susceptible to targeted cancer therapies, increasing the efficacy of the treatment and minimizing the risk of adverse reactions, for a more effective and safer treatment plan for patients. To scale up these AI applications there are many regulatory and compliance barriers to overcome. This requires investment in data security, creating clear guidelines, data security measures, and ensuring clinicians are fully trained. Our goal should be to create a regulatory environment that fosters innovation while safeguarding patient data and promoting public trust. We must democratize this powerful data to enable more physicians, practices, and hospitals to incorporate AI into daily clinical use so that a greater number of patients can access data-driven medicine, not just a select few. My message for governments investing in AI is clear: Balance investing in future AI tools with validating existing solutions that have already been proven to improve patient outcomes. Build the bridges that turn breakthroughs into benefits, so that data-driven medicine becomes a reality for every patient.
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Government Website Caught Hosting "Gay Impregnation" Content
Portions of the US government's official "Vaccine Hub" website, seem to have been taken over by an AI sloperation that hosts "gay impregnation" content — and pages featuring lots of other NSFW topics, too. As flagged by 404 Media, this same spam marketing scheme seems to have also targeted websites for AI chipmaker Nvidia, National Public Radio, and Stanford University. Prior to the AI spam pages being taken offline, a bit of clicking through on the Vaccine Hub site reveals a wild, weird world of pages with titles like "Gay Firry [sic] Porn," "Lesbian Guy," "Bi Twinks," and, hilariously, "Lesbianism and Gayism [Sic]." While there are also plenty of explainers about vaccines on these raunchy pages contain no information about healthcare at all. As for "gay impregnation," that porn-brained terminology seems to be shorthand for "male impregnation," an umbrella term used for fantasies of cisgender men being impregnated by other men, the scientific pursuit of cis male pregnancies, and the real-life occurrence of transgender men getting pregnant. The latter became something of a right-wing strawman when Apple added a pregnant man emoji to its library, though that appears to have more to do with an obsession with reproduction and breeding than anything else. The "gay impregnation" page seemed primarily to point to the scientific part of the so-called "mpreg" trifecta. "With the rapid progress being made in the fields of reproductive medicine, genetics, and assisted reproduction, it's not entirely implausible to imagine a future where male pregnancy could become a reality," the page read, prior to being taken down. "For instance, recent studies have explored the possibility of using artificial wombs or ectogenic pregnancies, where an embryo is developed outside of a human body." The other porn-y pages we viewed — which we won't link to, but which are easy enough to find with a bit of Google elbow grease — feature the same meandering and faux-intellectual syntax that seems very likely AI-generated. The "Bi Twinks" page, for instance, repeatedly explains what the terms "bisexuality" and "twink" mean, before insisting on the kind of wokeness that the Trump administration is so adamantly against. "When considering the intersection of these identities," the page reads, "it's crucial to approach the topic with sensitivity, understanding the complexities and nuances of sexual orientation and gender expression." Though the Nvidia pages were taken down after 404 contacted the chipmaker, archival snapshots show that those, too, struck a hilariously woke tone. "The exploration of Brazilian facesitting fart games, while seemingly niche, opens up broader discussions on sexuality, humor, and cultural diversity," the obvious AI slop description on the formerly Nvidia-hosted "Brazilian facesitting games" page reads. "It underscores the importance of respecting and understanding the varied ways in which people express themselves sexually and find humor in different activities." Because the pages were so obviously written by AI, some of the images that ended up featured alongside the text are either nonsensical or, in some instances disturbing. On "Gay Straight Clips" page, for instance, a random image of a woman wearing clip-in hair extensions is included without context, while the page titled "Is Everyone Gay" features a similarly decontextualized photo of NBA superstar Charles Barkley. The "Gay Impregnation" page also, confusingly, is home to what appears to be an anti-incest public service announcement. A quick reverse image search reveals that the ad made waves online in 2016 when Florida officials asked Refuge House, the abuse survivor nonprofit that put it up along a Panhandle highway, to take it down because it could upset economic development. How or why that ad got onto the page is, like everything else with this debacle, a mystery. We've reached out to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Office of Infectious Disease and HIV/AIDS Policy (OIDP), both of which are involved in the government's vaccine messaging, to ask what's up with Given that health secretary and known anti-vaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. gutted the latter, it's not all that shocking that the site was not only abandoned but co-opted by AI slop. So goes the United States government, apparently. More on mpreg: Elon Musk Says He Longs to Get Pregnant So He Can Produce as Many Children as Possible
Washington Post
8 hours ago
- Washington Post
Nvidia chief calls AI ‘the greatest equalizer' — but warns Europe risks falling behind
PARIS — Will artificial intelligence save humanity — or destroy it? Lift up the world's poorest — or tighten the grip of a tech elite? Jensen Huang — the global chip tycoon widely predicted to become one of the world's first trillionaires — offered his answer on Wednesday: neither dystopia nor domination. AI, he said, is a tool for liberation.
