ICC rejects Duterte's bid to disqualify judges in jurisdiction challenge
The International Criminal Court (ICC) has unanimously rejected former Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's request to disqualify two judges from ruling on a challenge to the court's jurisdiction in his ongoing case over alleged crimes against humanity.
In a decision dated June 9, and signed by ICC President Judge Tomoko Akane, the plenary of judges ruled against Duterte's attempt to remove Judges Reine Adélaïde Sophie Alapini-Gansou and María del Socorro Flores Liera from the case.
Duterte had accused the judges of bias for their prior involvement in authorizing the ICC's investigation into the Philippine situation and issuing an arrest warrant against him.
'The plenary of judges, acting unanimously, decided to reject the Application. A fully reasoned decision of the plenary will follow,' the ICC said in the decision.
The move comes after ICC prosecutors described Duterte's application as 'legally untenable,' arguing that the defense failed to meet the high threshold needed to rebut the presumption of judicial impartiality.
In a prior filing dated May 22, the prosecution said the judges' earlier rulings were procedural and did not prejudice their ability to remain impartial.
'Judges regularly adjudicate the same, or similar, legal issues… their prior determinations do not, under regular circumstances, create the appearance of conflict,' the Office of the Prosecutor said.
Duterte's legal team had claimed the judges had 'predetermined' the case's jurisdictional outcome. However, the prosecution emphasized that both the investigation order and the arrest warrant were issued under a limited mandate, and explicitly noted they were without prejudice to future decisions.
Judge Beti Hohler, also initially assigned to the deliberations, recused herself from the plenary, citing her prior role as a prosecution lawyer in the Philippine case from 2019 to 2022.
Duterte faces accusations of crimes against humanity linked to the thousands of killings during his administration's controversial war on drugs. The ICC issued an arrest warrant for Duterte earlier this year, and the proceedings continue before the Pre-Trial Chamber.
A detailed explanation of the plenary's rejection is expected in a forthcoming decision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
29 minutes ago
- Zawya
UAE President, Pakistani Prime Minister discuss bilateral cooperation, regional developments
UAE President His Highness Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan today received His Excellency Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif, Prime Minister of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, who is on a working visit to the UAE. During the meeting, which took place at Qasr Al Shati in Abu Dhabi, His Highness and the Pakistani Prime Minister exchanged Eid Al-Adha greetings, offering prayers for continued prosperity for both nations and peace and stability across the Muslim world and beyond. The two sides discussed ways to strengthen bilateral cooperation, with a particular focus on the economic, investment and development sectors. They reaffirmed their commitment to deepening constructive ties and broadening their partnership in pursuit of shared interests and national development goals that aim to deliver greater prosperity for both peoples. His Highness Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed and Prime Minister Sharif also reviewed a range of regional and international issues of mutual concern and exchanged views on recent developments. They emphasised the importance of supporting international efforts to promote stability and strengthen peace both regionally and globally. The Pakistani Prime Minister commended the efforts of His Highness in advancing peace, security and stability at both regional and global levels. He highlighted the key role played by UAE diplomacy in promoting dialogue and finding common ground for diplomatic solutions to conflicts and crises around the world. He also expressed his appreciation for the UAE's ongoing support to Pakistan and its impactful development initiatives in the country. The meeting was attended by H.H. Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Ruler of Abu Dhabi and National Security Adviser; H.H. Sheikh Hamdan bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Chairman of the Presidential Court for Special Affairs; Sheikh Mohammed bin Hamad bin Tahnoon Al Nahyan, Advisor to the UAE President; Ali bin Hammad Al Shamsi, Secretary-General of the Supreme Council for National Security; Mohamed bin Mubarak Al Mazrouei, Minister of State for Defence Affairs, and Dr. Ahmed Mubarak Al Mazrouei, Chairman of the President's Office for Strategic Affairs and Chairman of the Abu Dhabi Executive Office. The meeting was also attended by the accompanying delegation of the Prime Minister of Pakistan, which included a number of ministers and senior officials. Earlier today, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif arrived in Abu Dhabi, where he was received at Al Bateen Airport by His Highness Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Ruler of Abu Dhabi and National Security Adviser, along with a number of senior officials.
Filipino Times
36 minutes ago
- Filipino Times
Marcos says disinformation is plague to freedom
False news and misinformation are among the biggest threats to freedom today, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. warned on Independence Day as he urged Filipinos to continue defending its democratic future. Speaking at the 127th anniversary of Philippine Independence and Nationhood, Marcos issued a strong message about the dangers of unchecked disinformation and blind conformity, which he said can erode the nation's values and dismantle hard-won liberties. 'Freedom is fleeting. Fake news, misinformation, herd mentality can erase our way of life, our culture, our value system that we hold so dear,' said Marcos. He emphasized that Philippine freedom was not handed over—it was fought for and must now be protected from modern forms of attack, including the deliberate spread of falsehoods. 'Ang mga kasinungalingang walang hangganan—mga balitang walang katotohanan at maling impormasyon, ito ang mga salot sa ating kalayaan,' he said. The president called on Filipinos to remain vigilant, urging them to think critically, seek the truth, and reject lies, even when such lies serve personal or political interests. 'Nakakalungkot din na may ilan sa ating mga kababayan ay pinipilit ang maling paniniwala para sa interes ng iba at hindi para sa kapakanan ng ating mga kababayang Pilipino,' Marcos lamented. 'Maging mapanuri tayo lagi. Alamin natin ang totoo. Labanan ang mga kasinungalingan,' he continued. Marcos also called for moral courage and unity in the face of division and deception. 'Piliin nating maging tapat, kahit walang nakakakita. Piliin natin na manindigan, lalo na kung may nagkakamali. Piliin natin ang pagkakaisa sa gitna ng pagkakaiba.'
Khaleej Times
43 minutes ago
- Khaleej Times
India plane crash: Pakistan PM Sharif offers prayers to those affected by 'heartbreaking tragedy'
Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif offered his condolences to the victims of the plane crash in Ahmedabad, India, on Thursday. "Saddened by the tragic crash of Air India flight near Ahmedabad today. We extend our condolences to the families of the victims grieving this immense loss. Our thoughts and prayers are with all those affected by this heartbreaking tragedy," Sharif said in a post on X. Meanwhile, Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said he was "saddened" by the plane crash. "Condolences over the loss of precious lives in this tragic incident. Our sympathies are with the families of the victims in this hour of grief," Dar, who also serves as deputy prime minister, he said on X.
