Attorney General ‘regrets' comparing calls to leave ECHR with 1930s Germany
The Attorney General 'regrets' remarks in which he compared calls for the UK to leave international courts with 1930s Germany, his spokesman has said.
In a statement, Lord Richard Hermer's spokesman said the peer acknowledged his 'choice of words was clumsy' but rejected 'the characterisation of his speech by the Conservatives'.
Lord Hermer has faced criticism for a speech on Thursday in which he criticised politicians who argued that Britain 'abandons the constraints of international law in favour of raw power'.
Arguing that similar claims had been made 'in the early 1930s by 'realist' jurists in Germany', Lord Hermer added that abandoning international law would only 'give succour to (Vladimir) Putin'.
He also said that because of what happened 'in 1933, far-sighted individuals rebuilt and transformed the institutions of international law'. That is the year that Adolf Hitler became German chancellor.
The speech prompted Tory leader Kemi Badenoch, who has suggested the UK would have to leave the ECHR if it stops the country from doing 'what is right', to accuse Lord Hermer of 'starting from a position of self loathing, where Britain is always wrong and everyone else is right'.
In a post on social media, she said: 'The fact is laws go bad and need changing, institutions get corrupted. Our sovereignty is being eroded by out-of-date treaties and courts acting outside their jurisdiction.
'Pointing this out does not make anyone a Nazi. Labour have embarrassed themselves again with this comparison and unless the Prime Minister demands a retraction from his Attorney General, we can only assume these slurs reflect Keir Starmer's own view.'
Lord Hermer's spokesman said: 'The Attorney General gave a speech defending international law which underpins our security, protects against threats from aggressive states like Russia and helps tackle organised immigration crime.
'He rejects the characterisation of his speech by the Conservatives. He acknowledges though that his choice of words was clumsy and regrets having used this reference.'
In his same speech to the Royal United Services Institute on Thursday, the Attorney General said 'we must not stagnate in our approach to international rules' and that officials should 'look to apply and adapt existing obligations to address new situations'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Liz Kendall to face Labour MPs as government braces for huge benefits revolt
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall is set to address the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) ahead of a major vote this month on cuts to sickness and disability benefits Liz Kendall is expected to face Labour MPs as the government braces for its biggest revolt yet over controversial welfare cuts. The Mirror understands the Work and Pensions Secretary will address a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) in the coming weeks. It will be a key chance for Labour MPs to quiz the minister on major welfare reforms behind-closed-doors. It is likely to come before MPs are asked to vote in June on major cuts to sickness and disability benefits, with Keir Starmer facing the biggest rebellion of his premiership so far. Earlier this month Keir Starmer faced angry backbenchers at the same private meeting, with many raising the issue of welfare reform and migration. Labour MP Ian Byrne told The Mirror: 'I will be attending the briefing from Liz Kendall and I hope the Government have listened to the disabled community who are terrified of the planned cuts, charities who have outlined their catastrophic impact and MPs who are relaying this message to the Government from their constituencies. 'After the Winter Fuel debacle and the damage it's done to the Government's standing, we need desperately to listen to the country and return to the core Labour values of tackling poverty and inequality and I hope this is the case otherwise I and many of my colleagues will vote against these measures as they currently stand.' Another MP said: 'The PLP has a declining number of true believers. She'll be met by a mix of distant silence, lots of searching questions, and a sense of bewilderment.' One MP told The Mirror: "If you think that Keir Starmer got a bit of a rough ride a couple of weeks ago and the largest issue that people had concerns about was welfare reform, and then you've got Liz Kendall standing in front of them, all of the concerns are going to be about welfare reform." They added: "I would have thought that's going to be quite an interesting meeting." A second MP said: "There's a clear indication of the mood in the PLP - it's not very forgiving at the moment." Concern has been building in the party since March when the government unveiled around £5billion in cuts to sickness and disability benefits. Most of the savings will be made from restricting eligibility to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) - a key disability benefit for people regardless of employment status. Over 100 Labour MPs have said they cannot support the changes without further evidence. And a separate group of more than 40 MPs said they were "impossible to support", describing the cuts as the "biggest attack on the welfare state since George Osborne". One MP told The Mirror many had also written privately to No10 expressing concerns, adding: "There has to be an alternative way". Last week the Commons Work and Pensions Committee - led by the senior Labour MP Debbie Abrahams - urged the government to delay the reforms. The government has been given until Monday to respond. But in a recent speech Ms Kendall stood by the reforms saying they will ensure "our welfare state is sustainable for the future". She added: "The truth is welfare reform is never easy, and it is rarely popular. Perhaps especially for Labour governments. But no responsible Labour government can resile from taking decisions because they are too difficult. Because this is not good enough for the people we came into politics to serve. "So, we will reform the welfare state. Just as great reforming Labour governments have done in the past." And she recently told The Mirror: "I understand people's concern and I understand people are anxious. But we are consulting with disabled people and the organisations that represent them on our PIP review, to look at the assessment process. I believe the task of helping people who can work, get work, is urgent." Labour MP Ian Byrne told The Mirror: 'I will be attending the briefing from Liz Kendall and I hope the Government have listened to the disabled community who are terrified of the planned cuts, charities who have outlined their catastrophic impact and MPs who are relaying this message to to the Government from their constituencies. 'After the Winter Fuel debacle and the damage it's done to the Governments standing, we need desperately to listen to the country and return to the core Labour values of tackling poverty & inequality and I hope this is the case otherwise I and many of my colleagues will vote against these measures as they currently stand.' Another MP said: 'The PLP has a declining number of true believers. 'She'll be met by a mix of distant silence, lots of searching questions, and a sense of bewilderment.'
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Podcaster charged after Scots councillor targeted with vile racist abuse
SUNDAY MAIL EXCLUSIVE: Craig Houston has been charged after the Glagsow politician was bombarded with Islamophobic hatred. A Scottish podcaster has been arrested after a councillor was bombarded with racist abuse online. Councillor Dr Soryia Siddique, who represents Glasgow Southside Central, faced a barrage of Islamophobic and racist hatred last week after she spoke about her reasons for entering politics. In a video for ElectHer, a campaign group which helps women get into politics, Siddique said she had been surprised by how 'pale, male and stale' the environment she entered was. Some of her comments were picked up by online trolls after a video was made specifically targeting Siddique. The councillor, who was elected in 2012, also spoke about the challenges of being a woman in politics and her passion for the job, which were not commented on. The abuse against the Labour councillor came in the same week Nigel Farage was accused of racism for highlighting a speech made by Anas Sarwar where he was encouraging more people from ethnic minorities to go into politics. Scottish podcaster and Youtuber Craig Houston has now been arrested and charged by police. A Police Scotland spokesman said: 'A 52-year-old man has been arrested and charged following a report of an online communication offence. 'He is due to appear at Glasgow Sheriff Court at a later date and a report will be sent to the Procurator Fiscal.' A Glasgow Labour spokesperson said 'We understand the content of these videos is under police investigation and an individual has been charged.'
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Reform to end gold-plated pensions for council workers
Reform UK has unveiled plans to reduce gold-plated staff pensions at the councils it won from Labour and the Tories at the local elections. Richard Tice, the party's deputy leader, said it would take an axe to final salary schemes, describing them as unaffordable and an 'outrage'. Speaking to The Telegraph, he said Reform-controlled authorities would stop offering such generous terms to new recruits. He added that staff on existing contracts would have to accept lower annual pay rises to balance out the huge cost of funding their retirement. Nigel Farage's party won control of 10 councils across England last month, marking its major electoral breakthrough. It did so on a pledge to find huge savings, promising to end local authority focus on diversity and inclusion schemes and hitting net zero targets. 'Country is going bust' Mr Tice is fronting efforts to free up money that could be reinvested in improving services like bin collections or used to freeze council tax. He has identified wasteful and underperforming pension schemes as an area where Reform councils can save hundreds of millions of pounds. 'Whether people like it or not we should not be employing people on defined benefit contribution schemes,' he told The Telegraph. 'It's an outrage – the public can't afford it. It's absolutely ludicrous, and this is why the country is going bust and it's all got to stop. 'We're going to have to go to war with these people. Our job is to wake people up as to where their money is going and why we're all being ripped off.' Mr Tice said under many gold-plated pension schemes councils were having to contribute up to 30 per cent of their officials' salaries. Such final salary schemes are substantially more generous than those in the private sector. He said that if staff are on such terms 'then candidly that has to be taken into account when you look at people's annual pay rises'. 'You look at the overall cost of employment and if they're not prepared to then a whole load of people are going to have to be made redundant,' he warned. 'Councils are going bust all over the country – the country's going bust, and until we've come along no one dared admit it.' Last year it emerged that a quarter of council tax revenue was now being spent on pension schemes that are 'unjustifiably generous'. It means the average household is now contributing £230 a year to the retirement plans of officials who, on average, earn nearly £40,000 a year. Last year local authorities contributed almost £7 billion to staff pension pots, The Times revealed, making them one of their highest costs. Mr Tice said that, as well as the generous contributions, many councils were also investing in 'woke' pension funds that were underperforming. He said Reform would be examining how much money was being put into net zero funds and whether they were making below average returns. The councils controlled by the party could also save upwards of £200 million a year just by renegotiating the investment fees they are charged, he added. 'I can smell the taxpayer being ripped off,' he said. 'Their council tax is being gobbled up by pension fund contributions because they're overgenerous and they've been badly managed for decades.'
