Presidents at War: how battle has shaped American leaders

Yahoo

18-02-2025

In his new book, Presidents at War, Steven M Gillon considers how the second world war shaped a generation of presidents, a span that takes in eight men – but not all of them served in uniform between 1941 and 1945.
Gillon likes to 'ask people, 'There are seven men who served in uniform in world war two and who went on to be president: who are they?' And most people think Jimmy Carter did, and they forget Ronald Reagan.'
Carter was born in 1924 and came of age in wartime. But the submariner turned peanut farmer turned politician, who died aged 100 in December, graduated the US Naval Academy in 1946, the year after the war. Reagan, meanwhile, joined the Army Reserve in the 1930s and spent the war years enlisted – but stayed at home in Hollywood, where he made his name as an actor, narrating films and joining fundraising drives.
Related: Did Reagan pave the way for Trump? 'You can trace the linkages,' says biographer
'Reagan was the most fascinating for me,' says Gillon, emeritus professor of history at the University of Oklahoma and scholar-in-residence at the History Channel. 'I once bought the story about: 'Oh, he wanted to go and fight but his eyes were too bad.' In fact, there's all these machinations going on behind the scenes that keep him from going overseas, to make sure he stays in California so he can make movies, while at the same time creating this public image of a guy who has been off to war, and he comes home to his wife [Jane Wyman], and there's a picture of him in his uniform, kissing his wife – who in fact he slept with every night during the war.'
Gillon focuses on how the war affected men who led their country through the cold war with Russia, into the quagmire of Vietnam, and eventually into the first Iraq war. To Gillon, 'those presidents who came closest to combat were the ones who were most restrained in their use of force afterwards,' meaning Dwight Eisenhower, who commanded Allied forces in Europe, and John F Kennedy and George HW Bush, who flirted with death in the Pacific, JFK as a torpedo boat captain, Bush as a navy flier.
'Reagan is the exception of so many of these things,' Gillon says. 'Reagan never sees war. He thinks he saw the Holocaust camps, but he didn't. He just makes stuff up, and he thinks it's true. But what I did not know was how he came out of the war with the real fear of nuclear weapons, and he belonged to an organization for international control of atomic weapons, largely a liberal organization, as he was involved in other liberal organizations like Americans for Democratic Action.
'While he shed all the other liberal ties, he never shed that fear of nuclear weapons. And despite all his bombastic language, he was very restrained in the use of force. I mean, the only thing he did was create a phony war in Grenada [in which 19 Americans died] and see 241 Americans killed in Lebanon [both in 1983], and that was a peacekeeping mission.'
In response to the Beirut embassy bombing, Reagan launched limited strikes. He also bombed Libya, in 1986, and funded and fueled conflicts elsewhere, his efforts in Nicaragua creating the Iran-Contra scandal. But on the global scene, Gillon 'was surprised at how restrained Reagan was. And then his fear of nuclear weapons made him open to [Mikhail] Gorbachev's overtures' for detente and arms control 'during his second term … this was where Reagan followed his own instincts and in this case his instincts were right, and he was the right person to do it because he had such strong anti-communist credentials. So that was a twist I had not appreciated before.'
Gillon's book contains more twists. Many involve Lyndon Baines Johnson, like Reagan no stranger to distorting facts for political gain. A congressman when the US entered the war, LBJ got himself into uniform for a Pacific fact-finding tour. Hitching a ride on a bomber, he survived an attack by Japanese fighters.
'There's controversy over whether that took place the way he described it,' Gillon says. 'There was an article written by some aviation historians who said it never could have happened. And then, years later, the Japanese pilot who had actually led the attack against the American planes said he remembered Johnson's plane. He remembered crippling it, and he said the plane was so wounded that he knew it wasn't going to do any damage, so he broke off and went back into the main attack.'
Related: Den of Spies: Craig Unger on Reagan, treason and the first October surprise
Johnson's plane made it back to base, leaving him alive to tell tales of his own bravery on the campaign trail. Gillon shows how those tales grew more shameless but thinks the basic story 'is definitely true', including how a bathroom break meant Johnson lost a spot on a plane which was shot down, killing all onboard.
'Yeah, Johnson was just cool as a cucumber. And I'm sure he was thrilled when he landed.'
Gillon was born in working class Philadelphia in 1956, in the shadow of the war. Too young for the Vietnam draft, fascinated by the presidency, he graduated from Widener and Brown and then taught at Yale and Oxford. Recent books include America's Reluctant Prince, about his late friend John F Kennedy Jr, and The Pact, about Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich, a Democratic president and a Republican House speaker whose relationship resonates loudly today.
With his latest book, Gillon focuses on the major lessons of the second world war, particularly the cost of appeasement, Hitler's triumph at Munich in 1938 a constant ghost at the feast. Such lessons, he says, 'some forgot, like Lyndon Johnson in Vietnam, while others, like Kennedy and Bush, those who really saw battle and the horrors of war, you see them thinking about world war two all the time when they're making big decisions, whether it's the Cuban Missile Crisis for Kennedy or it's the invasion of Iraq with George Bush'.
Looking to Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford, Gillon describes how both served but did not see battle. Both were in the navy. Ford's closest brush with action involved a fire aboard his ship during a Pacific typhoon. Nixon was posted to tropical islands, working logistics and supply, failing to reach the front line.
Vietnam dominates Gillon's book. US involvement began under Eisenhower, accelerated under Kennedy, swirled into nightmare under Johnson and finally ended under Nixon – though he had lengthened the horror by thwarting peace talks for his own political gain. Gillon retells the extraordinary Anna Chennault affair, in which a Washington socialite acted as a go-between with the government of South Vietnam, relaying Nixon's urge to boycott talks till the 1968 election was done. When Johnson learned of it, he told a senior Republican: 'This is treason.' The senator agreed. Johnson called Nixon, who denied it. Gillon writes: 'According to some reports, after hanging up, Nixon collapsed with laughter.'
In 1968, Nixon beat Hubert Humphrey. The war did not end until 1973. Reading Presidents at War, it is striking to realize that no future president who was of an age to serve in Vietnam did so.
Bill Clinton opposed the war, studied abroad and denied accusations of dodging the draft. Joe Biden secured student deferments then was exempted on account of teenage asthma. George W Bush, the son of a war hero, went into the Texas Air national guard, which, Gillon notes, 'is a place notoriously where rich, powerful people put their kids during war'. Al Gore, John Kerry and John McCain did go to Vietnam – but lost presidential elections.
As so often, Donald Trump is a whole other matter. He obtained student draft deferments but also found a doctor to say 'bone spurs' in his heels rendered him unfit for service. He has also said avoiding sexually transmitted diseases while dating in New York was his 'personal Vietnam', making him feel like 'a great and very brave soldier'. It's not a line to endear him to Gillon, who says he cast his first vote for a Republican president, Ford, but whose epilogue to Presidents at War makes clear his distaste for Trump, his view of military matters and his reported negative comments about those who serve.
'I have my political point of view but when I write history, I try to be really fair-minded,' Gillon says. 'And I can't be fair-minded toward Trump. I just dislike him so much that I don't think I could write a book about him. I wrote a book about Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich, and what made me happy was that both Clinton and Gingrich liked it. I take great pride in being fair of mind towards someone like Newt Gingrich, who I have no political affinity for, but I just can't get to that point mentally with Trump. I can't write a book that I feel I can't be fair.'
Presidents at War is out now