Six in 10 Scots worried domestic abuse victims would seek assisted death
Two previous attempts at Holyrood to change the law on the issue were decisively defeated, but Mr McArthur has expressed confidence that it will pass this time.
Several MSPs have said that they would support the legislation in the first vote so the debate over assisted dying could continue and to see what amendments are made at the next stage.
However, they have said that they may not support the Bill in the final vote, which would decide whether the amended Bill should become law.
Separate legislation introducing assisted dying in England and Wales has been tabled in the House of Commons by Kim Leadbeater, the Labour MP for Spen Valley.
The poll was published after John Swinney, the First Minister, disclosed that he will oppose the legislation in Tuesday's vote. He also expressed concerns that vulnerable people could come under pressure to end their own lives.
The Other Half, which develops policy in women's interests, said that the survey confirmed 'Scottish people are worried about the vulnerable being coerced into state death'.
Fiona Mackenzie, The Other Half's chief executive, said: 'That worry is heightened for older people and disabled people, who report the greatest concern of all the public. They may see the vulnerability and dependence of older age and disability. We should listen to them.
'We know that older adults, especially older women, are vulnerable to escalating abuse in older age, with one in six over-60s estimated to have experienced elder abuse in the last 12 months.'
The poll of 1,088 adults was conducted by Whitestone Insights between May 2 and 7. It also found that concern about the effects on domestic abuse victims was higher among women (62 per cent) than men (60 per cent).
'Direct threat'
Stephen Kerr, a Scottish Tory MSP, said: 'Liam McArthur's assisted dying Bill is a direct threat to vulnerable people. Most Scots now fear that victims of domestic abuse could be pressured into ending their lives – and they're right to.
'The Bill says nothing about domestic abuse. Its definition of 'terminal illness' is dangerously vague and could be widened through the courts, just as experts have warned.'
Isabelle Kerr, who recently retired as the head of a women's refuge founded by JK Rowling, also warned that the Bill 'may place domestic abuse survivors in even more danger from perpetrators'.
Ms Kerr, formerly of the Beira's Place support service in Edinburgh, said: 'Domestic abuse survivors who have lived with coercive and controlling behaviour from a partner will believe that she is the one making the decision to end her life, that it is best for everyone, and that her life is worthless as this is part of that pattern of behaviour common to many controlling and abusive men.'
But Mr McArthur told BBC Scotland's The Sunday Show that there had been a 'huge shift' in the 'political mood' in Holyrood since legislation to allow assisted dying was last defeated in 2015.
He said that any application would have to be approved by 'two doctors acting independently', who would discuss with the patient the 'rationale' for their decision because 'there is a need to ensure that no undue pressure or coercion has been brought to bear'.
Mr McArthur denied that the legislation would be the 'thin end of the wedge', with eligibility criteria expanding over time, saying a Commons inquiry had found no evidence of this.
Mr McArthur added: 'I am confident that my proposals represent a robust and well safeguarded Bill, allowing Scots access to the choice of an assisted death if they have an advanced, progressive terminal illness and the mental capacity to make the decision.
'Under the current ban on assisted dying, terminally ill people – women included – are taking matters into their own hands, ending their own lives at home or travelling to Switzerland. Right now, we cannot know whether these people have made an entirely voluntary decision.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
33 minutes ago
- The Independent
The major change Daniel Dubois has made to ensure ‘the greatest victory in boxing history' against Oleksandr Usyk
Confidence in the Daniel Dubois' camp is unwavering ahead of his rematch with Oleksandr Usyk. Dubois is more confident than anyone, seemingly counting down the days until he can ink 'undisputed heavyweight champion of the world' on his CV. 'I'm raring to go – get ready for the greatest victory in boxing history,' the Brooks athlete says, relaxing into a leather sofa after a few rounds of performative padwork – all-out efforts are saved for when he is behind closed doors. Catch all the latest boxing action on DAZN But while boxing is the prototypical individual sport, it is now a team game. And Dubois' team for this fight has grown to new heights, ensuring no stone is left unturned in his preparations for the heavyweight clash. 'This is only done at the top level,' says trainer Don Charles, who sits at the helm. 'I've been in the coaching industry for 25 years, and I've trained other high-profile boxers. This is the first time the team has grown to where we're getting all of this support: nutritional advice, a doctor present at training. That's unheard of, having a doctor present at training sessions. He adds: 'It's because this is the pinnacle. It doesn't get any higher than this, contesting for the undisputed. Daniel is a part of history, and we are all involved in it.' Among his team are Dr Ravi Gill and physiotherapist Tom Kopelman, who have been brought in from Premier League side Tottenham Hotspur. 'Our main remit is illness and injury prevention, recovery optimisation, and giving Don Charles the best possible version of Daniel Dubois every day,' Gill says. As well as taking precautions to avoid a repeat of Dubois' illness-caused withdrawal from his Joseph Parker fight, Gill stays ringside to keep tabs on metrics such as heart rate variability, blood oxygen levels, heart rate and more via a chest-worn monitor. His summary: 'I've worked with elite athletes and World Cup winners, and Daniel has the best physique I've seen. He goes on: 'It's impressive how well he recovers. His heart rate goes up when sparring and training, then it comes down again really efficiently. He can go 18 rounds, no problem.' Recovery is another big focus, physio Kopelman adds. Alongside prehab work and strengthening exercises to build a buffer against injury, he employs several techniques to allow Dubois to bounce back from tough 20-round training days. 'Recovery can involve lots of different things,' Kopelman explains, 'and it's very individual, so it's [about] finding what works for the athlete to make sure they're ready. Everyone talks about improving the one per cents, but even if you can improve things by 0.1 per cent, it adds up. Sleeping is a huge part of that, he says. 'You can have the best ice bath in the world, but it means nothing if you don't sleep well. Then there's an individual aspect to being an athlete. You have to be happy.' Dubois does seem happy, and remarkably at ease. After leaving the ring, he is led through some stretches, then unflinchingly lowers his imposing frame into a tub of freezing cold water. A torrent of ice cube-laden liquid is displaced onto the floor in the process. As eyebrows raise over his lack of reaction, he laughs, submerges his head, then reemerges with a laugh: 'It gets easier over time,' he says. Rather than the act itself becoming easier, he might simply be getting better at it. Most would agree this is mirrored in his career, with Dubois growing in composure, guile and ability with each passing fight. This, twinned with his team's fastidious preparations for the Usyk fight, means we are likely to see the best version of Daniel Dubois to date on Saturday, 19 July. For boxing fans across the world, this is an exciting prospect. Watch the very best boxing with a DAZN subscription DAZN is the home of combat sports, broadcasting over 185 fights a year from the world's best promoters, including Matchroom, Queensberry, Golden Boy, Misfits, PFL, BKFC, GLORY and more. An Annual Saver subscription is a one-off cost of £119.99 / $224.99 (for 12 months access), that's just 64p / $1.21 per fight. There is also a Monthly Flex Pass option (cancel any time) at £24.99 / $29.99 per month. A subscription includes weekly magazine shows, comprehensive fight library, exclusive interviews, behind-the-scenes documentaries, and podcasts and vodcasts.
The Guardian
37 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘How did it get to this?' What happens when care in a residential home breaks down
'If we had known what was really going on, we'd have taken her out of there straight away,' said Greg Gillespie. 'It makes you question your decision-making. But the real shame of this is we just didn't know. It was hidden so well.' Gillespie's elderly grandmother lived at The Firs, a Nottinghamshire care home that was dramatically shut down by the Care Quality Commission in April due to a catalogue of shocking failures – everything from meeting nutritional and hydration needs, staffing, equipment, fire safety and governance was found to be lacking. The CQC found people were at 'serious risk of harm from overdose' due to poor medicine management, while some were at 'increased risk of developing pressure sores and ulcers', and one person was 'at risk of choking from not having their immediate needs met'. The people living in the care home, who were elderly, vulnerable or receiving end-of-life care, were evacuated in ambulances by the council into the early hours of the morning. One person who was receiving palliative care died within hours of the move. Soon after, the home in Lowdham – which housed 11 people with dementia and physical disabilities – went into liquidation. Staff lost their jobs and have been left with wages unpaid, and many residents are owed thousands of pounds in fees – people paid from £1,250 a week to live there. 'People must be held accountable for this. I don't think anyone who can run a home like this should be allowed to work in the care sector ever again,' said Gillespie, a corporate investigator more accustomed to turning his hand to international cases of public office bribery and fraud than care homes. He is compiling a dossier of evidence on what went wrong at The Firs and why it took so long to act on whistleblowing complaints, which he plans to submit to his local MP and the health secretary. 'I won't be letting the matter go, not just for my own relative and the staff who lost their jobs, but out of principle, because no one's loved ones or their families should have to go through this,' he said. 'I think this situation is so unique and appalling it needs to be looked at a higher level.' Emma Locking's 87-year-old grandfather, Tim, who has dementia, lived at the home. She said her family were shocked when they received a call at 5.30pm on a Friday saying the home was being shut down with immediate effect. 'Obviously my nan, at 85, was panicking, thinking: 'Oh my God, now he's homeless,'' she said. 'It was really stressful. It's awful for all the residents. These are people in their 80s and 90s. Some of them didn't even have family to help. I just think the way it was all handled was disgusting.' They had held concerns about the home for a while, particularly after Tim was left for 15 hours with an open wound on his wrist after a fall in December. His family said they were not informed of the seriousness of the injury until the next morning, when staff asked them to take him to hospital for stitches. When they arrived to pick him up, one staff member said the wound had been 'like a bloodbath'. 'I said: 'Why the hell did no one tell us this last night?' I would have taken him in. The wound was horrific,' she said. 'He's diabetic. He's on blood thinners. He's 87 years old. He could have died from that cut because he could have got sepsis. It makes you think: would he have been better off at home?' She said her grandfather's medication was not stored correctly and was often out of date, and he suffered two other falls at the home due to faulty or missing equipment. Her family considered raising concerns with the CQC, but worried about the repercussions for Tim while he lived there. The CQC report on the failures at The Firs found a number of serious safety breaches. A fridge used to store medicine, including insulin and antibiotics, had been switched off for five days with no one noticing, meaning the medicine may have become ineffective. Errors and a lack of training led to frequent overdoses – three residents received above the maximum dose of their pain relief, putting them at 'serious risk of harm'. Others weren't receiving medication regularly, including one person on end-of-life care. People with dementia had unsupervised access to unlocked doors, leading outside to a busy road and to a retaining wall that had been taped off as it was at risk of collapse. Fire exits were blocked, and there was no equipment to transport two people living upstairs with mobility issues down in an emergency. The home's manager was absent for long periods of time. The findings didn't come as a surprise to many of the staff at The Firs, some of whom had been raising concerns for months. One care worker, who asked to remain anonymous, said in the four years they had worked there only two fire drills were carried out. 'It was scary. No one knew how to get the residents downstairs if there was a fire,' they said. 'The whole time I was there, we only had two fire drills and we failed both of them – and we didn't get more training on it.' Another care worker, Megan O'Neill, said she had been pressed into taking on medication duties due to staff shortages, but wasn't given proper training. 'I was just chucked into it. I didn't really feel comfortable about it and they knew that,' she said. She claims she was unfairly dismissed when she left a shift early due to poor mental health exacerbated by the pressure of providing medication without training, and later reported her concerns to the CQC. Another care worker said one person was given double the amount of morphine they should have received and it was simply 'brushed under the carpet'. Across the country there are concerns that increasing strain on the care home industry is leading to deteriorating levels of care, and could lead to more emergency closures. 'Seeing this CQC report, it's horrendous, but some of it is stuff that we're hearing quite often every day,' said Helen Wildbore, the director of Care Rights UK, which runs a national advice line for older people with care issues. 'Closed cultures and institutionalisation is on the increase. Staff don't have the time and the resources to give personalised care. And that is having an impact on people not being able to live with dignity, basic rights being breached and relatives experiencing anxiety, more stress and unnecessary trauma.' Staff shortages, a lack of funding and the rise in national insurance contributions were all playing their part in pushing the sector to breaking point, Wildbore said. She added that failures by the CQC, which the health secretary, Wes Streeting, described as 'not fit for purpose' last year, were exacerbating the situation and leaving poor care unchecked for long periods of time. 'They're supposed to be setting minimum standards and making sure they're there, but they can only do that if they're responding when people raise concerns and actually crossing that threshold to see with their own eyes what's happening,' she said. The Firs was previously rated 'requires improvement' at its last full CQC inspection in February 2021, four years before the one that led to its closure, with many family members questioning why it took so long for it to revisit when there were known issues. 'How did it get to this? Why didn't the CQC intervene earlier?' said Gillespie. The Firs has been contacted for comment. James Bullion, the CQC's interim chief inspector of adult social care and integrated care, said: 'Following an inspection in April 2025 of The Firs care home in Lowdham, we took action to suspend the registration of the home for three months following concerns we had around safety, care planning and oversight of the service. 'We have since been informed that the provider has gone into liquidation. We are considering if any further action needs to be taken. Care homes are people's homes and everyone living there deserves to be treated with dignity and respect – and to be listened to. We will continue to hold providers to account where we find this is not the case.'
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Throat cancer patient praises new Salisbury District Hospital kit
A throat cancer patient has praised new equipment at Salisbury District Hospital for making an uncomfortable procedure more bearable for Russell, 67, from Maiden Bradley, was diagnosed with squamous cell carcinoma in November 2019 after discovering a lump in his throat. Since then, he has undergone monthly check-ups using videoscopes to monitor his condition - a procedure he once described as feeling like going "a couple of rounds with Mike Tyson".With funding from the Stars Appeal, the hospital's charity, six new videoscopes which cut appointment times have been purchased at a cost of £115,000. These devices allow for quicker and more comfortable diagnoses for patients with suspected head and neck their introduction in September, more than 1,600 patients referred with suspected head and neck cancers have benefitted from their use. 'Felt like a punch' Mr Russell said: "I am well used to this unpleasant procedure, but the new cameras make it so much more comfortable. For new patients, they will significantly reduce the fear of having it done."He added: "The new cameras made the procedure so much easier to manage. Sometimes it used to feel like being punched in the nose."The upgraded scopes also offer doctors much clearer images, helping them to detect changes in patients over time. This is particularly important for people like Mr Russell, whose cancer has been persistent and unpredictable. "The unique nature of my cancer meant it kept coming and going. This equipment is really important because doctors can now see subtle changes that may signal something's happening," he scopes are part of a new 'one-stop' diagnostic service led by the hospital's Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) and Maxillofacial can now receive assessments in a single visit, instead of attending multiple departments. ENT consultant Mr Kostas Marinakis said the new equipment has had a major impact. "The superior image quality gives us the best chance of detecting early cancers and significantly improves the comfort of the procedure. "We're extremely grateful to the Stars Appeal supporters for making this possible."
