Hong Kong doesn't need lawmakers who have to be reminded to do their job
Every now and then, Hong Kong's Legislative Council reminds us of grade school. Just like in a school year, lawmakers have historically enjoyed a summer recess – of two to three months at the end of July – before beginning the next legislative year in October.
Advertisement
After the
2021 overhaul of the electoral system, however, Legco elections were moved from September to December, which meant the legislative year started in January instead.
To ensure that school could still be out for the summer, lawmakers voted in 2023 to abolish a rule of procedure requiring that two consecutive meetings are not held more than six weeks apart in the same legislative year. Summer was saved – by lawmakers undoing the rules.
There has been noise over the prolonged summer 'break' our honourable legislators enjoy. Most notably in 2020, in the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic,
Leung Chun-ying , vice-chairman of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference and the city's former chief executive, challenged the need for a Legco recess when so much needed to be done.
In 2022, former lawmaker Wong Kwok-hing urged the chief executive to cancel the recess altogether. In 2023, commentator Chris Wat Wing-yin called the arrangement ridiculous and wondered why not a single member of the expanded 90-person Legco had proposed its cancellation.
Advertisement
Every time the subject is brought up, lawmakers react with indignance. It's not a break from work but an adjournment of meetings, they say; they don't stop working because there are other meetings and events to attend and people to meet; and, some of these people they need to meet require overseas travel as lawmakers work to tell good stories of Hong Kong, they also say.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
2 days ago
- HKFP
Hong Kong hails ‘overwhelming support' for legalising basketball betting, proposes 50% levy on profits
The Hong Kong government has hailed 'overwhelming support' from scholars, athletes, and youth groups for its plan to legalise basketball betting in the city, following the conclusion of a one-month public consultation last month. Ninety-four per cent of the 1,063 submissions received by the government between April and May 'expressed support or positive views' on the proposal to regulate basketball betting under the Betting Duty Ordinance, according to a paper submitted by the Home and Youth Affairs Bureau to the Legislative Council on Thursday. Those who supported the legal amendment said public demand for basketball betting has 'increased significantly,' and a regulatory regime can protect bettors' rights and interests. The government proposed in April to amend the ordinance to grant the Secretary for Home and Youth Affairs the power to issue a basketball betting license to the Hong Kong Jockey Club (HKJC). The regulatory regime will mirror the existing one for football betting, the government said. In the paper released on Thursday, the government proposed imposing a 50 per cent levy on the net profits from basketball betting. Citing responses from supporters of the legislative proposal, the government said the HKJC may donate its additional revenue to welfare and charitable purposes. The tax revenue generated may also help the government allocate more resources on social welfare, supporters said, according to the government. Financial Secretary Paul Chan first unveiled the government's intention to regulate basketball betting during his 2025 budget speech in February. He said the legalisation could tackle illegal gambling and raise tax revenue amid the city's estimated deficit of HK$87.2 billion. The finance chief projected that regulating basketball betting could generate HK$1.5 billion to HK$2 billion in tax revenue. The government acknowledged on Thursday that 36 submissions – or 3.4 per cent of the responses collected – opposed the proposal. Those who objected raised concerns about the adverse impact of basketball betting on the youth, adding illegal gambling still existed after football betting was legalised. Responding to the concerns, the government said in the paper that the impact of betting activities on young people has been 'steady' in recent years. The proportion of bettors aged between 18 and 21 also 'consistently remained below two per cent,' the government said quoting the HKJC. Some suggested the government to prohibit individuals aged between 18 and 25 from placing bets online, while others proposed imposing restrictions on the amount and number of bets that can be placed by young people. The paper submitted on Thursday is set to be discussed by lawmakers on the Legislative Council's Panel on Home Affairs, Culture and Sports on Monday. 'Disastrous move' In February, the Hong Kong Committee on Children's Rights criticised the government's plan to regulate basketball betting, saying that giving a green light to basketball betting was a 'disastrous move.' The group said popularising sports betting could 'lure' young people to bet with their limited financial resources that should otherwise go to other needs. Gambling loss may also result in psychological pressure and guilt, which may deter individuals from seeking help, it said, warning that gamblers could enter a 'vicious cycle' where they turn to lending agencies or engage in criminal activities.
South China Morning Post
2 days ago
- South China Morning Post
Alarm over Hong Kong student suicides, but minister rejects calls for counsellors
Hong Kong's education minister has dismissed suggestions to introduce counsellors at schools to address students' mental health concerns, arguing that the issue should be tackled through concerted efforts across campus, rather than relying on a single individual. Secretary for Education Christine Choi Yuk-lin told lawmakers on Friday that primary and secondary schools in the city had reported 11 suspected student suicide cases between January and April this year. This follows 28 such cases in the whole of 2024. Most lawmakers at the Legislative Council's education panel meeting described the student suicide situation as serious. Choi attributed poor mental health among young people to the impact of the online world. 'The current online world affects the health of teenagers in many ways, including insomnia and character development. Playing video games, echoing or attacking each other on social media has a very bad impact on the mental health of teenagers,' she said. 'Spending too much time [online] also affects brain development.' Choi suggested a 'whole-school approach' to address the problem, with personnel collaborating with various professionals to provide students with comprehensive support and services.
RTHK
2 days ago
- RTHK
Joshua Wong in court over collusion conspiracy
Joshua Wong in court over collusion conspiracy Joshua Wong appears at West Kowloon Magistrates' Courts. File photo: RTHK Jailed former activist Joshua Wong has appeared in court charged with conspiring to collude with foreign forces under the National Security Law. Wong, 28, is serving a sentence of four years and eight months for conspiracy to commit subversion for his involvement in an unsanctioned Legislative Council primary poll, in a plot to overthrow the government. He was arrested in Stanley on Friday and taken to West Kowloon Magistrates' Courts in the afternoon to face one count of "conspiracy to collusion with a foreign country or with external elements to endanger national security". According to the charge sheet, he is accused of colluding with wanted national security suspect Nathan Law and other individuals between July 1, 2020, and November 23 that year to request foreign organisations and officials to impose sanctions, or blockade, or take hostile action against Hong Kong or the country. Wong is also alleged to have asked foreign organisations and officials to seriously obstruct the formulation and implementation of laws and policies by SAR or central authorities. National security police, in a separate statement, said officers arrested a man on suspicion of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces as well as "dealing with property known or believed to represent proceeds of an indictable offence" under the Organised and Serious Crimes Ordinance.
