Public inquiry into brain surgeon Eljamel spends £1m before hearing any evidence
More than £1m has been spent on a public inquiry into a disgraced brain surgeon that has not started hearing evidence yet, new figures show.The inquiry into Sam Eljamel, who harmed dozens of patients and left some with life-changing injuries, was launched last month and has racked up £1.08m in costs so far.Eljame was head of neurosurgery at Dundee's Ninewells Hospital until his suspension in December 2013. He resigned a year later and is now believed to be operating in Libya.The inquiry outlay was revealed by Holyrood's finance committee which is investigating the cost-effectiveness of public inquiries in Scotland.
New Scottish parliament research suggests the total cost of all public inquires launched over the last 18 years, in today's prices, has been £230m so far.On 20 May, MSPs will begin their examination of what spending controls are in place to ensure the taxpayer is getting value for money from the statutory probes.They will hear from Prof Sandy Cameron, who was a panel member on the inquiry into historic abuse of children in care in Jersey. In his written submission, Prof Cameron said keeping on top of legal costs are a big challenge for all inquires.He said: "It has to be recognised that inquiries are a source of substantial income for some large legal firms and as such the question arises as to the extent to which they are motivated to keep costs to a minimum and within budget".
The finance committee will also consider a written submission from the logistics and procurement support agency of the health service, NHS National Services Scotland (NSS).In its submission, NHS NSS said the "current processes for monitoring public inquiry costs are inadequate" and revealed it has spent £3.1m in responding to public inquiries, as well as providing around £9m in legal services to other health boards for doing the same since 2021. The health board suggest the introduction of mandatory interim recommendations in all public inquiries, as happens in the UK Covid inquiry, would help speed up improvements. NHS NSS also suggest that an independent advisory body could be established to support Holyrood in deciding whether a public inquiry should be held, and the best way to go about it.
New Zealand approach
Alternatives to statutory inquires should also be considered, according to NHS NSS.It points to New Zealand where a Royal Commission was established to look at the country's response to Covid. This was chaired by an epidemiologist, with a former government minister and a treasury secretary as panel members, rather than a judge.The New Zealand Covid inquiry, which has cost around £7m so far, started in 2022 and its terms of reference include a deadline of completing by February next year. The Scottish Covid Inquiry has cost £34m so far and the UK Covid Inquiry is expected to top £200m.
Questions have been raised about the cost-effectiveness of the inquiries in recent years but the Scottish government, which picks up the bill for running them, said they provided important opportunities to establish facts and learn lessons.All of the current public inquires have been supported in votes at Holyrood, as well as by families and campaigners. The Eljamel Inquiry, headed by Lord Weir, launched its terms of reference last month and is expected to begin full hearings later this year.The inquiry will determine whether patients were let down by failures in clinical governance, risk management, and complaints procedures, and to what extent Eljamel's private practice, research, and workload impacted on the care received by his patients within NHS Tayside.Lord Weir said the independent inquiry would be "fair and thorough" and put patients "at the centre" of the process.Most of the inquiry's costs to date have gone on staffing (£666,949) and legal services (£316,035).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Ambulance call-outs to deal with prison overdoses soar amid 'drugs epidemic'
The number of ambulance call-outs made to prisons after reported overdoses and 'poisonings' has almost doubled in the past year, fuelling fears of a 'drug epidemic' behind bars. New Scottish Ambulance Service (SAS) figures show that 109 calls were made in 2023-24, a sharp increase on the 62 calls in 2022-23 – a rise of 76 per cent. Prison bosses insisted they are working with police to 'prevent illicit substances entering our establishments, to protect people from the harm they cause'. The figures came as a group which receives taxpayers' money claimed free needles and vapes should be handed out to prisoners so they can take Class A drugs in a safer way. Last night Scottish Tory justice spokesman Liam Kerr said: 'This shocking rise in ambulance call-outs for overdoses and poisonings in prisons confirms what staff have been warning about for years. 'The drugs epidemic inside Scotland's jails is escalating, putting inmates' lives at risk, creating a toxic atmosphere for those trying to get clean and putting prison officers in danger. 'It's also adding to the strain on our already overstretched emergency workers - at a time when Scotland's ambulance service is unable to meet demand, these additional, avoidable pressures are making things worse.' Among the prisons with the highest number of ambulance call-outs for 'overdose/poisoning' since 2019 were HMP Shotts (65) in Lanarkshire and HMP Addiewell in West Lothian (47). A further 45 calls were made to HMP Glenochil [in Tullibody, Clacks], 42 at HMP Barlinnie in Glasgow, 38 at HMP Grampian, 23 at HMP Perth. Meanwhile, the Scottish Drugs Forum - which received almost £2million from the public purse last year - has suggested the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) should provide drug paraphernalia so inmates can inject narcotics in prison. That is despite guards battling a drug crisis as more than a third of inmates have admitted taking illegal substances in prison, with more than a quarter saying their drug use only started - or increased - while in custody. The Forum's plan came after Health Secretary Neil Gray last week said a heroin shooting gallery in Glasgow may be extended to allow addicts to inhale crack cocaine. Commenting further on the ambulance call-outs last night, Tory MSP Mr Kerr said: 'Nationalist ministers, detached from reality in their Holyrood bubble, have allowed this situation to spiral out of control. 'There are solutions to this problem if the Scottish Government would only put in the time, effort and resource to examine and implement them.' An SPS spokesman said: 'The health and wellbeing of those in our care is a key priority. 'We work with NHS partners, who are responsible for healthcare in our establishments, to ensure emergency calls to the SAS are only made when necessary and appropriate. 'Our staff work hard, alongside partners, including Police Scotland, to prevent illicit substances entering our establishments, to protect people from the harm they cause.' A Scottish Government spokesman said: 'The SPS are managing a high and complex prison population and work closely with Police Scotland and other justice partners to prevent the availability and supply of illicit substances. 'This includes SPS piloting the introduction of grilles on windows in HMP Perth, HMP Edinburgh, and HMP Glenochil to prevent items being passed from drone to an individual in a cell. 'If successful, this pilot will be expanded where appropriate. 'The NHS, which is responsible for healthcare in prisons, works closely with the SPS to ensure emergency calls to the Scottish Ambulance Service are only made when necessary and appropriate. 'We are also increasing investment in our vital prison service by increasing the SPS resource budget by 10 per cent to £481.5million in 2025/26, which helps promote the health, safety, and wellbeing of all people who live in Scotland's prison system.'
The Sun
13 hours ago
- The Sun
‘Contaminated' supermarket item is linked to mystery hepatitis outbreak that left 95 Brits ill and 58 hospitalised
OFFICIALS are investigating a mysterious surge in hepatitis A cases believed to be linked to a supermarket item. A total of 95 people have been left ill from the outbreak with a further 58 falling so ill they needed to be hospitalised. 3 3 The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) has confirmed two separate clusters of the virus have been identified. Officials have received reports of 54 cases since December 2024 and are now investigating the cause of the outbreak. Patient interviews have indicated that the outbreak comes from a specific food item purchased from an unnamed supermarket. A UKHSA report reads: "A particular food item purchased from a particular supermarket has emerged as a possible vehicle of transmission due to its frequent reported consumption." The product has not been named despite officials identifying it as a "possible vehicle of transmission." The first identified cluster saw 19 people hospitalised with the infection that affects the liver. Most of the patients in the first cluster to be identified were between the ages of 50 and 69. The second cluster saw a further 39 people requiring hospitalisation after catching the virus. Cases related to the first cluster were identified between January 2021 and March 2025. The latest wave of infections began in January 2023 with cases still being reported in March this year. No deaths linked to the outbreak have been reported as of yet. Public Health Scotland are leading the investigation alongside the UKHSA. Hepatitis A begins with mild symptoms but can quickly develop into a more serious illness. It causes weakness and fatigue, a loss of appetite, nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea, fever jaundice and abdominal pain. If left untreated the infection can lead to liver failure and can even be fatal. 3 Unlike hepatitis B and C, hepatitis A isn't known to cause chronic liver disease. Symptoms tend to develop within two months of infection but can go undetected for longer. The NHS warns that children and some adults may have no symptoms. In less extreme cases the virus usually clears up on its own within six months but doctors can prescribe medication to alleviate symptoms. The UKHSA is continuing to investigate the recent outbreaks with an unnamed food item from an unnamed supermarket identified as a possible cause. UKHSA officials have not stated the name of supermarket, or the food item. The UKHSA report reads: "Given the reported lack of international travel in most cases, and implicated food items, further investigations into the possible sources of these clusters are in progress to inform control measures." The UKHSA has been contacted for comment. The symptoms of hepatitis A you need to be aware of Symptoms of Hepatitis A can include jaundice, a yellowing of the skin and whites of the eyes, dark-coloured urine and itchy skin. This is because when your liver isn't working properly, it stops being able to get rid of bilirubin, a substance that causes jaundice. There may be earlier flu-like symptoms including mild fever, joint and muscle pain, feeling and being sick, diarrhoea and stomach pain. Losing your appetite, feeling or being sick and pain in the upper right part of your tummy could also be a sign of the condition. Not everyone infected will have all these symptoms. Anyone with suspected hepatitis A infection should contact their GP and remain at home, until their GP advises their return to school or the workplace. It is an unpleasant illness but is not usually serious and most people make a full recovery in two months. However, it can last several months and also be deadly if it causes liver failure — when the organ stops working properly. More information on hepatitis A can be found on the NHS website.
The Independent
16 hours ago
- The Independent
Retired banker reaches Scotland after running 50 marathons along the coast
A retired banker who is striving to become the first man over the age of 60 to run the entire coastline of mainland Britain has reached Scotland as he completes his 50th consecutive day of running. Reaching the border marks the quarter-point of his goal to run 200 marathons in 200 days, while researchers at the University of Exeter monitor the impact on his body. Steve James, 65, set off from Topsham, Devon on April 16 and will end his feat there after running anticlockwise around the coast for seven months. He currently runs for around six hours each day, occasionally staying with his wife in their camper van or in a variety of accommodations. Mr James, who lives and trains on Dartmoor, is being supported during his challenge by his wife and their five children. 'I'm so proud to have made it to over 50 days. I've made it all the way from Exeter along the coast to the Scottish border, a total of 1,380 miles,' he said. 'There have been a few bumps along the way, but I've overcome them all and am that much stronger because of it and ready to take on the next stage. 'I'm really looking forward to the many facets of the Scottish coastline and meeting the people of this beautiful country.' Mr James has already faced his share of hardships on his journey, running through harsh weather conditions, closed footpaths, severely blistered feet and a gout flareup resulting in a trip to A&E. The Exeter research team assessed him before his departure and continues to monitor him throughout this challenge, while he captures his own measurements daily for them to analyse. They are studying his calorie intake, blood, oxygen and muscle measurements to examine the effect of such an extreme sport on the body. Mr James said: 'By the end of this challenge, the scientists will have more insight into how far a 65-year-old person can push their body. 'Of all the challenges I've done, this is the most extreme and the biggest stretch.' At this stage, the team has seen no adverse effects of this high-endurance challenge in the blood samples, which are being used to measure hormone fluctuations, inflammation and overall health. He has lost weight, although this was a likely result that researchers anticipated due to his extreme calorie output. Dr Freyja Haigh, nutritional physiology researcher at the University of Exeter, said: 'We're currently tracking Steve's energy intake and expenditure in order to assess any changes in body mass, which is to be expected with this very physical challenge. 'We're unsure at the moment if Steve's weight loss is from fat or muscle mass. 'I'm hoping to visit him in the near future to take muscle thickness measurements at multiple points on the body to compare with those we took before he left. 'Having reached this point would be an incredible achievement for anyone, but doing it in your 60s is a whole different ballgame. 'What Steve is doing really challenges the stereotypes of ageing and redefines what's possible later in life. 'It's also fascinating in terms of the science – Steve gives us a real insight into how this type of endurance affects the body of an older person. 'It's been such a privilege to work with him so far and I can't wait to see how he gets on in this next stage.' Throughout his life, Mr James has loved physical challenges, from taking part in Ten Tors while at school to cycling around the world in 220 days in 2019. The record for running the British coastline is held by Nick Butter, who completed the feat in 128 days at the age of 31. But Mr James is the first person over 60 to take on the feat.
