To judge is human. To persuade is AI?

Boston Globe

2 days ago

Get The Gavel
A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr.
Enter Email
Sign Up
The study's finding is consistent with
Advertisement
AI tailors its arguments differently when it knows something about a user than when it does not. With background info, AI can identify common ground before making its case. If AI knows, for example, that it's dealing with someone with a liberal political affiliation, it will use arguments popular among liberals, such as the importance of immigrants to the national culture and economy. If a user leans conservative, the AI highlights ideals such as lack of government intervention or regulation. That means an AI with even fairly basic information about users can make them more receptive by tapping into their confirmation bias — in other words, by affirming their existing beliefs.
Advertisement
This might seem manipulative, but the AI is assessing the rhetorical situation, which involves figuring out what will and won't appeal to a specific audience and adjusting arguments accordingly. I teach this concept to my rhetoric students at Boston University. When presented with evidence that runs counter to their views, many people cling even more firmly to their positions — a phenomenon known as the '
Of course, humans should be better than AI is at understanding and bonding with fellow humans. Why aren't we? For one, our ability to 'read the room'
AI doesn't shout, curse, judge, threaten, or doxx users. That's one reason AI can more easily change someone's mind: Freedom from judgment and retaliation liberates the mind enough to allow people to consider other viewpoints.
AI also deploys an age-old human bonding technique: mirroring. Experiments have demonstrated that if an interactive robot smiles at you, you'll probably smile back, and vice versa. We all do this beginning in infancy as a way of expressing and emulating other people's behavior and emotional states. If an AI discerns that you're smiling, it might tell you a joke so it can capitalize on and match your positive mood. Mirroring can also involve language choice and tone, which is another reason AI excels at it. Establishing even a fleeting bond via mirroring makes humans more likely to cooperate with an AI or robot.
Advertisement
Perhaps AI succeeds in part because humans so often fail at effective communication. The bar has become frighteningly low for interactions, both online and off. If displaying a modicum of respect and not spewing vitriol gives AI a communication advantage, that's on us. If a noncorporeal, nonhuman entity can read the room and connect with people better than most humans can, something is seriously off.
Research into AI reveals what's too often missing in human interactions: common ground, curiosity, and compassion. Perhaps two of the ways AI will serve us best are by reflecting the failures of human societies in its black mirror and reminding us that we can do better. In turn, that perspective can help us choose what or who we want to become — and how.