Crisis for at-risk children worse now than it was when Daniel McAnaspie was murdered in 2010, inquest hears
The crisis in secure care for the most at-risk children has intensified since the murder of teenager Daniel McAnaspie, social workers involved in his care say.
An inquest into the boy's death returned a verdict of unlawful killing on Thursday.
It also heard that the needs of at-risk children are becoming more complex.
High Court
judge John Jordan recently described such children as 'frequently broken, traumatised, actively suicidal'.
Just 14 of 26 secure-care beds are operational due to 'staff shortages', Meath Coroner's Court heard on Thursday.
READ MORE
A young person who is deemed to be at such risk to themselves, or others, as to need therapeutic residential care may be detained in secure care by order of the High Court.
Daniel McAnaspie was 17 when he was murdered on February 26th, 2010. He had been known to care services since birth.
The inquest heard that in the last 15 months of his life, Daniel had 20 care placements, including one he could not access until after midnight.
His badly decomposed remains were found in a drainage ditch in Co Meath by a farmer in May 2010. In 2017, two men were convicted in connection with his death, one of murder and the other of manslaughter.
There are currently four young people who are the subject of a High Court Order and are awaiting a placement in special care
—
Tusla
Daniel's inquest heard he pleaded with social workers to 'lock him up' because he was terrified of drug dealers to whom he owed €2,000. Social workers made multiple applications to the HSE's special care committee for secure care as his life spiralled into chaos. Their applications were refused.
Tusla
said on Thursday: 'There are currently four young people who are the subject of a High Court Order and are awaiting a placement in special care. For these young people, we are currently unable to fully meet our statutory obligations regarding special care.
'We share the concern this causes for the High Court, for professionals involved in the care of these young people and most importantly, for the young people themselves and their families.'
Mark Smith, Tusla's director of special care services, worked with Daniel in a high-support unit around 2006. He told the inquest he expected one secure-care bed to become free before the weekend.
'I would love to see a situation where we would have all 26 beds [fully staffed],' said Mr Smith.
Asked whether improved pay in secure-care work would help, he said: 'The pay is always a challenge... If the pay was significantly better I am sure we would have better retention rates.'
He said children were presenting who are in need of detention for their own safety. These cases are 'increasingly complex', said Mr Smith, pointing to the need for 'greater resources' and 'a greater level of care'.
Pól Ó Murchu, solicitor for Daniel's guardian ad litem, said: 'The evidence is that this situation at the moment is worse than what it was at the time of Daniel's death'.
My brother would be still alive today if they had done their job right
—
Cathriona McAnaspie
Avril Connolly, Daniel's social worker at the time of his death, told the inquest her work with him involved 'considerable firefighting and emergency responding to crisis events'.
No longer working in the same area of child protection, she told the inquest: 'I thank God that I don't have to work with children that require secure care currently'.
The six-person jury made 13 recommendations aimed at improving outcomes for the most at-risk children in care, including that the State carries out 'a review of its funding to child protection and welfare services delivered by Tusla to ensure that the agency has sufficient resourcing to keep children safe'.
Cathriona McAnaspie, Daniel's older sister, said the family thought of him every day.
She said: 'He was loving. He was our brother, nephew. He was one of our babies. The HSE has a lot to answer. My brother would be still alive today if they had done their job right. So yes, I am very angry with them and I hope no family will ever, ever have to go through this again, ever.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
28 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Boy (12) who fell from Cliffs of Moher had ‘instantaneous' death, says coroner
A 12-year old boy lost his balance after slipping in a puddle close to the edge of the Cliffs of Moher before falling over the edge to his death, his inquest has heard. In eye-witness testimony at the Clare coroner's court, reviewing the accidental death of Zhihan Zhao at the Cliffs of Moher last July, French tourist Marion Tourgon described seeing him fall over the edge at about 1.45pm on the day. Zhihan had set out on walking the Cliffs of Moher trail with his mother, Xianhong Huang, and her friends. In her evidence, a tearful Ms Huang said Zhihan was walking ahead of her on the trail when she lost sight of him. READ MORE Ms Tourgon told the inquest she and her family were taking a selfie when she saw a young Asian boy, who was alone, come into view. She said she saw his right foot slip into a puddle and his left foot ended up in the air as he tried to stop himself from falling. 'It was very quick. He found himself in an awkward position with his left foot in a void over the cliff and his right knee on the edge of the cliff.' 'His right knee eventually fell into the void over the cliff and he was trying to grasp the grass with his hands to pull himself up. He didn't shout and there was no noise.' She said her family alerted the emergency services by phone. Speaking through an interpreter Ms Huang said her son walked 'very fast and was ahead of us by 50 metres'. 'As there was only one path I thought we would meet him along the way. When I didn't I walked to the visitor centre and I checked the visitor centre.' When she couldn't find her son there, she walked back along the path to search for him and then reported him missing. Ms Huang asked: 'What exactly caused Zhihan to fall from the Cliffs?' Clare coroner Isobel O'Dea said Ms Tourgon's evidence would help answer that question. Sgt Claire McGuigan said Ms Huang provided a photo of Zhihan she had taken taken earlier on the Cliffs of Moher trail. Garda Colm Collins said the Coastguard later spotted a body at the base of the cliffs. A lifeboat was launched but it could not access the area due to the sea conditions. Zhihan's body was recovered from the sea five days later after it was spotted by fisherman, Matthew O'Halloran from Corofin, Co Clare. The coroner said the post mortem found Zhihan died from multiple traumatic injuries consistent with a fall from a height. Ms O'Dea said her verdict was one of 'accidental death'. 'It is clear from evidence we heard that Zhihan slipped off the cliffs rather than any other way. His death would have been very quick - instantaneous.' Ms O'Dea told Ms Huang: 'I can't imagine how upsetting this is for you'. On August 22nd of last year, the Clare Local Development Company, which manages the trail, closed off large sections of the route, which remain closed off today due to continuing safety concerns. At the time, the company confirmed it was taking the action following two recent fatal accidents on the trail. In May 2024, a woman in her 20s from Belgium died after she fell from the cliffs.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Overcrowded jails spark ‘grave concerns' about safety of staff and inmates
The head of the Irish prison system warned the Department of Justice she had 'grave concerns' about the safety of staff and inmates because of dire overcrowding in jails. A letter sent by Irish Prison Service director general Caron McCaffrey in 2024 said the Minister needed to think carefully about the appointment of 20 new judges, which would lead to a further influx of prisoners the service could not cope with. 'Undoubtedly a large element of the current overcrowding crisis is directly related to the appointment of additional judges,' the letter read. '[This led to] the scheduling of over 600 extra court sittings this year, decisions taken when our prisons were already over capacity and not in a position to absorb the inevitable increase in committals safely.' READ MORE The correspondence was sent on a day in May last year when there were 4,960 people in the custody of the Irish Prison Service (IPS). That number has since risen as high as 5,400. Ms McCaffrey's letter has been released following an appeal to the Information Commissioner under Freedom of Information laws. She wrote: 'In the absence of an urgent decision [on temporary release measures], I need to advise you that I now have grave concerns in relation to the ability of this service to ensure the safety of both those who work and live in our prisons.' Ms McCaffrey said with nearly 5,000 people in custody, prisons were already operating with 'dangerous levels of overcrowding'. She said there had been a sharp increase in temporary release to relieve pressure but all of the main prisons were well above operational capacity. [ Provision of almost 1,000 extra prison places to be fast-tracked Opens in new window ] Ms McCaffrey also told the department that the Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) was due to visit in the coming weeks, writing : '[They] will be scathing in their criticism of the conditions we are being forced to hold people in with over 200 people sleeping on mattresses on the floor this morning.' Ms McCaffrey said she wanted an urgent decision on new rules around who could and could not be given temporary release. She also asked for a commitment that no new measures would be introduced that would add to the burden, particularly then minister for justice Helen McEntee's wish to appoint 20 new judges 'with haste'. An earlier letter from Ms McCaffrey from February 2024 to the department said the prison system was now in an 'untenable, unacceptable and potentially unsafe situation' due to overcrowding. She said there was a real risk the IPS would not be able to produce all prisoners for court hearings, saying it was 'at a tipping point' in terms of its ability to fulfil that service. : She said every possible measure had been used to ease overcrowding including the recommissioning of small areas of prisons to provide extra beds, provision of bunk beds, and reopening of the Training Unit at Mountjoy in Dublin. 'Despite these efforts, numbers continue to grow to record levels,' she said.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda reviews open into Satchwell, Gaine murder inquiries and searches that missed victims' bodies
Gardaí are reviewing the criminal investigations into the murders of Tina Satchwell and Michael Gaine , whose bodies were not found during initial searches but were later discovered in the location they had vanished from. Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said a report would be compiled for Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan on the Satchwell case and that the Gaine case was undergoing a 'peer review'. Richard Satchwell (58) was on Wednesday jailed for life for the 2017 murder of his wife, Tina. Her skeletal remains were found in a deep grave under the stairs of the couple's Co Cork home in October 2023, more than six years after her husband reported her missing. Last month, in a separate case, the remains of Kerry farmer Mike Gaine (56) were discovered in a slurry tank on his farmyard just outside Kenmare, two months after he vanished from the farmyard. His remains were initially found after slurry was taken from the tank for spreading on nearby fields. READ MORE In the Gaine case, the farmyard was searched in late March as part of the first phase of investigation, after Mr Gaine was reported missing. In the case of Ms Satchwell, gardaí visited her home and searched it in 2017, though they did not seek to intrusively examine an area where construction work had just been carried out. 'We are subjecting the Michael Gaine investigation to a peer review because I think there's learning for us around those who commit crime and then attempt to dispose of the body, and often are successful in disposing of the body,' Mr Harris said, speaking to the media at the Garda College, Templemore, Co Tipperary, on Friday. Asked if a cadaver dog should have been brought into the Satchwell home in Cork in 2017, especially as there were clear signs significant construction work had just been carried out that should also have aroused suspicion, Mr Harris said: 'it's very early for me to make a judgment on that'. 'We want to review that ourselves. We have the expertise within the organisation and obviously then we'll report on that to the Minister and the Policing and Community Safety Authority. 'But I think there's definitely lessons we wish to learn from all these homicides; where it's a missing persons (investigation) and then it converts in time to a homicide investigation. We've seen a real pattern around that in recent years.' When a person vanishes, and a missing persons investigation begins, it is 'important we have an investigative mindset around a crime also being committed', he said. This week, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said it took gardaí 'longer than maybe ordinarily' to conclude the Satchwell case, and he believed the inquiry, which missed the victim's remains for so long, should be evaluated internally. Mr Harris pointed out that although the investigation into the Tina Satchwell disappearance in 2017 did not discover her remains, it yielded a significant amount of information. That evidence was then used for a subsequent review of the case, which resulted in her remains being found and the murder conviction being secured. Mr Harris also pointed out when the initial search was carried out at the Satchwell home in 2017, a forensic analyst accompanied gardaí. They were looking for 'blood spatter' – which would have revealed the murder at the house – but none was found. Ms Satchwell had also been 'isolated' and 'coercively controlled' by her husband for many years. That meant there were very few people in the community who knew her very well and from whom gardaí would ordinarily get valuable information in such cases. Also speaking to the media in Templemore, where 120 new gardaí graduated on Friday, Mr O'Callaghan said he was very pleased the Satchwell case had concluded with the victim's remains being found and a murder conviction secured. However, it would always be 'preferable if murders were solved sooner than was the case' with the Satchwell murder, he said. While the first Garda inquiry had yielded a lot of evidence, the second investigation uncovered 'more beneficial' evidence, resulting in the remains being found and the charges being brought, he said. It was a fact of policing that 'not all murders get solved immediately' and some remained unsolved. 'There would be questions' about the case, and the Garda's investigation of it if justice had not been served with the conviction and imprisonment for life of Richard Satchwell,' the Minister said.
