logo
'Right To Be Left Alone': Delhi Court Upholds Wife's Privacy After Major's Plea For Hotel CCTV

'Right To Be Left Alone': Delhi Court Upholds Wife's Privacy After Major's Plea For Hotel CCTV

News1824-05-2025

Last Updated:
A Delhi court rejected an Army Major's plea for hotel CCTV footage to prove his wife's alleged affair, citing the right to privacy.
A Delhi court on Friday rejected a plea by a man and upheld the right to privacy of his wife, whom he alleged was having an affair with a man.
The man identified himself as Major in the Indian Army and sought the CCTV footage of a hotel, where he alleged his wife was with another man, also a Major.
'The right to privacy and to be left alone in a hotel would extend to the common areas as against a third party who was not present there and has no other legally justifiable entitlement to seek the data of the guest. The same would hold good for the booking details," civil judge Vaibhav Pratap Singh of Patiala House Court observed, as he upheld the right to privacy of the wife and her alleged lover.
He added that the concept of 'stealing' the affection of a wife by another man, as if a woman is not in control of whom she loves, is 'dated" and has been rightly rejected by the Supreme Court Joseph Shine v. Union of India.
'The dated idea of a man stealing away the wife of another man, without ascribing any role or responsibility to the woman, is to be rejected. It takes agency away from women and dehumanises them," the judge said.
The court also cited the novel 'The End of the Affair' by Graham Greene, and said that even the Indian Parliament has given its imprimatur to the said jurisprudence when, while doing away with the colonial penal law, it enacted the The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and did not retain therein the offence of adultery, showing that the 'modern day Bharat has no place for gender- condescension and patriarchal notions."
As the major alleged his wife, with whom he was involved in a marital dispute and divorce, visited the hotel with her alleged paramour, the judge observed that hotels generally owe a duty of confidentiality to their guests and are required to protect the privacy of their records, including booking details and CCTV footage.
The court also said that the wife and her alleged paramour were central to the husband's claims, but they were not impleaded in the suit, which raised significant questions about their right to be heard before any disclosure was made.
Further, the judge said that courts are not meant to serve as investigative bodies for private disputes or as instruments for the collection of evidence in internal proceedings, especially when no clear legal entitlement to that evidence exists.
First Published:
May 24, 2025, 11:12 IST

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Chandigarh Rapido Driver Scammed Out Of Rs 4,000 By Passenger: "My Earnings Vanished..."
Chandigarh Rapido Driver Scammed Out Of Rs 4,000 By Passenger: "My Earnings Vanished..."

NDTV

timean hour ago

  • NDTV

Chandigarh Rapido Driver Scammed Out Of Rs 4,000 By Passenger: "My Earnings Vanished..."

A Rapido driver from Chandigarh recently shared a post on Reddit about falling victim to a digital scam and losing Rs 4,000. In the post, the driver explained that he had accepted a ride request near Command Hospital and was asked to make a detour to drop off the passenger's wife at the railway station. The situation seemed slightly unusual, but didn't raise immediate red flags. However, it eventually turned out to be a clever ruse. "I got a ride in morning near CH((Army hospital) As I was close I accepted it. The passenger called me saying that his wife is inside hospital and needs to be dropped at Railway station. And he is paying 4200 and I can take my amount and repay at her id as it was not getting done from his account," the Rapido driver wrote. The passenger claimed to have paid Rs 4,200 for the ride but asked the driver to transfer the amount to another account, citing issues with his UPI. The driver verified a Rs 4,000 credit in his account and, trusting the passenger, transferred the money to the QR code provided via WhatsApp. "Then he said he sent 4000 and I check ky account there was 4000 received but I didn't check date of receipt. He said his wife is inside and I should send money on QR which he sent on WhatsApp and I did. As I saw 4009 received I wasn't worried but he said he is sending more money to transfer where I got doubt and disconnected," the driver added. See the post here: by u/Jasszzi in Chandigarh The driver later realised the Rs 4,000 credit in his account was actually from a friend, sent the previous day. The scammer had cleverly exploited the timing, and by the time the driver grew suspicious, the damage was done. The scammer's attempt to send another fake transaction alerted the driver, who disconnected the call, but he had already lost his earnings from several days. "I was happy that I escaped untill I saw date of receipt of 4000. It was Friend who sent me 4000 yesterday. I was scammed, being understanding everything and being smart and educated. My earnings of 4-5 days vanished in a minute bcz of lil ignornace. Where can I report this or is there any chance to get money back?" he said, concluding the post. The incident resonated with many Reddit users, who shared similar experiences. Many urged the driver to file an online complaint on the cybercrime portal and share the FIR with the bank to facilitate a chargeback. One user wrote, "The same happened with a rapido driver, I know. The exact hospital and the exact story. He did go to the police station, and the number was found to be from Rajasthan, iirc. But nothing much happened."

Cybercrime: Nawada gang tricks youth with bizarre job offers
Cybercrime: Nawada gang tricks youth with bizarre job offers

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Cybercrime: Nawada gang tricks youth with bizarre job offers

Patna: Nawada is fast emerging as a breeding ground for cybercrime. In a sensational case that has left police stunned, a cyberfraud racket with an unusually provocative front—offering money to men for impregnating women—has been busted in the district's Kunj village. The racket was masterminded by Rajesh Kumar (26), son of a retired Army personnel. A resident of the nondescript Kunj village under the Roh police station area, Rajesh exploited the notion that "sex sells" by launching a fake job agency with a bizarre name: 'All India Pregnant Job Company'. The "company" lured men with promises of payments up to Rs 5 lakh for helping women conceive. However, this was just a front for an elaborate cyberscam targeting youth, unemployed people, and women across the country. People were duped into paying hefty registration fees and additional charges, believing they were enrolling for well-paying jobs. The gang siphoned off lakhs of rupees from unsuspecting applicants through various digital transactions and manipulative schemes. According to police, Rajesh's arrest came after the ministry of home affairs (MHA) shared mobile data analysis with the state authorities. Acting on the lead, a Special Investigation Team (SIT), led by Cyber DSP Priya Jyoti, on Sunday conducted a raid at Kunj village, which led to the arrest of Rajesh and three others, including three minors, one of whom was just 17 years old. An FIR was registered under multiple sections of the BNS and IT Act. The police recovered five cellphones and a keypad phone, along with fake job cards, photographs of women, and other incriminating documents. Further investigation revealed that the gang employed highly professional techniques to build credibility, including well-designed online ads, fake training videos featuring young women endorsing the scheme, social media campaigns and newspaper advertisements, promises of free cellphones and laptops, fake job offers with reputed 5G telecom companies, claiming work-from-home roles with monthly salaries between Rs 22,500 and Rs 75,500 This is the third major cyberfraud busted in Nawada in the past two years. In Jan 2025, a similar racket operated under the same 'Pregnant Job' and 'Playboy Service' banners was uncovered. And in Dec 2023, police had busted another cybercrime gang at Gurma village under the Mufassil police station area, where 11 people were arrested. Those arrested included people with modest backgrounds—a truck driver, a street food vendor. Speaking about the Sunday's arrest, superintendent of police (SP) Abhinav Dhiman said, "The gang specifically targeted vulnerable sections of society, including students, jobseekers, and women. Their scams were designed to lure people with greed."

Supreme Court grants interim protection from arrest to MP Journalist alleging police assault
Supreme Court grants interim protection from arrest to MP Journalist alleging police assault

New Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • New Indian Express

Supreme Court grants interim protection from arrest to MP Journalist alleging police assault

The Supreme Court on Monday directed two Madhya Pradesh-based journalists, who have accused the Bhind superintendent of police and other officers of custodial assault and harassment, to approach the Madhya Pradesh High Court for relief. The court granted them interim protection from arrest for two weeks to allow time to file their plea. A bench comprising Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Manmohan told the petitioners—Shashikant Jatav and Amarkant Singh Chouhan—that it was not inclined to entertain their plea under Article 32 of the Constitution. However, noting the gravity of the allegations, the bench permitted them to seek remedy before the High Court. 'We are not entertaining the plea. However, looking at the allegations, we permit the petitioners to move the concerned high court within two weeks from today. Till the time the petitioners move high court …the petitioners shall not be arrested,' Justice Mishra said. The journalists have alleged that they were targeted by police due to their reporting on alleged corruption related to sand mining. In their plea, they sought protection from coercive action by the MP Police and claimed they feared for their lives. The petition also accused a senior police officer and his subordinates of kidnapping, custodial assault, and using casteist slurs against them. The bench previously questioned why the Bhind superintendent of police had not been made a party to the petition. "It is very easy to say all kinds of things against an IPS officer without making him a party. Whatever comes to your mind, just put it in black and white against the IPS officer," the bench remarked. The court also asked why the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and the National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi were named as respondents. The counsel for the journalists said the NHRC had been included because a complaint had been filed there, but agreed to remove it from the petition. On the inclusion of NCT of Delhi, it was submitted that both petitioners are currently residing in the national capital. Meanwhile, on May 28, the Delhi High Court had granted Chouhan interim protection for two months after he claimed that the Bhind SP had threatened him following an alleged assault in his office. The Supreme Court has listed the matter for further hearing on June 9.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store