
Why Rick Tocchet left the Canucks and what it means for their offseason
Rick Tocchet and Vancouver Canucks hockey operations leadership spent last weekend in meetings, discussing the difficult year they'd just endured, the future of the organization and their plans for a high stakes, all-in summer.
Less than a week later, Tocchet and his agent informed Canucks president of hockey operations Jim Rutherford that he'd decided not to return to Vancouver as head coach.
As the Tocchet saga reached its conclusion this week, it really wasn't a back-and-forth negotiation. There was nothing adversarial or acrimonious about it.
The Canucks 'stepped up' financially, according to two league sources, and offered Tocchet a contract that would have made him one of the highest-paid coaches in the NHL. Keeping Tocchet was the club's first choice, a fact that Rutherford wasn't going to shy away from Tuesday simply because the outcome was a disappointing one from the team's perspective.
Advertisement
As Tocchet wrestled with his decision over the past week, which was an arduous process for him, it wasn't about money or term or a counteroffer being met (or not). It wasn't about the relationships with ownership or management. It wasn't about the city, or the Vancouver media, or the sometimes overwhelming attention about town.
No, for Tocchet, this seems to have been a highly personal decision. One that he didn't make lightly.
It's a decision made at a fork in the road of an NHL head coaching career during which Tocchet has had to contend with significant organizational dysfunction at every turn.
Tocchet's first shot at being an NHL head coach came with the pre-Jeff Vinik Tampa Bay Lightning, and he was tasked with picking up the pieces of the disastrous 16-game Barry Melrose era.
Then, after years as a successful assistant coach with the Pittsburgh Penguins, Tocchet resurfaced with the cap-laundromat version of the Arizona Coyotes.
Finally, with the Canucks, Tocchet had appeared to land somewhere relatively stable, working with people he trusted and for a franchise that — after he helped author the most incredible single-season defensive turnaround in recent NHL history — seemed on the verge of breaking through as a consistent playoff team and fringe contender.
That was before this season, though.
That was before Elias Pettersson's form dipped to an excruciatingly low level. Before Thatcher Demko missed extended stretches of games with three separate injuries, including an unprecedented knee tear. Before the rift between J.T. Miller and Pettersson tore the Canucks locker room apart and scuttled a season that opened with such incredible promise.
That was before Quinn Hughes' future, clouded by his status as an extension eligible player in the summer of 2026, became the lens through which every piece of Canucks news was filtered.
Advertisement
After a trying campaign for the Canucks, a season that was more difficult for the people involved to live through than anyone on the outside can gather, there are dark clouds gathering unmistakably on the horizon.
There are massive, difficult questions shrouding all of Vancouver's top players. There are real questions about the makeup and maturity level of this team, too, outside of Hughes and a handful of other reliable veterans.
The Canucks are the only team in the NHL without a practice facility, something that genuinely matters, especially for a coach like Tocchet who focuses a lot of his and his staff's time, effort and thought to hands-on on-ice teaching.
All of that factored into Tocchet's decision.
If it wasn't about the money and it wasn't about the relationships — and it wasn't — then it's fundamentally difficult to process Tocchet's departure as anything but a complicated personal decision that leaves us fairly questioning whether he believed that there was a path to winning in Vancouver. Or not.
The implications of that, of course, are heavy for Canucks fans to consider.
That sense of an organization that, after one magical season of apparent progress, appears to be headed swiftly in a concerning, confidence-sapping direction. The Hughes dynamic raises those stakes further, stoking fears of a club that never really emerged from the unintentional Jim Benning era rebuild and could already be headed inexorably back into the relative irrelevance that the Canucks have largely toiled under for the past decade and a half.
This is the environment, and the level of fan-driven anxiety, that Rutherford attempted to settle by explaining the situation on Tuesday. Over the course of a typically honest 30-minute media availability, Rutherford admitted that Hughes had yet to call him back when he tried to reach him to inform him of the news about Tocchet's departure.
Advertisement
The veteran executive was also asked about his Canucks future.
'I don't think about it a lot, so I'm not thinking about leaving town,' Rutherford said, after a pregnant pause. 'I'm still here for the same reasons, and I don't feel comfortable with the job that I've done. We were on the right track a year ago, we got off that track. I take a lot of responsibility for it. It's my job. I have the hockey department. We have a lot of work to do to get back on track and at this point in time that's my focus, to see if we can do it.'
If getting this all back on track seems like an impossible task at this point, especially in the absence of Tocchet, the Canucks' handpicked, culture-changing head coach, it's at least worth bearing in mind that this isn't the first time that this Rutherford-led management group has seemed to have its backs to the wall, tasked with microwaving a contender against all odds.
You'll recall that the sky was falling in Vancouver too after l'affaire Bruce Boudreau in 2023, with the club having made a series of widely panned trades, including dealing captain Bo Horvat, and having fired its head coach in absurd, unbecoming circumstances.
The next year, the Canucks made it work. There was some luck involved, absolutely, but there were also some sharp, disciplined bets placed on bargain-bin free agents. Some dexterous work on the trade market to reallocate money and talent from the wings into center and defense.
And, of course, in landing Tocchet as Boudreau's replacement, they indisputably nailed the head coaching hire.
Obviously, it's difficult to repeat an improbable trick shot, and this isn't where the Canucks would want to be positioned to begin this critical offseason. However, that seems to be where they've landed. It's on Rutherford and his management group to do it again, whether that's a fair ask or not.
Advertisement
This is really the thing to bear in mind here, more than anything. The crisis of confidence in the Vancouver market emanating from Tuesday's news of Tocchet's departure is, in some ways, indicative of a fan base that's beginning to see the bottom of a deep, dark well.
That deep, dark well, however, has been visible for the entirety of this decade to anyone paying attention. An organization that's been left behind in several crucial respects by its competitors, who have generally been far more willing to invest in facility upgrades, tanking seasons and the lost revenue and hope in stretch run games that are an inevitable byproduct of executing seller trades at the deadline than Vancouver has been.
There's a cost to that, one that informs the club's positioning, and indirectly, some of the factors that shaped Tocchet's departure.
There's a distinction between grappling with reality, however, and indulging unduly in cynicism. And underneath the churn of dysfunction and disappointment that has characterized the Canucks experience for the past 12 months, it's worth recalling, after all, that this is still a hockey club with a vibrant, locked-in fan base that only missed the Stanley Cup playoffs by seven points — despite its star center struggling, and a significant late-season injury to one of the league's most impactful superstar players.
This is a team that has quality goaltending and legitimate blue-line depth. There are emergency-level holes up front, without question, but the Canucks have both the assets and meaningful cap flexibility to take a credible shot at addressing it.
Vancouver has also still got a management team that's proven itself at being adept at acquiring players on the trade market, and has proven itself efficient at identifying undervalued contributors.
Ironically, too, for the first offseason in well over a decade, the organization's actual self-interest and penchant for reckless, all-in swings in pursuit of immediate gratification are actually aligned.
Advertisement
There's no sense, after all, in rebuilding or charting a new direction now.
If you believe the Canucks can convince Hughes to stay provided that they prove that there's a path to contention, then the club has to get back to the business of winning games in the playoffs. That necessitates major short-term improvement, a transformative, aggressive offseason in which future assets — like Vancouver's 2025 first-round pick — should absolutely be on the table in trade talks for win-now help.
If you're more dubious about their chances of getting Hughes' autograph on an extension next summer, then next season should be viewed as the organization's last kick at the can with the best defender in franchise history. Go all in, because there's no sense in ripping the band-aid off now. Hughes isn't extension eligible until next summer anyway, and his value will be maximized when you're able to trade him in a Mikko Rantanen-style deal where an eight-year mega extension is baked into the return.
Of course, in either scenario, you'd feel more comfortable with a coach of Tocchet's quality at the helm. The Canucks will miss the thoughtfulness and tactical ingenuity that Tocchet brought to the job. He established a holistic way to play and win. He unquestionably elevated this team during his two-and-a-half-year stint in Vancouver.
That Tocchet will immediately be considered among the top head coaching candidates on the market is a testament to the work he did in Vancouver, and the magnitude of the Canucks' loss.
For the Canucks, however, and for their fans, there's no time to be sullen about Tocchet's decision. No point in being fatalistic about what it means for the franchise. Or what it portends.
There's a new head coach to hire, a top-six center to land and a lot of scoring skill to graft onto this roster.
For the Canucks, this remains an all-in summer. Perhaps the most critical offseason in recent franchise history.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Forsyth County leaders approve $225 million development in hopes of attracting the NHL
Forsyth County leaders voted unanimously to approve a major development, all in hopes of bringing a pro hockey team to north Georgia. This was the final vote on the $225 million project and a critical step in efforts to attract a hockey team. [DOWNLOAD: Free WSB-TV News app for alerts as news breaks] Developer Vernon Krouse was at the meeting that included the Forsyth County Board of Commissioners, the Forsyth County Board of Education and the Development Authority. Members of all three boards met, and all voted unanimously to approve the final, official documents for the project. It's a milestone. 'Without this vote, we could not go to the NHL. This was a prerequisite,' Krouse told Channel 2's Bryan Mims. TRENDING STORIES: Officer hit by car in Carrollton while directing traffic 'Senseless': Brothers, ages 13 and 14, accused of Clayton party shooting, posting it to social media Sheriffs' Assoc. sues Judge Hatchett after sheriff's guilty plea for groping her It was April 2023 when Krause publicly announced his plans to build a mixed-use development centered around an 18,000-seat hockey arena in Forsyth County. It's named 'The Gathering at South Forsyth' and would be located along Georgia 400 between Alpharetta and Cumming. The National Hockey League has not said it plans to expand and bring a franchise to the Atlanta market. However, Krause says the demand is here and his development can accommodate a team. 'A lot of people in this state believe we should have a hockey team. I believe we're gonna have one,' Krause said. Forsyth County commissioners agreed to provide $225 million in bond financing, but only if The Gathering lands a pro hockey team. With county officials approving these final, critical documents, Krause plans to meet with the NHL commissioner after the Stanley Cup playoffs. [SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter] Krause said to see three governing bodies in Forsyth County unanimously approve the project brings him to tears. 'It's emotional. It's been a lot of hard work by a lot of people. It's nice to see when your hard work, our team has worked hard, it has paid off,' Krause explained. Krause says he talked with Commissioner Gary Bettman this week. He says if this final approval from the county came today, Bettman would meet with him after the NHL finals. Krause says he expects a decision from the NHL about expansion at the latest by the end of this year.

Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Wild Forward Signs Contract In Czech Extraliga
One of the Minnesota Wild's pending unrestricted free agents, Devin Shore, has signed a contract in the Czech Extraliga with the HC Sparta Praha. Shore, 30, recorded one goal and five points in 55 games for the Wild during the 2024-25 season. He was on a one-year contract worth $775,000. Advertisement He also recorded two goals and ten points in 15 games with the Iowa Wild of the American Hockey League (AHL) this season. Wild's Brock Faber Receives Norris Trophy Vote. Wild's John Hynes Receives Vote For Jack Adams Award. Wild AHL Head Coach Takes NHL Assistant Coaching Job With Vancouver Canucks. The 6-foot-1 forward has played in 498 career NHL games and recorded 52 goals, 92 assists, and 144 points in ten NHL seasons. He played on six different NHL teams and has now signed a contract in the Czech league. Photo Credit: Mar 29, 2025; Saint Paul, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Wild center Devin Shore (19) shoots against the New Jersey Devils in the second period at Xcel Energy Center. Mandatory Credit: Matt Blewett-Imagn Images.


New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
NHL rumblings: Latest on Kreider, Marchand, Tavares, Pettersson, more as the trade market heats up
The potential Chris Kreider trade from the New York Rangers to the Anaheim Ducks has kicked off what should be a rather intriguing summer. Intriguing because as I made calls over the Past few days, taking time away from the Stanley Cup Final to get caught up on offseason affairs, one central theme popped up: Where are the sellers? Advertisement The landscape in the NHL is changing with long-established rebuilding clubs like the Ducks, Montreal Canadiens and Detroit Red Wings all wanting to add — and even teams further down the pecking order like the Chicago Blackhawks and San Jose Sharks wanting to get better by adding pieces as well. 'Almost everyone is looking to add or get better, pretty much,' one NHL general manager said Wednesday. 'There's almost no one purely selling.' Or as another NHL GM put it: What team is entering a new rebuild right now? Instead, it seems teams that need to get younger are looking at the fantastic re-tool the Washington Capitals pulled off over the past few years and deciding that's the model they want to follow. In a more traditional offseason, several teams would be entering a rebuilding phase, saying, 'Take our veteran players off our roster' for future assets. But there really isn't a single franchise ready to implode its roster. The Pittsburgh Penguins could be considered that team, in some ways. They are listening on pretty much everyone other than their legacy guys. Bryan Rust is the guy most teams are calling on. Rickard Rakell is also a name to monitor. It could put the Penguins in an interesting position with the lack of sellers to cash in on that leverage. But overall, it's really interesting how many teams, regardless of their place in the standings, are looking to add to some degree. It's a one-sided market, at least at the onset of this offseason. What else I'm hearing from around the league: • On Kreider, a potential trade first reported by Frank Seravalli, there were more discussions Wednesday. The deal is agreed to, but Kreider would need to waive as Anaheim is on his No list. Kreider was doing his homework on Anaheim on Wednesday and will make a decision. I assume his old pal Jacob Trouba is selling him hard on it. Advertisement • Apparently Brad Marchand has decided he's going to score in every single game of the Stanley Cup Final. I'm kidding of course, but I mean, could anyone have anticipated this kind of playoff performance from the 37-year-old? His rejuvenation coincides perfectly with his pending free agency, and there's no question that contenders are licking their lips hoping to make him an aggressive offer come July 1. The door isn't closed on staying with the Florida Panthers, but with pending unrestricted free agent and Conn Smythe contender Sam Bennett a top priority for the Panthers and Aaron Ekblad also a pending UFA, it's probably most likely Marchand is going to market where total dollars will be the top probity moreso than the actual average annual value. I think he's going to get three or four years and easily north of $8 million a year. And yes, as others have wondered, I do believe the Toronto Maple Leafs will be among the possibilities for Marchand. I mean, he mentioned during the second-round series with Toronto that he grew up a Leafs fan. But to be clear, there are multiple teams in play for Marchand if and when he hits the market. • The Calgary Flames, the Vancouver Canucks and the Canadiens are among the Canadian teams looking for a young No. 2 center, but I would say among those three, the Canucks have the most interest in Wild center Marco Rossi. The Flames have mild interest (they would rather get a center with more size), and I don't think the Habs are on that very much at all. • Speaking of centers, there's a long list of teams eager to see where things go with the New York Islanders under new GM Mathieu Darche when it comes to Mathew Barzal and Bo Horvat. Could either center become available? The answer is no. Darche has communicated with both star players that they're staying put. That's going to be disappointing for teams who were hoping to make offers on either. I think Montreal would have probably been one of those teams. But keeping both Barzal and Horvat is part of Darche's decision to not undergo a massive, long-term rebuild. He sees a team that can compete for a playoff spot next year. Advertisement Of course, there are going to be roster changes. I think the overall theme will be to get younger when possible. But overall, the idea is he's not dropping a grenade on the roster. Darche and head coach Patrick Roy are aligned on wanting to play a higher-pace brand of hockey, and certainly Barzal and Horvat are at the heart of that. • Pat Brisson, the agent for Jonathan Toews, has heard from multiple teams regarding interest in his client, who is returning to the NHL next season. But Brisson is keeping the list of real suitors down to three or four teams, max. The Winnipeg Jets, as discussed before, are one of those teams. I wonder about the Colorado Avalanche as an option as well, but regardless of where it goes, Brisson already has it narrowed down to a tight list. • Never say never, but all signs point to the Canucks keeping Elias Pettersson, whose full no-move clause kicks in July 1. The Canucks are encouraged by Pettersson's approach this offseason. While production over the past two years hasn't matched his $11.6 million salary (he's got seven more years on his deal), there were teams monitoring that situation given how thin the UFA market is. But it sounds like Vancouver wants to keep him. • The Carolina Hurricanes, not surprisingly, are ready to make a splash. They've got $30 million to spend under the salary cap. The Canes intend to inquire on pending UFA Mitch Marner, as many contending teams do, but their eggs are not all in that basket. They are ready to take a run at several free agents and also are inquiring on the trade front. Get ready to see Carolina mentioned in a lot of speculation over the next four weeks. They also need to add on defense with the expectation that pending UFA Dmitry Orlov will go to market. • Utah is looking to take a big swing. It's listening on the No. 4 pick, but you just don't see top-five picks traded very often, and while I think GM Bill Armstrong is genuinely fielding calls on it, I don't think that pick moves. But Utah absolutely wants to be aggressive in upgrading, and I believe it would be among the more serious suitors for Sam Bennett if he goes to market. (I still think he probably re-signs in Florida.) • The Nashville Predators won't be setting off July 1 fireworks after two consecutive years of adding big names. The Predators want to let their roster settle. They might make a subtle signing or two, but nothing too flashy. They've got several players entering the last year of their deals (guys like Micheal Bunting, Colton Sissons, Michael McCarron, Jeremy Lauzon) so if they don't bounce back, they could sell at the March trade deadline, but otherwise it's about keeping the path open for some of their top prospects. • The Chicago Blackhawks are exploring options to add to their forward group. They feel like they're in a good spot on the back end with their young guys and set in goal. They want to start turning the team over to their younger players overall, so while they would like to add a player or two up front this offseason, they also don't want to hinder their younger players' path to quality playing time. So while the Hawks are looking to add up front, I don't think they're going to chase something unreasonable or do anything that doesn't make sense in terms of the path they're on. Advertisement • The Kings continue to have discussions with Vladislav Gavrikov's camp. This one is hard to read right now. I think there's a pretty robust market on July 1 for the pending UFA defenseman, given how thin the position is in free agency this year. The list is eight or nine teams deep that I believe would be making Gavrikov an offer July 1. (I would put the Rangers in that group of suitors.) But the door hasn't been closed on L.A. to this point, either. All things being equal, though, this feels like Gavrikov is more likely going to market than not. • Jamie Benn's agent, Bayne Pettinger, was slated to speak with Stars GM Jim Nill about the pending UFA captain before the end of this week. There's mutual interest in getting a deal done. Ditto with pending UFA Matt Duchene as far as ongoing discussions; his preference would be to stay in Dallas if possible. • The Leafs and John Tavares' camp continue to talk and touched based again this week. There remains mutual interest in getting something done, but finding that sweet spot on a fair deal isn't quite there yet. The idea that Tavares might sign for a bargain $5 million AAV seems like a stretch to me. It's going to have to be above that to get it done given the year he just had, although term is part of the equation as well. • In non-player news, I reported Wednesday that league sources have informed me that Ron Burkle, Mario Lemieux and David Morehouse have decided to explore the possibility of buying back the Penguins from Fenway Sports. Burkle and Lemieux sold the Penguins to Fenway in 2021. Fenway made public several months ago that they were seeking to sell a minority share. But the intention here from the Burkle, Lemieux and Morehouse group, as I understand it, would be the buy back the entire team. I've also heard that Fenway had been in talks with another potential group. We'll see where this all goes, but it sure is interesting to hear that Super Mario wants back in. • In CBA news, the NHL and NHL Players' Association had another bargaining session Wednesday and continue to get closer and closer to a CBA extension. I'm told that there are still a handful of issues that need ironing out but that the feeling is, barring a major setback, there could be a CBA done by the end of the month and perhaps in time for the June 25 Board of Governors meeting. • And finally, one of the by-products of having a decentralized draft is how much impetus it put on NHL team execs and player agents to get their face-to-face time at the recent combine in Buffalo. One NHL GM said it was the busiest combine he can remember in terms of taking meetings to prepare for the trade and free-agent market. One veteran agent said he had 20 meetings in a few days. Never seen anything like it, he said. Advertisement And that's because for the June 27 and 28 NHL Draft, GMs will be at their team headquarters across the 32 markets, not in one place. So from here on out this month, it's all phone work. It's still too early for most of the high-profile trade conversations to go next level. So much of what happened in Buffalo was planting seeds and trying to get a sense of the market. But the first round of the draft on June 27 will act as the first deadline, of sorts, of the offseason as far as trades that may involve first-round picks. (Top photo of Nate Schmidt, John Tavares and Brad Marchand: Carmen Mandato / Getty Images)