Jury urges driver-facing cameras at end of OC Transpo bus crash inquest
The jury at the coroner's inquest into the fatal 2019 OC Transpo bus crash has issued dozens of recommendations for preventing similar tragic accidents — everything from driver-facing cameras on all Ottawa buses to requiring more time for retraining drivers involved in on-duty collisions.
The 60 prompts for change also cover Transitway speed limits and maintenance.
The jury's recommendations are not binding, but they do also include a call for government funding to make them a reality.
They were delivered on Thursday afternoon, the 19th day of an exhaustive deep dive into the events and fallout of Jan. 11, 2019.
On that afternoon, a packed OC Transpo double-decker slammed into a Transitway bus shelter at Westboro station. Three people — Judy Booth, Bruce Thomlinson and Anja Van Beek — died in the crash and many others were injured.
While the city accepted civil responsibility, the driver, Aissatou Diallo, was charged with 38 counts of dangerous driving causing death or bodily harm. She was acquitted of all charges in a judge-only trial in 2021.
The fact-finding (as opposed to fault-finding) inquest homed in on a number of areas including tightened driver training and recruitment, the already-numbered days of double-deckers in Ottawa, and the knotty issue of how the city designs routes and OC Transpo drivers book their work.
The inquest heard that booking is a seniority-based system that can result in less-experienced drivers like Diallo driving double-deckers, though there was disagreement about whether those larger buses are in fact harder to handle than single-deckers. Jurors also heard that the Westboro collision was "unique and so unusual" in its circumstances.
The jurors ultimately did not issue recommendations on the booking system.
The Thomlinson and Booth families, as well as lawyers representing the city, the union for OC Transpo drivers and the coroner's office, made their own pitches for change to the jury last week.
But while the jury of five Ottawa-area civilians could consider those suggestions, the final list of recommendations was up to the jurors.
Some of their recommendations to OC Transpo touched on the following areas:
Driver monitoring and safety
Installing driver-facing cameras on all buses, a move the union opposes.
Closer monitoring of drivers who get in an on-duty collision and undergo refresher training.
A separate evaluation procedure for probationary operators following a serious preventable collision. Before those drivers return to service, they must undergo a minimum of five days of retraining. The inquest heard that Diallo only underwent one day of retraining after crashing a bus one month before the Westboro collision.
Increasing checks on driver licence abstracts from twice a month to daily.
Transitway and bus design
Temporarily reducing the speed of buses approaching stations on the Transitway to 30 kilometres an hour.
Once that's done, removing or replacing canopies with a narrow lateral offset from the curb (as was the case at Westboro station), as well as installing tapered concrete barriers or other forms of guardrail.
Regularly inspecting the Transitway for safety hazards.
Making sure remnants of Transitway construction — like the orange lines that some have argued may have been a distraction to Diallo — are properly removed.
Ensuring the "appropriate" removal of snow on the road leading to Transitway stations. The ditch on the day of the Westboro collision was icy and snow-packed.
Calling on the city and the manufacturer of the double-decker involved in the Westboro crash to study the effectiveness of barriers at the front upper deck of buses to prevent passenger ejections during collisions.
Training
More one-on-one time between experienced drivers and recruits undergoing OC Transpo's New Bus Operator Training (NBOT) program.
A dedicated fleet of buses for training purposes to help ensure recruits get adequate time on all bus types in spite of fleet availability issues.
Enhanced new driver training on emergency braking and the existing prohibition on cell phone use while driving.
Accident oversight
Having the federal government consider making the Transportation Safety Board of Canada investigate serious bus transit collisions that involve deaths.
The entire list of recommendations can be viewed here.
The jurors also declared the Westboro crash an accident. Other choices included homicide, natural causes and suicide.
The city said at the outset of the inquest that it would not be commenting while the process was on but that, after recommendations were made, it would report back to city councillors.
The inquest comes at a key moment for the city and Amalgamated Transit Union (ATU) Local 279, which represents OC Transpo bus drivers. Their last collective agreement expired at the end of March, and negotiations on a new contract are expected to begin soon.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
14 hours ago
- CTV News
Britain's MI6 spy agency gets its first female chief
OTTAWA, Ontario — Britain's real-life spies have finally caught up with James Bond. MI6 has appointed its first female chief. Prime Minister Keir Starmer announced Sunday that Blaise Metreweli will be the next head of the U.K.'s foreign intelligence agency, and the first woman to hold the post since its founding in 1909. She is currently the MI6 director of technology and innovation — the real-world equivalent of Bond gadget-master Q. A career intelligence officer, Metreweli, 47, steps from the shadows into the light as the only MI6 employee whose name is made public. She said 'I am proud and honored to be asked to lead my Service.' Starmer said the 'historic appointment' comes at a time 'when the work of our intelligence services has never been more vital. 'The United Kingdom is facing threats on an unprecedented scale – be it aggressors who send their spy ships to our waters or hackers whose sophisticated cyber plots seek to disrupt our public services,' he said. Starmer made the announcement as he arrived in the Canadian province of Alberta for a Group of Seven leaders' summit. Metreweli takes over at MI6 as the agency faces growing challenges from states including China and Russia, whose use of cyber tools, espionage, and influence operations threatens global stability and British interests, even as it remains on alert against terrorist threats. Metreweli is the first woman to get the top job, known as C – rather than M, the fictional MI6 chief of the 007 thrillers. M was played onscreen by Judi Dench in seven Bond movies starting in the 1990s. She will take up her post in the fall, replacing Richard Moore, who has held the job for five years. Britain's two other main intelligence agencies have already shattered the spy world's glass ceiling. MI5, the domestic security service, was led by Stella Rimington from 1992 to 1996 and Eliza Manningham-Buller between 2002 and 2007. Anne Keast-Butler became head of electronic and cyber-intelligence agency GCHQ in 2023. Moore, an Oxford-educated former diplomat, fit the 007 mold like a Savile Row suit. But in recent years MI6 has worked to increase diversity, broadening its recruitment process from the traditional 'tap on the shoulder' at an elite university. The agency's website stresses its family-friendly flexible working policy and goal of recruiting 'talented people from all backgrounds.' Moore suggested he would like his successor to be a woman. He wrote on X in 2023 that he would 'help forge women's equality by working to ensure I'm the last C selected from an all-male shortlist.' Like many things about MI6, also known as the Secret Intelligence Service, the process of choosing a new chief took place out of public view. It began with the country's top civil servant writing to government departments in March asking them to put forward candidates. The job was open to applicants from other intelligence agencies, the civil service, the diplomatic service, the armed forces or the police. In the end, MI6 opted for an internal candidate with a 25-year career in espionage, a degree in anthropology from Cambridge University — where she was on the women's rowing team — and expertise in cutting-edge technology. 'At a time of global instability and emerging security threats, where technology is power and our adversaries are working ever closer together, Blaise will ensure the U.K. can tackle these challenges head on to keep Britain safe and secure at home and abroad,' said Foreign Secretary David Lammy, who oversees MI6. Jill Lawless, The Associated Press
Winnipeg Free Press
17 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
A teenager with a job making burritos became a powerful Minnesota lawmaker who trained service dogs
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Melissa Hortman' s influence at the Minnesota Capitol and her power as a Democratic leader to shape the course of a deeply divided Legislature were a far cry from her job as a teenager making chili-cheese burritos and overshadowed her volunteer work training service dogs for veterans. She was a lifelong Minneapolis-area resident who went to college in Boston and then returned home for law school and, with degree fresh in hand, worked as a volunteer lawyer for a group fighting housing discrimination. Elected to the Minnesota House in 2004, she helped pass liberal initiatives like free lunches for pubic school students in 2023 as the chamber's speaker. With the House split 67-67 between Democrats and Republicans this year, she helped break a budget impasse threatening to shut down state government. Tributes from friends and colleagues in both parties poured in after Hortman and her husband were shot to death early Saturday in their suburban Brooklyn Park home in what authorities called an act of targeted political violence. Helping Paws, which trains service dogs, posted a message on its Facebook page, along with a photo of a smiling Hortman with her arm around a friendly-looking golden retriever. 'Melissa Hortman was a woman that I wish everyone around the country knew,' U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, a longtime friend and Democratic ally, said Sunday on ABC's 'This Week.' Klobuchar added: 'She was a true leader and loved her work, but was always so grounded and such a decent person. I think that's probably the best word to describe her. You look at her pictures and you know what she was about.' The shootings followed a big Democratic dinner The killings of Hortman and her husband early Saturday followed the shootings and wounding of another prominent Minnesota lawmaker, state Sen. John Hoffman, and his wife, at their home in Champlin, another Minneapolis suburb. Hoffman is chair of the Senate committee overseeing human resources spending. A nephew posted Sunday on Facebook that the Hoffmans were out of surgery and recovering from multiple gunshot wounds. The Hortmans, the Hoffmans and other top Democrats had gathered at a downtown Minneapolis hotel Friday night for their party's annual Humphrey-Mondale dinner. It's named for two Minnesota liberal icons who served both as U.S. senators and vice presidents, Hubert Humphrey and Walter Mondale. Minnesota Democrat and U.S. Sen. Tina Smith said she saw both lawmakers at the dinner. 'So it feels so personal, because we're all very good friends, of course, to have that have happened so shortly after we were all together,' Smith said on CNN's 'Inside Politics Sunday.' Outside the state Capitol in St. Paul, a memorial to Hortman and her husband included flowers, candles, small American flags and a photo of the couple. Visitors left messages on Post-It notes commending Hortman's legislative work, including, 'You changed countless lives.' Hortman supplied a key vote for a budget deal Democrats disliked Legislative colleagues described Hortman as funny, savvy and fiercely committed to liberal causes. When lawmakers convened in January with a vacancy in a Democratic seat in the House giving the GOP a temporary advantage, Hortman led a boycott of daily sessions for more than three weeks to force Republicans into a power-sharing arrangement. Republicans were intent this year on ending state health coverage for adult immigrants who entered the U.S. illegally, authorized in 2023 as part of a sweeping liberal program. Democrats wanted to keep it, and lawmakers began June — the last month of the 2025 budget year — without having passed a 2026-27 spending blueprint. Hortman helped negotiate a package that included a bill ending the state health coverage for adult immigrants on Jan. 1, 2026. She was the only House Democrat to vote for it last week— the 68th vote it needed to pass the chamber. She told reporters afterward that Republicans insisted on the bill, and Minnesota voters who gave the House an even partisan split expect the parties to compromise. But she acknowledged she worries about people who will lose their health insurance. 'I know that people will be hurt by that vote,' she said, choking up briefly before regaining her composure. 'We worked very hard to get a budget deal that wouldn't include that provision.' Tacos, auto parts, physics and Habitat for Humanity Hortman's earliest jobs didn't suggest that she'd become a power in Minnesota politics. The earliest job listed on her profile, when she was 16, was as a cook and cashier at a restaurant, where she made tacos and, 'most importantly, chili cheese burritos.' She also worked for caterers and was a runner at an auto parts store, putting inventory away and retrieving items for customers. Her husband, Mark, earned a physics degree from the University of North Carolina and later, a master's of business administration. He was the chief operating officer of an auto parts company for 10 years before co-founding a business consulting firm. He was active in Helping Paws and worked with homebuilding nonprofit Habitat for Humanity. Melissa Hortman earned a degree in philosophy and political science from Boston University, where she also worked as a residence assistant in one of its dormitories. She earned her law degree from the University of Minnesota, but also a master's of public administration from Harvard University. She served a decade on the board of a local nonprofit providing transportation and car repairs for low-income residents. She also was part of a committee in 2005 considering whether Minneapolis should submit a bid to host the Summer Olympics. 'We remember Melissa for her kindness, compassion, and unwavering commitment to making the world better,' Helping Paws said in its Facebook message. ___ Hanna reported from Topeka, Kansas. Associated Press video journalist Obed Lamy also contributed reporting from St. Paul, Minnesota.
CTV News
19 hours ago
- CTV News
Jewish and interfaith leaders condemn vandalism at National Holocaust Monument
The words 'FEED ME' are seen painted in red on the National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa on Monday, June 9, 2025. (Sean Kilpatrick/THE CANADIAN PRESS) Jewish and interfaith leaders are gathering Sunday afternoon at the National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa to condemn a recent act of vandalism and to stand united against hate. The monument, which honours the six million Jewish people killed in the Holocaust, was defaced last week with red paint and the words 'Feed Me.' The event begins at 3 p.m. 'The desecration of the National Holocaust Monument was not just vandalism — it was an attack on the memory of six million Jews murdered in the Holocaust and on the values of decency and humanity we hold as Canadians," said Adam Silver, president and CEO of the Jewish Federation of Ottawa, in a press release. 'We must not stay silent. This vigil is about standing together to say clearly: hate has no place here.' The gathering comes amid a rise in antisemitism across Canada. According to a global task force against antisemitism, a report shows incidents have jumped more than 170 per cent in Canada since 2020. 'This vigil is a potent reminder that unchecked hatred and discrimination do not only affect the targeted community; they threaten the social fabric of our society; they are corrosive to our entire society,' said Annette Wildgoose, president of the National Holocaust Monument committee, in a press release. 'By all of us standing together at the National Holocaust Monument, we reaffirm our commitment to fighting against all forms of intolerance and antisemitism.' The Ottawa Police Service hate and bias crime unit continues to investigate the incident. This story will be updated.
