logo
Hong Kong's elderly fabric shop owners face uncertain future as historic Western Market slated for renovation

Hong Kong's elderly fabric shop owners face uncertain future as historic Western Market slated for renovation

HKFP10-05-2025

Hong Kong fabric store owner Chan Sun began slashing prices after he received word last month that the historic Western Market building – home to his shop for three decades – would be under renovation and that he would soon need to move out.
'HK$500, 2 Yds,' the 83-year-old wrote on a signboard outside his shop, located on the first floor of the old red-brick colonial structure.
Chan has until the end of October to move out and make way for the Urban Renewal Authority (URA) revitalisation works, which will take at least two years.
The imminent eviction coincides with the declining demand for the fabric market's products, which has been on for decades. The city's textile and tailoring industries are now shadows of their former selves, their heydays long past.
'At our peak, we were responsible for a fifth of an English manufacturer's business,' Chan recalled their import volumes.
'Look over there,' he said, pointing at the rolls of wool and camel hair blends outside the shop, which stood behind the till. 'Those used to be HK$600 a yard. Now I have to sell two for HK$500.'
It will be hard to sell the fabrics he has left, particularly the high-end cashmere fabrics he sells for HK$6,200 a yard, the octogenarian said.
Eighteen fabric stores, including Chan's Lee Loy Piece Goods, moved to the Edwardian-style market building in Sheung Wan in 1991, after the Land Development Corporation – the URA's predecessor – redeveloped old buildings in the nearby Wing On Street, nicknamed 'Cloth Street.'
This time around, there is a lot of uncertainty. With less than half a year before the fabric shops must leave the Western Market, its mostly elderly tenants are unsure where they will go or whether they will reopen their businesses.
'They're saying the repairs will take two years, but I don't even know if I'll still be around by then,' Chan sighed, saying he had not made plans for when the deadline comes.
From errand boy to store owner
Chan began working at Lee Loy six decades ago, mopping the floor and running errands for HK$40 a month, back when the shop was still on Wing On Street, in Central.
He later inherited the four-storey store from his uncle and expanded its operations by selling fabric to textile factories. When the shop relocated to the first floor of the Western Market in Sheung Wan, he had to downsize his business as he was allocated a refurbished wet-market stall measuring barely 80 square feet.
Chan is still in business despite incurring losses for the better part of 33 years running the shop at the market. It is kept barely afloat by a small band of loyal customers who keep coming back to buy suit fabrics.
The fabric vendors have built close and friendly relationships over the years, said another elderly seller who only wanted to give his surname, Chow, due to privacy reasons.
That afternoon in April, he was manning a neighbouring store while the owner was out for lunch.
That sense of community also helped on the business front, he said.
'If we get split up, we won't be able to source our fabrics in bulk together anymore,' he said, pointing to the rolls of British, Italian, and German suit fabrics at his store, which Chan also stocks at Lee Loy.
Chow's shop, Three Geniuses Furnishing Fabrics, and many others in the market sell colourful cloths – jacquard fabrics and screen-printed patterns in reds, magentas, and other bright hues – which bear a striking contrast to the blacks and greys at Chan's stall.
One of their main clientele is local fashion students and designers. Film crews also come to the market for fabrics. However, with cheaper materials available online, far fewer of them come to local stores, Chow said.
Oldest surviving market building
First completed in 1906, the Western Market is Hong Kong's oldest surviving market building. It served as a wet market for more than 80 years before it underwent a major renovation and reopened in 1991.
The building, which was declared a monument in 1990, was refurbished in 2003 – more than two decades ago. Decades later, natural wear and tear have left the structure in need of a facelift.
'We do see the need for it. Look, the rain is seeping through the bricks, and water is leaking through the ceiling next door,' said Chow, 73, shortly after a rainy April morning.
The URA said it would contact the fabric market tenants in due course to explain the refurbishment works and provide assistance. But it did not say whether it would offer special compensation or relocation arrangements to the stallholders.
Its statement read: 'As for the fabric traders, when the Land Development Corporation (LDC) redeveloped Wing On Street in Sheung Wan years ago, it already offered compensation to the affected fabric traders in accordance with the policy at that time.'
Besides tackling the water seepage, the URA's revitalisation works will also address the historic building's ageing electrical and mechanical equipment, roof tiles and timber components, as well as its facade, doors and windows.
'To facilitate the commencement of the works and for safety reasons, all commercial tenants will have to move out,' the authority said in an emailed reply to HKFP's enquiry.
The fabric store is all Chan has left. 'I don't have other interests, I don't drink or gamble, and I don't have friends anymore,' he said.
'People my age – lots of them – are no longer around, so I don't know what I'll do without the shop. We're just here to ride out the rest of our lives.'
As the vendors brace for the inevitable evictions, tourists are unaware of the plan for the century-old red-brick building and its tenants. On the day of HKFP's visit, they took photos of the fabric stores, though few purchased anything and left empty-handed.
'Can't see a future'
Katy, a florist on the market's ground floor, has found a new address for her store a few streets away. She declined to disclose her full name due to privacy concerns.
'We're renting the new place for around the same price, but I'll miss the market,' she said. 'After all, it's a landmark, and we've been here for 30 years,' she said.
Under a different tenancy agreement with the building's landlord, the Telford Recreation Club, she is among the Western Market's tenants who will only have until the end of the month to move out.
Katy said she had emotional ties to the historic market building, as it was where her son grew up.
'We've experienced Hong Kong's rise and fall. Now there aren't as many tourists as there used to be. Back in the day, we could strike up a conversation with them, but there aren't many opportunities for that,' she said.
Katy's last two rental contracts at the market were only for two months each, instead of the customary two years.
The URA says it may make 'flexible arrangements' or provide tenants with intermediary services for relocating their businesses, or look into moving those businesses to other commercial premises managed by the authority.
'Hong Kong seems to have slowed down. When I can't see a future, I just don't have the motivation to do anything, not even install an Octopus card reader,' she said. 'I want to touch up the shop and make it more presentable, but I just don't have that drive.'
Chan lamented the current political environment, saying he was not bothered to reach out to lawmakers or district councillors for help.
'Times have changed,' he said. 'Look how peaceful it is now. There used to be protests against this kind of thing, but not anymore.'
Original reporting on HKFP is backed by our monthly contributors.
Almost 1,000 monthly donors make HKFP possible. Each contributes an average of HK$200/month to support our award-winning original reporting, keeping the city's only independent English-language outlet free-to-access for all. Three reasons to join us:
🔎 Transparent & efficient: As a non-profit, we are externally audited each year, publishing our income/outgoings annually, as the city's most transparent news outlet.
🔒 Accurate & accountable: Our reporting is governed by a comprehensive Ethics Code. We are 100% independent, and not answerable to any tycoon, mainland owners or shareholders. Check out our latest Annual Report, and help support press freedom.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ex-district councillor's candle shop inspected by Hong Kong customs officers on eve of Tiananmen anniversary
Ex-district councillor's candle shop inspected by Hong Kong customs officers on eve of Tiananmen anniversary

HKFP

time8 hours ago

  • HKFP

Ex-district councillor's candle shop inspected by Hong Kong customs officers on eve of Tiananmen anniversary

Hong Kong customs officers inspected ex-district councillor Katrina Chan's incense shop for hours on the eve of the Tiananmen crackdown anniversary, accusing her of failing to comply with product safety regulations. Two plainclothes officers, who later introduced themselves as Customs and Excise Department (C&ED) personnel, visited Chan's shop, Heung Together, in Dragon Centre in Sham Shui Po with three other customs officers on Tuesday evening. The plainclothes officers bought products from the shop twice within the span of 20 minutes on Tuesday evening. They told her she was suspected of violating the Consumer Goods Safety Regulation because she had failed to include bilingual safety labels on products. Inspections of the products lasted more than four hours, from 7.30pm to around 11.40pm, after the mall had already closed. The officers photographed and seized some of the products Chan was selling but did not arrest her. Candles for $6.4 Chan, who served as Tsuen Wan district councillor from 2019 to 2021, sold soy wax candles for '$6.4' on Tuesday, one day before June 4, the anniversary of the 1989 Tiananmen crackdown. A customs officer at the scene said that Tuesday's operation was part of a routine inspection. When asked if the team had inspected other shops at Dragon Centre on the same day, he said he could not reveal operational details. At least five other plainclothes officers, who a customs officer said were not part of the department's team, stood in the vicinity of the shop, regularly rotating positions. Just before midnight, two of the officers identified themselves as police officers to Chan, saying they were at the scene to observe the customs officers and that they did not know the other unidentified men in plainclothes. Throughout the inspections, Chan said the presence of the unidentified men left her feeling uneasy. When reporters on the scene began recording the exchange between Chan and the two police officers, the officers asked them to stop, saying it was a 'private conversation.' HKFP has reached out to the C&ED and the police force for comment. Chan said last month that she was being 'silenced' after being ousted from her job and a theatre production she was part of. In May last year, she and five others were arrested under the city's homegrown security law, also known as Article 23. Their arrests were linked to a Facebook page called 'Chow Hang-tung Club,' named after the activist who was the vice chairperson of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements of China. The Alliance once organised the city's annual Tiananmen vigils until Hong Kong police banned the Tiananmen vigil gathering at Victoria Park for the first time in 2020, citing Covid-19 restrictions. The ban was imposed again in 2021, nearly a year after a national security law imposed by Beijing came into effect. The Tiananmen crackdown occurred on June 4, 1989, ending months of student-led demonstrations in China. It is estimated that hundreds, perhaps thousands, died when the People's Liberation Army cracked down on protesters in Beijing.

'Shopping festival can help boost silver consumption'
'Shopping festival can help boost silver consumption'

RTHK

time11 hours ago

  • RTHK

'Shopping festival can help boost silver consumption'

'Shopping festival can help boost silver consumption' Commerce chief Algernon Yau says a shopping festival in the city will be a good chance for retailers to grasp the silver economy. Photo: RTHK Annie Yau Tse says retailers must embrace new technology to break through the extreme challenges facing the industry. Photo: RTHK Secretary for Commerce and Economic Development Algernon Yau on Wednesday called on retailers to take the opportunity of a shopping festival later this year to boost consumption for silver-haired residents. His remark came after authorities last week rolled out 30 measures to tap into the "silver economy" to spur growth, of which half were related to boosting consumption for senior residents. Speaking at the Hong Kong Retail Summit 2025, Yau said the third edition of the Hong Kong Shopping Festival in the third quarter will be a good chance to put the measures into practice. "I encourage the business community to take this opportunity to offer exclusive discounts, products, as well as a combination of services for the elderly, to create a pleasant silver consumption atmosphere in the market, and to attract more silver-haired consumers," he told summit participants, many of them retail professionals. "I also hope that retailers such as supermarkets, department stores, pharmacies and personal care stores will classify the products clearly and concisely at their physical stores, and to place some common and popular silver products at places that are easy to access, so as to enhance the consumption experiences for them and their families and caregivers," he added. The commerce chief also said the government will ramp up certifications for relevant products and services to ensure their reliability. Echoing Yau, Annie Yau Tse, chairwomen of the Hong Kong Retail Management Association (HKRMA), said local retailers must embrace new technology and channels to break through the extreme challenges facing the sector. "New retail must embrace the artificial intelligence and innovative technologies, attach importance to the consumer experience, and seize the development opportunities in different fields, such as the mega event economy, low-altitude economy and silver economy, to break through the limitations of our Hong Kong retailers and open a new chapter," she said. "Hong Kong brands still have unique advantages, and we can look around and explore new markets, such as first establishing themselves in the Greater Bay Area market, before tapping into markets of other provinces and cities on the mainland." The retail veteran's remarks came as the city's retail sales fell for the 14th month in a row, dropping by 2.3 percent year on year last month to HK$28.9 billion, as changing consumption patterns continued to weigh on the industry. Yau Tse earlier estimated that the sector will see flat growth for this year, saying she hopes the April data "reached a bottom" and that the industry will stabilise in the coming months.

Hong Kong pro-democracy business hit with ‘unwarranted' tax demand, owner says
Hong Kong pro-democracy business hit with ‘unwarranted' tax demand, owner says

HKFP

time16 hours ago

  • HKFP

Hong Kong pro-democracy business hit with ‘unwarranted' tax demand, owner says

A Hong Kong pro-democracy shop owner has said his business is facing 'unwarranted' tax demands. Derek Chu, an ex-district councillor and the owner of e-commerce company As One, said on Tuesday that the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) demanded in April that his business pay HK$120,075 in profit tax for the financial year 2023-24. The tax assessment would mean As One made a profit of about HK$1.5 million in 2023-24, but in reality, his shop only recorded a profit of less than HK$100,000, Chu told HKFP in a phone interview. Most of As One's HK$4 million income last year was spent on salaries, rent, and restocking products, he added. 'The numbers should have been obvious to the IRD,' Chu said. 'I don't know how they could see that much profit.' The shop owner, who also founded the prisoners' rights advocacy group Waiting Bird, accused the IRD of 'targeting' his business and said he decided to speak up about the tax demand to 'set the record straight.' 'It's about telling people that what the IRD did was completely unwarranted,' he said. HKFP has contacted the IRD for comment. Part of As One's business model is selling gift packages for prisoners, which accounted for about a third of the shop's income, according to an Instagram post published on Monday. The company relies on loans from Chu's family members to maintain cash flow, and it has accumulated debts totalling over HK$1 million since the business started in 2021, he said. He has been repaying the loan, but there is still an outstanding amount of 'hundreds of thousands' of dollars, Chu told HKFP. The five full-time staff members and two part-time staffers only earn meagre salaries of less than HK$20,000 a month, while Chu himself has never got paid in full, he said. The IRD's tax demand has made his business 'harder' as he has to borrow more from his family members to pay the tax, he added. Independent media's tax audits Chu's disclosure comes nearly two weeks after the Hong Kong Journalists' Association (HKJA) made a similar announcement last month. According to the press union, six independent media outlets in the city have been facing tax audits from the IRD since late 2023, with the IRD making errors and 'strange, unreasonable claims' in its tax assessments and demands. The outlets include HKFP, InMedia, The Witness, ReNews, Boomhead, and one that did not wish to be named. In a statement, HKFP said it has been cooperating fully with the IRD's tax audit, adding that it has 'always met its tax obligations, paid IRD demands immediately, and ensured meticulous record-keeping' since it was established in 2015. According to the HKJA, 20 individuals, including heads of media outlets and their spouses, are also subject to the IRD's audits and backdated tax demands. The HKJA also faces the IRD's scrutiny. When asked by a reporter about the matter, Chief Executive John Lee brushed off HKJA's allegations and said that journalists 'have no privilege to evade taxes.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store