logo
Israel's Gaza aid blockade contested in World Court hearings

Israel's Gaza aid blockade contested in World Court hearings

RNZ News29-04-2025

A demonstrator stands beside a placard outside the International Court of Justice as an interrogation on Israel's humanitarian obligations towards Palestinians takes place at the International Court of Justice, in The Hague on April 28, 2025.
Photo:
LINA SELG
By
Bart Meijer
, Reuters
UN and Palestinian representatives at the International Court of Justice accused Israel of breaking international law by
refusing to let aid into Gaza
, on the first day of hearings about Israel's obligations to facilitate aid deliveries.
Since 2 March, Israel has completely cut off all supplies to the 2.3 million residents of the Gaza Strip, and
food stockpiled
during a ceasefire at the start of the year has all but run out.
At the opening of the hearings at the UN's top court, the UN's legal counsel said Israel had a clear obligation as an occupying force to allow and facilitate humanitarian aid for the people in Gaza.
"In the specific context of the current situation in the occupied Palestinian Territories, these obligations entail allowing all relevant UN entities to carry out activities for the benefit of the local population," Elinor Hammarskjold said.
Palestinian representative Ammar Hijazi said Israel was using humanitarian aid as "a weapon of war", while people in Gaza were facing starvation.
Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar said Israel had submitted its position in writing to the hearings, which he described as a "circus".
Speaking in Jerusalem on Monday, Saar said the court was being politicised, while the UN was failing to root out employees of its Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA who are members of Gaza militant groups.
"They are abusing the court once again to try and force Israel to cooperate with an organisation that is infested with Hamas terrorists," Saar said. "The goal is to deprive Israel of its most basic right to defend itself."
The UN said in August that nine UNRWA staff may have been involved in Hamas' 7 October, 2023 assault and had been fired. Another Hamas commander, confirmed by UNRWA as one of its employees, was killed in Gaza in October, according to Israel.
The ICJ, also known as the World Court, was tasked in December to form an advisory opinion on Israel's obligations to facilitate aid to Palestinians that is delivered by states and international groups, including the United Nations.
Israel has repeatedly said it would not allow the entry of goods and supplies into Gaza until Hamas releases all remaining hostages. It has accused Hamas of hijacking humanitarian aid, which the militant group denies.
"This case is about Israel destroying the fundamentals of life in Palestine, while it blocks the UN and other providers of humanitarian aid from providing life-saving aid to the population," Hijazi, the head of the Palestinian mission to the Netherlands, told the hearing.
US President Donald Trump on Friday said he had pushed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to allow food and medicine into Gaza. Germany, France and Britain last week called to allow the unhindered passage of humanitarian aid into the besieged Palestinian territory.
Advisory opinions of the ICJ carry legal and political weight, although they are not binding and the court has no enforcement powers.
After the hearings, the World Court will likely take several months to form its opinion.
- Reuters

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference
Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference

Scoop

time5 hours ago

  • Scoop

Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference

Press Release – Government of Vanuatu Nice Action Plan comes ahead of anticipated ruling from International Court of Justice that could set path for climate action linked to accountability 'It is time to move beyond voluntary pledges to making climate action a binding legal duty.' Statement from Ralph Regenvanu, Minister of Climate Change Adaptation, Meteorology & Geo-Hazards, Energy, Environment and Disaster Management for the Republic of Vanuatu NICE, FRANCE (9 June 2025) 'At this UN Ocean Conference, the stakes could not be clearer. 'Vanuatu's contributions to climate change are minimal, yet we — and our neighbours — suffer severe repeated climate impacts that devastate our economy and people. We are living through the collapse of ocean stability and witnessing a dangerous acceleration in sea-level rise and ocean temperatures. Our oceans are increasingly hostile even to the very creatures that live in them. The consequences of this will ripple through the entire food chain, hitting vulnerable countries like Vanuatu the hardest and ultimately affecting all of humanity and future generations. The role of our ocean as our greatest carbon sink is being threatened. 'The Nice Ocean Action Plan aligns with the standards set by the landmark International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) Advisory Opinion delivered in May 2024, which made it clear: greenhouse gas emissions are marine pollution. And under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, all States are legally bound to prevent, reduce, and control them. This obligation extends not only to domestic emissions but to global ones as well. 'Even so, plans like these are voluntary. Promises without enforcement. Declarations without duty. 'Protecting the ocean from climate change should not be a matter of choice. We need concrete mechanisms and independent monitoring to ensure that nations uphold their legal responsibilities. Conferences like this one, and the upcoming COP30, must not leave frontline nations feeling that nothing is changing — despite the overwhelming urgency. 'It is time to move beyond voluntary pledges to making climate action a binding legal duty.' Climate action must be grounded in a robust framework of legal principles: human rights, the right to self-determination, the duty to prevent harm, precautionary approaches, intergenerational equity, and obligations enshrined in key international treaties — from the Biodiversity Convention to the UNFCCC to the Law of the Sea. 'That's why we eagerly await the International Court of Justice's Advisory Opinion on the broader climate obligations of nations, in hopes of a strong ruling supporting global accountability for the climate crisis and enforceable climate action. 'It's time for States to catch up with the law, with the science, and with the urgency of this moment.'

Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference
Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference

Scoop

time7 hours ago

  • Scoop

Vanuatu Climate Minister Ralph Regenvanu On UN Ocean Conference

Government of Vanuatu - Latest News [Page 1] Nice Action Plan comes ahead of anticipated ruling from International Court of Justice that could set path for climate action linked to accountability More >> At The ICJ, The Global South Has Presented A World Of Climate Change Impacts & A Dire Need For Climate Justice Friday, 13 December 2024, 9:29 pm | Government of Vanuatu Statement after statement makes the case that destruction of the climate system is unlawful and big polluters must be held accountable. More >> Vanuatu Statement On The Remarks Of US And Australia At Landmark ICJ Climate Case Thursday, 5 December 2024, 9:06 pm | Government of Vanuatu Statement after statement makes the case that destruction of the climate system is unlawful and big polluters must be held accountable. More >> Vanuatu Statement On UN Climate Change Agreement: 'It's Not Enough. It Was Never Going To Be Enough.' Sunday, 24 November 2024, 2:51 pm | Government of Vanuatu With COP29's conclusion, the stage shifts to the Hague, where Vanuatu's landmark ICJ climate change case—110 UN member states and intergovernmental organisations testifying—will start on 2 December. More >> Ahead Of COP29, Landmark ICJ Climate Case Looms, With Vanuatu As First Country Speaking Monday, 11 November 2024, 5:41 am | Government of Vanuatu In schedule change, Vanuatu's testimony will now open landmark ICJ climate change case as 110 UN member states and intergovernmental organisations make their case in The Hague, starting 2 December. More >>

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store