Air India disaster deals heavy blow to 'world class airline' ambition
NEW DELHI: The Air India plane crash in which more than 200 passengers were killed on Thursday (Jun 12) has plunged the airline into its deepest crisis yet and will deal a heavy blow to its efforts to revamp its reputation and fleet.
After taking the carrier over from the government in 2022, the Tata Group unveiled ambitious plans to reverse years of underinvestment in an ageing and outdated fleet and create a "world class airline", as CEO Campbell Wilson has repeatedly put it, on a par with rivals like Emirates.
The turnaround has been aimed at tackling its myriad problems including persistent flight delays, disgruntled customers, a shortage of spare parts, delayed plane deliveries and years of financial losses.
"Newer aircraft and better maintenance should be the hallmark for Air India to survive. Proper maintenance is what they should be looking into, because Air India has had a chequered past," said Vibhuti Deora, a former legal expert at India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau.
That past includes, while under government ownership, Boeing 737 flight from Dubai overshooting the runway at one domestic airport and crashing into a gorge in 2010, killing 158 people. More recently, its low-cost unit Air India Express saw one craft skid off a runway in India in 2020, killing 21 people.
Only a few days ago, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi told an international gathering of hundreds of airline executives in New Delhi that the country's aviation industry stood at a crucial point of takeoff.
On Thursday, however, Air India swapped the bright red colour scheme and logo on its website for a more sombre black and grey one, covering it with a banner that carried the crashed flight's number: "AI-171".
"For an airline, the most important thing is the brand's identity with safety. This will be a major setback for the brand in that aspect," said Dilip Cherian, a communications consultant and co-founder of public relations firm Perfect Relations.
"DIFFICULT DAY"
With its maharajah mascot, Air India was once renowned for its lavishly decorated planes and stellar service championed by its founder, JRD Tata, India's first commercial pilot.
But since the mid-2000s, the carrier's reputation has worsened as financial troubles mounted. It has flown widebody planes with business class seats in poor condition and grounded some of its new Boeing 787 Dreamliners for lack of spare parts.
When Tata regained control, the airline was "just in absolute shambles", its CEO Wilson told Reuters in a 2024 interview, noting that some of its planes hadn't had a product refresh since they were delivered in 2010-2011.
Air India, which has a 30 per cent share of the domestic passenger market, has a fleet of 198 planes, of which 27 are 10 to 15 years old and 43 are more than 15 years old, the civil aviation ministry told parliament in March. Air India Express had 101 planes, with 37 per cent of them more than 15 years old.
The plane that crashed on Thursday was 11 years old, according to Flightradar24.
Rival Indian airlines like IndiGo operate newer planes.
Air India, which is part-owned by Singapore Airlines, has placed orders for 570 new jets in recent years and is in talks for dozens more.
It has even aggressively expanded its international flight network in the face of the fury of its passengers, who often take to social media to show soiled seats, broken arm rests, non-operational entertainment systems and dirty cabin areas.
It has also been ranked the worst airline for flight delays in Britain, where its departures were on average just under 46 minutes behind schedule in 2024, according to analysis of Civil Aviation Authority data by the PA news agency published in May.
It has also been reporting losses since at least fiscal 2019-20. In 2023-2024, it reported a net loss of US$520 million on sales of US$4.6 billion.
Before it can make any further progress on these problems, however, it faces the difficult task of investigating one of India's worst aviation disasters ever.
"This is a difficult day for all of us at Air India," CEO Wilson said in a video message.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
31 minutes ago
- CNA
Geopolitical Tensions, Tariffs and Tragedy to Shadow Paris Air Show
PARIS: War, tariffs and the deadly Air India crash will cast a shadow over the Paris Air Show as the aerospace industry's biggest annual gathering opens on Monday (Jun 17). More than 2,400 companies from 48 countries are set to display aircraft and aerospace technology during the week-long event at Le Bourget airfield, just outside the French capital. The fierce commercial battle between Airbus and Boeing typically dominates headlines, as the world's two top civil aircraft manufacturers announce blockbuster orders. But this year's show 'is much more complex,' said Airbus chief executive Guillaume Faury, who also chairs the board of the Gifas association of French aerospace firms, which organises the biennial event. GROWING CHALLENGES Russia's war in Ukraine has entered its fourth year, and fears are mounting of a broader Middle East conflict after Israel struck targets in Iran on Friday, disrupting commercial aviation across the region. The recent crash of an Air India-operated Boeing 787 Dreamliner in Ahmedabad, which killed at least 265 people, has also shaken the industry. The disaster marks the first fatal crash of a 787 and comes as Boeing continues efforts to recover from past safety and production issues. Boeing CEO Kelly Ortberg has cancelled his plans to attend the show to focus on the investigation. Both Boeing and Airbus have also been facing delivery delays due to lingering global supply chain disruptions. Airbus, in particular, is experiencing bottlenecks including a shortage of fuel-efficient engines for its A320 jets and even a lack of aircraft lavatories for its wide-body models. TRADE PRESSURES Adding to the strain is US President Donald Trump's sweeping tariff plan. In April, Trump imposed a 10 per cent tariff on imports from nearly every country, with steeper duties for dozens of others under consideration. The aerospace sector, reliant on global supply chains, is especially vulnerable. Trump's administration is weighing tariffs of 10 to 20 per cent specifically on civil aircraft and parts. Faury and Ortberg have both called for tariffs to be reset to zero, as had been the case since a 1979 agreement. 'The entire Western aerospace industry considers that would be the best that could happen,' said Faury. Ortberg told Aviation Week the tariffs are an 'added cost' Boeing cannot absorb, warning they come just as the company is trying to rebuild financially. 'I'm hopeful that, as each of these country-by-country negotiations resolve, those tariffs will go away in the long run,' he said. DEFENCE IN FOCUS While civil aviation struggles, the defence sector is gaining prominence. European nations have boosted defence budgets amid the war in Ukraine and concerns over Trump's commitment to NATO. 'The geostrategic environment has led us to bolster this aspect which was in the background in previous years,' said Gifas head Frederic Parisot. About 75 defence-related firms will participate in this year's event, showcasing military jets, helicopters and drones. Highlights include Lockheed Martin's F-35 stealth fighter and France's Rafale jet by Dassault Aviation. Nine Israeli companies are expected to exhibit, despite an unsuccessful legal attempt by NGOs to ban their participation over their alleged role in the Gaza conflict. BOEING UNDER SCRUTINY The crash of the Boeing Dreamliner has cast a long shadow just days before the show. The aircraft had been seen as a centrepiece of Boeing's renewed push under new leadership to restore confidence. Boeing's absence from the air show's executive stage will be noted amid investigations, and the crash is likely to dominate conversations throughout the event. The industry also remains on edge due to unresolved supply chain fragilities dating back to the COVID-19 pandemic, adding further uncertainty to production and delivery timelines.
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
With tragic plane crash, Air India's revamp to take longer
Debris of Air India flight 171 seen after it crashed in a residential area near the airport in Ahmedabad on June 13. PHOTO: AFP Follow our live coverage here. - The crash of the London-bound Air India flight in Ahmedabad on June 12 that left at least 241 dead could slow the erstwhile national carrier's plans to expand and revive its reputation and profitability. This is because it must turn its attention now to restoring internal morale and consumer confidence after the tragic accident. Officials are still investigating why AI-171 crashed, but it is the airline's first wide-body aircraft accident in 40 years. The Tata Group bought the carrier from the Indian government in 2022. For Air India, which posted an operational profit in early June after decades of losses and hoped to reach full profitability by 2027, the crash changes many plans. The incident could result in significant losses for Air India not only because all except one of the 242 passengers were killed, but also the airline may be held liable for the plane's plunge onto a medical hostel in a residential area. After the accident, Tata Sons chairman N. Chandrasekaran announced a compensation of 10 million rupees (S$148,932) to the families of each person who lost their life. He also promised to cover medical expenses of those injured and help reconstruct the BJ Medical hostel the plane fell on. The airline is suffused with nostalgia with its turbaned Maharaja mascot and delicious Indian meals, and unsmiling but efficient crew. In recent years, however, it has become a butt of passenger ridicule for persistent delays, poorly maintained planes and years of losses. Under Tata ownership, Air India's chief executive Campbell Wilson helmed a five-year intensive transformation plan beginning in 2022 to revamp an ageing and outdated fleet, upskill staff, upgrade IT systems, and create a world-class airline on a par with rivals like Emirates. Air India's losses had reduced by more than 40 per cent since the privatisation in January 2022 as it aimed to break even. It flew a total of 43.5 million passengers during the financial year April 2024 to March 2025. In April 2025, Air India announced a US$400 million (S$513.5 million) fleet upgrade programme for 106 of its 198 aircraft. This involved refurbishing seats, carpets, curtains and lavatories. The full-service carrier, which started making money in 2025, had made financial gains reportedly from cost cutting and streamlining operations, aided by lower fuel costs and a surge in passenger numbers. Sources close to the company said the airline was eyeing full profitability by 2027, once the low-cost arm of the group, Air India Express, which has been expanding its fleet, also increases its revenue. Mr Campbell , a former CEO of Scoot, had reportedly informed employees during a townhall in June that Air India was advancing towards becoming 'a self-sustaining company'. The crash changes, if not all the well-laid plans, many of them. 'We are devastated. All of us are wondering what went wrong,' an Air India pilot who has worked for over 15 years in the company told ST, requesting anonymity. Aviation expert Sanjay Lazar, chief executive of Availalaz Consultants in Mumbai, said: 'A tragedy like this strikes at the heart of an airline. It will set the company back tremendously, as crashes do. The morale of personnel and external consumer trust will have to be rebuilt.' This is the first accident of an Air India wide-body aircraft since 1985, said Mr Lazar. The last Air India hull-loss – which means an aviation accident that damages the aircraft beyond repair – was on June 23, 1985, when a London/Mumbai-bound flight from Montreal exploded due to a bomb planted by a Canadian Sikh terror group. Just 17 years old at the time, Mr Lazar had lost his entire family in the 1985 crash, after which he trained to be a pilot and worked in Air India for 38 years. 'From 1985 to 2025, there has been no hull-loss for Air India. Strong companies bounce back. Air India has a good safety record and robust systems that must be reinforced like in the past,' he told ST. Beyond the aftermath of the crash, headwinds in the form of trade tariffs imposed by the US, tensions on the India-Pakistan border and airspace closures from conflicts in other parts of the world such as the ongoing bombing of Iran by Israel remain concerns for the airline. Mr Wilson told The Hindu in May that Air India has requested a subsidy worth US$600 million annually from the government to tide it over the financial hit from the closure of Pakistan's airspace and the resultant re-routings undertaken by the airline for its west-bound flights. The airspace closure in Iran worsens this situation. While the reason for the crash is yet unknown, it could also affect the aviation sector temporarily, as passengers put off travel, fearing the worst. Relatives and hospital staff carry the body of a victim who died in an airplane crash in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, western India. PHOTO: EPA-EFE The crash of the 12-year-old 787 Dreamliner has refuelled scrutiny of Boeing, whose safety reputation began to unravel in October 2018 when a Lion Air flight operating a 737 MAX crashed due to a malfunction, killing 189 people. Just months later, in March 2019, an Ethiopian Airlines flight using the same aircraft model crashed for the same reason, killing all 157 people aboard. But until now, the 787 Dreamliner aircraft had maintained a relatively strong safety record, said aviation professional Hemanth DP. Launched in 2011, there are around 1,100 Boeing 787s in the world. Air India owns an estimated 35 of them, not including the one that crashed. Some Indian media reports said the Ministry of Civil Aviation was considering grounding Boeing 787s for a safety review. Shortly after the crash, shares of Tata Group's companies saw an increase in selling pressure on June 12. However, analysts said it was sentiment-driven and that the long-term impact of the crash may be limited only to the Tata-owned airline business, and not extend to other entities. Air India operates as a standalone entity, and any liabilities arising from the crash, be it aircraft damage, compensation or lawsuits, are expected to be covered through aviation insurance, analysts who track aviation finance and safety told ST. Shares of Singapore Airlines, which holds a 25.1 per cent stake in Air India, dropped by 1.7 per cent on the Singapore Exchange. Rohini Mohan is the India Correspondent based in Bengaluru. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Independent Singapore
7 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
100 Air India pilots to be offered the chance to work on Scoot flights
SINGAPORE: Around 100 Air India pilots will be given opportunities for work with Scoot, Singapore Airlines' low-cost brand, the Hindu Business Line reported on Jun 8 (Sunday). Campbell Wilson, Air India's CEO and managing director, has called the programme a win-win for both Air India and Scoot. The programme will be on a voluntary basis and will allow Scoot to fill vacancies. At the same time, Air India's captains and first officers will have the opportunity to train on Embraer aircraft and gain international exposure. 'Air India pilots have been offered deputation to Scoot (Singapore Airlines' low-cost airline) on a voluntary basis. Here, they will also have the opportunity to train on Embraer 19 and Boeing 787s, the budget airline flies,' tweeted Indian aviation journalist Jagriti Chandra late last month. 'We actively seek talent within and outside Singapore, focusing on attracting and retaining qualified individuals who align with our values and can contribute to Scoot's continued growth,' Hindu Business Line quoted Scoot as saying. See also Singapore Airlines reports nearly $150 million virus loss Mr Wilson joined Air India in 2022, after 26 years with Singapore Airlines. He had served as CEO of Scoot from 2011 to 2016 and again from 2020 to 2022. The CEO of Singapore Airlines, Goh Choon Phong, also spoke to Hindu Business Line, saying, 'Indian market continues to be strong, and we are optimistic about it. We are looking at how to collaborate closely with Air India.' Last year, Singapore Airlines carried more than 2.4 million travelers to and from India, with 65% of traffic flying onward or connecting from Singapore to India. The partnership between Singapore Airlines and Air India is not a new one. In November 2022, the Indian multinational conglomerate Tata Group announced that its airlines, Vistara and Air India, would merge, making it the country's largest international carrier and second-largest domestic carrier. Vistara is a joint venture between Tata and Singapore Airlines, established in 2013. The Indian conglomerate owns 51%, and SIA owns 49%. Following the completion of the merger between Air India and Vistara last year, it was reported that Singapore Airlines (SIA) held a 25.1% stake in the merged entity. 'Singapore Airlines (SIA) confirms the completion of the merger of Air India and Vistara. With this, SIA now holds a 25.1% stake in Air India. The merger reinforces SIA's multi-hub strategy and underscores its long-standing commitment to India through a direct stake in this large and rapidly growing aviation market,' SIA said in a statement at the time. /TISG Read also: SIA & Tata Sons celebrate Air India-Vistara merger
