logo
Mass. lawyer and his wife say they were handcuffed, detained for hours at Canada border: ‘It was a shock'

Mass. lawyer and his wife say they were handcuffed, detained for hours at Canada border: ‘It was a shock'

Boston Globe19-04-2025

Advertisement
Jessica Fakhry, right, poses with her sister-in-law, immigration lawyer Celine Atallah. Fakhry and her husband, Bachir Atallah, were detained at the Canadian border on Sunday for more than five hours as they were returning home to Massachusetts.
Josh Reynolds for The Boston Globe
The couple said they were led from their car to the CBP station in handcuffs, and had no idea how long they'd be in custody. Officers answered their questions with vague statements about how 'the government' needed to search them, Atallah said.
While being led down a hallway, Fakhry saw a pile of mattresses and feared they'd have to spend the night in custody.
Atallah's sister, immigration lawyer Celine Atallah, criticized what she said was 'not normal protocol' from CBP in an interview Wednesday.
'I believe CBP thinks they are above the law, but they don't have a blank check at the border,' said Celine, who has a law office in Methuen, and lives in Salem, N.H.
CBP Assistant Commissioner Hilton Beckham said Bachir Atallah's account of the couple's detainment is not accurate.
Advertisement
'The traveler's accusations are blatantly false and sensationalized,' Beckham said in a statement. 'CBP officers acted in accordance with established protocols.'
Celine Atallah said that while international travelers can be subject to more thorough secondary searches, she maintains that what happened to her brother was not 'routine security.'
A CBP spokesperson said Friday the couple was detained for less than four hours. Officials did not immediately comment on the couple's other allegations about their detention.
What happened to Bachir Atallah?
Bachir Atallah, a lawyer who became an American citizen in October 2012, was driving back from Montreal with his wife when CBP officers at the Interstate 89 border crossing in Vermont told them to get out of their car, he said. Atallah gave the officers his keys, not knowing he and his wife were about to be handcuffed, he said.
The couple were confused, but otherwise compliant as officers placed them in separate cells. But they began to worry when officers would not answer questions about why they were being held, Fakhry said.
Atallah said he reluctantly signed a form giving officers permission to search his phone and email. That was concerning, he said, because information from his legal clients must remain private.
Beckham,
in a statement Friday, said CBP officers 'worked to ensure an attorney-client privilege was respected during the electronic media search.'
Lawyer Bachir Atallah said he has been in the US lawfully since he was 14 years old. He became a US citizen in 2012.
Bachir Atallah
Sunday's detainment at the border did not feel like an isolated incident to Atallah. He was stopped three days later at Boston's Logan Airport and subjected to a secondary search before he boarded a flight to Lebanon to visit his parents.
TSA agents inspected 'every credit card and every business card' in his wallet, as well as all his other belongings one by one, Atallah said.
Advertisement
TSA's New England spokesman confirmed Atallah was 'selected for Secondary Screening' at Logan, but did not provide further details. The spokesperson said the additional screening lasted 20 minutes.
Atallah's wife and sister said they worried for his safety on Tuesday and Wednesday, while he
flew first from Boston to Istanbul, on the way to Beirut. They're even more concerned about his flight back home to the U.S. this summer, they said.
'I'm pretty sure CBP will be waiting for me,' Atallah said.
Wife was 'freezing cold' in cell
Fakhry, who got her green card four years ago and applied for US citizenship in November, said she felt like she was in a dream when she heard the click of handcuffs placed on her wrists Sunday, shortly after 4:30 p.m.
'When they did that to me, I thought, 'Oh my god, I can't believe this is happening,'' she said. 'It was a shock. I was frustrated, I was shaking.'
Bachir Atallah and Jessica Fakhry took a photo in downtown Montreal on Sunday, April 13, hours before they were taken into CBP custody at the border on their way back to Massachusetts.
Jessica Fakhry
Once in the cell, she was 'freezing cold,' shaking, and felt light-headed. She said
CBP officers had taken her jacket and wouldn't give it back. When she asked for something to keep her warm, an officer gave her a yellow plastic tablecloth, she said.
The couple's detainment comes a month after New Hampshire resident and green card holder Fabian Schmidt was
Husband's blood pressure spiked while he was detained
Like Schmidt, who was
Advertisement
An emergency medical responder came to the CBP station, took Atallah's blood pressure, and gave him an EKG test, which reported an abnormality, Atallah said.
Because Atallah's blood pressure of 153/112 meant he was at risk for a stroke, CBP officers said he could go to a hospital, according to documents — but would be returned to their custody afterward.
'I said, 'No, I'm not going, I don't want to elongate the process,'' he said.
During the five and a half hours Atallah and his wife were in custody, CBP officers did not tell him what they were looking for, even as they searched his phone,
he said.
'I got the impression that if I don't give them access to what they wanted to look for, they'd hold me indefinitely,' he said.
Detainment was not 'normal,' sister says
Celine Atallah said the family plans to file a lawsuit to ensure what happened on Sunday at the border doesn't happen again, especially given her brother's busy travel schedule.
Celine said it is normal for CBP officers to conduct secondary, in-depth searches, but she says what happened to her brother and his wife went beyond that.
'There was no reason for them to treat him that way, have all these officers around him like he's some sort of criminal,' said Celine. She described CBP's actions as 'harassment.'
Bachir Atallah said he supports President Trump's goals to deport undocumented immigrants who have criminal records. Those policies make the US safer, Atallah said. Still, he believes the way he and Fakhry were treated violated their rights.
'You just took my freedom away for five and a half hours,' he said of his experience at the border.
Advertisement
'I am a Republican, I believe in family values,' Atallah said. 'When it comes to immigration, I think maybe the intent is right, but they're handling things completely wrong.'
Claire Thornton can be reached at

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Valley father detained by ICE while driving to work sparks protest for release
Valley father detained by ICE while driving to work sparks protest for release

Yahoo

time41 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Valley father detained by ICE while driving to work sparks protest for release

Around 100 people gathered in central Phoenix on June 8, 2025, at an event organized by the Phoenix chapter of the Party for Socialism and Liberation to call for the release of Joel Gutierrez, an undocumented man taken by ICE agents last week, and to protest Trump's immigration policies. Photo by Emily Holshouser | Arizona Mirror In the early hours of June 4, 48-year-old Joel Gutierrez was driving his coworker to a home they were renovating in Phoenix when their work van was stopped by U.S. Immigration Customs and Enforcement officers. Agents pulled Gutierrez and his coworker out of the van and arrested them. ICE agents scattered Neatly stacked papers and a packed lunchbox throughout the car. Gutierrez was taken to the Central Arizona Florence Detention Center, where he remains today. His coworker was arrested, too. Both men are undocumented. On June 8, around 100 people gathered at University Park on Van Buren Street just west of downtown Phoenix at an event organized by the Phoenix chapter of the Party for Socialism and Liberation to call for Gutierrez's release and protest the Trump administration's sweeping and aggressive immigration policies. 'My dad is honestly the best person there is,' Gutierrez's daughter, Denise, 19, told the crowd. 'He is the sweetest, most understanding person, and he truly does not deserve to be where he is right now.' SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX Gutierrez's detention comes at a time when the Trump administration has ordered ICE to boost deportation numbers by focusing their efforts on largely law-abiding immigrants, which has spurred a slew of workplace raids and targeting people seeking relief in immigration courts. During his campaign, President Trump promised to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, calling it the 'largest domestic deportation operation in American history.' The administration's plans have ramped up throughout the year, with a new plan taking shape in recent weeks to deport 'the worst first' in the first 100 days of the Trump administration. Since January, according to federal data, ICE has arrested over 26,000 people. The agency says 995 of those arrests have taken place in Phoenix. Across the country, ICE has carried out raids at workplaces and immigration courts. On June 7, a workplace raid at a Home Depot in the working-class Los Angeles enclave of Paramount set off a weekend of intense and chaotic protests. Trump has since seized operational control of the California National Guard and deployed 4,000 soldiers to the city, as well as several hundred U.S. Marines. Denise said that her father believes he was profiled because of his work van. Joel told his family later that he noticed ICE officers following him before he was stopped. 'He has one of those big white vans that you see everywhere, and they simply stopped him because they saw the van,' Denise said at the protest. 'They assumed that there's probably someone in there who doesn't have legal status.' Gutierrez unsuccessfully attempted to earn citizenship several times, but remained in the country with his family, Denise said. Joel came to the United States from Mexico with Denise's mother in 2000, when they were in their early 20s. They settled in Mesa to start a life. Joel and his wife had four children — two immigrated from Mexico, but two were born here and are United States citizens. Their youngest is a nine-year-old boy. 'My nine-year-old little brother and my dad are very close, because that's his only boy,' Denise said. 'They play soccer almost every day, and right now, this is a situation that we never thought we would have to live in.' The crowd marched from the park to the Arizona Capitol building, Phoenix Police Department cars and motorcycles lurking around every corner. The group eventually arrived back at the park. 'I'm just sick and tired of seeing my people be taken away for no reason,' said Marilyn Ramos, 24, as she marched with the crowd. 'I feel like, if they're really criminals, why are they going after people out at the workplace? … It's giving Hitler, and I don't like that.' As these raids ramp up in other cities including Miami, Chicago, and New York, local advocacy groups are concerned that Phoenix could be next. On Monday, several local groups announced that ICE raids were planned in Phoenix throughout the week, and warned immigrant communities to be on alert. 'Community organizations have received credible information that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) may be conducting mass workplace raids in the Phoenix area this week,' Puente Arizona said in a written statement. 'Particularly targeting businesses that have previously been audited for employing undocumented workers.' In January, Trump signed an executive order that greatly expanded the expedited removal process, reviving a 2019 program that fast-tracked deportations for immigrants, oftentimes without any due process. In late May, ICE agents detained more than a dozen people outside the Phoenix immigration court across two days as part of the Trump administration's crackdown. Denise said on Sunday that Joel is being held in an overcrowded facility with poor treatment and little food. 'They're moving my dad to a different part of the facility because of how insanely crowded it is,' Denise told the Mirror on June 9. 'They don't get any time outside. It's really terrible, and that's what makes it really hard on my dad.' There is no publicly available data on the Florence facility's capacity and current population. A spokesperson for the U.S. Department of Homeland Security did not answer emailed questions. Several of the rally-goers spoke about their personal experiences with immigration and expressed deep concern that Phoenix could be targeted. 'This system is barbaric, yet it is exactly how it's designed,' said Dania Duran, an organizer with PSL. 'Both Republicans and Democrats have demonized immigrants as a tool to incite fear in people and a tool to make themselves richer.' A GoFundMe for the family has raised over $5,000, which will go towards legal fees and paying bills that Joel was primarily responsible for. 'My sisters and I have been doing everything possible to kind of get our story out there, because this really is terrible, and it's not just happening to our family,' Denise said. 'It's happening all over the United States right now, to multiple families, people with different stories than ours.' Phoenix-area immigration advocacy groups were advising community members on Tuesday to avoid areas that may be targeted for deportations and to know their legal rights. 'We are asking people at risk of deportation to stay away from places where confirmed raids are happening and other high risk areas if they can,' said Casey Clowes, a spokesperson for the nonprofit advocacy group Progress Arizona in a written statement. 'We are calling on allies to report ICE activity to the Phoenix Hotline by calling or texting (480) 506-7437 and get trained in Migra Watch so you can safely and peacefully bear witness and document ICE's actions.' SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE

DHS releases video of agents arresting suspect who allegedly assaulted border patrol officer
DHS releases video of agents arresting suspect who allegedly assaulted border patrol officer

Fox News

timean hour ago

  • Fox News

DHS releases video of agents arresting suspect who allegedly assaulted border patrol officer

Video shows the moment the Department of Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) arrested "a violent rioter" in Los Angeles accused of punching a U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officer. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) shared video of the chaos on X, showing two HSI vehicles blocking a white sedan before officers got out with guns drawn. "This was no hit and run," DHS wrote. "This was a targeted arrest of a violent rioter who punched a CBP officer." DHS said HSI tried to arrest Christian Damian Cerno-Camacho for the assault, and he attempted to flee in the vehicle. Cerno-Camacho was arrested and taken into custody, the video shows. "Our officers are facing a 413% increase in assaults against them as they put their lives on the line to arrest murder[er]s, rapists and gang member[s]," DHS said. "[DHS] Secretary [Kristi] Noem's message to the LA rioters is clear: you will not stop us or slow us down. ICE and our federal law enforcement partners will continue to enforce the law. And if you lay a hand on a law enforcement officer, you will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law." Riots across Los Angeles erupted Friday, when U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents conducted operations targeting criminal illegal aliens at businesses across the city. About 45 people were arrested in several locations, including two Home Depot stores, a store in the fashion district and a doughnut shop. Among those arrested was 49-year-old Cuong Chanh Phan, an illegal alien from Vietnam with a criminal history that includes a conviction for second-degree murder. Phan was convicted of shooting up a high school graduation party after a dispute, killing an 18-year-old and a 15-year-old. Seven others were injured in the shooting, according to DHS. The FBI also announced it was looking for Elpidio Reyna after he allegedly assaulted a federal officer during one of the anti-ICE demonstrations in Los Angeles. Reyna was allegedly captured on video throwing rocks at law enforcement vehicles on Alondra Boulevard in Paramount, California, resulting in an injury to a federal officer and damage to government vehicles. DHS did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.

CIA analyst who leaked Israel strike plan sentenced to three years
CIA analyst who leaked Israel strike plan sentenced to three years

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

CIA analyst who leaked Israel strike plan sentenced to three years

A former CIA analyst who leaked classified documents about Israel's plans to strike Iran has been sentenced to 37 months in prison. Asif William Rahman, 34, pleaded guilty in January to two counts of willful retention and transmission of national defence information under the Espionage Act. Authorities say that, using his high-level security clearance, Rahman printed, photographed and sent out top secret documents. They later ended up being circulated on social media. Israel carried out air strikes on Iran last October, targeting military sites in several regions, in response to the barrage of missiles launched by Tehran weeks earlier. "For months, this defendant betrayed the American people and the oaths he took upon entering his office by leaking some of our Nation's most closely held secrets," John Eisenberg, assistant attorney general for national security, said in a press release. In October 2024, documents appearing to be from a Department of Defense agency were published on an Iranian-aligned Telegram account. The documents, bearing a top-secret mark, were viewable between the Five Eyes intelligence alliance, made up of the US, Britain, Canada, New Zealand and Australia. The leaked documents are also said to have contained the US' assessment of Israeli plans ahead of the strike on Iran and the movements of military assets in preparation. One referred to Israel's nuclear capabilities, which have never been officially acknowledged. When asked about the leak, former President Joe Biden said he was "deeply concerned". Israel ended up carrying out those air strikes later in the month, targeting military sites in several regions in response to missiles fired by Tehran weeks prior. Rahman, who worked abroad, was arrested by the FBI in Cambodia and brought to the US territory of Guam to face charges.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store