Soccer-European giants humbled as Club World Cup script gets rewritten
Soccer Football - FIFA Club World Cup - Group B - Paris St Germain v Botafogo - Rose Bowl Stadium, Pasadena, California, U.S. - June 19, 2025 Botafogo's John and Alexander Barboza celebrate after the match as Paris St Germain's Khvicha Kvaratskhelia looks dejected REUTERS/Daniel Cole
PHILADELPHIA (Reuters) -The script seemed predetermined - Europe's football giants would cruise through FIFA's expanded Club World Cup against grateful opponents from distant continents. Instead, the tournament has delivered a plot twist, leaving the game's traditional powerhouses scrambling for explanations.
With Porto and Atletico Madrid eliminated in the group stage and European sides winning just two of seven matches against South American opposition, the continent's expected dominance has failed to materialise.
"We knew beforehand that the tournament came at the end of a long season, whereas for the South Americans it's right in the middle, when they are peaking," lamented Atletico Madrid's Diego Simeone after his side's early exit.
The exhaustion narrative has become familiar, with players' union FIFPro Europe pursuing legal action against FIFA over the punishing calendar. There's also America's scorching summer heat. But South Americans, however, reject these explanations entirely.
"Having played for many years in Europe, I don't buy this end-of-season fatigue narrative," said Flamengo's Filipe Luis, who played under Simeone at Atletico, after a commanding 3-1 win over Chelsea.
"We came here seeing every game as a final. That makes a big difference."
Statistics further complicate the European exhaustion argument. Among participating clubs, four Brazilian teams, including Botafogo, top the list for matches played in the last year, each surpassing 70 games.
Botafogo, who qualified from Group B along with Paris St Germain at the expense of Atletico Madrid, played 18 more matches than their Spanish opponents during the same period.
While Brazilian teams had a month's rest before their domestic season began, their packed schedules have long been a source of complaint in South America.
Brazilian great Zico criticised European attitudes, saying, "We are seeing some European figures act like they own football and that must stop. As soon as they see things not going well, they start making lots of excuses."
'They seem unable to play when faced with adversity. The heat is the same for everyone and we have been playing forever the previous version of the Club World Cup at the end of our season. So why is it now a problem?'
The Club World Cup in its previous format was played in December.
Not all European managers have blamed external factors for their teams' struggles. Juventus coach Igor Tudor said he didn't see "any signs of fatigue" in his squad, while PSG boss Luis Enrique, despite a surprise 1-0 loss to Botafogo, praised the tournament.
"I think the concept is brilliant. It's a celebration of all football," Luis Enrique said. "It's no surprise for me. It's nice to see teams from different parts of the world."
The tournament, traditionally dominated by European clubs, has seen South American teams embrace the opportunity to challenge the hierarchy and as matches continue under the scorching summer heat, the event has evolved into a genuine global competition.
(Reporting by Fernando KallasEditing by Toby Davis)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
14 minutes ago
- The Sun
Extreme heat and storms disrupt Club World Cup matches
SCORCHING temperatures and severe weather are disrupting the Club World Cup, offering a preview of potential challenges for the 2026 World Cup. As a heatwave grips the eastern United States, teams are adjusting tactics to cope with extreme conditions. Borussia Dortmund kept substitutes in the dressing room during the first half of their match against Mamelodi Sundowns in Cincinnati to avoid exposure to blistering sunlight. Chelsea coach Enzo Maresca shortened training in Philadelphia, where temperatures hit 99°F (37.2°C). Dortmund's Niko Kovac highlighted the weather's impact, stating, 'This tournament will be decided by the team that adapts best to these conditions.' Teams are using ice baths, cold towels, and cooling breaks to manage heat stress. A recent study in the *International Journal of Biometeorology* warned that 14 of 16 host cities for the 2026 World Cup frequently exceed safe heat thresholds. Researchers urged scheduling matches outside peak afternoon heat. Lightning delays have also plagued the tournament. Boca Juniors vs. Auckland City became the fifth match paused due to US safety protocols, which halt play if lightning is within 10 miles (16.1 km). Benfica's game against Auckland faced a two-hour interruption. National Weather Service expert Ben Schott noted that current conditions, though record-breaking, are typical for summer. 'People should prepare for similar weather next year,' he said. Improved forecasting since 1994 allows earlier storm detection, but Schott emphasized that thunderstorms remain common in North America.
The Sun
22 minutes ago
- The Sun
Messi faces PSG reunion as Miami eyes Club World Cup upset
INTER MIAMI coach Javier Mascherano believes Lionel Messi's difficult stint at Paris Saint-Germain could motivate him ahead of their Club World Cup clash. Miami, surprise qualifiers from Group A, now face the European champions in Atlanta on Sunday. Messi joined Miami after two underwhelming seasons at PSG, where he admitted struggling to adapt. 'I spent two years that I didn't enjoy. I wasn't happy on a day-to-day basis,' Messi said. Mascherano hopes those memories will push the Argentine superstar. 'It's clear that it would better for us if he was angry,' he told ESPN. The eight-time Ballon d'Or winner will encounter a transformed PSG under Luis Enrique, who coached Messi and several Miami players at Barcelona. Left-back Jordi Alba praised Enrique, calling him 'the best' in man-management. 'I'll give him a hug, but when the ref blows the whistle, we'll try to beat him,' Alba said. Luis Suarez, another former Barcelona star, credited Enrique for shaping his career. 'He taught me how to adapt to new roles,' Suarez said. Mascherano, meanwhile, acknowledged his friendship with Enrique but emphasized Miami's underdog mentality. 'We need a perfect game to have a chance,' he said.
New Straits Times
22 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
Extreme heat, storms take toll at Club World Cup
LOS ANGELES, UNITED STATES: Furnace-like heat and the threat of thunder and lightning are wreaking havoc at the Club World Cup – and more of the same is likely at the 2026 World Cup. With a brutal heatwave blanketing swathes of the eastern United States, adapting to the weather has become a key focus for coaches and players. Borussia Dortmund took the unusual step of leaving their substitutes in the dressing room for the first half of their game against Mamelodi Sundowns in Cincinnati, rather than have them sitting on the bench in blazing sunshine. Chelsea coach Enzo Maresca meanwhile cut short his team's training session in Philadelphia on Monday as the City of Brotherly Love baked in temperatures of 99 degrees Fahrenheit (37.2 degrees Celsisu). Dortmund coach Niko Kovac, meanwhile, said the weather could ultimately shape the destiny of the tournament. "I think that this tournament will be decided not by the best team, but the team that can adapt to these weather conditions the best. They will probably win this tournament," Kovac said. While cooling breaks midway through each half have become standard during the tournament, Dortmund, like other teams, are taking extra steps to mitigate the brutal heat and humidity. "Our boys are very well taken care of by our doctors and the medical staff," Kovac said. "We have very cold towels. We put them in ice baths. The boys also need to cool down their legs and their feet in cold water and ice baths." The experience of the Club World Cup is likely a preview of what can be expected at next year's men's World Cup in the United States, Canada and Mexico. A recent study published by the International Journal of Biometeorology warned of the risk posed by extreme heat at the tournament for players and spectators, citing climate change as a cause of "extreme heat" events that were "more frequent and intense." The study concluded that 14 of the 16 host cities being used for the 2026 World Cup experienced temperatures that frequently exceeded the commonly accepted safe thresholds for wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT) – a widely used measure for heat stress. The study argued for games to be scheduled outside of the afternoon windows when conditions were typically at their most fierce. In addition to the brutal heat and humidity, teams at the Club World Cup have also had to deal with matches being halted due to the threat of lightning. On Tuesday, Boca Juniors' game against Auckland City became the fifth match of the tournament to experience a lengthy delay due to public safety regulations used in the United States that mandate play is halted whenever lightning is within 10 miles (16.1 kilometres) of a stadium. A weather delay in Benfica's game against Auckland led to an interruption in play of nearly two hours. National Weather Service official Ben Schott, who advises FIFA and the US World Cup taskforce for 2026, says the kind of weather affecting the ongoing competition is not out of the ordinary, and said teams and fans next year should plan accordingly. "Nothing that we're seeing right now is unusual even though we are breaking records," Schott told AFP. "Most of the eastern United States is breaking records, and then that happens almost every summer. To expect something similar next year as a possibility is something that people should prepare for if you're going to come and enjoy the games." While roasting heat was an issue when the United States last hosted the World Cup finals in 1994, no games at that tournament were halted by storm warnings. That is due to increasingly sophisticated forecasting technology, Schott said. "We're at a point now where we can start to see things almost a week in advance and predict them pretty accurately, as compared to 15-20 years ago," Schott said. "The advances in meteorology since we last had the World Cup here in 1994 have been substantial." Schott said thunder and lightning were "par for the course" in several regions of North America. "This is pretty typical for United States weather for this time of the year," Schott said. "We get a lot of moisture that pumps in from the Gulf of Mexico, and they get the afternoon thunderstorms pop up. "So as we move towards World Cup 2026, things that we're seeing right now would be quite typical to be seen again."
