Dismissed: Homeless woman cited for street camping while in labor cleared of charge
This story has been updated with information from a motion to dismiss and a comment from a prosecutor in the Jefferson County Attorney's Office.
A Louisville judge has dismissed charges against the woman Louisville Metro Police cited for unlawful street camping while in labor.
The incident, first reported by Kentucky Public Radio in December, garnered national attention and public uproar.
In body camera footage, the woman told Lt. Caleb Stewart her water had broken. Stewart called in an ambulance for her but also proceeded to charge her with unlawful camping for having a mattress beneath an overpass.
'Am I being detained?' she asked at one point while trying to walk away.
'Yes, you're being detained,' Stewart said. 'You're being detained because you're unlawfully camping.'
Jefferson District Court Judge Karen Faulkner dismissed the woman's case during a large docket of unlawful street camping citations in court on Wednesday.
Susan Ely with Jefferson County District Court said there are plans to have a specialized docket for unlawful street camping citations once a month, with some exceptions. There will also be service providers available, she said. Providers were present at the docket on Wednesday.
Kentucky legislators passed a law making unlawful street camping offenses a Class B misdemeanor during the 2024 General Assembly. Since the law took effect in July, police have issued more than 40 citations in Louisville and its suburbs, with most issued in the city's downtown area.
Public defenders representing the pregnant woman called the street camping law "unconstitutional" in their motion to dismiss the charges.
"The explicit criminalization of not just sleeping outdoors, but also the mere intent to sleep or 'camp,' which is defined broadly enough to encompass sitting on a mattress, encourages exactly this sort of cruel and arbitrary enforcement," the motion reads. "It is an unconstitutional exercise of the state's police power."
The attorneys requested the court declare the street camping law unconstitutional. However, when the charge was dismissed, it also stopped the woman's challenge of the law.
Erin White, the criminal division director for the Jefferson County Attorney's Office, agreed to the motion to dismiss without objection.
"We take each case individually, we evaluate the evidence, and we believe the just decision was to dismiss this case," she said.
When the pregnant woman's story first came out in December, the Louisville Metro Police Department said it supported its officers using their discretion.
"We support our officers in using discretion and the information available to them at the time in making decisions," an LMPD spokesperson wrote in a statement to the media. "We also understand everyone may not agree with those decisions, but we are committed to being transparent in communicating and explaining processes and policy to the community."
Later, Chief of Police Paul Humphrey told WAVE-TV that an "error" was made in issuing the woman a citation.
"Lieutenant Stewart's reasoning was he felt like she was using a medical condition to get out of enforcement action, shows after the fact that she wasn't," he said. "That's an error that was made based on sound reasoning. It just happened to be wrong."
Reporter Marina Johnson contributed. Reach reporter Eleanor McCrary at EMcCrary@courier-journal.com or at @ellie_mccrary on X, formerly known as Twitter.
This article originally appeared on Louisville Courier Journal: Street camping charge against pregnant Kentucky woman dismissed
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Off-duty Louisville Metro Police officer arrested in Hardin County for DUI
A Louisville Metro Police officer has been placed on paid administrative leave after being arrested for allegedly driving a motorcycle while intoxicated in Hardin County. An arrest citation shows that Kenneth Lawrence, 31, of Rineyville, was arrested by Kentucky State Police June 4. He is charged with a DUI, improper display of registration plates and failure to notify the proper departments of an address change. Lawrence, who was off-duty at the time of his arrest, was driving along Dixie Highway on a motorcycle when KSP conducted a traffic stop. He had allegedly been driving with an expired registration plate and told troopers that he had just purchased the vehicle. The LMPD officer informed KSP he was wearing his off-duty gun and was able to provide proof of registration and insurance for the motorcycle. At that time, the arresting trooper was able to smell alcohol on Lawrence and asked him if he had been drinking. Lawrence said he had a few beers but stopped three to four hours before driving and he agreed to a field sobriety test. KSP said in the arrest citation that Lawrence could not maintain his balance and forgot to look at his toes during the one leg stand test. Troopers believed Lawrence was "near the legal limit" and he was asked to do a breathalyzer test. After several minutes, Lawrence refused and he was arrested. While arresting Lawrence, KSP asked if his address remained the same as on his driver's license. He provided a different address and said he had been living there for more than a month. Lawrence was eventually taken to the Radcliff Police Department, where officials said his mouth was "visually inspected for any foreign substances." He also agreed to a breathalyzer test about an hour and a half after the traffic stop, blowing a 0.077, which is just below the legal limit. Lawrence declined a blood test and was taken to the Hardin County Detention Center on several charges. Jail records further show that Lawrence was released at around 8 a.m. June 5. LMPD spokesperson Matthew Sanders said the agency has launched an internal investigation. Lawrence is set to make his first court appearance June 25. More: After Mother's Day visit, Louisville woman says LMPD officer dragged her from her car Reach Marina Johnson at This article originally appeared on Louisville Courier Journal: Off-duty LMPD officer arrested in Hardin County for DUI
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Highlands to see increased LMPD patrols after Memorial Day weekend crowd shuts down street
Louisville Metro council member Ben Reno-Weber is promising changes to policing habits in the Highlands neighborhood after hundreds of people swarmed Bardstown Road near Grinstead Drive early May 25, blocking traffic and causing disturbances in the area. In a May 29 news release, Reno-Weber condemned the group's activity, which resulted in Louisville Metro Police having to clear the street. "The behavior we witnessed by groups of people in our district this weekend was completely unacceptable," the statement reads. "Blocking traffic, preventing emergency vehicles from passing through and disturbing neighbors trying to sleep is not how we celebrate a holiday weekend in the Highlands." LMPD received a call reporting the crowd and people doing burnouts in the street at around 3:20 a.m., spokesperson John Bradley said. When officers arrived, they found several hundred people in the vicinity fully blocking the area. A Facebook video shows people surrounding a car with a man standing up through the sunroof, saying, 'We can't move.' The group dispersed willingly when police arrived and no violence occurred, Bradley said. The road was cleared by 4:10 a.m. Many bars surround the area where the crowd broke out, including Highlands Tap Room, Chill Bar Highlands, Atomic Sound Club & Game Yard and The Hub Louisville, some of which are open as late as 4 a.m. on the weekends. "We welcome everyone to enjoy the Highlands for its legendary hospitality, amazing food, and great vibe, but we expect that enjoyment to be responsible and respectful," Reno-Weber said in his statement. Reno-Weber said he is working with LMPD to assign a detail squad to Bardstown Road on Friday and Saturday nights to "saturate the area during times when large gatherings are most likely." LMPD announced at a Highlands Commerce Guild meeting that the department will be taking additional steps to increase police presence and deter crime in the Highlands neighborhood, including closing and limiting access to some parking lots, installing more surveillance cameras and working directly with local business owners to prevent trespassing. LMPD said it encourages business owners affected by local disturbances to file a Trespass Enforcement Request Form, which authorizes officers to address trespassing without an on-site complaint. 'We have seen a significant drop in crime and revival of business in this area over the last two years by focusing on hot spots, partnering with neighbors, and working closely with LMPD and [Alcoholic Beverage Control],' Reno-Weber said in the release. 'Hopefully this incident is the spark we need to take that to a new level.' Residents and businesses are encouraged by LMPD to report suspicious activity to 574-LMPD (5673) or online. Reach reporter Molly Gregory at msgregory@ This article originally appeared on Louisville Courier Journal: Bardstown Road incident sparks action from Metro Council, LMPD
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Legislative immunity is an old concept gaining new notoriety
The National Conference of State Legislatures said most state constitutions contain similar immunity from arrest provisions. (Photo from Indiana State Archives) Many Hoosiers recently learned that Indiana has an immunity statute that protects lawmakers from some arrests during the legislative session. The reaction has been surprise and frustration. One social media user posted, 'How have we gotten to the point in this state where our elected leaders are above the law? This is pure insanity & would NEVER be acceptable for the average citizen.' Another reader responded, 'Are they immune from common sense too?' So, I thought I would delve into the provision and explain why it exists and how often it's used. State Sen. Mike Bohacek was pulled over for suspected drunk driving in January and recorded a blood-alcohol content of 0.238%. But the Michiana Shores Republican wasn't charged until this week due to the legislative immunity provision. The first important fact is that no modern-day lawmaker created this exemption, and it basically mirrors a similar provision for federal lawmakers. The National Conference of State Legislatures said most state constitutions contain similar provisions. The state's prohibition is found in Article 4, Section 8 of the Indiana Constitution. 'Senators and Representatives, in all cases except treason, felony, and breach of the peace, shall be privileged from arrest, during the session of the General Assembly, and in going to and returning from the same; and shall not be subject to any civil process, during the session of the General Assembly, nor during the fifteen days next before the commencement thereof.' Indiana's current Constitution was adopted in 1851 with numerous amendments since then. But this portion goes back as far as the state's 1816 constitution before Indiana became a state. Then it was under Article 3. SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE For a long time, there was no definition of breach of the peace in Indiana code but lawmakers in 2021 added one: 'breaking or disturbing the public peace, order, or decorum by any riotous, forcible, or unlawful proceedings, including fighting or tumultuous conduct.' The federal immunity provision is almost exact. Some historical texts indicate the language was created so that lawmakers weren't blocked from being able to vote on a matter or otherwise participate in proceedings. In his Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story said this: 'When a representative is withdrawn from his seat by a summons, the people whom he represents, lose their voice in debate and vote, as they do in his voluntary absence. When a senator is withdrawn by summons, his state loses half its voice in debate and vote, as it does in his voluntary absence. The enormous disparity of the evil admits of no comparison. The privilege, indeed, is deemed not merely the privilege of the member, or his constituents, but the privilege of the house also.' The Supreme Court of the United States has interpreted the provision to apply to all crimes, but Indiana has generally seen it used in cases of misdemeanors. Bohacek's case is almost identical to one from 1992 when then-Rep. Keith Bulen was pulled over for drunk driving in January. Police also didn't arrest him due to the immunity clause and he was charged weeks later after session ended. Similar to Bohacek, Bulen refused the breathalyzer test and said a prescribed medicine made him groggy. But Bulen's incident resulted in him hitting an off-duty police officer's car. Bulen's case, though, was not hidden from public view at the time. He was eventually acquitted. In 2002, two northwest Indiana lawmakers — Reps. Charlie Brown and Vernon Smith — used the provision to contest their criminal case. The Gary Post Tribune reported the pair was arrested June 18 on traffic and related offenses. They protested the action and claimed they were shown a lack of respect as elected officials and residents. The legislature was in special session in Indianapolis, although the men were in Gary. They were arrested immediately but the chief of police quickly apologized. The men were charged with obstructing traffic later that year by a special prosecutor. Smith was acquitted but Brown was found guilty. If Hoosiers want to change the constitutional provision they will have to convince lawmakers to start that years-long process because Indiana doesn't allow citizen-initiated constitutional amendments or referendums. It remains to be seen what will happen to Bohacek, including any punishment by leaders of the Senate. Voters have the ultimate say on consequences at the ballot box, but they will have to wait a long time. Bohacek isn't up for election again until 2028. SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
