5 former schools in Bedok, Tampines and Pasir Ris set to be replaced by new homes, Singapore News
Five former schools in the east that have moved or been merged with other schools are set to be replaced by new homes.
Proposed amendments to the Urban Redevelopment Authority's (URA) masterplan that were published on April 24 and May 7 showed that land occupied by the five schools have been earmarked for new homes.
They are the former Bedok Town Secondary, Temasek Primary and Temasek Secondary in Bedok, Qiaonan Primary in Tampines and Siglap Secondary in Pasir Ris.
The HDB is in the midst of demolishing three of the schools, and has permission from the URA to tear down the remaining two.
Other proposed amendments to the URA Master Plan 2019 – a statutory document – showed that new homes are being planned in areas such as Sin Ming and Toa Payoh.
One of the proposed amendments is to rezone a site near Bedok MRT station from educational to residential use.
The site, at the intersection of New Upper Changi Road and Bedok South Road, was formerly occupied by Temasek Primary and Secondary schools. Both schools have moved to other sites in Bedok South and Upper East Coast.
The HDB received permission from URA to demolish the two schools in February 2023, but has yet to tear them down, according to checks by The Straits Times.
The site is about 31,500 sq m, and has been assigned a gross plot ratio of 2.8.
Gross plot ratios determine the maximum permissible floor area of developments.
Property analysts said the site can yield 1,000 to 1,100 condominium units, or 700 to 820 public flats.
Mr Nicholas Mak, chief research officer at property search portal Mogul.sg, said, however, that condo developers might not be keen on a site so close to the industrial area in Bedok South Road, which potential homebuyers might not like.
Temasek Primary used the site from 1980 to 2000 before moving to Bedok South Avenue 3, while Temasek Secondary was there from 1980 to 1999 before moving to 600 Upper East Coast Road.
About 1km away at 232 Bedok North Street 3, the HDB is demolishing the former Bedok Town Secondary School, which merged with Ping Yi Secondary in 2016.
A noticeboard at the site states that demolition works are slated for completion in the second quarter of 2025.
Based on a proposed amendment to URA's masterplan, about 22,000 sq m of the school's site will be rezoned for residential use, with a plot ratio of 2.5.
The remainder of the site has been earmarked for health and medical care use.
Analysts said the area for residential use can yield 450 to 520 flats, or 630 to 700 condo units.
Ms Christine Sun, real estate company OrangeTee Group's chief researcher and strategist, said public housing is likely to be built on the site, so that residents can have easy access to the planned medical facility next door.
Mr Mak, who noted that the medical facility could be a small community hospital, hospice, or nursing home, agreed with her assessment, as 'private residential property buyers are less inclined to purchase homes near such healthcare facilities'.
At 15 Tampines Street 11, the HDB recently finished demolishing Qiaonan Primary School, and is carrying out drainage and other land works at the site.
Qiaonan was formed by a merger between Kiau Nam School and Pulau Tekong Primary School in 1985 – the year that it started operating in Tampines.
In 2015, Qiaonan merged with Griffiths Primary School to form Angsana Primary, and the merged school took up residence at Griffiths' location in Tampines Street 22.
About 14,000 sq m of the site formerly occupied by Qiaonan has been earmarked for housing, with a plot ratio of 2.0, based on a proposed masterplan amendment published by URA on May 7.
The remainder of the site is set to be used for health and medical care.
For reasons similar to the Bedok Town Secondary plot, Mr Mak and Ms Sun believe that this plot in Tampines will be used for public housing.
Mr Mak said the site can yield 125 to 150 flats, while Ms Sun gave a higher estimate of 200 to 250 flats.
Farther north, the HDB is demolishing the former Siglap Secondary School at 10 Pasir Ris Drive 10.
Demolition works are slated for completion in the first quarter of 2026.
Siglap Secondary School used the Pasir Ris campus from 1998 until its merger with Coral Secondary in 2017 to form Meridian Secondary at 31 Pasir Ris Street 51.
A proposed amendment to the masterplan shows that Siglap Secondary's site, which is about 30,500 sq m, is slated for housing use with a plot ratio of 3.2.
Analysts said that the site can yield 700 to 900 flats, or 1,000 to 1,200 condo units.
Mr Mak noted that the proposed plot ratio of 3.2 is the highest among other housing plots in the vicinity.
He said it indicates that the Government may be planning to build flats here, as housing sites developed by HDB are typically the most densely developed, with the highest plot ratios within residential towns.
Meanwhile, analysts expect that a site in Sin Ming that is undeveloped will be used for private housing. The site, which has an area of about 4,000 sq m, is opposite Ai Tong School in Sin Ming Avenue and is around 200m from Bright Hill MRT station.
A proposed amendment to URA's masterplan published on May 7 assigned the site a plot ratio of 2.8.
Mr Mak said the site is too small to be developed by HDB, which will not be able to reap economies of scale, while Ms Sun noted that the site's size means ancillary facilities that typically come with public housing, such as playgrounds or childcare facilities, cannot be built.
They said the site can yield 120 to 150 condo units.
In Toa Payoh, the authorities are also preparing a relatively small site for housing development.
The site, now an open-air carpark bounded by Lorong 4 Toa Payoh and several HDB blocks, has an area of about 7,500 sq m.
In a proposed amendment published on May 7, the URA assigned it a plot ratio of 3.4, up from the current 3.0.
Mr Mak said it is most probable that new flats will be built on the site, given that it is surrounded by HDB blocks – some more than five decades old.
He said the site can yield 210 to 260 flats, while Ms Sun estimated that 200 to 250 flats can be built there.
She said that the rezoning indicates the authorities are trying to maximise the use of land in central Toa Payoh, which is already densely populated.
Besides new homes, latest proposed amendments to URA's masterplan published by the authority on May 9 showed that a new nursing home will be built in Dover, while a 'health and medical care development' is slated to be built in Eunos Avenue 5, near Paya Lebar MRT station.
URA said the latter facility will serve residents in the region. It will add to other medical facilities in the area, such as Eunos Polyclinic, which opened in 2022.
This article was first published in The Straits Times. Permission required for reproduction.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AsiaOne
12 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Malaysian govt-owned land in Marsiling? Residents express surprise at land acquisition for Woodlands Checkpoint extension, Singapore News
Land owned by the Malaysian government will be acquired for the extension of Woodlands Checkpoint, according to a joint press release by the Immigrations and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) and the Singapore Land Authority (SLA) on Wednesday (June 4). The plots of land to be acquired, which total approximately 0.79ha, are opposite HDB blocks 214 and 215 along Marsiling Lane and are currently covered in vegetation and unused. The first phase of the redevelopment will see an extension built at Old Woodlands Town Centre in September this year, alongside an extension of the Bukit Timah Expressway (BKE). Around 10 residents whom AsiaOne spoke to shared that they were not aware that the plots of land are owned by the Malaysian government. One of them is Marsiling resident Justin Teo, who has lived in the neighbourhood for the past year and a half. The 17-year-old student said he didn't know the plots of land even existed. Another resident, Chia, 65, observed that the area is "deserted and hardly maintained". He too, was not aware the Singapore government is in talks to acquire the two plots of land. "But I know that the HDB blocks beside them will eventually be acquired to develop ICA in the near future," he stated. In 2022, the government had announced that nine blocks in Marsiling Crescent and Marsiling Lane will be acquired to be redeveloped into an expansion of Woodlands Checkpoint. Flat owners in blocks 210 to 218, consisting of 732 affected flats, will be offered similar benefits to those under the Selective En-bloc Redevelopment Scheme (Sers) reported The Straits Times in June that year. AsiaOne understands that the redevelopment project for Woodlands Checkpoint includes both the acquired HDB blocks and the two plots of land to be acquired, although the timelines for further phases cannot yet be confirmed. Responding to queries from AsiaOne, ICA confirmed that the planned area of the redeveloped Woodlands Chekcpoint is about 95ha, including the existing Woodlands Checkpoint. ICA expansion — excitement and concern The expansion is "set to provide a long-term solution to the chronic congestion at this land crossing", according to the ICA and SLA. Under Phase 1, new automated clearance facilities for cargo vehicles, arriving cars, and arriving motorcycles will be constructed alongside the extension to BKE. Following phases will see the construction of additional clearance facilities and retrofitting the existing Woodlands Checkpoint. Teo said that he looked forward to the expansion, as it will be "easier to [travel to and from] JB" with fewer jams, adding that he travels to Malaysia with his family about thrice a year. Marsiling resident Victor Koh and other residents whom AsiaOne spoke to also expressed enthusiasm about the expansion. Speaking with AsiaOne, Koh, a 78-year-old retiree, commented that the expansion will likely be of interest to the younger generation who might be looking for good food outside of Singapore. Koh shared that during his younger days, he would often cross the border to pump petrol, back when customs regulations on fuel had yet to be enforced. "But I'm almost 80," Koh said, sharing that he has medical conditions that make travel difficult. "I know older people regularly visit JB to buy medicine." Although he agreed that the expansion would benefit those travelling for leisure, he also pointed out the importance of faster access for cargo operators and heavy vehicles. "Those things, I think, are more important, because they contribute to our GDP (gross domestic profit) and trade." Koh and Chia, however, expressed some concern over the expansion, with both highlighting the acquisition of HDB blocks in the area. While he personally isn't affected, Koh shared that his friend who is living in one of those blocks will be. "They will be offered a [new flat] nearby that's under construction; they'll [then] be assigned and given preference," Koh explained. While it was reported that these replacement units will require little to no top-ups for similar flat types, Koh shared that the units will be smaller, and there are fears among residents that they "cannot break even". Chia also wondered if the expansion will be enough to smoothen travel between Singapore and Malaysia. He elaborated: "After all, it's two countries… Malaysia and Singapore are two sovereign nations and have two different sets of processes. "Even with the RTS (Johor-Singapore Rapid Transit System Link), I don't think [the expansion] will be a game changer." [[nid:718702]] khooyihang@
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Ong Ye Kung ‘dismayed' at $52k bid to rent Tampines HDB clinic
I-Health Medical Holdings won the tender to operate the 50 sq m ground-floor unit at Block 954C Tampines Street 96 in March. ST PHOTO: ARIFFIN JAMAR SINGAPORE - Health Minister Ong Ye Kung said he was 'dismayed' at the $52,188 monthly rental bid for a general practitioner (GP) clinic in a Tampines HDB estate as it may lead to higher healthcare costs. He pointed out that going forward, bids for future HDB GP clinics will be assessed using a model that focuses less on price, and more on quality of care, he said in a Facebook post on June 4. Mr Ong said the high rental bid 'must translate to higher cost of healthcare one way or another, and negate the effort of Ministry of Health (MOH) to try to keep the cost of primary healthcare affordable'. 'More importantly, higher rental bids do not necessarily translate to the best healthcare that the community needs,' he added. I-Health Medical Holdings won the tender to operate the 50 sq m ground-floor unit at Block 954C Tampines Street 96 in March. Bidding on the unit had closed in January. Mr Andrew Chim, 37, the co-owner of I-Health Medical Holdings, had said his bid was based on the attractive attributes of the area. He pointed out that the unit is in the middle of Tampines West where there are five Build-To-Order projects with 5,000 households, as well as other upcoming developments like a new mixed-use project and a shopping mall. Mr Ong said on June 4 that the role of a GP is increasingly important as the population ages. It is also key in developing a relationship of trust with patients, and the vital link to connect patients to acute hospital care and preventative community care. MOH and HDB in May launched a new tender approach for GP clinics at the Bartley Beacon development, where quality of care will account for 70 per cent of tender evaluation and rental price will be 30 per cent. The tender closed on May 29. MOH had received proposals with rental bids significantly below that for the Tampines site, Mr Ong added. He noted that the Tampines clinic launched for tender in December 2024 and was awarded in March 2025, before tenders took on the price-quality evaluation model. The new model which will be the norm moving forward. 'It will be a meaningful shift, both in improving primary care, and ensuring greater affordability,' Mr Ong said. The $52,188 rent came to public attention on May 31 after healthcare practitioner Hisham Badaruddin took to professional networking platform LinkedIn to say this was an 'obscene' amount to pay for rent for a clinic in an HDB estate. General practitioners who run clinics in HDB estates either rent directly from the state, or from landlords who own HDB commercial units. GPs that the The Straits Times spoke to felt the $52,188 rental was too high to be sustainable. Some doctors that rented from private landlords described a volatile rental market that has seen prices rising after the pandemic. Dr Conrad Chin, who runs the E. L. Chin Family Clinic and Surgery in Clementi, said he thought the rental amount was outrageous. 'Most older doctors do not pay above $2,000 for rent. I doubt that the ($52,188) price is sustainable in the long term,' he added. Dr Wong Choo Wai, who runs two HDB clinics in Bedok and Jurong, said if rent is not sustainable the clinic will have to pass on the cost to patients. Dr Wong, who rented before buying his own units in 2009 and 2015, said the rental market has been volatile. 'When the clinic starts doing well, private landlords may jack up the rent,' he said. In 2009, the landlord for his Bedok unit asked for a 40 per cent increase in rent. As the rent 'did not make sense' for the clinic, Dr Wong bought a neighbouring unit for about $750,000. 'I'm thankful I made the decision to buy, else I will be at the mercy of the landlord,' he added. A doctor who runs a clinic in Clementi, and declined to be named, said he hopes the $52,188 rent will not trigger rent hikes as small businesses are already struggling with rentals. 'Anything over $10,000 would be difficult for me to run the clinic. As solo GPs, we don't make that kind of money to justify the rental,' he said. Parkway Shenton chief executive Tay Wee Kai said that rents at their clinics in HDB estates have increased across the board post Covid-19. 'This is partly due to inflation and also due to some landlords adopting a 'catch-up' mentality and expecting higher rent,' he said. Mr Tay added that during the Covid-19 pandemic, rents remained stagnant and even went down at some locations. Their branches in HDB estates comprise about half of their more than 30 clinics. Isabelle Liew is a journalist at The Straits Times. She covers housing issues in Singapore, with a focus on public housing. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
CNA
a day ago
- CNA
'Not trying to squeeze patients': Company that bid S$52,000 for Tampines clinic rental explains business model
SINGAPORE: Instead of trying to "squeeze" patients, building long-term relationships is key to the business model of the healthcare firm that bid S$52,188 in monthly rent for a unit in a Tampines Housing and Development Board (HDB) estate, said its co-owner. Speaking to CNA on Wednesday (Jun 4), Mr Andrew Chim, who co-owns I-Health Medical Holdings, said that when they open a clinic at the unit later this month, patients will not pay above what other general practitioners (GPs) are charging for consultations and medicine. "Rent is not commensurate with (consultation) fee," he said. "I can assure you that the total bill for different cases will be in range for other heartland clinics." The successful bid for the ground floor unit at Block 954C Tampines Street 96 had raised eyebrows in recent days, sparking conversations over rental fees and healthcare costs. "We thought that there was a number that even if HDB does not reduce the rent after three years, we will be very happy with what we get back in terms of the returns on the clinic," said Mr Chim. There have been other successful rental bids for GP clinics in HDB estates in recent times. These include a S$40,088 bid for a unit at Block 235B Tengah Garden Walk in January. Mr Chim also pointed out that in January last year, there was a successful bid for a clinic in Tampines North for S$39,938. I-Health had submitted a bid but was unsuccessful, he added. "We believe that our unit is 10 to 20 per cent better than Tampines North. We believe our unit is 10 to 20 per cent better than Tengah Garden Walk," he added. Other recent successful bids include a S$40,088 bid at Tengah Garden Walk and a S$25,388 bid at Tampines Street 64, both of which closed in January. There was also a S$25,900 bid at Champions Way in December 2024. Health Minister Ong Ye Kang said in a Facebook post that he was "dismayed" at I-Health monthly rental bid for the clinic in Tampines. "This must translate to higher cost of healthcare one way or another, and negate the effort of Ministry of Health, Singapore (MOH) to try to keep the cost of primary healthcare affordable," he added. "NOT TRYING TO SQUEEZE PATIENTS" The profitability of I-Health's clinics and the business hinges on a number of factors, including the number of cases and repeat customers, he added. "The foundation of I-Health is - we're not trying to squeeze the patients on every bill ... The philosophy is, if you take care of patients, if you take care of staff, the money will come," said Mr Chim. "Who are the best clinics in the neighbourhood? The clinics (that) have been around the longest, have the trust of the patients." The idea is to focus on patients who stay with the clinic for decades and return for annual health screenings, vaccinations and chronic disease management, said Mr Chim. "This is where we make our bread and butter – by looking after people over their entire lifetime," he said. "People come to you three times, they like you, they trust you. What happens? They shift their entire wallet share to you. So they stop going to other clinics. They only want to come to you, so that is the nature of our business." The clinic will charge patients a consultation fee of S$30 on weekday mornings, S$33 on weekday nights, and S$35 on the weekends. These prices are "benchmarked very closely" to other clinics, said Mr Chim. I-Health, which currently runs three other clinics in Singapore, plans to open its Tampines clinic between 13 and 14 hours every day, said Mr Chim. Its clinics in Bedeemer, Yishun and Serangoon are currently open about 10.5 hours every day. He added that the plan is to eventually have two doctors per shift at the Tampines site, with two to three shifts per day. Eventually, seeing 150 patients a day in total is "entirely possible". At its Bendeemer clinic, Mr Chim said that there are close to 75 to 80 patients a day. When asked whether this could result in doctors working long hours, Mr Chim said the company's doctors currently work about 43 to 48 hours a week. CONFIDENT BECAUSE OF GROUNDWORK The S$52,188 bid was one that was made after much research, said Mr Chim. There were several factors behind the decision for such a high bid, he said. "We believe that it is a rate that we can have decent ROI (return on investment)." For one, he pointed out that there is less competition in new Build-to-Order (BTO) estates due to the zoning of shops. In comparison, I-Health's other locations have between eight and 10 clinics in their areas. "Our experience is that in mature estates, competition is very high from the old doctors ... If you have been going to the same doctor for 10 years, why would you switch?" Mr Chim said that there is first-mover advantage for a clinic to establish itself in a new area, where a younger demographic is more "sensitive" to online reviews. "If your digital marketing is good, meaning that your SEO (search engine optimisation) is good, and stuff like that, it's quite easy to capture the customers," he said. "There is no barrier for them to try you out; they will search you up." Mr Chim also pointed out that the density of residential estates that the Tampines clinic could potentially serve exceeds that of other clinics. The Tampines unit is near five BTO projects. "We are extremely confident, because we've done all the groundwork. We have seen all the different units – we didn't bid for the other units. This is the best," he said. I-Health pays between S$7,000 and S$10,000 for rental for each of its three other clinics, added Mr Chim. "Different locations have different values, and the market determines the value," he said, noting that there were 13 bidders for the Tampines space – the most of all the locations listed in this particular sealed envelope tender. "The BTOs are more in line with our business model and can allow us to grow faster, much faster, in terms of patient load. With growth in patient load, we will reduce all our costs, all our overheads." When asked if I-Health's Tampines bid would result in higher rents across the board, Mr Chim said that this is not necessarily the case. He said that should landlords hike rents, there is no guarantee tenants will be able to afford it. "The risk to the landlord is extremely high for a new tenant coming in ... because they don't have the customer base and they have to burn money to get there," he added. According to Mr Chim's estimates, the Tampines clinic will be able to break even within one-and-a-half years to two years and make a "decent" monthly profit by the third year. He added that I-Health is also looking to expand to more locations, with three to four clinics a year from next year, at "top locations" in Singapore.
