logo
Muslims in Singapore know that Islam is not about ‘qabaliyyah' (tribalism) but a ‘millah' (faith) that is about justice, morality, and goodness — Hafiz Hassan

Muslims in Singapore know that Islam is not about ‘qabaliyyah' (tribalism) but a ‘millah' (faith) that is about justice, morality, and goodness — Hafiz Hassan

Malay Mail01-05-2025

MAY 1 — A mustafti is the term for a person who seeks a fatwa, or a religious opinion or ruling from a mufti who is a qualified Islamic scholar.
In simple words, a mustafti is the one who poses a question to a mufti who provides the answer. The answer is called a fatwa, which is a legal opinion or ruling that is non-binding.
Sometime in March 2017, the mustafti was an Indonesian student majoring in International Relations. The mufti was Dr Khaled Abou Al-Fadl, one of the world's leading authorities on the Shariah (Islamic law) and Islam, and a prominent scholar in the field of human rights.
He is the Omar and Azmeralda Alfi Distinguished Professor of Law at the UCLA School of Law where he teaches International Human Rights; Islamic Jurisprudence; Political Asylum and Refugee Law; The Trafficking of Human Beings: Law and Policy; Political Crimes and Legal Systems; and Muslims, Race and Law.
The question was: Does Islam allow a Muslim to vote for a non-Muslim to be in the position of governor, in a Muslim-majority country?
The mustafti explained the context of his question as follows:
Asked if a Muslim should vote for a fellow Muslim with no track record or a non-Muslim failed as the better candidate, Professor of Law at UCLA Khaled Abou Al-Fadl replied that he will choose the candidate who best serves justice as he ultimately has to answer to Allah. — Picture from X/usuliinstitute
'In the capital city of Indonesia, there is currently an election going on. And for the first time in the country's relatively young democracy, we are faced with a dilemma that we have never faced before.
'We have to choose between a candidate for a governor who is a non-Muslim and has been hailed as one of the finest (but far from perfect) candidates, and another candidate who is Muslim and has no proven record yet, but shows great potential to become a good leader.
'This situation has never happened before, that a non-Muslim candidate can be a serious challenger for the governorship of the country's capital province – the country being a Muslim majority country.'
The mustafti further explained:
'Muslims in my country are split along three lines: (1) those who feel that democracy is un-Islamic, with Islam forbidding participating in the voting process; (2) those who believes that the Quranic verse (Surah Al-Maidah: 51) forbids Muslims from voting for non-Muslims, when there are Muslim alternatives, especially in a Muslim majority country, and (3) those who are in favour of the principle of 'the greater good', believing that the Quranic verse is only applicable when it comes to war, but not when it comes to democratic processes, especially when the elected would not have the authority to intervene in the religious matters.
'So how should I position myself in this matter?' asked the mustafti.
The mufti responded to the question as follows:
'If I understand the situation correctly, the question is whether, in a democratic system in which there are Muslim candidates and non-Muslim candidates, it is permissible for a Muslim citizen to vote for or otherwise help elect the non-Muslim candidate in preference to the Muslim candidate?
'And further, I understand that your question is based on the situation in Indonesia where there is a Muslim candidate and a non-Muslim candidate for elections, and you feel that the non-Muslim candidate is more qualified or otherwise preferable to the Muslim candidate.
'I refer you to my book Rebellion and Violence in Islamic Law (Cambridge University Press 2001), especially to the portions discussing whether Muslims owe an obligation to support the just, regardless of their faith or religious affiliation, or whether they should always support a Muslim, even if the Muslim is less just or unjust.
'My position is best reflected in the treatise of the Hanafi jurist Zayn al-Din al-Malibari titled Tuhfat al-Mujahidin, where it is argued that Muslims have an affirmative duty to support what is just and what is right, and if there is a non-Muslim who is just versus a Muslim who is unjust, and similarly if there is a non-Muslim who is not corrupt versus a Muslim who is corrupt, then in my view, it is an affirmative sin to support an unjust Muslim over a just non-Muslim.
'Islam is not about qabaliyyah (tribalism). Islam is a millah (faith), a faith that is about justice, morality, and goodness.
'I must say that there are normative demands created by the nature of democratic aspiration. If Indonesians wish to live in a democratic order, then their ethical commitment must be to civic virtues; in other words, to principles of justice, equity and goodness, and not to narrow principles of tribalism, superficial identity politics and nepotism.
'Anyone [who] dares to participate in a democratic system must be honest. Either they reject democracy altogether and then they should not participate in elections and should not run as candidates because to do so while not believing in democracy is sheer hypocrisy and dissimulation, which is of course haram.
'But if they do run for elections or vote, then they implicitly accept the principles of democracy. For a democracy to work, people must commit to, as I said, civic virtues, not identity politics.
'So, when someone comes to me and says: vote for a Muslim who is unjust, corrupt or otherwise unethical, I tell them: you want me to pick loyalty to a fellow Muslim over my loyalty to Allah?
'I cannot do so in good faith as a Muslim. Even more, I believe I would ultimately have to answer directly to Allah in the Hereafter if I do so.
Dr Khaled concluded his fatwa with an advice:
'My advice to you and to all Indonesians who believe in a democratic order is to vote for the person who will best serve justice. For this person is the person who truly embodies the principles of Islam whether that person calls himself/herself a Muslim or not.'
The above fatwa and advice should guide Muslims everywhere, whether in countries where Muslims are the majority or in countries where Muslims are the minority.
Like the Muslims in Singapore.
The island republic holds a parliamentary election on May 3, the first big test for new prime minister Lawrence Wong.
I reckon that Muslims in Singapore know that Islam is not about qabaliyyah (tribalism) but a millah (faith) that is about justice, morality, and goodness.
* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Indonesia's PSI opens doors for former President Jokowi to join their leading ranks
Indonesia's PSI opens doors for former President Jokowi to join their leading ranks

The Star

time35 minutes ago

  • The Star

Indonesia's PSI opens doors for former President Jokowi to join their leading ranks

JAKARTA (Bernama): Indonesia's Solidarity Party (PSI) has declared its readiness to welcome former president Joko Widodo, also known as Jokowi, into its ranks - should he choose to join the party. The party's deputy chairman, Andy Budiman, stated in a statement that PSI considers itself Jokowi's "political home' and is prepared to receive him with open arms. "PSI was founded to support Jokowi's vision and mission for Indonesia's development,' Andy said, stating that all party members continue to champion those goals. The statement came days after Jokowi indicated he favoured joining PSI rather than accepting an offer to become chairman of the Islamic-based United Development Party (PPP). Last Friday, the former president announced at his Surakarta residence that he will not join PPP, saying many candidates are better qualified and possess the capacity and competence to lead the party. Jokowi's connection with PSI is no surprise, as his youngest son, Kaesang Pangarep, was appointed PSI chairman in September 2023, boosting the party's profile among young urban voters. Though PSI failed to surpass the four per cent parliamentary threshold in the 2024 general election, it won seats in several regional legislatures and remains a key player in Indonesian politics. -- Bernama

Respect religious sensitivities, refrain from commenting on qurban
Respect religious sensitivities, refrain from commenting on qurban

The Sun

time4 hours ago

  • The Sun

Respect religious sensitivities, refrain from commenting on qurban

BATU PAHAT: Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Religious Affairs) Senator Dr Zulkifli Hasan has reminded all parties, including celebrities, to refrain from making statements that could touch on religious sensitivities, particularly concerning the qurban ( sacrificial) ritual. He said the sacrificial ritual in Malaysia has always adhered to Islamic rulings (syarak) and is closely monitored by the relevant authorities to ensure that all slaughtering procedures are conducted in accordance with religious and legal requirements. 'I advise everyone, be it celebrities or the general public, to be cautious when making public comments. Please avoid making statements on this issue. 'The qurban ritual has been practised for a long time without controversy, and now it is suddenly being questioned. Let's not reignite this matter,' he told reporters after officiating the 'Peduli Komuniti Madani' Carnival (KAPKOM) 2025 at Kampung Orang Asli Bumiputera Dalam in Rengit, here, today. He was responding to a recent statement made by former Miss World Malaysia 2009, Thanuja Ananthan, who questioned the practice of animal slaughter during the Hari Raya Aidiladha celebrations. Zulkifli further stressed that qurban should be carried out with sincerity and in full compliance with Islamic guidelines. KAPKOM aims to engage local communities, including the underprivileged, the poor, and the Orang Asli community, in line with the aspirations of Malaysia MADANI. Activities during the event included qurban rituals, animal slaughter demonstrations and the Smart Solat Workshop.

Deputy Minister Urges Caution on Qurban Remarks
Deputy Minister Urges Caution on Qurban Remarks

The Sun

time4 hours ago

  • The Sun

Deputy Minister Urges Caution on Qurban Remarks

BATU PAHAT: Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Religious Affairs) Senator Dr Zulkifli Hasan has reminded all parties, including celebrities, to refrain from making statements that could touch on religious sensitivities, particularly concerning the qurban ( sacrificial) ritual. He said the sacrificial ritual in Malaysia has always adhered to Islamic rulings (syarak) and is closely monitored by the relevant authorities to ensure that all slaughtering procedures are conducted in accordance with religious and legal requirements. 'I advise everyone, be it celebrities or the general public, to be cautious when making public comments. Please avoid making statements on this issue. 'The qurban ritual has been practised for a long time without controversy, and now it is suddenly being questioned. Let's not reignite this matter,' he told reporters after officiating the 'Peduli Komuniti Madani' Carnival (KAPKOM) 2025 at Kampung Orang Asli Bumiputera Dalam in Rengit, here, today. He was responding to a recent statement made by former Miss World Malaysia 2009, Thanuja Ananthan, who questioned the practice of animal slaughter during the Hari Raya Aidiladha celebrations. Zulkifli further stressed that qurban should be carried out with sincerity and in full compliance with Islamic guidelines. KAPKOM aims to engage local communities, including the underprivileged, the poor, and the Orang Asli community, in line with the aspirations of Malaysia MADANI. Activities during the event included qurban rituals, animal slaughter demonstrations and the Smart Solat Workshop.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store