Should Man Utd sell Bruno Fernandes? Transfer window Q&A
BBC Sport chief football reporter Simon Stone has been answering your questions on the summer transfer window.
A suffering Man Utd fan asked: Do you think Manchester United should sell Bruno Fernandes and reinvest in a couple of players? I can't make my mind up if he is part of the problem through no fault of his own as we are so reliant on him!
Advertisement
Simon answered: Oh my goodness, where do you start with this? By some considerable distance, Fernandes is Manchester United's most effective attacking player. He is the one they rely on to create, score goals, galvanise the team and lead. Aside from that, he is a pivotal figure off the field, tries to guide young players around what it means to be a young player and the behaviours and scrutiny that entails.
If he left, it would be absolutely huge. On the negative side, I accept his approach does not help when it comes to a 'system' because if he has a flaw, it is his positional discipline, which can create massive problems for his team-mates. I actually thought Erik ten Hag found the answer when he played him as a false nine in the FA Cup final against Manchester City but Ruben Amorim is not heading down that route, so if he stays it will either be as one of two number 10s or as a holding midfielder.
Given his age and where United are, I would be inclined to sell. But, and it is a very big but, they have to buy well and so many alarm bells go off in my head when I think of that because of United's overall recent record.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Manchester United and Tottenham book passage to Europa League final
Manchester United will face Tottenham Hotspur in an all-English Europa League final. Both sides booked their place in the decider on Thursday night, earning comfortable aggregate victories in their semi-final ties. Manchester United held a 3-0 advantage over Athletic Bilbao but fell behind in the return. Mikel Jauregizar's goal gave the Spaniards a glimmer of hope but Athletic were unable to extend their advantage despite chances at Old Trafford. Mason Mount came off the bench to inspire a turnaround for the home side. Advertisement The midfielder made it back-to-back games with a brilliant equaliser, turning sharply inside the box and firing home. Casemiro and Rasmus Hojlund added late goals to make the result safe, before Mount's crowning moment. The 26-year-old fired in from near the halfway line with Julen Agirrezabala wayward after a poor clearance. It was a huge night for Mount, who has endured an injury-plagued time at Manchester United. Ruben Amorim's side will face Tottenham Hotspur in a fascinating final with plenty on the line. Leading 3-1 from the first leg, goals from Dominic Solanke and Pedro Porro earned a 2-0 win at Bodo/Glimt in the return and aggregate progress. The North Londoners have reached their first final in this competition since 1984. With both sides enduring disappointing domestic campaigns, the Europa League final offers a winner-takes-all shootout to salvage their seasons. Currently 15th and 16th in the Premier League, the winners will win silverware and a place in next season's Champions League. Advertisement Read – 📈 Power Rankings: PSG and Inter climb after famous wins See more – How Enrique and Inzaghi built Europe's best teams Follow The Football Faithful on Social Media: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube | TikTok
Yahoo
15 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Man United announce surprising third quarter profits for 2025
Manchester United have announced that they have made a profit in the third quarter fiscal results of 2025. There were fears for the company's economic situation after an interview by Sir Jim Ratcliffe in March where he claimed the club would have run out of money in December if not for his investment. Advertisement Nonetheless, United have made a strong start to the transfer window by agreeing to pay Matheus Cunha's £62.5 million release clause and offering north of £60 million for Brentford's Bryan Mbeumo. Through clever accounting, it also seems that United will not have the PSR problems that most thought they would have and that they will have more wiggle room . The club have released their quarter results on the official website and have claimed that 'the company recorded an operating profit £0.7m in the quarter compared to an operating loss of £66.2m in the third quarter of 2024. What's more, 'total revenues increased 17.4% in the quarter with increases across all three key revenue streams, driven by additional matches played in the quarter as a result of strong performance in the UEFA Europa League and high demand for the club's hospitality offering.' Advertisement Commercial revenue has seen an increase of 7.3% in the third quarter last year from £69.6 million to £74.7 million. Moreover, broadcasting revenue has grown from £37.5 million to £41.3 million, which accounts for a 10.1% growth. Matchday revenue has also seen a big jump from £29.6 million to £44.5 million owing to greater European involvement this year. Overall, The Muppetiers YouTube channel analysed that the club could actually break even this year if the current course is continued. It is claimed that fourth quarter projections could grow in broadcast, commercial and matchday revenue. To sum up, United are on course to lose a lot less money as they lost £29 million in 2023, a staggering £130 million last year but may even make a profit this year according to The Muppetiers. Advertisement United are still not totally in the clear though despite their improvements on the spreadsheet. Debt is still a concern and that will only continue to grow as United plan for an active transfer window to replenish their ailing squad. The BBC reported that around '£1.2bn has been spent on debt interest, debt repayments, dividends and fees to the Glazer family since their takeover 20 years ago.' Furthermore, the club is certainly lacking in cash flow. According to The Athletic, the cash reserves have fallen to £73.2 million. Therefore, player sales will still be essential in spite of the improving financial situation. The Muppetiers predict that the Red Devils can perhaps spend £200 million net with no issues in the transfer window but without sales, this could put the club on the precipice for next summer. Advertisement It was also reiterated that cash flow remains the biggest problem, therefore the structuring of deals over instalments is probably a greater sticking point in negotiations than overall price. All in all, United fans will hope that after months of bad press over their new owners, that finally, the club has something to be cautiously optimistic about over its financial future. Featured image by Justin Setterfield via Getty Images Follow us on Bluesky: @
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Bayern Munich Ponder €80M Raid for Man Utd, Liverpool Target With PSG Sell-on Clause
PSG sold Xavi Simons to RB Leipzig earlier this year, resulting in Liverpool and Manchester United showing serious interest in the Dutch midfielder. Moreover, the deal included a sell-on clause, meaning PSG could cash in again if Leipzig decides to move him on. According to Fabrizio Romano, Leipzig paid €80 million total—€55 million up front—and Simons signed a deal through June 2027. Still, there's no certainty he'll see out that contract in Germany. Advertisement With the summer transfer window approaching, speculation around Simons' future is heating up. CaughtOffside reports that Manchester United may have the upper hand over City in the chase to land him. Could Bayern Munich beat Liverpool for former PSG ace?Fichajes reports that Bayern Munich view Xavi Simons as a strong fit for their plans, but RB Leipzig's asking price could be a major hurdle. The Red Bull-owned club, facing the setback of missing out on European competition, has already made Simons available for transfer. Leipzig are reportedly demanding around €80 million, which has forced Bayern Munich to think carefully about whether they're ready to commit to such a significant investment. Advertisement Simons' camp is reportedly watching Bayern Munich's next steps. While the interest from the Bavarian side is serious, any deal will likely hinge on potential departures from the squad—and whether deeper-pocketed clubs decide to make a move for the talented Dutchman. Empire of the Kop recently reported that Liverpool are preparing an opening bid of around €60 million ($67.8 million) for the Netherlands international playmaker, as Arne Slot aims to boost his attack for next season. However, despite Slot's desire to make this player his first summer signing, the offer will likely fall short. RB Leipzig are reportedly holding out for closer to €80 million ($90.4 million).
