'He doesn't take no for an answer': Prosecutors give closing arguments in Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial
The prosecution in Sean "Diddy" Combs's trial made its final case Thursday, arguing the music mogul used a business "kingdom", violence, drugs and fraud to coerce women into unwanted sex acts"You've learned a lot about Sean Combs," Assistant US Attorney Christy Slavik told 12 New Yorkers on Thursday. "He's the leader of a criminal enterprise. He doesn't take no for an answer." Combs has pleaded not guilty to charges of sex trafficking, racketeering and transportation to engage in prostitution. For four hours, Ms Slavik reviewed seven weeks of evidence, accusing Combs of manipulating women into fulfilling his sexual fantasies with employees' help.
The rapper, wearing a cream sweater, watched, leaning back in his chair at the defence table, while his twin daughters and 85-year-old mother sat a few rows behind. For the racketeering charges - the allegation that Mr Combs relied on a loyal network of employees to facilitate and conceal sex trafficking and other crimes - Ms Slavik reminded jurors that they needed to find Combs committed only two crimes through his "criminal enterprise". She alleged he committed "hundreds" with the help of his employees.Among those crimes, she included drug trafficking - when his employees allegedly procured drugs for him and others - as well as arson, when prosecutors say he hired someone to blow up musician Kid Cudi's car. But the "brutal crimes at the heart of the case" were sex trafficking, Ms Slavik said, citing harrowing testimony from two of Combs' ex girlfriends, Casandra Ventura and "Jane".They had testified Combs manipulated them into participating in freak-offs - having sex with a male escort while Combs watched and filmed. Combs used repeated beatings to coerce Ms Ventura into the unwanted sex acts, Ms Slavik said - a rebuttal to the defence's main argument that Combs' domestic violence did not amount to sex trafficking. "The cloud of abuse was hanging over Cassie's head - always hovering," she said. Jurors again watched the viral 2016 video of Mr Combs beating Ms Ventura in a Los Angeles hotel hallway, attempting to drag her back to a room, allegedly after she tried to leave a freak-off. Combs kept his head down and his daughters shifted in their seats as jurors were shown the footage, played repeatedly during ther trial. "This is what happened when Cassie said no," Ms Slavik told the court. The video is particularly effective in helping prosecutors turn theoretical sex trafficking arguments into something more concrete, said Mitchell Epner, a New York-based lawyer and former prosecutor. "The government is doing a very good job saying that these particular incidents on these particular days constituted sex trafficking," he said. Ms Slavik also described other ways Combs allegedly coerced the women into unwanted sex, including "plying" them with copious amounts of drugs, and in the case of Jane, refusing to pay her rent if she did not comply. She cited texts from Jane telling the rapper she did not want to participate and that she was "in fear of losing the roof over my head". The prosecution was not there to "criminalize dysfunctional relationships" or criticize "unconventional sex lives", she told jurors. Combs' lawyers have argued he participated in a "swingers" lifestyle. "Cassie and Jane did not want to have sex with escorts while the defendant watched," Ms Slavik said. The government's summation did what it needed to do, said Anna Cominsky, associate professor at New York Law School. "They have marshaled the evidence - walked the jury through their case and told them the significance of each piece of evidence."The 12 jurors could begin deliberations on Combs' fate as soon as Friday. His lawyers are set to give closing arguments then, after which the judge will instruct the jurors on its deliberations.Earlier this week, Combs' legal team rested its case after about 20 minutes, introducing text messages from Jane, but calling no witnesses. Combs faces a maximum sentence of life in prison if convicted of the most serious charges of sex trafficking and racketeering.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
11 minutes ago
- The Guardian
The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood audiobook review – a puzzle waiting to be decoded
It's 25 years since the publication of The Blind Assassin, Margaret Atwood's intricately plotted, multi-narrative novel which led to her first Booker prize win. Blending romance, pulpy sci-fi and family drama, it opens with octogenarian Iris Chase Griffen recalling the moment she was told her sister, Laura, had driven off a bridge. The police inform her that two people witnessed Laura deliberately swerve off the road. Though Iris believes this to be true, she insists to the officers that it was an accident. We go on to hear about Iris's privileged upbringing and marriage of convenience to Richard Griffen, the wealthy owner of a button factory, and her estrangement from her granddaughter with whom she hopes to reconcile. The book also contains excerpts from Laura's posthumously published novel which features clandestine romantic encounters between an unnamed man – seemingly a fugitive – and a wealthy woman. During their trysts, they concoct a wild fable about life on a distant planet. All this is interspersed with newspaper items reporting on the lives of the Chases and Griffins over 60 years. This is one of a series of new audio recordings of Atwood novels made exclusively with Canadian actors; others include Alias Grace, Cat's Eye, The Robber Bride and the Oryx and Crake trilogy. The Blind Assassin comes with three narrators: Emma Love reads the novel-within-a-novel; David Attar delivers the newspaper reports; and Jennifer Higgin is the inscrutable, complex Iris whose actions are a puzzle to be decoded. 'You want the truth of course,' she says, addressing the listener. 'You want me to put two and two together. But two and two doesn't necessarily get you the truth.' Available via Little, Brown Audio, 23hr 2min When the Going Was GoodGraydon Carter, WF Howes, 12hr 29minThe former Vanity Fair editor documents his star-studded career in magazine publishing. Read by the author. Missing White WomanKellye Garrett, Simon & Schuster Audio, 11hr 59minAriel Blake narrates this thriller in which a woman wakes up during a romantic weekend break to find a body in her holiday rental and her boyfriend nowhere to be found.
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Shocking new twist in 'Pokemon Go' killing of baseball star Calvin Riley... nine years after unsolved shooting
The FBI has released a new sketch of a second person of interest in the unsolved 2016 killing of college baseball star Calvin Riley. Riley, 20 was gunned down in San Francisco on the night of August 6, 2016, while he was playing the video game, Pokemon Go, with a friend. His loved ones said he was struck from behind. His friend heard the shot and saw the 20-year-old fall to the ground. Riley was a rising star for the San Joaquin Delta College Mustangs, who dreamed of playing for the Red Sox. But his killing has remained a mystery for the past nine years. Earlier this week, however, federal investigators revealed the new composite drawing in the hope that those responsible can finally be found. It shows a bearded man with glasses. Riley's father, Sean Riley, paid tribute to the authorities and told KTVU that he hopes this represents a turning point in the investigation. 'They've done an outstanding job,' Riley said of the FBI. 'It's been a lot. I mean, it has been nine years.' The family also posted a statement to social media, per Fox News, which read: 'There's not a day, hour, minute or second that we don't think about you and the great memories that you left us with. 'Calvin, we promise you that we will find this person and bring them to justice. Cal we love you and miss you so much. Until we all meet again!!!' Both the killers and the motive have remained a mystery. The FBI is offering up to $25,000 as a reward for information that helps bring down those responsible. Not long after the shooting, police released a sketch of one person they thought could be connected to the case. The man was reportedly driving a car - with a blonde woman aged between 20 and 30 - which was parked nearby. According to KTVU, a family friend previously said Riley and his friend had noticed someone watching from the top of the hill above them. Another person was seen recording the crime scene and the new sketch shows a bald man with a beard and glasses. Police also identified a couple of suspicious cars - a 2015 white Hyundai Sonata and a dark Audi A3 - that arrived together and left together after the killing. It's not believed Riley was involved in any confrontation or robbery before being shot. Neither his phone nor his wallet was touched. 'This has ripped my family apart,' Sean Riley said at the time. 'I miss my family. I miss him. I miss it all.'
The Guardian
37 minutes ago
- The Guardian
The Bear season four review – finally becoming the show it was always destined to be
Recalibrate your palate: The Bear is not the show it used to be. The relentless drama you were stunned by in season two – when you finished an episode and said it was the best show you had ever seen, then played the next one and said it again – is not coming back. Season four starts with Uncle Jimmy (Oliver Platt), the family friend who has invested in the fledgling Chicago eaterie The Bear, installing a countdown clock that says the business has 1,440 hours to save itself. But much of the new run isn't even about the restaurant. The show is outgrowing its premise, leaving behind 'yes, chef!', lingering closeups of seared beef and screaming matches in the pantry in favour of a different intensity, one that draws even more deeply on the characters and how they fit together. Indulge it – and you will have to indulge it, in a few ways – and you will find this experience just as rich. The restaurant is reeling from negative press – the Chicago Tribune's reviewer reports understatedly that they observed 'dissonance' – but the show returns seeming almost arrogantly relaxed. The first two episodes potter, enjoying extended montages of folk cooking to the artfully curated sounds of the Who, Talk Talk, the Pretenders and, in a preparing-for-service sequence that goes on for longer than you think it would dare, a brilliantly deployed excerpt from Tangerine Dream's soundtrack for the 1981 movie Thief. Between courses, characters set out their self-improvement goals: Tina (Liza Colón-Zayas) wants to train herself to cook a pasta dish in under three minutes; Cousin Richie (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) wishes the little speeches he gives the waiting staff were more inspiring; Ebraheim (Edwin Lee Gibson) would like to help pull the numbers out of the red by becoming a commercial visionary. Dealing with the big stuff as usual are the head chef, Carmy Berzatto (Jeremy Allen White), and his faithful, frustrated assistant, Sydney (Ayo Edebiri). He wants to 'do better': communicate more, apologise more, explain more, shout less. She continues to wonder if she should jump ship to take a job at a flash new startup. A whole episode, co-written by Edebiri and Lionel Boyce (who plays Marcus), is given over to Syd visiting her cousin's house to have her hair done and discuss the dilemma with her cousin's young daughter. It's a lovely digression, but is it necessary? Well, yes. It may not feel like it during this year's slow start, just as it didn't during that apparently directionless third season, but Christopher Storer, the showrunner, knows what he is doing. More than ever, this is a show about family – the traumas they inflict on each other and the power they have to soothe them – and how families extend to friends and colleagues who can be just as beloved and just as maddening. That Richie is not actually Carmy's cousin and Uncle Jimmy is not anyone's uncle has always been an endearing quirk of the setup, but now it becomes essential and endlessly moving. Where once The Bear made pulses pound, now it lets the happy tears flow; the second half of the season is like one long therapy session. Syd isn't just deciding whether or not to take a job – she is deciding whether or not she is becoming a Berzatto. Once again, the centrepiece is a double-length episode dedicated to a family get-together. The whole gang is there, so that unbelievable extended cast – including Sarah Paulson, Bob Odenkirk and John Mulaney, plus new additions Josh Hartnett and a hilarious Brie Larson – is reunited, this time for the wedding of Richie's ex-wife, Tiff (Gillian Jacobs). With the unstable Berzatto matriarch, Donna (Jamie Lee Curtis), in attendance, passive-aggressively transferring her anxieties to whoever she is speaking to, the potential is there for another psychodrama along the lines of that sublime but gruelling Christmas flashback from a couple of seasons ago. But having put his creations and his audience through hell, Storer now lets the light in via a torrent of tenderly written, fiercely performed interactions where broken people who love each other start to heal, saying variations on those two beautiful phrases, 'sorry' and 'thank you'. Payoffs big and small ping in every scene as narrative seeds carefully sown – including in that bad third season! – burst into bloom and these people we have come to adore are rewarded. Not that it's ever easy: if the wedding episode is a classic, so is the painfully fraught, stunningly acted finale, where we don't know whether the most troubled of our cousins will find the courage to open up. Storer has shown a lot of courage in giving them the chance. This new Bear is doing much better. The Bear is on Disney+ in the UK and Australia and on Hulu in the US
