Rs40b scandal exposes gaps in govt depts
The largest financial scandal in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa's history — amounting to a staggering Rs40 billionhas left government departments reeling, as they failed to provide satisfactory answers before the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) of the K-P Assembly. Departments including Finance, Accountant General's Office, and Communication & Works (C&W) were unable to present complete documentation or convince committee members of their performance regarding embezzlement in Upper Kohistan.
During the high-level meeting chaired by Assembly Speaker Babar Saleem Swati, department representatives mostly shifted blame onto each other. The speaker criticized the departments for their poor coordination, emphasizing that this is not just a Rs40 billion scandal, but likely part of a broader corruption network potentially reaching Rs500-600 billion.
In contrast, the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) earned praise for recovering Rs20 billion from the misappropriated funds. Speaker Swati highlighted this as a rare case where no political figures are implicated, and said the scandal involves deep-rooted institutional corruption, especially within the AG Office, Finance Department, and C&W.
Despite the magnitude of the corruption, only two officials were suspended initially. The PAC ordered the suspension of additional officials across the involved departments. The AG's office was instructed to suspend two more officers within three days and initiate further action. Finance and C&W were also directed to identify and penalize more employees.
The AG claimed NAB had taken all records related to Upper Kohistan and had not returned them. However, NAB clarified that it only takes copies of documents, not originals. The Speaker reprimanded the AG for overstepping boundaries and insisted the office should have maintained copies.
The C&W Secretary revealed that an internal inquiry had led to the suspension of seven officials, but the PAC demanded all SDOs and XENs from 2019 to 2024 be suspended. The Speaker added that even check signatories must be held accountable. Contractors operating under fake companies are to be blacklisted, along with their beneficiaries.
DG Audit Sirajul Haq informed the committee that over Rs21 billion in irregularities were detected last year alone, and more discrepancies worth Rs6 billion were found in 18 districts. He stressed the need to audit a full decade's worth of records from Kohistan, promising a complete report by December.
A heated exchange also erupted between PPP MPA Ahmad Karim Kundi and Finance Advisor Muzzammil Aslam, with Kundi demanding Aslam's resignation. Aslam denied any involvement in the scandal, asserting his department's innocence. The session concluded with warnings that no department or officer would be spared accountability.
Speaker Swati summed up the sentiment: "This isn't just theftit's systematic institutional failure."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Five AVLC cops held for kidnapping
Malir Cantt police raided the Anti-Vehicle Lifting Cell (AVLC) office in Khawaja Ajmer Nagri, rescuing an abductee and arresting five AVLC personnel, including a sub-inspector. Reportedly, the victim, Madad Ali, had gone missing from near his residence in Bilawal Jokhio Goth. After failing to locate him, his family registered a complaint at the police station. Then, acting on intelligence, police raided the AVLC office and recovered Madad Ali, who had been detained on the station's rooftop for three days. The arrested personnel were identified as Constables Abdul Ghaffar, Riyaz, Khalid, Naeem, and Sub-Inspector Rashid Ali. They allegedly demanded a ransom of Rs500,000 from the victim's family for his release. Another individual reportedly involved was also taken into custody. During interrogation, the officers confessed to keeping the victim in illegal detention and attempting to extort ransom money. Further investigations are ongoing.
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Panel postpones RDA scam hearing
The meeting of the special committee formed by the Punjab Chief Secretary to investigate the Rs1.94 billion corruption scandal in the Rawalpindi Development Authority (RDA) failed to be held in Lahore on Thursday. The Director-General of RDA, along with a Deputy Director and an Assistant Director, who had travelled to Lahore for the meeting, were informed about rescheduling of the meeting on June 11. Meanwhile, NAB has intensified its probe into the financial scandal and conducted a raid at the residence of the late Deputy Director. The special committee, comprising DMG officers, had summoned RDA's Director-General Kinza Murtaza, Deputy Director Iftikhar Janjua, and Assistant Director Waqar Asghar Raja to Lahore for a review of records. However, upon their arrival, they were informed that one committee member was unavailable, leading to the postponement of the hearing until June 11. Surprisingly, despite the ongoing investigation, only one retired officer from the approximately dozen former Directors General and Directors of Administration and Finance of RDA, who served between 2016 and 2024/25, has been summoned. Some of these officers have retired, while others hold key positions in Punjab.
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Suthra Punjab neglects low-income areas
Like many projects of the Punjab government, the Suthra Punjab project too has been reserved for affluent areas. Despite the passage of four months, its scope could not be extended to the entire province, due to which the residents of low-income areas are still forced to dispose of garbage on their own. The Punjab government had launched the Suthra Punjab project for garbage collection and sanitation in the province four months ago however, the project is practically limited to advertisements, billboards and expenditures on the vehicles and uniforms of sweepers from the solid waste management companies. Till date, the sanitation system in the low-income areas of Lahore, including Wagah, Nishtar, Ravi, Samanabad, Data Ganj Bakhsh Town and other areas, remains deplorable. Except for a few posh areas of the city including Gulberg Town, Raiwind, Jati Umra and Adda Plot, garbage collection has not been started in downscale areas. Abdul Rahim, Muhammad Nasir, and Noman Naeem, three locals from Harbanspura, Nishtar Colony and Baghbanpura confirmed that more than four months had passed since the project had started -- however, the Suthra Punjab project team had still not visited their areas. 'Even today, we pay monthly charges to private garbage collectors. Although main roads in our areas are cleaned, there is no sanitation system in the streets, neighborhoods and small areas. The private garbage collector charges Rs200 to Rs500 per month from each household. We are not getting any benefit from this project, which appears operational only in government advertisements,' lamented the locals. According to information available to the Express Tribune, the outsourced Suthra Punjab program is a long-term project costing more than Rs190 billion. Under this project, garbage is to be collected from the doorsteps of citizens across all cities of Punjab. In this regard, the government has also implemented a garbage tax. However, in Lahore, despite a budget of Rs20 billion, door-to-door garbage collection has been initiated in residential areas from only 100 out of 274 union councils due to the unavailability of machinery, inattention of officers and other reasons. Moreover, the deadline for garbage collection across all 274 union councils, set for March 30th, could not be met either. According to Mian Sohail Hanif Bhandara, an urban planner, the government has started the Suthra Punjab project without an effective strategy hence more than four months have passed yet the results are yet to been seen. 'The garbage collection operation has been outsourced after dividing urban and rural areas. Due to this distinction, cleaning is done on a daily basis in a few areas, while some areas are cleaned weekly and others do not even have an effective sanitation system. If the government had started phase-wise work on the project, effective results would have been seen. Unless the solid waste companies, in collaboration with the municipality and corporation, formulate an effective plan for garbage collection, the Suthra Punjab project will not be fruitful,' assessed Bhandara. Chief Executive Officer Lahore Solid Waste Management Company (LWMC) Babar Sahib Deen claimed that on the instructions of Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz, the Suthra Punjab program was successfully underway to provide garbage collection services in rural areas as it is provided in cities. 'Several complaints have been received regarding non-collection of garbage in some areas of Lahore, and these complaints are being addressed,' said Deen.
