Ireland's energy and climate plan far from sufficient, EU Commission finds
Ireland's current National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP) remains far from sufficient to meet its
climate
commitments, an assessment by the
European Commission
has found.
Although investment needs of €119 billion - €125 billion are outlined in the plan, 'there is no explanation of how this will be funded or whether a financing gap exists', it concludes.
Ireland remains off course for its
2030 climate targets
, with its NECP projecting a 25.4 per cent emissions reduction, well below the legally binding 42 per cent target under the EU's key 'effort-sharing regulation'. This sets national climate targets for emissions in road transport, buildings, agriculture, waste and small industries.
The NECP outlines each EU member state's strategy to meet its climate and energy targets for 2030, including emissions reductions, renewable energy deployment and energy efficiency.
READ MORE
The commission's assessment evaluates whether these plans are sufficient and credible, offering guidance on gaps, shortcomings and areas for improvement. It plays a critical role in holding governments accountable and ensuring collective progress toward EU climate goals.
Its assessment was released on Wednesday, the same day the Environmental Protection Agency published updated emissions projections for achieving Ireland's 2030 climate targets – 'which together offer a stark and urgent warning about the widening gap between Ireland's climate commitments and actual delivery', according to Environmental Justice Network Ireland (EJNI).
[
Ireland's emissions trend 'alarming and shocking, with actions reset required'
Opens in new window
]
Ireland is projected to achieve a reduction of just 23 per cent in total greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, compared with a national target of 51 per cent.
EJNI director Dr Ciara Brennan said: 'This is another clear signal that Ireland's climate plans are not on track. The commission's assessment confirms what Irish civil society has been saying for some time. Ireland is still far from meeting its 2030 climate and energy targets, and its NECP has missed a critical opportunity to make necessary course corrections.'
The commission noted Ireland's renewable energy target was raised, but short-term delivery lags. 'While the 2030 target was increased to 43 per cent, interim milestones for 2025 and 2027 fall short.'
The plan lacks specific targets for buildings and district heating, 'with many measures relying on speculative technologies and unclear timelines', it finds.
Agriculture measures, it says, fall short on ambition and feasibility. 'The plan leans heavily on technologies still in development and lacks incentives for uptake. Crucially, it avoids deeper reforms such as reducing dairy herd size or diversifying agricultural systems.'
Land-use emissions are rising, with Ireland projected to miss its target by 1.36 million tonnes of CO₂ equivalent. 'The plan lacks robust monitoring and credible data, undermining the reliability of projected [carbon] removals,' the commission concludes.
The Government is criticised for having no clear plan to phase out fossil fuel subsidies.
Its assessment may not compel an immediate revision of the NECP, but reinforces legal concerns already raised by EJNI and others, Dr Brennan said. The persistent delivery gaps, especially in agriculture, energy efficiency and land use, leave the Government exposed to potential infringement procedures, she warned.
The findings have consequences for Ireland's social climate plan, due by June 30th, which must be consistent with the NECP to unlock EU funding.
In November 2024, EJNI joined a coalition of NGOs from other EU states to call on the commission to take legal action against what they identified as noncompliance EU laws in the updating of NECPs. The action highlighted widespread deficiencies in NECPs from France, Ireland, Germany, Italy and Sweden.
Why is Ireland so far off its climate targets?
Listen |
21:07
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Who was Sunny Jacobs? A remarkable life from Florida's death row to Connemara
Sonia 'Sunny' Jacobs was 76 when she died on Tuesday morning in a house fire in Connemara . Her tragic death made headlines far beyond Galway and Ireland because Jacobs had led a truly remarkable life. It included a death row sentence for the murder of two policemen in Florida in 1976. She spent 17 years in a US jail, five in solitary confinement, before a deal with prosecutors saw her released in 1995. Another person died in the fire in the remote cottage, her carer a young man called Kevin Kelly from Moycullen. READ MORE Her life – before and after that highway shooting – has been chronicled in books, a play and a film as Jacobs became a campaigner against the death penalty. In an extraordinary twist of fate, a coincidence that could barely have been imagined, she ended up married to a man whose experience mirrored hers. [ Death row survivor Sonia 'Sunny' Jacobs found 'tranquility' in Connemara before death in house fire Opens in new window ] Peter Pringle had also been handed the death sentence over his part in the murder of two policemen: gardaí John Morley and Henry Byrne during a bank robbery in Co Roscommon in 1980. After serving 15 years in jail, Pringle was acquitted of the killings in 1995 when the Court of Appeal ruled the original verdict was unsafe and unsound. The two former prisoners met in Ireland at an Amnesty event – Jacobs was a tireless campaigner for the rest of her life – and married in 2011 before settling in Connemara. Irish Times reporter Ronan McGreevy has been in Connemara where Jacobs found peace and sanctuary and where she died. He tells In the News her story. Presented by Bernice Harrison. Produced by John Casey.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Corporate tax take tumbles 30% for May with €1.1bn less over same month last year
The State's corporate tax receipts fell 30 per cent last month, with the exchequer collecting €1.1 billion less in May compared to the same month last year. Downplaying the decline, the Department of Finance attributed it to 'once-off factors' which, it said, boosted receipts last year and distorted the year-on-year comparison. The latest exchequer returns for May indicated the Government collected €2.5 billion in corporate taxes last month, compared to almost €3.6 billion last year. Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said May was among the more important months for tax revenues and the steady growth in most tax headings pointed to an economy 'that is in a relatively good position'. READ MORE While the drop in corporate tax could be attributed to one-off factors, he said, it highlighted the degree of concentration in the corporate tax base where a small number of multinational firms 'can significantly impact on the overall tax yield'. 'In a context of unprecedented uncertainty in the international economic landscape, this serves as a timely reminder of Ireland's exposure to changes in the global trading environment, and of the vital importance of adhering to a sensible and sustainable budgetary strategy,' he said. Meanwhile, the European Central Bank (ECB) confirmed its latest interest rate cut yesterday. For tens of thousands of mortgage holders, the eighth cut in the last year means they have seen the annual cost of their home loans fall by about €2,000. However, the downward rate cycle appears to be coming to an end. ECB president Christine Lagarde confirmed as much when she said that 'at the current level of interest rates, we believe that we are in a good position to navigate the uncertain conditions that will be coming up'. When asked if the bank was on the cusp of declaring victory in its battle against inflation, she replied that 'victory laps are always nice, but there is always another battle.' Those who will be first in line to benefit from the latest rate cut will be about 126,000 tracker mortgage holders. Each rate cut of 0.25 per cent is worth about €13 to this cohort, with the eight cuts over the last 12 months equating to savings of just under €2,000 over a year for someone with an outstanding home loan of €150,000. Although there is speculation that September will be marked by a further rate cut, the ECB said it would 'follow a data-dependent and meeting-by-meeting approach to determining the appropriate monetary policy stance' and stressed it was not committing to a particular rate path. Separate figures on Thursday from the Central Statistics Office pointed to economic growth of almost 10 per cent in the first quarter, up from a previous estimate of 3 per cent, as exporters rushed to get merchandise into the US in advance of the imposition of tariffs. Since April 5th, goods imported from all countries into the US have been subject to a 10 per cent tariff, while US president Donald Trump has put a stay on a possible 50 per cent tariff on all EU imports until next month. Pharma accounts for the lion's share of Irish goods exports to the US, and companies in the sector here have been fast-tracking products to avoid the tariffs. The pharma-dominated industry sector expanded by 17.1 per cent in the first quarter compared with the previous three-month period. By contrast, the domestic economy grew by just 0.8 per cent.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Swimming banned at Dollymount Strand due to suspected sewage discharge after heavy rainfall
Swimming has been banned at Dollymount strand in Dublin Bay after a 'suspected discharge' of sewage following heavy rainfall. The restriction at the popular designated bathing area on North Bull Island will continue over the coming days. Deputy Lord Mayor of Dublin Donna Cooney criticised the way the alert was issued and Uisce Éireann for failing to indicate the source of the discharge. 'This is disgraceful at the start of the bathing season,' she said. READ MORE She said alerts about bathing restrictions needed to be more widely disseminated, as she had found people swimming on the beach despite the measure being in place. Cllr Cooney, a member of the Green Party, said she received an alert to confirm water quality at the beach was 'excellent' on May 26th, but got no notice about the recent restriction. She said the utility company should have indicated where the discharge happened, given that real-time monitoring is supposed to be taking place at its Ringsend wastewater treatment plant. Ms Cooney is a regular swimmer at Dollymount and at the Bull Wall Ladies Shelter. She said she was concerned the discharge would lead to algal blooms as seawater warmed in the coming weeks, which would affect swimmers, water sports activities and marine life in the bay. Discharges have occurred intermittently from the plant, which has been operating at excess capacity for many years. Uisce Éireann said the discharge arose due to overflows from storm tanks at the Ringsend plant. 'There is online monitoring of these storm tanks and Dublin City Council, who are responsible for monitoring of bathing water quality, are notified of any overflows during the bathing season,' said a spokesman. 'Stormwater overflows are an essential part of any wastewater network that enable excess flows to be discharged into the sea, rivers or watercourses in a controlled and regulated manner ... Stormwater discharges normally do not have a lasting effect on bathing waters,' he added. 'The tide will wash out the spill and the salt water and sunlight acts to clean the water. Uisce Éireann apologises for any inconvenience caused and regrets the impact overflow incidents may have on beach users.' Uisce Éireann is investing more than €500 million to upgrade the plant so it can serve a 2.4 million population equivalent by the end of 2025. 'The upgrade of Ringsend means the capacity will be increased and these incidents will be fewer in number, although in extreme weather conditions they could still occur,' said the spokesman. The Environmental Protection Agency and the Health Service Executive have been informed, while the council, which erected notices at Dollymount, said it is awaiting laboratory results to determine whether the temporary prohibition can be lifted.
