Remember the Church's beginnings when electing the pope
From catacombs to cathedrals, the temptations of empire remain May 07, 2025
A church in West Sussex is home to a scale replica of the Sistine Chapel's ceiling
Francis is no longer with us. The cardinals are meeting again under the painted ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. But what's really at stake isn't just continuity or change. It's whether the Church dares to follow the path Francis spent a decade pointing toward — or turns back.
The question is not just who will lead. It's what kind of Church they will inherit — and what kind they intend to become.
The earliest Christian community was an underground movement. The first pope, Peter, led from the shadows, not the throne.
The Church in its infancy was fragile, decentralized and deeply rooted in solidarity with the poor. It had no cathedrals, no state alliances, and no political capital. Its strength came from its witness — its radical commitment to love, mercy, and shared life.
But when Constantine converted in the fourth century, everything changed. The persecuted became privileged. Christianity became the official religion of empire, and with that came new temptations: prestige, wealth, hierarchy.
Over time, the Church began to mirror imperial structures. What had started in the catacombs now occupied marble halls.
The consequences were lasting. The Church's long descent into power came with no shortage of scandal: the Crusades waged in the name of Christ, the Inquisition burning those who questioned, indulgences sold as tickets to heaven, and the Renaissance — an era where beauty and corruption lived side by side.
Even St. Peter's Basilica, magnificent as it is, was funded in part through those indulgences. That abuse didn't just stain the Church. It helped spark the Reformation.Not all responses led to schism. Not everyone broke away. Ignatius of Loyola stayed and reimagined the Church from the inside. Francis of Assisi stepped outside it, barefoot and broke, trusting that the Gospel was enough. His call still haunts us: 'Go, repair my Church, which as you see is falling into ruin.'Pope Francis, elected in 2013, took that summons to heart.From the very beginning, he signaled a different kind of papacy. He refused the trappings of empire — choosing simpler vestments, paying his own hotel bill, riding in a modest car. But these gestures were not cosmetic. They were theological.In a Church long burdened by hierarchy, he emphasized mercy over judgment, dialogue over dogma, and proximity to the poor over protection of privilege.
He named the global peripheries — not Rome — as the Church's new center. He challenged a clerical culture that had often concealed abuse and silenced dissent. While his critics accused him of ambiguity or populism, his true project was clear: to bring the Church closer to the Gospel, and the Gospel closer to the people.
Yet not all welcomed this return.
In the US, a group of conservative bishops pushed back hard. For them, Francis went too far. Raymond Burke, Carlo Maria Viganò, Joseph Strickland, and Robert Barron, all made it clear — this wasn't the kind of pope they wanted. They spoke as if the Church had lost its footing, when it was their grip on control that was slipping.
At its core, their vision is not a return to roots, but to robes.
History teaches that the Church loses its moral clarity whenever it grows too comfortable with temporal power. It becomes a mirror of empire, not a mirror of Christ.
The next pope will face pressure to retreat into tradition, reassert dogma, and mollify political allies. But if the Church is to remain credible, it must once again choose witness over control.
It must remember that its authority never came from pageantry, but from proximity to the suffering.
Pope Francis did not fix everything — he couldn't — but he reoriented the Church toward its origins. He reminded us that faith is not performance — it's presence.
As the conclave decides the Church's next leader, the most crucial question is not how Catholicism will govern itself in Rome, but how it will live out its mission on the margins.
The Church was born in catacombs, not in palaces. And its future — if it is to remain faithful — lies not in reclaiming its throne, but in remembering where it began.--ucanews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
16 hours ago
- The Sun
'Mass grave' excavation to finally start at Irish mother and baby home
TUAM: A quiet, walled patch of grass in the middle of an Irish housing estate is set to reveal the latest disturbing chapter in Ireland's 'mother and baby' home scandal. Beneath the ground at this peaceful spot in the town of Tuam, 135 miles (220 kilometres) west of Dublin, significant quantities of human remains have been identified. The land, attached to a home run by nuns between 1925 and 1961, was left largely untouched after the institution was knocked down in 1972. But on Monday, excavation crews will seal off the site before beginning the search for remains next month. 'There are so many babies, children just discarded here,' local historian Catherine Corless told AFP at the site. It was her discovery of the unmarked mass burial site that led to an Irish Commission of Investigation into the so-called mother and baby homes. In 2014, the now 71-year-old produced evidence that 796 children, from newborns to a nine-year-old, died at Tuam's mother and baby home. Her research pointed to the children's likely final resting place: a disused septic tank discovered in 1975. 'There are no burial records for the children, no cemetery, no statue, no cross, absolutely nothing,' said Corless. It was only in 2022 that legislation was passed in parliament enabling the excavation work to start at Tuam. Dark shadow 'It's been a fierce battle, when I started this nobody wanted to listen, at last we are righting the wrongs,' said Corless. 'I was just begging: take the babies out of this sewage system and give them the decent Christian burial that they were denied,' she added. In findings published in 2021, the Commission of Investigation found 'disquieting' levels of infant mortality at the institutions Women pregnant outside of wedlock were siloed in the so-called mother and baby homes by society, the state and the Catholic church, which has historically held an iron grip on Irish attitudes. After giving birth at the homes, mothers were then separated from their children, often through adoption. The state-backed enquiries sparked by the discoveries in Tuam found that 56,000 unmarried women and 57,000 children passed through 18 such homes over 76 years. The commission report concluded that 9,000 children had died in the homes across Ireland. Often church and state worked in tandem to run the institutions, which still operated in Ireland as recently as 1998. Homes were run in various ways -- some funded and managed by local health authorities and others by Catholic religious orders like the Bon Secours nuns who managed the Tuam home. 'All these babies and children were baptised but still the church turned a blind eye. It just didn't matter, they were illegitimate, that's the stance that they took,' Corless said. Analysis at the Tuam site in 2016 and 2017 identified human remains in underground cavities. A commission of investigation later concluded that they were in a disused sewage tank. But it was only in 2022 that legislation was passed in parliament enabling the works to start there. For Anna Corrigan, 70, who was in her mid-50s when she learned that her late mother gave birth in secret to two boys, John and William, in Tuam, the slow process has been 'justice, Irish-style'. As no death certificate was ever issued for William, and John's death was not medically certified, the few official documents Corrigan has been able to access have left her with more questions than answers. 'Dirty little secrets' In her kitchen she showed AFP a copy of a 1947 inspection report of the Tuam home. It described John as 'a miserable emaciated child', even though he was born healthy a year earlier. Both could be buried in Tuam according to Corrigan while William may also have been illegally adopted out of the country. 'They prevaricate, they obfuscate, they make it difficult for people to get to the truth,' she said. 'There are dirty little secrets in Ireland that have to be kept hidden, Ireland has a wholesome reputation around the world but there's also a dark, sinister side,' she said. A team was finally appointed in 2023 to lead the Tuam site excavation, tasked with recovering, memorialising and re-burying remains recovered at the site once the work starts. Sample DNA will be taken from people who have reasonable grounds to believe they are a close relative. 'I never thought I'd see the day that we'd get over so many hurdles -- push them to finally excavating what I call the 'pit', not a grave,' said Corrigan. 'I'm glad it's starting, but if we can even find and identify a certain amount it's not going to give us all closure,' she said.
The Sun
16 hours ago
- The Sun
Tuam Mass Grave Excavation Begins in Ireland Scandal Probe
TUAM: A quiet, walled patch of grass in the middle of an Irish housing estate is set to reveal the latest disturbing chapter in Ireland's 'mother and baby' home scandal. Beneath the ground at this peaceful spot in the town of Tuam, 135 miles (220 kilometres) west of Dublin, significant quantities of human remains have been identified. The land, attached to a home run by nuns between 1925 and 1961, was left largely untouched after the institution was knocked down in 1972. But on Monday, excavation crews will seal off the site before beginning the search for remains next month. 'There are so many babies, children just discarded here,' local historian Catherine Corless told AFP at the site. It was her discovery of the unmarked mass burial site that led to an Irish Commission of Investigation into the so-called mother and baby homes. In 2014, the now 71-year-old produced evidence that 796 children, from newborns to a nine-year-old, died at Tuam's mother and baby home. Her research pointed to the children's likely final resting place: a disused septic tank discovered in 1975. 'There are no burial records for the children, no cemetery, no statue, no cross, absolutely nothing,' said Corless. It was only in 2022 that legislation was passed in parliament enabling the excavation work to start at Tuam. Dark shadow 'It's been a fierce battle, when I started this nobody wanted to listen, at last we are righting the wrongs,' said Corless. 'I was just begging: take the babies out of this sewage system and give them the decent Christian burial that they were denied,' she added. In findings published in 2021, the Commission of Investigation found 'disquieting' levels of infant mortality at the institutions Women pregnant outside of wedlock were siloed in the so-called mother and baby homes by society, the state and the Catholic church, which has historically held an iron grip on Irish attitudes. After giving birth at the homes, mothers were then separated from their children, often through adoption. The state-backed enquiries sparked by the discoveries in Tuam found that 56,000 unmarried women and 57,000 children passed through 18 such homes over 76 years. The commission report concluded that 9,000 children had died in the homes across Ireland. Often church and state worked in tandem to run the institutions, which still operated in Ireland as recently as 1998. Homes were run in various ways -- some funded and managed by local health authorities and others by Catholic religious orders like the Bon Secours nuns who managed the Tuam home. 'All these babies and children were baptised but still the church turned a blind eye. It just didn't matter, they were illegitimate, that's the stance that they took,' Corless said. Analysis at the Tuam site in 2016 and 2017 identified human remains in underground cavities. A commission of investigation later concluded that they were in a disused sewage tank. But it was only in 2022 that legislation was passed in parliament enabling the works to start there. For Anna Corrigan, 70, who was in her mid-50s when she learned that her late mother gave birth in secret to two boys, John and William, in Tuam, the slow process has been 'justice, Irish-style'. As no death certificate was ever issued for William, and John's death was not medically certified, the few official documents Corrigan has been able to access have left her with more questions than answers. 'Dirty little secrets' In her kitchen she showed AFP a copy of a 1947 inspection report of the Tuam home. It described John as 'a miserable emaciated child', even though he was born healthy a year earlier. Both could be buried in Tuam according to Corrigan while William may also have been illegally adopted out of the country. 'They prevaricate, they obfuscate, they make it difficult for people to get to the truth,' she said. 'There are dirty little secrets in Ireland that have to be kept hidden, Ireland has a wholesome reputation around the world but there's also a dark, sinister side,' she said. A team was finally appointed in 2023 to lead the Tuam site excavation, tasked with recovering, memorialising and re-burying remains recovered at the site once the work starts. Sample DNA will be taken from people who have reasonable grounds to believe they are a close relative. 'I never thought I'd see the day that we'd get over so many hurdles -- push them to finally excavating what I call the 'pit', not a grave,' said Corrigan. 'I'm glad it's starting, but if we can even find and identify a certain amount it's not going to give us all closure,' she said.
Herald Malaysia
6 days ago
- Herald Malaysia
Rupnik's mosaics quietly removed from Vatican News
The move is seen as an overdue sign of hope and healing for survivors of his alleged decades-long abuse Jun 10, 2025 A mosaic designed by Father Marko Rupnik's studio Centro Aletti at the Basilica of the Sanctuary of Lourdes, France. (Photo: UCAN Files) By Paulina Guzik, OSV News In a quiet but powerful move, Vatican News has begun removing artwork by Father Marko Rupnik -- the once-renowned mosaicist now accused of abusing over two dozen women -- from its website. His mosaics, long used to mark major feast days online, were recently replaced or left blank -- a shift many survivors say is long removed mosaics include one for the June 9 memorial of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of the Church, and one that illustrated the feast of the Assumption Aug. 15."I can't tell you how hopeful of a sign it is for me," said Weronika, whose name was changed and who is a victim of abuse by a Polish Dominican priest. "I saw it immediately and simply felt relieved," she told OSV News, adding: "you don't even know how much this gesture means to me. That the victims' pain was heard at last." Since the allegations were revealed, calls to remove the priest's artwork have grown, including from victims who said the mosaics were a painful reminder of the abuse they suffered. One victim, identified as Sister Samuelle, recounted that she was abused by Father Rupnik while installing one of his mosaics. A number of shrines that featured his work have taken steps to either cover or limit the public display and use of Father Rupnik's mosaics since the abuse revelations were made public. The St. John Paul II National Shrine in Washington as well as the Basilica of Our Lady of the Rosary in the Sanctuary of Our Lady of Lourdes, France, opted to cover or partially cover the mosaics out of respect for his victims. OSV News asked the Vatican's Press Office whether removing Father Rupnik's art from Vatican News is a coordinated effort and is awaiting an answer. Mosaics to be or not to be? In June 2024, on the final day of the Catholic Media Conference in Atlanta, the prefect of the Vatican's Dicastery for Communication addressed questions posed by America's Colleen Dulle and OSV News about the dicastery's regular practice of posting art by Father Rupnik on the Vatican News website and social media, especially to illustrate church feast days. "As Christian(s), we are asked not to judge," Paolo Ruffini said to a room full of communications professionals after giving an address at the CMC June 21, 2024. He explained that while the process of a Vatican investigation into Father Rupnik is still ongoing, "an anticipation of a decision is something that is not, in our opinion, is not good." "There are things we don't understand," he said. Ruffini also added they "did not put in any new photos" of Father Rupnik's art, but rather have been using what they had. "We didn't decide what was not on our charge to decide," he Father Rupnik's art from public space "is not a Christian response," Ruffini said. "We are not talking about abuse of minors," Ruffini said at the CMC. "We are talking (about) a story that we don't know." "I don't think we have to throw stones thinking that this is the way of healing," the prefect added."Do you think that if I put away a photo of an art (away) from … our website, I will be more close to the victims? Do you think so?" he pressed journalists at the end of his answer. When an answer was given in the affirmative, Ruffini responded: "I think you're wrong." Five days later, in a separate June 26 communication, Cardinal Seán P. O'Malley of Boston, president of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, told the dicasteries of the Vatican Curia that Father Rupnik is currently under Vatican investigation and entitled to the presumption of innocence. However, he made clear that "pastoral prudence would prevent displaying artwork in a way that could imply either exoneration or a subtle defense" of a person alleged to have committed abuse, "or indicate indifference to the pain and suffering of so many victims of abuse." Father Rupnik's case investigated for over 500 days Father Rupnik, a former Jesuit, was briefly excommunicated by the church in 2020 for absolving an Italian novice with whom he had sex. The excommunication was lifted after he repented. The Jesuits disclosed in December 2022 that it had suspended the Slovenian artist after allegations of abuse had surfaced. In June 2023, Father Rupnik was expelled from the Jesuits for refusing to obey restrictions imposed upon him related to the sexual, spiritual and psychological abuse of some two dozen women and at least one man over the course of 30 years. Despite the credibility of the accusations and his dismissal from the Jesuits, the Diocese of Koper in the priest's native Slovenia announced it had incardinated Father Rupnik in its diocese. After the diocese confirmed in October 2023 that the priest had been there since August, the Vatican announced that Pope Francis had lifted the statute of limitations, allowing the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith to proceed in its investigation and eventual case. In a statement published in October 2023, the Vatican said the decision was made after "the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors brought to the pope's attention that there were serious problems in the handling of the Father Marko Rupnik case and lack of outreach to victims."The canonical process of Father Rupnik is ongoing. "The sentence is expected in the not too distant future," a source told OSV News in the retired bishop of the Diocese of Koper, where Father Rupnik was incardinated in August 2023, told OSV News in February that the priest 'continues his work all over the world.'Father Rupnik's case is one of the most urgent cases on the table for the new pope to handle in canonical terms, abuse experts Father Hans Zollner, director of the Institute of Anthropology at the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, and a top expert on the abuse crisis, told OSV News upon the election of Pope Leo XIV: 'I do hope that, as soon as possible, we will have a verdict. Many of us are looking forward to hearing about that, because it has been a very long time, especially for those who have brought forward the allegations -- so that finally there will be clarity about this,' Father Zollner said. For any pope, he added, the issue of abuse is critical, as it becomes "a question of the credibility of our existence and our message."--ucanews
