NHS wastes money on overpriced foreign tech, says ex-health secretary
The NHS is overspending on expensive foreign IT systems and should buy British instead, a former health secretary has said.
Steve Barclay said health service bosses could save money, cut waiting lists and improve clinical outcomes by contracting with local suppliers, rather than overseas providers – typically from the US – who charge higher fees.
He told The Telegraph: 'A government that claims to want to drive UK growth needs to stop spending money on overseas companies that are not committed to the NHS, and prioritise British business.
'A government that claims to want to cut wastage needs to ensure value for money for the taxpayer.'
He singled out the health service's vast expenditure on electronic patient records (EPR), which offer digital versions of people's medical history.
A Freedom of Information request has revealed that some NHS trusts are spending up to £4.3m a year on EPR contracts with overseas suppliers. Many hospitals award contracts to US tech giants such as Larry Ellison's Oracle.
The NHS's reliance on overseas tech comes despite alternative offers from UK-based tech companies.
System C, a software company based in Stratford-upon-Avon, last year launched legal action against Mersey and West Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust over its decision to award a £65m EPR contract to US-based Altera.
The trust subsequently reversed its decision after System C claimed there had been favouritism during the procurement process.
Nick Wilson, the chief executive of System C, told The Telegraph: 'The Government has stated that of its six missions, growth is the most important – and one of the easiest ways to promote that growth is to spend hard-earned taxpayers money right here in the UK.
'We have an amazing and vibrant health-tech industry, supporting UK job creation, R&D, exports and of course providing hundreds of millions in tax revenues to the Chancellor.
'It is a complete no-brainer to prioritise and actively support British tech which is built with the NHS and UK social care in mind from the ground up – most of the time at a fraction of the cost of overseas competitors.'
Guy's and St Thomas' Foundation Trust (GSTT) and King's College Hospitals Foundation Trust announced a deal worth £450m with US-based company Epic in February 2022 to roll out an EPR software across six hospitals.
Ian Abbs, the GSTT chief executive, described the cost as 'chicken feed' in comparison to the NHS's pool of resources.
'We [the NHS] are running a £150bn industry, and the percentage spent on tech is relatively small,' he told the Health Service Journal, adding: 'I think the headline number looks big, but I actually think it's small.'
However, Mr Barclay, who served as health secretary under Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak, said the NHS needed to overhaul its procurement to ensure the right technology was being bought at a fair price.
He said: 'Harnessing technology and deploying it swiftly and effectively across the NHS could transform the service, cut waiting lists, and improve clinical outcomes.
'However, we can do this whilst getting more bang for the taxpayer buck. It needs to be the right technology, at the right price, designed with the specific needs of our NHS in mind.'
Mr Barclay's intervention comes shortly after Amanda Pritchard resigned as NHS England's chief executive. He has urged her eventual successor to make 'cost-effective digitisation – at the right price – a top priority'.
James McMurdock, the Reform MP for South Basildon and East Thurrock, has also called for greater transparency over the NHS procurement process.
'We need a deep and transparent discussion around how the NHS functions operationally and what contracts it signs,' he wrote on X, adding: 'The NHS should not be paying £££s for things that can be bought off the shelf for pennies.'
An NHS spokesman said: 'While the NHS prioritises British businesses when appropriate, it is right we offer contracts based on what offers the best value for the taxpayer – in line with Cabinet Office procurement regulations.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
32 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
Saturday's briefing: Liverpool agree club-record deal for Florian Wirtz
Liverpool agreed a club-record deal with Bayer Leverkusen for playmaker Florian Wirtz. The much-anticipated move could break the British record, with the Germany star set to join his former team-mate Jeremie Frimpong at Anfield. Elsewhere, Thomas Frank reacted to his move to Tottenham, while Matheus Cunha spoke of his desire to help turn around Manchester United's fortunes. Wirtz capture close Premier League champions Liverpool are set to pay up to £116million to sign Wirtz after Leverkusen finally settled on a fee. The Reds had two bids rejected, the last one of £113m, which would have seen £100m paid up front with performance-related add-ons, but have finally got the deal over the line. Liverpool will still pay an initial £100m – comfortably surpassing their own record outlay – but the performance-related add-ons, if achieved, would make it a potential British record. Liverpool's overall outlay could surpass the £115m Chelsea paid Brighton in 2023 for Moises Caicedo. Striker Darwin Nunez was the Reds' previous record signing in 2022, although they have not paid the full £85m as he has not met all the requirements for certain add-ons to be due. Bournemouth left-back Milos Kerkez is next on Liverpool's list, which could take their summer spending close to £200m. Frank gets to work We are delighted to announce the appointment of Thomas Frank as our new Head Coach on a contract that runs until 2028. Welcome, Thomas! 🤍 — Tottenham Hotspur (@SpursOfficial) June 12, 2025 Tottenham are prepared to rival Manchester United for Brentford attacker Bryan Mbeumo this summer after the appointment of Frank, the PA news agency understands. Spurs announced former Brentford boss Frank as their new head coach on Thursday night on a three-year deal. One of Frank's first moves in charge could be to try and tempt Mbeumo to follow him across London. The Dane declared 'a big piece of my heart' would always remain at Brentford in an emotional message posted on their official website. 'The time has come for me to move on. But, even as I leave, I know I have left a big piece of my heart at Brentford, not just at the football club but with the community and, of course, the incredible and loyal supporters,' said Frank. 'I want to extend my profound gratitude to the club for giving me the chance to pursue my dreams and for everyone involved who made the journey such a memorable one.' Dream move for Cunha View this post on Instagram A post shared by Manchester United (@manchesterunited) Matheus Cunha is delighted to have joined his 'dream' team and determined to help Manchester United bounce back from their worst season in 51 years. The 20-time English champions are in the midst of a rebuild under Ruben Amorim, having limped home 15th in the Premier League and lost the Europa League final to fellow strugglers Tottenham. The Red Devils' issues did not deter Brazil international Cunha, who completed his eagerly-anticipated £62.5million switch from Wolves on Thursday. 'It is the most common phrase that you can say at this moment, but this is the dream come true,' he told MUTV. 'Maybe outside, I think maybe my decision, they don't understand. But when you have always dreamed to play here, it's easier to pick this decision. 'For me, no-one else is like United. Of course, I know it's been a hard season for everyone. I think my decision shows what this club is for me and what I believe this club can be.' Mikey eyes more silverware One player hoping to impress Frank is Spurs youngster Mikey Moore, but the teenager's immediate focus is ending an unforgettable breakthrough campaign with another European trophy. The highly-rated 17-year-old made 19 appearances in all competitions for his boyhood club, with five of those coming in the Europa League. The winger was on the bench for the final in Bilbao and three weeks on has more continental glory in his sights as England kick off their bid for Under-19 European Championship glory. 'It was a top experience – some of the best times of my life on that Wednesday night,' Moore told PA. 'Hopefully going on to win another medal and another trophy with these boys here would be a brilliant feeling and experience for everyone. 'There's some top players. We think we can go on and hopefully win the tournament. It's been a good little build-up but excited to get into the games now.' What's on today? The summer of fútbol kicks off tomorrow. 👊 Let's Dial In. ✨ — Inter Miami CF (@InterMiamiCF) June 13, 2025 The Club World Cup gets under way on Saturday night at the Hard Rock Stadium, with Inter Miami playing in their home city against Egyptians Al Ahly in Group A.
The Sun
36 minutes ago
- The Sun
Mobile network offering DOUBLE data SIM-only deal – get 200GB for £12p/m
For anyone looking to switch networks, it's a great time to upgrade. Smarty has some seriously good data boosting SIM-only plans right now, with up to 200GB of data for just £12. 1 Smarty SIM-only deal, 100GB 200GB data for £12/month BUY FROM SMARTY I've covered SIM-only deals for a while now, and over time, you learn to spot the real gems from the overhyped fluff. This latest offer from Smarty is easily one of the better ones to pop up in recent months. Right now, Smarty is running two impressive promotions that boost data without hiking up the price. If you're someone who chews through mobile data, these are well worth a look. The first is its 16GB plan, which has just been bumped up to 50GB per month, all while staying at just £8. The real eye-catcher, though, is Smarty's 100GB plan, which has now been doubled to 200GB for just £12 a month. That's a huge amount of data for a great price, especially since there's usually a big leap between low GB plans and Unlimited. Deals like this make Unlimited plans feel less necessary, and are ideal if you're not a heavy user but still want peace of mind. It's also a great time to join Smarty, as the provider runs on Three's network, which is in line for some major improvements following Three's merger with Vodafone. That means better coverage and faster speeds are likely on the horizon as the networks start sharing infrastructure. Best SIM-only deals from Smarty If you want to spend less and use less data, or if Unlimited is what you need, Smarty has plenty of other budget-friendly deals going right now. Smarty plans are all rolling 1-month contracts, meaning you're never locked in and can switch or cancel easily. It's another reason the network is a favourite for budget-savvy shoppers. And if you're in the market for a new handset too, this week has delivered some tempting extras in the Android world. One major provider is offering a free tech bundle worth £410 when you pick up the latest Honor phone, with plans starting from just £20 per month. If these deals aren't quite the right fit, check out our roundup of the best SIM-only deals across the big networks.
Daily Mirror
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
NHS GP shares life-saving check 'everyone' should do monthly
Dr Shireen explained how to complete the check that everyone is recommended to complete on a regular basis An NHS doctor has highlighted an easy check "we should all be doing" as it could help diagnose cancer and save lives. GP and medical educator Dr Shireen has reminded her TikTok (@doctorshireen) followers to check their breasts following Jessie J's cancer diagnosis. The 37-year-old singer has revealed she's been diagnosed with "early breast cancer" and plans to undergo surgery. Praising the Price Tag singer, Dr Shireen said: "Jessie J has very bravely shared that she's been diagnosed with early breast cancer. "In her video, she says that she's holding on to the fact that it was diagnosed early, and she's absolutely right in doing so. The earlier we diagnose breast cancer, the better the prognosis, i.e., the better the outcome." "I'm a GP and today I'm going to share with you what we should all be doing to ensure if we were to get a breast cancer, it'd be picked up early, and that is self-checking," Dr Shireen shared. "Don't forget that breast cancer can affect men, too. So we recommend everyone to check their breasts once a month at least. It's really important for us to know what's normal so that the second that things might start becoming abnormal, we can pick it up quickly." In her video, the GP explained how to complete the check in a few steps. "The first thing you need to do is look, and it's not just looking at the breasts, it's also looking all the way up to the collarbone and into the axilla. "You're looking at the skin, you're looking for any tethering, any puckering, even any eczematous changes. Looking at the nipple for any inversion, any sign of any potential discharge, any changes like that," she said. Dr Shireen continued: "Next is feeling. So again, when we are palpating, we need to go all the way up and all the way into the axilla area. "But if we think about the breast as a round ball, you want to cut it into four quadrants, and you want to palpate each quadrant separately. So the way to do it is you push on one side, and then you literally just feel the area, and you're feeling for any lumps, any swellings, anything new that you're unsure about." The doctor urged people to speak to a GP if they have any health concerns. "If you do notice any of these changes, please make an appointment to speak to your GP. We refer patients to the urgent breast clinic all of the time, and more than 90% of the time it's nothing. But it is really important that if it is a breast cancer that is picked up early, because prognosis is so dependent on that," she said. The NHS explains that how serious breast cancer is depends on how big the cancer is, if the cancer has spread, and your general health. Advice on how to check your breasts is available on the NHS website. It says: "Checking your breasts or chest regularly helps you learn what looks and feels normal for you. This makes it easier to notice any changes that could be a sign of a condition such as breast cancer. You should try to check your breasts or chest about once a month."
