Parents' pain after Harlow hospital failures led to baby's death
Hospital failures led to baby's death - inquest
9 minutes ago
Share
Save
Lewis Adams
BBC News, Essex
Nikki Fox
BBC health correspondent, Essex
Share
Save
Russo family
Emmy Russo's death was preventable had hospital staff acted sooner, an inquest heard
The parents of a baby who died after five missed opportunities for a C-section said their lives had transformed into a "continuous reel" of grief.
Emmy Russo died three days after she was born at the Princess Alexandra Hospital in Harlow, Essex, in January 2024.
A coroner ruled that had staff acted on concerns raised by mother Bryony Russo earlier, it was likely the newborn would have survived.
Sharon McNally, the hospital's chief nurse, said she recognised the coroner's findings, and added: "We sincerely apologise to baby Emmy's family."
Russo family
The pregnancy had been deemed low-risk and the couple expected a healthy baby
She said: "The safety of women, babies and families when receiving maternity care is our absolute priority and we ensure that learning from any incident is part of our focus on continuous improvement."
The inquest at Essex Coroner's Court heard Emmy's brain was starved of oxygen during labour, causing her catastrophic brain injuries.
It followed several warning signs, including meconium, the consistency of "toothpaste" in Mrs Russo's waters, not being heeded by hospital staff.
"When we knew meconium was starting to show, I felt that Emmy was too high up in my belly," Ms Russo told the BBC.
"I'd never had a baby before, so it was just an instinct, a feeling of I couldn't see my baby naturally coming out that way."
Russo family
Bryony and Daniel Russo said they were "overjoyed" at the thought of becoming parents
Mrs Russo said she asked for a C-section, but was "laughed off" and told to proceed with a natural birth.
Her husband, Daniel, added: "I kept telling Bryony 'please trust them, they're professionals so let them do their job'.
"It was a very relaxed atmosphere at the Princess Alexandra, everything was 'don't worry, it'll be OK'.
"But everything wasn't OK for a very long period of time, and it resulted in the death of our daughter."
Mr Russo said staff congratulated him on becoming a father before telling him Emmy had been "born dead".
"In one minute, I went through the emotions of thinking it was all OK, to confusion, to heartbreak," he added.
Emmy was transferred to Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge but died in her father's arms three days later.
Russo family
Mr and Mrs Russo hope hospital staff learn from Emmy's death
Mrs Russo said she lost her job of 10 years and did not leave the house for four months in the aftermath of her daughter's death.
"You lose any direction of life, how I experience grief is a continuous reel of what happened."
'Upset and anger'
The couple said they finally felt heard after the inquest laid bare the hospital's failures.
Independent expert obstetrician Teresa Kelly told the court there had been enough evidence "this baby wasn't coping with labour" and staff should have acted sooner.
"It was overwhelming because it was a relief, but then there was so much upset and anger because it just confirmed there were so many points where it could've been different," Mrs Russo said.
She claimed it was "terrifying" to witness staff interpret guidelines and scans differently, rather than everyone being "on the same page".
Mrs Russo added: "I really hope what happened with Emmy makes a change in those professionals involved, but also those people who are learning across all departments."
If you have been affected by this story, you can find organisations that offer help, support and information at BBC Action Line.
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE How women blighted by cruel back pain may actually have hidden arthritis - as doctors reveal there's a simple drug cure that can end the agony. Special report by ETHAN ENNALS
Clair Evans believes her back pain began during her teens – but she has lived with the debilitating problem for so long that she struggles to remember a time when she wasn't in agony. The 47-year-old from Doncaster says her lower back became extremely stiff, and often the pain would radiate down into her legs. She also found that certain movements triggered excruciating spasms.
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
STEPHEN POLLARD: Labour's created an atmosphere where the hard working middle class are now fair game for bigotry
That an eight-year-old can be refused healthcare on the NHS because of the school he attends is deeply troubling. It shows that the service once described by Margaret Thatcher 's Chancellor Nigel Lawson as 'the closest thing the English people have to a religion,' has become a battleground for class war where children seeking treatment are seen as the enemy of the proletariat. That includes my children. I am lucky enough to be able to pay for them to attend private schools. I pay the fees on top of my taxes, of course. Now it seems the NHS regards my kids as non-citizens to be shunned.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
One of NHS's biggest AI projects is halted after fears it used health data of 57 MILLION people without proper permissions
NHS England has paused a ground-breaking AI project designed to predict an individual's risk of health conditions after concerns were raised data from 57 million people was being used without the right permissions. Foresight, which uses Meta 's open-source AI model, Llama 2, was being tested by researchers at University College London and King's College London as part of a national pilot scheme exploring how AI could be used to tailor healthcare plans for patients based on their medical history. But the brakes were applied to the pioneering scheme after experts warned even anonymised records could contain enough information to identify individuals, The Observer reported. A joint IT committee between the British Medical Association (BMA) and the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) also said it they had not been made aware that data collected for research into Covid was now being used to train the AI model. The bodies have also accused the research consortium, led by Health Data Research UK, of failing to consult an advisory body of doctors before feeding the health data of tens of millions of patients into Foresight. Both BMA and RGCP have asked NHS England to refer itself to the Information Commissioner over the matter. Professor Kamila Hawthorne, chair of RGCP, said the issue was one of 'fostering patient trust' that their data was not being used 'beyond what they've given permission for.' She said: 'As data controllers, GPs take the management of their patients' medical data very seriously, and we want to be sure data isn't being used beyond its scope, in this case to train an AI programme. 'We have raised our concerns with NHS England, through the Joint GP IT Committee, and the committee has called for a pause on data processing in this way while further investigation takes place, and for NHS England to refer itself to the Information Commissioner. 'Patients need to be able to trust their personal medical data is not being used beyond what they've given permission for, and that GPs and the NHS will protect their right to data privacy. 'If we can't foster this patient trust, then any advancements made in AI – which has potential to benefit patient care and alleviate GP workload – will be undermined. 'We hope to hear more from NHS England in due course, providing definitive and transparent answers to inform our next steps.' Katie Bramall, BMA England GP committee chair, said: 'For GPs, our focus is always on maintaining our patients' trust in how their confidential data is handled. 'We were not aware that GP data, collected for Covid-19 research, was being used to train an AI model, Foresight. 'As such, we are unclear as to whether the correct processes were followed to ensure that data was shared in line with patients' expectations and established governance processes. 'We have raised our concerns with NHS England through the joint GP IT committee and appreciate their verbal commitment to improve on these processes going forward. 'The committee has asked NHS England to refer itself to the Information Commissioner so the full circumstances can be understood, and to pause ongoing processing of data in this model, as a precaution, while the facts can be established.' 'Patients shouldn't have to worry that what they tell their GP will get fed to AI models without the full range of safeguards in place to dictate how that data is shared.' An NHS spokesperson confirmed that development of the Foresight model had been paused for the time being.
