Anniversary of Tiananmen Square crackdown passes off quietly
The 36th anniversary of a bloody crackdown that ended pro-democracy protests in China passed like any other weekday.
Security was tight on Wednesday around Beijing's Tiananmen Square, where weeks of student-led protests shook the party in 1989.
Advertisement
Under then-leader Deng Xiaoping, the military was sent in to end the protest on the night of June 3-4. Using live ammunition, soldiers forced their way through crowds on the streets that tried to block them from reaching the square.
Hundreds and possibly thousands of people were killed, including dozens of soldiers.
A plain clothes security person stands on duty near security cameras overlooking Tiananmen Square (Ng Han Guan/AP)
The ruling Communist Party has tried, with some success, to erase what it calls the 'political turmoil' of 1989 from the collective memory. It bans any public commemoration or mention of the June 4 crackdown, scrubbing references from the internet.
In recent years, that ban has been extended to Hong Kong, where a once-massive annual candlelight vigil is no longer permitted.
Advertisement
It is only in Taiwan, the self-governing island that is claimed by China but runs its own affairs, that large June 4 gatherings can still take place.
University students occupied Tiananmen Square in the spring of 1989. Their calls for freedoms divided the party leadership. The decision to send in the troops marked a decisive turning point in the evolution of modern China, keeping the party firmly in control as it loosened economic restrictions.
Chinese officials have said the country's rapid economic development since then proves the decisions made at the time were correct.
'On the political turmoil that happened in the late 1980s, the Chinese government has already reached a clear conclusion,' Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said on Wednesday.
Advertisement
He added that China would continue along its current path of what it calls 'socialism with Chinese characteristics'.
Tiananmen Mothers, a group formed by relatives of the victims, made an annual online appeal to the government. Signed by 108 members, it called for an independent investigation into what happened on June 4, 1989, including a list of all who died.
The group also demanded compensation for the families and a legal case against those responsible for the deaths.
The British and German Embassies in Beijing posted videos commemorating the anniversary on Weibo, a Chinese social media platform, but they were later taken down. The Canadian and German Embassies displayed images of a single lit candle on large screens facing the main street.
Advertisement
Police officers set up a road block in the Causeway Bay area of Hong Kong on Wednesday (Chan Long Hei/AP)
In Hong Kong, a carnival showcasing Chinese food and products was held in Victoria Park, where tens of thousands of people used to gather in the evening for a candlelight vigil to mark the anniversary.
Hong Kong authorities first shut down the vigil during the Covid-19 pandemic and arrested the organisers in 2021. The moves were part of a broader crackdown on dissent following monthslong anti-government protests in 2019 that turned violent and paralysed parts of the city.
Police were out in force to try to prevent any protest.
Jailed vigil organiser Chow Hang-tung said she would go on a 36-hour hunger strike to remember the events of the day.
Advertisement
The British and Canadian consulates posted social media messages about not forgetting June 4. Hong Kong was a British colony until 1997. The American consulate posted a message from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio on its website.
'The CCP actively tries to censor the facts,' Mr Rubio said, referring to China's Communist Party. 'But the world will never forget.'
Taiwan's President Lai Ching-te used the anniversary to position the island he leads on the frontline of defending democracy against authoritarianism. In a Facebook post, he drew a distinction between Taiwan's multiparty democracy and China's one-party rule.
'Authoritarian governments often choose to remain silent and forget about history, while democratic societies choose to preserve the truth and refuse to forget those who have contributed to the ideals of human rights and the dreams they embrace,' Mr Lai wrote.
Taiwan transitioned from authoritarianism to democracy in a process that began in the late 1980s. It relies on support principally from the US, along with other democratic partners, to deter China from an invasion.
The Communist Party says it favours peaceful reunification but does not renounce the use of force.
A commemoration and candlelight vigil remembering June 4 was planned for Wednesday evening.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Bidding war erupts over document that ‘proves Tibetan independence'
When Sir Basil Gould attended the enthronement of Tibet's new Dalai Llama in 1940, it was obvious history would be unfolding before his eyes. But 85 years later, the British diplomat's own papers are at the centre of a purported attempt to control the past. Documents written by Sir Basil that are said to prove the independence of Tibet became engulfed in a bidding war in London this week, as followers of the Dalai Llama sought to keep them out of Chinese hands. The document was part of a cache sold by Sir Basil's family at Bonhams on Thursday. It described how Tibet exercised 'de facto independence in internal and external affairs' before China tightened its grip in the 1950s – a claim seized on by campaigners, who say it runs counter to the Chinese narrative that the region has never been free. Among the bidders was a former representative of the Dalai Llama, who wanted to preserve the documents for the region's historical record. But the lot ultimately sold for more than £14,000 to an anonymous buyer. It came amid fears from Tibetan campaigners that Chinese buyers could be trying to snap up Sir Basil's estate and keep parts of it from the public eye. Tenzin Rabga Tashi, from the London-based campaign group Free Tibet, said: 'This is what it means when not only have you lost your country, but your history is sold to the highest bidder. 'In telegrams, letters and photos, the Basil Gould collection documents vividly the gathering darkness of 1940s Tibet before China's invasion. 'Even so, the sale to unknown bidders online does not negate the irrefutable evidence of Britain's unique connection with Tibet as an independent country.' Serving as a British trade agent in Gyantse, Tibet, from 1912 to 1913, Sir Basil went on to become a British political officer in Sikkim, Bhutan and Tibet for a decade from 1935. He attended the enthronement of the Dalai Llama, taking a young artist called Kanwal Krishna with him who captured the event with a series of watercolours. Other lots sold on Thursday included a portrait of the Tibetan leader during the ceremony. The painting, which sold for £152,800, was also among those that Tibetans were keen to keep from Chinese hands ahead of the Dalai Lama's 90th birthday next month. Another lot – a collection of 40 watercolours from Krishna's 1939 to 1940 visit to Lhasa with Sir Basil – sold for £457,600. In a video promoting the sale, Giles Peppiatt, head of fine art at Bonhams, said: 'These are extraordinarily rare images and to have these images from a first-hand source is unprecedented. 'The Gould collection shows a remarkable insight into Tibet in the 1940s and most importantly shows us the principal characters in the divination, in the search and the enthronement of the 14th Dalai Llama.' Today Tibet is recognised as part of the People's Republic of China, known as the Tibet Autonomous Region. China claims to have held control over Tibet since the 13th century. However, many dispute this narrative, with independence advocates arguing the country in fact had long periods of freedom to run its own affairs. The document in question, which archivists understand was written by Sir Basil, appears to support this view. The Telegraph understands that it describes how '... since 1912 the Tibetan government… continuously exercised de facto independence in both internal and external affairs'. The paper goes on to say that the Chinese Republic declared that Tibet was part of China. It added that the British took a 'middle line' and informed the Chinese that they upheld the autonomy of Tibet 'while admitting the suzerainty of China'. The writer then goes on to describe how a compromise was later reached in which Tibet was divided into Inner and Outer Tibet –with some degree of Chinese control 'contemplated for Inner Tibet', while Outer Tibet was to be autonomous. The document was auctioned off as part of a larger lot described as 'a large box of papers, letters, manuscripts and other ephemera relating to Tibet'. A proof copy of Sir Basil's 1957 book, The Jewel in the Lotus: Recollections of an Indian Political, which detailed his time in Tibet, was also included in the lot. After a bidding war that lasted more than five minutes, the item was eventually won by an anonymous online bidder – for a final total of £14,080 once auction charges were added. Sonam Tsering Frasi, a former representative of the Dalai Lama to the UK and northern Europe, was among those who unsuccessfully attempted to secure the lot. Speaking to The Telegraph following the auction, Mr Frasi, 70, said: 'All of these archive materials are important to us as Tibetans because they belong to the Tibetan people and it relates to what happened before the Chinese people [came]. 'So this paper has an independent British government's thinking [and] attitude [about] what was happening on the ground in Lhasa.' He added: 'Tibet was an independent country. But that doesn't fit with the Chinese narrative.' Mr Frasi said: 'There was definitely a concern about trying to keep these out of Chinese hands because we don't know who is online bidding. 'My suspicion is that there were Chinese bidders and there might be lots of records in there that will show the thinking of British-India with regards to Tibet autonomy.' He added: 'These papers – the danger is that they would not surface at all or they would be spun around to say something else.' Bonhams does not reveal whom successful bidders are. A spokesman would not approach the winner on The Telegraph's behalf, saying this would have gone against its privacy rules.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Business Matters Has a phone call led to the end of the tariff war?
The US and China have announced their delegations will meet in London to talk trade on Monday... so has a phone call between President Donald Trump and President Xi Jin Ping signalled an end to the tariff war between the World's biggest two economies? Andrew Peach discusses whether Elon Musk's time at the White House achieved anything for the tech sector that will survive his rift with President Trump. Elsewhere, we are on the road in China with a truck but no driver, and the fashion statement that's set to go up for auction in Paris. Global business news, with live guests and contributions from Asia and the USA.
The Guardian
6 hours ago
- The Guardian
Jailed Hong Kong democracy activist Joshua Wong hit with new charges
Jailed pro-democracy activist Joshua Wong has been hit with further national security charges, a move rights groups said showed the Hong Kong government was trying to keep dissidents behind bars for as long as possible. Wong, a well-known activist who has been in jail for more than four years either awaiting trial or serving sentences, is accused of conspiracy to collude with a foreign country. He appeared in court on Friday to hear the charge and did not apply for bail. Hong Kong's national security police said in a statement they had arrested a 28-year-old man on suspicion of the offence, as well as for 'dealing with property known or believed to represent proceeds of an indictable offence'. According to the charge sheet, viewed by Reuters and Hong Kong Free Press, Wong is accused of conspiring with fellow democracy activist Nathan Law, who is in exile overseas, and others to ask foreign countries, institutions, organisations or individuals outside China to impose sanctions or blockades. He is also accused of conspiring to ask foreign parties to 'seriously disrupt the formulation and implementation of laws and policies' in Hong Kong and China, 'which was likely to cause serious consequences', Hong Kong Free Press reported. The charge comes under Hong Kong's national security law, which was imposed on the city by Beijing in 2020 after the 2019 pro-democracy protests brought the city to a standstill. The law has been criticised by foreign governments and rights groups as overly broad and ill-defined, and easily weaponised to crush the opposition by criminalising even benign acts of dissent. The Hong Kong and central Chinese governments reject the criticism and say the law was needed to restore order to the city. Wong is due to be released in January 2027. He is serving protest-related sentences, including a 56-month term for his role among the so-called 'Hong Kong 47' group of politicians, activists, campaigners and community members who held unofficial pre-election primaries in 2020. The cohort were sentenced in November, at the end of Hong Kong's largest national security trial. Just two of the 47 were acquitted. Human Rights Watch's associate China director, Maya Wong, called the new charges against Wong 'arbitrary, cruel and outrageous'. 'While imprisoned under one trumped-up charge, Joshua Wong has been suddenly slapped with yet another as the authorities appear intent on keeping one of Hong Kong's most influential democracy leaders behind bars,' she said. Amnesty International said the new charges could see him given a life sentence if found guilty. 'Hong Kong's national security law is turning five years old at the end of the month, and these new charges against Joshua Wong show that its capacity to be used by the Hong Kong authorities to threaten human rights in the city is as potent and present as ever,' said the organisation's China director, Sarah Brooks. 'Once again, the vague and sweeping offence of 'collusion with foreign forces' is being weaponised to justify an attack on the freedoms of expression and association. 'This latest charge against him underscores the authorities' fear of prominent dissidents and shows the lengths they will go to keep them behind bars for as long as possible – in so doing, continuing a chilling effect on civic activism in the city.' Reuters contributed to this report
